Fabrication and preliminary testing of hydroxylammonium nitrate (HAN)-based ceramic microthruster for potential application of nanosatellites in constellation formation flying

Constellation formation flying of nanosatellites (< 10 kg) is becoming a trend for future space exploration missions. Liquid chemical micropropulsion that can provide high thrusting force for high ΔV orbital transfer is a crucial hardware component for successful constellation re-positioning. However, liquid chemical micropropulsion system dedicated for these nanosatellites still not currently available in the market. In this study, a microthruster was fabricated using alumina toughened zirconia (ATZ) as structural material and yttria-stabilised zirconia-graphene (YSZ-Gr) as electrode material. The device has a dimension of 1.7 cm (length) × 1.3 cm (width) × 0.5 cm (thickness) and weighing only 6.18 grams, comprising of five major components such as propellant reservoir, injector, electrodes, micronozzle and reaction chamber. Material characterization shows that both materials have negligible weight loss and small reduction in material hardness and fracture toughness after 20 thermal-vacuum cycles. Moreover, results from dynamic mechanical analysis (DMA) ascertain that addition of graphene significantly enhanced the damping behaviour of the zirconia composite. Electrolytic decomposition of hydroxylammonium nitrate (HAN) solution in the reaction chamber has been demonstrated with maximum thrust of 180.53 mN at a propellant flow rate of 60 µl/s. The preliminary results suggest that the HAN-based ceramic microthruster could potentially be used as primary propulsion for nanosatellites in constellation formation flying.


Introduction
In recent years, formation flying of nanosatellites (\ 10 kg) have attracted enormous attention from space community because of advantages such as short development time, low life cycle cost, reduced risk of mission failure, as well as versatility to changing mission goals (Kristiansen and Nicklasson 2009;Hu et al. 2015;Sun et al. 2017). In depth review on the formation control of nanosatellites, satellite formation flying, distributed satellite systems, and fractionated satellite formation have been reported previously Chong et al. 2016).
Formation flying of satellites can be categorized into trailing, cluster and constellation. The fundamental success of satellite formation flying lies on the relative spatial and temporal positioning of each satellite in the formation, which is susceptible to unpredictable and dynamic space environment. For constellation formation flying, constant orbital correction and orbit re-phasing are required. For instance, orbit re-phasing is necessary if one of the satellites in the constellation fails, others may re-position themselves to ensure continuity of the mission. For an interplanetary mission, a swarm of nanosatellites could be designed to perform a series of risky manoeuvres, such as orbiting and landing on an asteroid while the 'mothercraft' remain on orbit to receive and transmitting data from landed space probe using high gain antenna. Requirements for these high DV scenarios are highly dependent on the mission while the choice of propulsion concept depends on the available time to conduct such manoeuvre (Mueller et al. 2008). High specific impulse electric micropropulsion is suitable for long duration mission. Cold gas microthruster or chemical microthruster with moderate specific impulse but high thrust-to-weight is ideal for rapid orbital transfer.
Cold gas thruster has been demonstrated as the feasible propulsion concept for the rapid DV applications. SNAP-1, a 6.5 kg nanosatellite, developed by University of Surrey is the first nanosatellite carrying cold gas thruster (Underwood et al. 2003) to perform inspection manoeuvres to another satellite in orbit. The separation between SNAP-1 and Tsinghua-1 (target microsatellite) has successfully been reduced from 15,000 to 2000 km.
Nevertheless, the low specific impulse of cold gas thruster has limited total DV. Chemical propellant microthruster offers higher specific impulse and thus higher total DV. Hydrazine is a commonly used chemical propellant due to its heritage, such as GRAIL mission where two microsatellites used to measure moon gravity (Edwards-Stewart 2013).
However, the high handling cost of the toxic hydrazine propellant is a drawback which does not favour nanosatellite applications. Electrolytic ignition of HAN solution is a promising approach for application in micropropulsion system. Previous study has demonstrated a complete combustion of HAN solution inside a 0.82 mm 3 volume of combustion chamber produced 150 mN of thrust with deposited electrical energy as low as 1.9 J (Wu and Yetter 2009). A combination of cold gas and ADN green propellant thrusters have been demonstrated in the PRISMA rendezvous mission (Persson et al. 2010). Green ionic propellant, e.g. ADN and HAN, is a promising replacement of hydrazine for chemical micropropulsion system.
Although extensive research work focusing on formation coordination (Ren and Sorensen 2008) and control methods (Cai et al. 2017;Zhang and Liu 2018) have been carried out, developing microthruster hardware specifically for nanosatellites in formation flying has only been reported recently, in which a low power micropropulsion system based on thermal decomposition of an inert chemical blowing agent (CBA) capable of delivering thrust of 1 lN was reported (Romero-Diez et al. 2018).
Although specific requirement of green liquid propellant for nanosatellites in constellation formation flying have not been reported, several criteria for development of the microthrusters from literatures can be summarised as the following: 1. Provide mili-Newton level of thrust for rapid manoeuvre.
2. Environmentally friendly propellant-non-toxic, clean combustion by-products and easy to handle. 3. Compact system, i.e. small in size and light in weight for high thrust-to-weight ratio.
While green propellants are promising alternatives, their high combustion temperature poses stringent requirements on thermo-mechanical properties of the structural material. In recent years, advanced ceramic composites has been poised as the potential structural material for next generation liquid propellant or cold gas microthrusters (Lekholm et al. 2013;Cheah and Chin 2011, 2013. These ceramics are tolerant to high temperatures, lower heat conductivity, exceptional thermal shock resistance and chemically resistant (Schneider et al. 2008;Nevarez-Rascon et al. 2009;Bartolomé et al. 2016). Compared to stainless steel and siliconbased material, fabrication of microthruster using high temperature co-fired ceramic (HTCC) technique (Cheah and Low 2014) is relatively simple, and completed with less expensive equipment. However, HTCC are prone to crack after firing at high temperature (Khaji et al. 2016) and not tested in space simulated environment.
In this paper, a high DV HAN-based microthruster was fabricated using Alumina Toughened Zirconia (ATZ) ceramic and Yytria Stabilised Zirconia-Graphene ceramic composite as the structural and electrode materials, respectively. The microthruster is a scale-up based on Hydrazine mili-Newton Thrust (HmNT) developed by NASA Jet Propulsion Laboratory (Mueller et al. 2008). The ceramic materials were characterized with thermal-vacuum cycle analysis and Dynamic Mechanical Analysis (DMA) to evaluate their suitability in space environment. Lastly, a preliminary testing was conducted to measure the thrust produced by the ceramic microthruster via electrolytic ignition of HAN propellant.

Fabrication of ceramic microthruster
Preparations of ATZ and YSZ-Gr suspensions for gel casting have been described in our previous studies (Markandan et al. 2015(Markandan et al. , 2017. The microchannel pattern in the thruster was drawn and cut onto adhesive film of 100 lm thickness using a cutting plotter (CE6000-60, Graphtec). The film thickness is equivalent to the depth of microstructures. The unwanted parts on the film will be removed, leaving behind a negative pattern which serves as a master mold to prepare a PDMS soft mold, as shown in Fig. 1. The Vinyl film master mold and the replicated PDMS soft mold with microthruster design are shown in Fig. 2. ATZ suspension was then casted into the mold and heated to 50°C to accelerate gelation process. YSZ-Gr suspension was poured into the remaining region of the mold and reheated to 50°C. 85% aqueous glycerol solution was applied as adhesive to laminate the ceramic green layers, followed by sintering via double step sintering by first ramping the temperature to 1200°C, reduced to 900°C and held for another 30 h in a furnace (CWF1200, Carbolite). Then, the YSZ-Gr conductive paths were connected to the external electrical circuit and connecting tubes were inserted into the electrode holes and propellant reservoir, respectively. Figure 3 shows the sealed ceramic microthruster with an opening view of the micronozzle exit.

Thermal-vacuum cycling analysis
Pieces of ATZ and YSZ-Gr samples with dimension of 1.7 cm (length) 9 1.5 cm (width) 9 0.5 cm (thickness) were inserted into a custom-made vacuum chamber. The chamber was connected to a scroll type dry vacuum pump (DIS501, Ulvac Kiko) and a cryogenic pump (CRYO-U 12 HSP). In normal operating condition, the pressure inside the chamber is 8 9 10 -5 Pa with temperature control at ± 5°C. The temperature range was set from 70 to -20°C for a duration of 20 cycles in which each cycle lasted for 120 min.

Dynamic mechanical test
Ceramics have excellent refractory properties and high strength that make them ideal candidate for space components. One of the factors impeding the implementation of this material is their poor damping behaviour. The ceramic propulsion device may be subjected to a barrage of shock waves, which impart impulse forces onto the surface generating them. As such, damping of such impulsive forces is vital to prevent accumulative damage. Dynamic mechanical analysis (DMA) is a useful tool to study the damping behaviour of ceramics, in which tan d is used as a measurement of energy dissipated to energy stored.

Thrust measurement from the HAN microthruster
73 wt% of hydroxylammonium nitrate (HAN) ionic liquid was used as the propellant in this experiment. It is a green and environmental-friendly liquid propellant which is less toxic, easier handling and storage, as well as clean decomposition byproducts such as oxygen, water and nitrogen. The propellant was synthesised in house, in which the process and details of characterization can be found in our previous study (Chai et al. 2016). A syringe pump was used to deliver the HAN propellant into reservoir at controlled flowrates of 20, 40, 60 and 80 ll/s, respectively. The propellant undergoes electrolytic decomposition using a potential difference of 80 V and current of 0.1 A. A load cell (Futek, USA) with sampling rate of 100 ms and accuracy up to 0.01 mg was placed 2 mm from the micronozzle to measure the thrust generated in 120 s.

Results and discussion
3.1 Suitability of material in space environment

Thermal-vacuum cycling
Thermal-vacuum cycling induces repeated stress at the ceramic interface, thereby weakening the bond of ceramic particles. The reduction in the device dimension and weight is less than 1%, showing that most of the volatile chemicals and binders eliminated in multiple stages of heating and sintering. The material hardness has negligible changes after thermal-vacuum cycling while fracture toughness reduces by 9-11%, as shown in Table 1. The results suggest that both materials can function properly in thermal-vacuum environment.

Dynamic mechanical analysis
The addition of graphene platelets in YSZ not only providing electrical conducting paths for electrolytic decomposition, but also enhancing the damping behaviour by energy dissipating mechanism such as GNP pull-outs (Colombo et al. 2010). tan d for different compositions of YSZ-Gr composite are presented in Fig. 4. It can be seen that the presence of graphene platelets improves the damping behaviour of all but slow down towards 100 Hz. This is mainly due to the insufficient recovery time for effective damping behaviour. The effect of 0.5 wt% graphene platelets in comparison to monolithic YSZ is trivial at all frequencies since there is insufficient layers of graphene to improve the damping behavior. The YSZ reinforced with 1 wt% graphene platelets shows significant improvement in damping behaviour at low frequency, with improvement of 280% over monolithic YSZ at a frequency of 25 Hz. In our previous study, scanning electron microscopy images revealed that YSZ reinforced with 1 wt% graphene platelets are widely dispersed and distributed uniformly throughout the sample to form a networked structure with electrical conductivity of 0.9 S/cm (Markandan et al. 2016). This composition was chosen in the fabrication of electrode of good electrical conductivity and excellent damping behaviour.

Design and fabrication of ceramic microthruster
The layout of the zirconia composite microthruster design is shown in Fig. 5 with dimension of 1.7 cm (length) 9 1.3 cm (width) 9 0.5 cm (thickness) and weigh only 6.18 g. The HAN solution was pumped into the reservoir and flows through a microchannel with 90°bends, before entering the reaction chamber. Electrolytic ignition of HAN solution in the reaction chamber produces gaseous by-products that are accelerated through the micronozzle to produce thrust. A Hydrazine milli-Newton thrust (HmNT) weighed 40 grams, developed by JPL for high DV manoeuvres in a cubesat (\ 3 kg) produces 130 mN (Mueller et al. 2008) was used for scale up for microthrusters in nanosatellites. A factor of 3 of scale up shows that approximately 390 mN is required for similar applications in a nanosatellite (\ 10 kg).
The micronozzle design in the microthruster is based on a design previously developed in our research graoup. Detailed descriptions on the design processes of  (Cheah and Chin 2011). Design parameters of the existing micronozzle were revised accordingly and summarized in Table 2, to generate a target thrust of 360 mN. The converging part of the nozzle has a half angle of 30°. Expansion ratio of the thruster is 4.4 while the throat depth was kept at 300 lm. Previous numerical studies (Cheah and Chin 2011) have concluded that higher diverging angle, i.e. 30°, has reduced the viscous loss, which subsequently improve the efficiency of micronozzle operating at low Reynolds number. However, the Reynolds number at nozzle throat has increased to 24,704 as the micronozzle was scaled up for higher thrust, hence the diverging angle of the micronozzle was reduced to the typical value of 15°.

Surface contour of ceramic microthruster
Dispersion of graphene in YSZ composite is critical since the YSZ-graphene paths were used as electrodes. Before sealing the device, both ATZ and YSZ-graphene were examined under SEM to ensure even distribution of graphene and avoid stacking. Figure 6 shows the SEM images of ATZ and a graphene flake among YSZ, respectively. Figure 7 shows different sections of the ATZ microthruster. All design features including the propellant reservoir, combustion chamber, injector and micronozzle were successfully molded. A closer inspection reveals the capability of this technique to produce vertical smooth sidewalls. However, geometrical irregularity was occasionally observed, as shown in Fig. 7a. The presence of irregularities in non-critical components of the thruster is within the tolerance limit. It is noteworthy that geometrical dimensions of the micronozzle have been upscaled by 15% from the design values to account for the expected shrinkage of 10-15% during the sintering process (Cheah and Chin 2013). After comparing the dimension of five (5) micronozzles before and after the sintering, the shrinkage is evaluated as 15% in average. Quantifying measurements on the nozzle throat width and height after different fabrication processes were conducted and summarized in Table 3.

Performance evaluation of the microthruster
As shown in Fig. 8, the thrust profiles at low (20 ll/s and 40 ll/s) and high flowrates (60 ll/s and 80 ll/s) can be divided into 4 stages. First stage refers to a 6 s initial delay before the electrolytic decomposition of HAN solution Fig. 5 a Design of ATZ microthruster. b Green layers of the device after demoulding. Layer 1 is the top layer drilled with three holes and layer 2 is the bottom layer with the microchannel configuration. The microthruster was formed by folding both layer 1 and 2 towards each other. Hence the side walls of the reaction chamber acts as the electrodes starts. The second stage is the thrust generation stage, in which the HAN solution decomposes into hot gases. The thrust level increases steadily until a maximum value is reached. In the third stage, thrust level drops from the maximum value. After a few seconds, the thrust level achieves its steady state. In this study, the maximum thrust achieved increases proportionally to the flowrate as anticipated, as shown in Fig. 8e. A maximum thrust of 180.53 mN was recorded at flowrate of 60 ll/s. However, the steady state thrust remains rather constant at approximately 50 mN. This implies that the electrolytic technique is only effective in initiating the decomposition of HAN solution but not able to sustain the reaction when HAN solution was fed into the thruster continuously. The increasing amount of gases  produced from electrolytic decomposition has disrupted the continuity in deposition of electrical energy into the HAN solution. This is justified as unreacted HAN solution was observed flowing out from the micronozzle exit during the experiment.
There are two reasons contributing to the thrust fluctuation. First, accumulation and sudden discharge of gas bubbles in the reaction chamber towards the micronozzle due to variation of hydrodynamics condition in the upstream in reaction chamber (Chai et al. 2016). The condition was due to the sinusoidal pumping behaviour of the syringe pump.
The maximum thrust achieved in this study is only 50% of the design thrust (180.53 mN against 361 mN), suggesting the electrolytic decomposition alone is insufficient to achieve complete consumption of the flowing HAN solution. Although using of catalyst is common in macroscaled chemical propulsion system, pre-heating of catalyst bed requires substantial electrical energy, making it unfavourable for microthrusters in nanosatellites. Further improvement could be made to combine the electrolytic and catalytic techniques. Electrolytic ignition technique can be used in the initial stage to partially decompose the HAN solution into warm liquid-gas mixture, followed by flowing into a catalyst bed for complete decomposition to generate thrust.

SEM analysis on microthrustrer after electrolytic decomposition
The SEM analysis was only limited to ATZ but not the YSZ-graphene layer because its area in contact with HAN is limited to a thin layer at the wall. An original ATZ surface is shown in Fig. 9a, with clear and smooth surface. Figure 9b, c are two different reaction chamber surfaces after 2 min and 5 min of electrolytic decomposition of HAN at 60 ll/s, respectively. Figure 9b has some spheres and pits, and appears to be octahedral crystals while the surface fired while Fig. 9c has micron-sized platelets covering the surface. The phenomena on the ATZ samples are similar to that of hot corrosion (Schacht et al. 1998;Park et al. 2005;Manning et al. 2015), in which tetragonal phase of the zirconia was transformed into monolithic phase. The associated microcracks provides paths for minor leakage of gas products which reduces the pressure inside the reaction chamber. As such, this preliminary study indicates that further improvement is necessary to extend the operational lifetime of the ceramic microthruster. The sintering temperature could be increased to 1400-1500°C. Higher sintering temperature was proved to be effective in reducing the internal porosities and increases the thermo-mechanical properties, e.g. hardness has increased for as high as 20% for ATZ sintered at 1400°C (Kern and Gadow 2012).

Conclusions
In this paper, a microthruster fabricated with ATZ and YSZ-graphene has been demonstrated. YSZ-graphene is not only served as electrodes for electrolytic decomposition of HAN solution but also playing a role in damping. Thermal-vacuum analysis and dynamic mechanical analysis were conducted to evaluate the change in material properties under simulated space environments. Thrust generated by the ceramic microthruster at different flowrates was measured using a load cell. The maximum thrust achieved is 180.53 mN at flowrate of 60 ll/s. The thrust measurement experiment reveals the incomplete decomposition of HAN solution using electrolytic technique alone. Nevertheless, the experimental results suggest that electrolytic technique could be combined with the conventional catalytic technique for a complete combustion of HAN solution which releases more energy and subsequently generates higher thrust.
The ceramic microthruster weights only 6.18 g and able to generate thrust above 100 mN. After the discovered issues in decomposition of HAN solution are addressed, a high thrust-to-weight ratio microthruster could be realized in the future. Such microthruster has potential applications as primary propulsion system for rapid orbital transfer in constellation formation flying of satellites.