Silicon 45° micromirrors fabricated by etching in alkaline solutions with organic additives

The fabrication of 45° micromirrors by silicon anisotropic etching in potassium hydroxide (KOH) and tetramethylammonium hydroxide (TMAH) solutions containing organic additives is investigated in this paper. The reflective planes are formed by {110} sidewall planes inclined at 45° towards the Si (100) wafer. Isopropyl alcohol and Triton X-100 surfactant are used as additives, because they are supposed to provide the etch rate ratio R(100)/R(110) > 1, which is necessary for {110} sidewalls development. The fabricated spatial microstructures with 45° sidewalls are examined in terms of the {110} surface roughness and the quality of the {110} sidewall profile. The KOH solution saturated with the alcohol gives the striped {110} surface, though the stripes almost disappear after addition of Triton surfactant to KOH and TMAH etchants. The 45° sidewall profiles fully defined by {110} planes are obtained in KOH as well as TMAH solutions containing additives. The measurements of micromirrors’ reflectivity indicate that replacement of the alcohol by Triton surfactant in the KOH solution reduces the optical power loss caused by the reflection. The achieved reflectivity is comparable with the one obtained by etching in the TMAH solution with surfactant.


Introduction
Wet chemical anisotropic etching of silicon is widely used for bulk micromachining in MEMS and MOEMS technology because of the relatively low cost of the process and the exact geometries of the fabricated microstructures. The anisotropic etching method is especially interesting for manufacturing of micromirrors inclined at 45°towards the substrate. Such micromirrors, which provide 90°out-ofplane reflection, can be applied for optical switching or interconnecting (Helin et al. 2000;Yang et al. 2007;Hsiao et al. 2009;Xu et al. 2010). In the commercially available Si (100) wafer, the micromirrors' inclination of 45°t owards the bottom surface can be defined by {110} sidewall planes. Moreover, the 45°micromirrors can be fabricated together with V-grooves for optical fibers alignment in a one technological step (see Fig. 1). The main goal of this technology is to achieve smooth mirror-like {110} surfaces and micromirror sidewalls fully defined by 45°{ 110} planes.
The {110} planes can develop in the sidewalls on condition that the edges of the etching mask are aligned perpendicularly to h100i directions and the etch rate ratio R(100)/R(110) is higher than one. The fulfillment of the latter condition depends on the composition of etching solution. The solutions containing surface active organic compounds (such as alcohols and surfactants) are often used for fabrication of {110} sidewalls. The molecules of the compounds are supposed to preferentially adsorb on the {110} surface, hindering access of the reactants and, thus, slowing down the etching process. As a result, the {110} planes can develop in the sidewalls in h100i directions (see Fig. 2).
The {110} sidewalls were obtained in ethylenediamine pyrocatechol (EDP) and potassium hydroxide/isopropyl alcohol [KOH/IPA (also called isopropanol)] mixtures, in which the etch rate ratio R(100)/R(110) [ 1 occurred (Backlund and Rosengren 1992;Strandman et al. 1995 (Rola and Zubel 2011a, b;. The certain improvement of the smoothness of {110} planes appeared in the KOH solutions with alcohols below the saturation level, but the (100) surfaces were covered pyramidal hillocks Rola and Zubel 2013). What is more, maintaining the constant composition of the non-saturated solution would be problematic.
The tetramethylammonium hydroxide (TMAH) solution containing Triton X-100 nonionic surfactant was proposed for silicon etching by Resnik et al. (2005). This etching mixture allowed one to obtain high etch rate ratio R(100)/ R(110) and relatively smooth {110} sidewalls. Another nonionic surfactant NCW-1002 was also applied for TMAH etching of {110} micromirrors (Xu et al. 2010(Xu et al. , 2011Yagyu et al. 2010). The etching processes resulted in smooth {110} planes, though the rounded profile of {110} sidewalls in the cross section was reported by Xu et al. (2011).
In this paper, Triton X-100 surfactant is suggested as an additive to KOH solution in the 45°micromirrors fabrication process. Because of the lower price, the KOH solution could be an alternative to TMAH etchant. The microstructures with 45°sidewalls fabricated in the KOH/ Triton solutions are compared to the ones obtained in the KOH/IPA and TMAH/Triton etching systems. The surface morphology and the profile quality of {110} sidewall planes as well as reflectivity of {110} mirrors are taken into consideration.
2 Experimental details P-type silicon wafers with (100) and (110)  The low concentration of (2 M) KOH solution was chosen because it proved to produce the best parameters of 45°micromirrors (Rola and Zubel 2011b), while the 25 % TMAH solution with Triton concentration close to 200 ppm was reported to provide the high etch rate ratio R(100)/R(110) and the smooth 45°mirror planes (Resnik et al. 2005). The amounts of Triton for the KOH solutions were selected during the authors' preliminary experiments.
The etching processes were conducted at 75°C in the case of the KOH/IPA and TMAH/Triton solutions and at Additionally, to investigate the effect of Triton on the {110} surface, the (110) wafers were etched in the agitated 3 M KOH solution saturated with IPA and unagitated 2 M KOH solution containing 30 ppm of Triton surfactant, at 75°C. The surface roughness and morphology of these surfaces was examined using atomic force microscopy (AFM).
The fabricated {110} micromirror sidewalls were characterized in terms of their reflective properties. Light beam with 1,550 nm wavelength was generated by SANTEC tunable laser with tuning wavelengths accuracy at 1 pm. The beam was directed into the sample by pigtailed single mode fiber, aligned in the sample's groove to obtain the maximum value of optical power. Fiber's end used in the characterization setup was prepared by electrical splicer. The light reflected from the micromirror at an angle of 90°w as directed to a microscope through magnifying optics which were also used to control fiber positioning accuracy in the grooves. In the next step the optical signal was collected by the InGaAs photodetector with spectral range of 700-1,800 nm and then analyzed by a digital oscilloscope. Optical power intensity reflected from micromirror was directly proportional to the voltage read from the oscilloscope. Reference measurement of a groove without micromirror was performed in the same way. The scheme of the measurement system is shown in Fig. 3.

Results and discussion
The results of AFM measurements of Si (110) surfaces etched in two different solutions are shown in Fig. 4. The surface morphology of (110) surface displays a striped pattern after etching in the KOH solution saturated with isopropanol. However, the surface is smoothed and the average surface roughness (Ra) is decreased in the KOH solution with Triton. These AFM measurements indicate that Triton surfactant could be used instead of IPA for fabrication of smooth {110} micromirrors of 45°inclination. Figure 5 presents the SEM images of the grooves with reflective {110} sidewall planes at their ends fabricated by anisotropic etching in solutions of different compositions. The {110} planes are patterned with stripes after etching in the KOH solution with isopropanol, whereas the striped pattern is considerably less pronounced in the TMAH/ Triton solution. These results are in a good agreement with those reported in the literature (Backlund and Rosengren 1992;Strandman et al. 1995;Resnik et al. 2005). The stripes almost do not appear on the {110} surface when 20 ppm of Triton is added to the KOH etchant. Although the (100) surface is covered with hillocks, they are relatively small and, therefore, would be rather negligible when an optical fiber was aligned in the groove. Increasing of Triton concentration from 20 to 60 ppm reduces the hillocks coverage and further smoothes the {110} surface, but the spatial microstructure becomes less regular in the {111} corner. Generally, the {111} planes are well developed in the case of the KOH/Triton solutions. As a  The views of {110} sidewall profiles are shown in Fig. 6. In the case of the KOH/IPA and TMAH/Triton solutions, the sidewalls are fully defined by {110} planes inclined at 45°towards the (100) bottoms. When the Triton surfactant is added to KOH, the {110} sidewalls also make practically perfect angles of 45°with the (100) surfaces, though slight deviations can be observed at the bottom and the top of the sidewalls.
The results of reflectivity measurements of fabricated 45°{110} micromirrors are shown in Fig. 7. The use of Triton surfactant instead of IPA in the KOH solution gives the significant improvement of reflectivity of the micromirrors (from about 45 to 47 %). This is not surprising since the surface roughness of the {110} planes are considerably reduced (compare Fig. 4a with b and Fig. 5a with c). When the surfactant concentration is increased, the reflectivity rises (up to about 50 %), which can also be explained in terms of the surface roughness reduction (compare Fig. 5c with d).
In general, the reflectivity obtained in the KOH/Triton solutions is comparable with that achieved in the TMAH/ Triton mixture (about 49 %), which makes the former etchant composition potentially attractive for 45°micromirrors fabrication. KOH is less expensive than TMAH, which can be important in the mass production of MOEMS devices. On the other hand, the low etch rate of the (100) plane in the KOH solutions with Triton (see Table 1) is a certain drawback of this etching mixture, because it would slow down the fabrication process. The relatively large development of {111} planes in the corners of the grooves in the KOH/Triton solutions might also be a problem, but this would not matter if the V-groove array with the common 45°micromirror was used (Hsiao et al. 2009).
The reflectivity about 50 % obtained in the KOH solution with 60 ppm of Triton seems to be a good result if one realizes that silicon surface reflectivity is generally not high. For example, the reflectivity of {111} planes up to 60 % at the same light wavelength was achieved in the KOH solution by Sadler et al. (1997). The {111} planes are commonly considered to be the smoothest after wet anisotropic etching. Hence, the reflectivity of 45°F   Due to the low cost of KOH/Triton solution could be an alternative to TMAH/Triton mixture for fabrication of silicon 45°micromirrors. The drawback of the former solution composition is the comparatively low etch rate of (100) plane, which should be overcome in the future research. The effort to further increase the reflectivity of the micromirrors should be made as well.