Characterization of incineration residues from wastewater treatment plant in Polish city: a future waste based source of valuable elements?

To support the rational management of raw materials in the European Union more attention is being paid to the resource potential of waste materials, which are increasing in volume due to industrial development and the world population growth. One of the methods to reduce the amount of produced and landfilled waste is incineration. As a result of sewage sludge incineration, fly ash (ISSA—incinerated sewage sludge ash) and APC (air pollution control) residues are produced. The goal of this study was to characterize incineration residues from waste water treatment plant in Polish city with ca. one million inhabitants using mineralogical, chemical methods, and to estimate the recovery potential of valuable components. Both incineration products accumulate elements which are of valuable concentrations, such as P (17 wt% of P2O5 on average in the ISSA), as well as significant amounts of metals such as Zn, Pb, Cu, Ni, and Cr. Small particle sizes < 125 µm in both materials favor the accumulation of elements of higher volatility during incineration, but they are usually dispersed within a matrix, main minerals or amorphous substance, or are present in the form of micro inclusions or grains < 10 µm, which thus excludes their easy recovery.


Introduction
Resource depletion and the implementation of the circular economy principles, where mineral resources are preserved and valuable products and materials are reused and recycled for as long as possible, as well as rising environmental awareness have caused waste management to become a major social and economic issue in the development of a sustainable economy [14]. There is a strong emphasis on looking for a source of valuable elements in alternative resources, such as waste streams. In the near future, waste landfilling will become more expensive than other methods of waste treatment; thus, the European Union's (EU) Member States have committed to a significant reduction in the amount of landfilled waste, and to use its inherent energy and waste-based raw material potential. Recently, waste incineration is considered to be one of the most reasonable options to fulfill these commitments. The process deals with different types of waste, with proper calorific value to sustain an autothermic incineration reaction. The process of thermal treatment is applicable to municipal, medical and industrial wastes and residues from wastewater treatment [3,5,15,33].
Over the past decades, a significant development in waste incineration technology in the EU was noted. The main focus was on the reduction of the emission of gas and suspended particles, and on reducing the operating cost of the installation, as well as achieving a significant reduction in the amount of landfilled wastes to 50% already in 2009 and to 35% in 2016 in comparison to the amount from the 1995. Germany, the Netherlands, Sweden, Austria, Denmark and Belgium reached these goals by 2010 through the combination of recycling technology, biological waste treatment and energy recovery during waste thermal transformation [7].
The amount of municipal waste, which are landfilled in Poland is slowly but systematically decreasing, from 74% in 2010 to 57% in 2014. Despite this improvement, the volume is still almost twice that of the landfilled municipal waste in EU countries (~ 30%) where the waste management system is well developed. In the EU countries in 2014, on average ~ 27% of municipal waste was incinerated, while in Poland this was ~ 15%, which is a significant increase 1 3 compared to 2010, when < 1% of municipal waste was thermally treated.
Population growth causes an increase in the amount of sewage sludge produced as a result of wastewater treatment, which is one of the types of waste generated in the EU in huge quantities [27], presenting challenges for its proper management. It is estimated that by the year 2020, 13 million tons of sewage sludge will be produced annually in the EU countries [38].
Municipal wastewater is a mixture of water from households, small industrial plants, trading and service facilities, and sometimes rainwater depending on the rainfall, which depending on the rainfall intensity can cause a flush of mineral and organic pollutants into the storm sewers [13,18]. Therefore, sewage sludge obtained as a result of wastewater treatment is considered as a sink for different contaminants and mineral fraction suspended in water. The main purpose of incineration is to reduce mass, volume and the potential negative influence of sewage sludge on the environment through disinfection and detoxification at high temperatures. As a result of sewage sludge incineration, significant amounts of energy are recovered due to its relatively high calorific value (ca. 12-16 MJ Kg −1 kcal kg − 1 ) [12,26], which enables a waste-to-energy strategy to be followed.
Sewage sludge often accumulates metals (e.g. Zn, Cu, Ni, Cd, Pb, Hg, Cr, and Sb) [15] that are present in wastewater and suspended solid pollutants. For this reason, the direct utilization of sludge in agriculture is excluded, since this would not fulfill the requirements of European legislation [35] or national norms; therefore, sludge in agriculture could be excluded (Fig. 1). Interestingly, the application of sewage sludge in plant cultivation intended for compost production has remained at a similar high level since 2014 (Fig. 1).
Sewage sludge was landfilled for many years, and in developing countries this way of dealing with sludge is still commonplace; however, in the long term, landfilling of this material can negatively affect surface and ground water or soils, since it is known that sewage sludge contains non-biodegradable compounds containing heavy metals, toxic organic substances and parasites, pathogens and microorganisms. In Poland, the increasing amount of sewage sludge is currently thermally treated, whereas landfilling is being highly reduced (Fig. 1).
As a result of sewage sludge incineration, a variety of solid residues (ISSA and APC residues) and technological wastes (flue gas with suspended dust, wastewater, and used material from the fluidized bed in the boiler) are produced. A significant reduction of sewage sludge mass (70%) and volume (90%) after thermal treatment [4,23] leads to a concentration of numerous elements in the solid residues, including potentially valuable components. These residues can be considered, for example, as a source of metallic elements that can have industrial applicability, or as hazardous material, and thus after thermal treatment sewage sludge should be stabilized before any further application.
The goal of this study was to characterize the ISSA and the APC residues formed as a result of sewage sludge thermal treatment obtained from an incineration plant located in the southern Poland using mineralogical and chemical methods, and to estimate the recovery potential of components that can be considered as alternative resources of industrially valuable elements and rare earth elements (REE) based on the data obtained from this incineration plant over 1 year.

Fluidized-bed incineration of sewage sludge
To enable the autothermic incineration of sewage sludge, the excess moisture has to be removed. The partly dewatered sludge, from the wastewater treatment plant that contain 23% of the dry mass, is transported to the drying node for the sludge membrane drying system, where the sludge is dried down to 36% of the dry mass (solid content; using disc dryer-Haarslev). The dryer is equipped with a heating medium in the form of saturated steam, which is produced in a steam boiler or economizer, using the heat recovered in the sludge incineration process. This process takes place under low negative pressure. The dried sludge is incinerated in a fluidized-bed boiler (Pyrofluid™) that provides high turbulence for the fluidized bed at a constant intensity throughout the process to ensure the complete incineration of organic matter and a stable operating temperature in the range of 850-900 °C, which ensures a longer life of the boiler. In addition, the heat exchange area within the fluidized bed allows the size of the installation to be reduced. The thermal utilization station is equipped with a heat exchanger, which is responsible for the pre-cooling of flue gases and the production of saturated steam to power the drying node. Fluidization is obtained by the insertion of an inert material, namely silica sand. It is achieved by introducing an air stream into the bed at pressure, which causes the liquid in the bed to be brought to boiling point [16]. Dewatered sludge is pumped into the boiler and dried out. As a consequence of the turbulence streams in the fluidized bed, the sludge disintegrates [35]. As a result of the incineration, organic matter is combusted and heat-resistant solids and volatile components are carried out in the exhaust gas. Heavier components and incombustible fraction are separated in a multicyclone, captured on an electrostatic precipitator and transported in the form of ISSA into the ash silo, whereas the lighter components and flue gas cleaning products (APC residues) are caught up in a bag filter after reactant addition and subjected to further processing [16]. In the flue gas purification process NaHCO 3 is added. Uncaptured suspended particles in the flue gases are emitted through the chimney into the atmosphere. The flue gases are continuously monitored to measure the content of the suspended particles and gas composition (PM10, CO, NO x , NH 3 , HCl, HF, C org , and SO 2 , as well as the elements Cd, Ta, Hg, Sb, As, Pb, Cr, Co, Cu, Mn, Ni, and W) to control the emissions to the atmosphere with accordance to the 2000/76/ EC directive [9].

ISSA and APC residues
The ISSA is classified as non-hazardous waste in accordance to the European List of Waste (Commission Decision The ISSA (FA1-4) and the APC residues (APC1-4) samples were collected from sewage sludge incineration plants located in an urban agglomeration with ca. one million inhabitants. Sampling was performed quarterly for a 1-year period, starting in December 2015 (for details see Table 1). During each sampling, ca. 10 kg of the averaged ISSA and 5 kg of the APC residues were collected from the silo during chutes to the transporting trolleys. Since the ISSA and the APC residues are different, macroscopically differences in their composition were expected.
Due to a high content of water soluble phases in the APC residues, a soluble fraction was removed, precipitated and studied mineralogically. The averaged 1 kg of material was dissolved with 20 L of deionized water and filtrated, which as a consequence caused an APC residues' mass reduction of 98%. The residual non-soluble fraction was also investigated.

Methods
The granulometric composition was measured using a Mastersizer 3000 equipped with a Malvern Hydro EV detector. Prior to the analyses, the ISSA and the APC residues were averaged and passed through a sieve with a mesh size of 1.5 mm to obtain 100 g of each sample. After dispersion in deionized water, each sample was measured three times.
Chemical analysis using inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry (ICP-MS) and inductively coupled plasma atomic emission spectroscopy (ICP-AES) were performed by Bureau Veritas Minerals (formerly AcmeLabs Analytical Laboratories) in Vancouver, Canada. These analyses allowed the content of major and trace elements to be determined, respectively, as well as the content of valuable components including metallic elements. The C tot and S tot content were measured using LECO combustion analysis and loss on ignition (LOI) was obtained using the thermal methods.
Qualitative powder X-ray diffraction analyses (XRD) were performed to obtain information on the phase composition of the ISSA and the APC residues using a Philips X'Pert diffractometer (type APD, also used for quantitative measurements), with a goniometer PW 3020 (angle range of 2-70° 2Θ with a step of 0.02° 2 s − 1 ). To identify the phase composition, Philips X'Pert software (associated with the ICDD database) was used. For the analyses, the samples were milled manually in an agate mortar. To quantify the contribution of the individual components of the crystalline and amorphous phases in these materials, quantitative XRD analyses were performed. Interpretation was based on calculations using SIROQuant software packages (Sietronics Pty Ltd). Prior to the qualitative XRD analyses, averaged samples were milled dry in an agate mill, while for the quantitative analyses 2.7 g of the sample with the addition of ZnO (0.3 g) as the internal standard was milled in ethanol for 10 min using a McCrone micronizing mill (Glen Creston). Measurements were performed using disoriented specimens at an angle range of 2-70° 2Θ with a step of 0.02° 5 s − 1 .
Organic matter analysis was performed for a selected sample of the APC residues and one of the ISSA samples that contained the highest C tot content. Approximately, 50 g of each sample was extracted using ultrasonic agitation for three 20 min periods in 300 ml of dichloromethane (DCM) and methanol mixture (1:1 vol; all solvents spectroscopically pure). The solvent extracts were separated from the residues in the centrifuge, and then carefully concentrated by rotary evaporator and transferred to pre-weighed glass vials. Total extracts were converted before gas chromatography-mass spectrometry (GC-MS) analysis to trimethylsilyl derivatives by reaction with BSTFA [N,O-bis-(trimethylsilyl)trifluoroacetamide] dissolved in super-dehydrated DCM and heated at 70 °C for 3 h [28].
GC-MS analysis of the derivatized extracts was performed with an Agilent 7890A chromatograph equipped with an EPC Cool On-Column Inlet and fitted with a fused silica capillary column (60 m × 0.32 mm) coated with HP-5 MS (0.25 µm film thickness). Helium was used as a carrier gas and the samples were injected into the column at 40 °C. The oven temperature was kept constant for 3 min, increased up to 120 °C at 20 °C per min, then increased to 300 °C at 3 °C per min and maintained at that temperature for 60 min. Detailed microscopic studies were performed using a Hitachi S-4700 field emission scanning electron microscope (FE-SEM) combined with a Noran energy dispersive spectrometer (EDS). These studies enabled determination of the chemical composition of the phases, including those that are below the threshold of detection of the XRD method using the spot or micro-area analytical modes. The detailed characteristics of the studied minerals based on chemical analysis of the components were analyzed, as well as determination of the relationship between them, their forms of occurrence and research on the metallic elements occurring in various forms within the crystalline and amorphous phases, present in the form of grains and micro-grains' alloys and dispersed metallic inclusions. The ISSA and the APC residues, prepared as both polished thin sections and as grains mounted on carbon discs, were coated with carbon or gold. Analyses were performed at accelerating voltage 20 kV and beam current 10 mA, using the secondary electron (SE) and backscattered electron (BSE) imaging modes.

Incineration residues composition
Out of 76,374 tonnes of dewatered sludge (100 wt%) incinerated in 2015 in the studied installation, 4,452 tonnes of the ISSA (6 wt%), 836 tonnes of the APC residues (1 wt%) and 0.14 tons of suspended particles in flue gas (0.0002 wt%) (not discussed in this study due to the very low content) were produced (Fig. 2). Incineration caused 93% mass reduction of input sewage sludge and concentration of elements including those that can be considered both as potentially valuable metallic components and also as potentially hazardous.

Chemical and mineralogical characterization of sewage sludge incineration residues
The ISSA is a reddish, fine material, where on average 63 vol% of particles are below 100 µm. The particle size distribution is unimodal (Fig. 3a) with a mode at 98 µm for samples FA3 and FA4, modes between 46 and 67 µm in sample FA1, and between 67 and 98 µm in sample FA2. The soluble material content in the ISSA is around 1 wt%. The particle size distribution is an important characteristic that can not only influence the distribution and accumulation of elements, but also the planning of processing methods.
The results of the chemical analyses were averaged after four sampling campaigns ( Table 2). The ISSA is an Si-Fe-Ca-P-Al dominated material with very low content of Na, K, Ti, Mg Mn, C tot , and S tot ( Table 2). The content of the main components is quite invariable in all samples. High concentration of trace metals and toxic trace elements 1 3 were measured for Zn, Ba, Cr, Cu, Sr, Sn, Zr, Pb, Ni, V, Co, Mo, and As (Table 2). For the Y, La, Ce, and Nd the concentrations are higher than 10 mg kg − 1 , whereas for the other REEs and other trace elements the concentrations do not exceed a few mg kg − 1 . The high content of Si, Fe, Ca, and Al with the exception of P allows the ISSA to be considered as an alternative material for cement manufacture [12,29], bricks and tiles [1,37] or glass ceramics [36]. The LOI value for the ISSA on average is approximately 3.4 wt%.
The main minerals determined in ISSA using XRD are quartz (30 ± 0.6 wt%), feldspar (18.9 ± 1.0 wt%), hematite (7.8 ± 0.4 wt%), whitlockite (22 ± 0.8 wt%), and Fe-PO 4 phase (PDF card 15-0655) (1.5 ± 0.3 wt%). The quartz grains are rounded or semi-rounded, feldspar grains are rather angular with signs of fragmentation along the cleavage planes (Fig. 4a, b, respectively). The hematite (Fig. 4c) is composed of microcrystals which are grouped into partly rounded assemblages, whereas the phosphates' grains are either perfectly rounded or in the form of compact spherulites or radial aggregates. The EDS analyses of different phosphates (Fig. 4d-f) indicate that they typically contain Fe, Mg, and Ca in different proportions. The presence of a fine-grained matrix surrounding bigger grains is common. This matrix is formed of a mixture of micro-grains, which in chemical composition are dominated by Si and P, but they contain also Ca, Fe, Al, Mg, K, and Ti (and sometimes Na, S, Cl, Mn, and Ba). At the lower quantities Ti-Fe oxides (Fig. 4g), zircon (Fig. 4h), Fe-Cr-(Ni) alloys (Fig. 4i), and Si-Pb-K rich phases (Fig. 4j) are also found. The results of the quantitative XRD analyses using the Rietveld refinement method indicate that the content of amorphous phase is not very high (19.9 ± 2.4 wt%). The mineral composition of the ISSA can vary for different plants; however, but in many publications the above-mentioned mineral phases are common [e.g. 8,10,11,19], with the only differences being in their amount and the morphology. The APC residues comprise light gray, very fine material, where particles below 100 µm constitute over 95 vol%, and the water-soluble material content is ca. 98 wt%. The bimodal particle size distribution (Fig. 3b) with modes at 0.03 µm and 45.61 µm were measured for APC2 and APC3 samples, whereas in sample APC4, apart from the modes observed in previous samples a shoulder to the left of the second mode (at 6.72 µm) was also observed (Fig. 3b). In sample APC1, two modes were observed-at 0.03 µm and at 6.72 µm, and a shoulder to the right at 21.21 µm and 45.61 µm. The APC residues' composition is dominated by Na-rich water soluble phases. The Na content is the highest, together with high S tot concentrations, indicating the presence of sodium sulphates. In addition, the high C tot content may indicate the presence of either carbonate minerals or unburned organic material. As suggested by Donatello and Cheesman [12], the LOI value can indicate the unburned carbon content.
Trace elements (Zn, Se, Sn, Ba, Cr, Cu, Pb, Sr, and Hg) are highly concentrated (Table 2). Nevertheless, the concentrations of these elements in the APC residues are already several times lower than in the ISSA. The removal of water soluble phases from the APC residues by dissolution in deionised water caused significant mass reduction of 98%, and additional concentration of elements occurring in nonsoluble phases (Zn, Sn, Ba, Sr, Cu, Pb, and Cr, and also Hg, Se, Ni, Bi, V, Ce, Sb, Co, and La).
The extractable organic matter content in both the ISSA and the APC residues' samples is very low. The ISSA sample yielded 0.003 mg extract/g sample (0.28 wt% extract/ total carbon), whereas the APC residues' sample yielded 0.992 mg extract/g sample (3.03 wt% extract/total carbon). The molecular composition is very poor, dominated by free carboxylic acids as C 16 and C 18 normal saturated monocarboxylic acids, which are most probably contaminations (e.g. from solvents). Therefore, we assume that the high LOI value in the APC residues is not related to the inefficient combustion of the sludge, as suggested by Donatello and Cheesman [12], but rather due to the presence of minerals that contain water in their structure, such as thermonatrite, gypsum or apatite. Carbon was also detected in the EDS analyses, and thus the presence of organic matter in the form of carbon characterized by a different degree of coalification or non-extractable inert organic substance that is preserved after incineration cannot be excluded. For further investigations of the organic matter composition, different extraction procedures should be taken into consideration.

Partitioning of elements and mass flow calculations
As mentioned above, the particle size distribution is important for elements' accumulation. Li et al. [20] indicate that along with the decreasing particle size distribution the concentration of elements, which are considered as toxic, increases. Several authors have already attempted to evaluate the relation between the particle size distribution and the elements' concentration. Liao    show that most of the trace elements, however, economically valuable (e.g. Zn, Cu, Pb, Cd, Mo, As, Ba, and Sn) are concentrated in the particles whose size is in the range of 50-125 µm, whereas Cr is mostly found in the fraction from 125 to 250 µm. These results allow us to assume that most of the elements are gathered in the ISSA, in which most of the particles are within the aforementioned size range. The APC residues are characterized by much smaller particles; however, many of them are also in the given range. The particle size distribution can give us a first hint of the partitioning of elements during incineration.
The fractionation of elements is a function of the volatility of elements. Following the work of [6,22,25,32] the volatility of elements in coal-fired boilers and in coal combustion between the bottom ash (BA) and ISSA was described. Low volatile elements (REEs, Y, Sc, Hf, Mn, Rb, Th, and Zr) are distributed equally between BA and ISSA, Zn and As are enriched in ISSA in comparison to their content in BA, whereas Hg, Se, and B are the most volatile and concentrated in the ISSA. Some of these elements can overlap depending, for example, on the combustion conditions and combustor type, which can cause different ranges of volatility of the elements, as well as fluid dynamics and kinetic factors within the incinerator [12]. In addition, elements can concentrate more easily on smaller particles [24,39] owing to the high surface area of fine particles. Due to the fact that in the discussed fluidized-bed boilers BA is not produced, the studied sewage sludge partitioning of elements is described for the ISSA and the APC residues characterized by very fine fraction. Kasina et al. [17] suggest that the partitioning of elements in the ISSA and the APC residues depends mostly on their melting temperatures. Elements characterized by high melting temperature (Mo, Cr, Ti, Fe, Ni, Co, Mn, and Au) are mostly concentrated in the ISSA. As, Zn, and Cu are distributed evenly between both residues, whereas those of lower melting temperatures (Hg, Se, Sb, Sn, Pb, and Cd) could be released from the boiler in a volatile form, and thus are concentrated in the APC residues.
Material mass flows' calculations (the mass of a given material per year) and the results of the chemical analysis give the possibility for the evaluation of the possible recovery of highly concentrated elements in the ISSA and the APC residues. The mass flows are calculated by normalizing the concentration of each element in a given stream with the corresponding stream for the entire installation under consideration. The results of these calculations are listed in Table 2.
Elements highly concentrated in incineration residues are distributed unequally between the ISSA and the APC residues. Dominating elements such as Si, Fe, Ca, P, and Al are accumulated in the ISSA to the amount of 2,230 tons per year, comprising over 42% of all elements present in the incineration residues from the analyzed installation. Noteworthy is the high concentration of phosphorus, which is an important, however, non-renewable resource. In addition, in the EU countries, there is a lack of economically viable phosphate reserves, and thus the recognition and recovery of phosphorus from alternative sources such as incineration ashes would seem to be of importance. Over 17 wt% of P 2 O 5 is accumulated on average in the ISSA, giving almost 750 tons annually that can be recovered (assuming 100% effectivity of recovery) and only 1.5 tons per year is accumulated in the APC residues.
Even though over 90% of Na is accumulated in the APC residues, the concentration does not exceed 640 kg per year in the incineration residues, and its recovery for industrial purposes does not seem to be justified, especially we have to keep in mind that most of this element was added to the system in the form of sodium bicarbonate (Fig. 6a) during the purification of the exhaust gasses, and therefore, caused abnormal accumulation of this element.
A total of 99% of the REEs, which are known to be characterized by low volatility [22], are accumulated in the ISSA; however, their concentrations are very low, and far below the average composition of the upper continental crust [34]. Ce, La, Nd, and Y are of the highest concentrations, but in the 5,288 tons of annually produced residues the content of Ce is 187 kg, of La is 93 kg, of Nd is 4 kg, and of Y is 73 kg.
The measured concentrations of Cd, Cr, Cu, Ni, and Zn indicate their accumulations in the ISSA, while Hg, Pb, Sn, Sb, Bi, and Se are concentrated mostly in the insoluble part of the APC residues, which are precipitated as a result of the addition of NaHCO 3 in the purification process of the exhaust gasses; whereas the mass flow calculations indicate that 99% of Mo, Cd, Cr, Cu (Fig. 6b), Ni, Sn, and Zn, as well as over 97% of Pb, 94% of Sb, and 87% of Bi accumulate in the ISSA, comprising a total of 25.5 tons per year. Se is fractionated more or less evenly between the ISSA and the APC residues (ca. 25 kg per year and 18 kg per year, respectively), whereas 99% of Hg (~ 1 kg per year in the total amount of residues produced annually; Fig. 6c) is concentrated in the APC residues.

Conclusions
1. The valuable elements accumulated in the sewage sludge incineration residues in the studied installation are dispersed within components of very fine-grained matrix and in small grains of minerals and amorphous substances. Their presence in the form of discrete grains of own phases (e.g. minerals and alloys) is rare and their size hardly exceeds 10 µm. 2. The small particle size can favor the accumulation and enrichment of some elements in the sewage sludge incineration residues. 3. Elements which are characterized by high melting temperatures concentrate in the ISSA, while elements that are characterized by lower melting temperatures (e.g. Sn and Hg) concentrate in the APC residues. The As, Zn, and Cu are distributed evenly between the ISSA and the APC residues. 4. The concentration of metallic elements is quite high. In the ISSA, the annual average concentration is around 16 wt%; however, this is 14 wt% for Fe. In the APC residues, the total content of metallic elements is much lower and barely exceeds 2 wt%. The content of elements gives us important information about the composition of residues, but is not a reliable indicator of their recovery potential. 6. The content of valuable elements recalculated on the produced waste mass of the incineration residues and their extraction is currently not economically feasible for studied samples. Taking into consideration that the amount of sewage sludge incineration residues will increase significantly in the near future, and the resources of ores and natural raw material will be reduced or limited, while if we take into consideration the costs of exploitation or mining, mineral processing, and other technical costs such as infrastructure, environmental and social costs on the one hand, and easily accessible, cheap material that does not require complicated processing methods on the other, ISSA can be considered as an important waste-based source of economically important elements (i.e. P, Zn, Sn, Cr, Pb, Au, and Ag).