Characterization of neurogenic niches in the telencephalon of juvenile and adult sharks

Neurogenesis is a multistep process by which progenitor cells become terminally differentiated neurons. Adult neurogenesis has gathered increasing interest with the aim of developing new cell-based treatments for neurodegenerative diseases in humans. Active sites of adult neurogenesis exist from fish to mammals, although in the adult mammalian brain the number and extension of neurogenic areas is considerably reduced in comparison to non-mammalian vertebrates and they become mostly reduced to the telencephalon. Much of our understanding in this field is based in studies on mammals and zebrafish, a modern bony fish. The use of the cartilaginous fish Scyliorhinus canicula (representative of basal gnathostomes) as a model expands the comparative framework to a species that shows highly neurogenic activity in the adult brain. In this work, we studied the proliferation pattern in the telencephalon of juvenile and adult specimens of S. canicula using antibodies against the proliferation marker proliferating cell nuclear antigen (PCNA). We have characterized proliferating niches using stem cell markers (Sex determining region Y-box 2), glial markers (glial fibrillary acidic protein, brain lipid binding protein and glutamine synthase), intermediate progenitor cell markers (Dlx2 and Tbr2) and markers for migrating neuroblasts (Doublecortin). Based in the expression pattern of these markers, we demonstrate the existence of different cell subtypes within the PCNA immunoreactive zones including non-glial stem cells, glial progenitors, intermediate progenitor-like cells and migratory neuroblasts, which were widely distributed in the ventricular zone of the pallium, suggesting that the main progenitor types that constitute the neurogenic niche in mammals are already present in cartilaginous fishes. Electronic supplementary material The online version of this article (10.1007/s00429-020-02038-1) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.


Introduction
Neurogenesis can be defined as a series of developmental events leading to a new neuron (Götz and Huttner 2005;Espósito et al. 2005;Hevner et al. 2006). This definition involves the existence of progenitor cells that progressively restrict their proliferative potential and number of possible fates to become a terminally differentiated neuron (Hevner et al. 2006). During mouse development, neural progenitors within the dorsal telencephalon generate excitatory glutamatergic projection neurons of the cortex and the olfactory bulb (Gorski et al. 2002;Sequerra et al. 2016), while progenitors in the ventral telencephalon generate GABAergic inhibitory interneurons that migrate tangentially to the cortex (for review, see Marín and Rubenstein 2001;Achim et al. 2014). Despite it was believed that the neurogenic process was only restricted to the developmental period, in the past 60 years it has been discovered that, in some species, adult individuals also present constitutive neurogenesis. In the mammalian brain, adult neurogenesis in the telencephalon takes place mainly in two regions: the subgranular zone (SGZ) of the dentate gyrus of the hippocampus (first described by Altman 1963) and the subventricular zone (SVZ) of the lateral walls of the telencephalic ventricles (first described by Altman M. A. Rodríguez and Eva Candal have equally contributed to this work.
In the adult telencephalic niche of mammals, new-born neurons are generated from adult neural stem cells (aNSCs) also termed adult neural progenitor cells (Ming and Song 2011;Martínez-Cerdeño and Noctor 2018). Adult progenitors in mouse have been extensively characterized. Two models about the identity of these precursors were initially postulated (Ming and Song 2011): (1) progenitor cells are radial glial cells that express both astroglial and stem cell markers (Álvarez-Buylla and Lim 2004;Ma et al. 2009); (2) progenitor cells are not radial glial cells and they express stem cell markers such as Sex determining region Y-box 2 (Sox2; Suh et al. 2007). Later, it has been discovered that both models are not mutually excluding but rather complementary, revealing the wide diversity of adult progenitor types (Bonaguidi, et al. 2012), and the need to deepen in the characterization of progenitor cells in the adult brain.
Nowadays, it is accepted that adult progenitor cells in the telencephalon of mammals can be subdivided in radial glia-like and non-radial progenitors. Radial glia-like progenitor cells have the capacity of self-renewal, show longterm maintenance of the undifferentiated state and generate different kind of neurons (Bonaguidi et al. 2016). Radial glia-like progenitor cells occasionally divide and generate non-radial progenitors (Bonaguidi et al. 2012). However, they normally exhibit a relatively quiescent state. This type of cells is known as B cells in the SVZ and as Type-1 cells in the SGZ (Doetsch et al. 1997(Doetsch et al. , 1999Seri et al. 2004;Ming and Song 2011;Bond et al. 2015;Bonaguidi et al. 2016;Lim and Alvarez-Buylla 2016). These progenitors express the glial fibrillary acidic protein (GFAP), the brain lipid binding protein (BLBP), glutamine synthase (GS) and Sox2, among others (Götz 2013). On the other hand, non-radial progenitor cells are transit-amplifying cells (Martínez-Cerdeño and Noctor 2018) or intermediate progenitor cells (IPCs). IPCs are actively dividing cells that lack radial processes and they express proliferating and neuronal lineage markers that depend on their future phenotype (Suh et al. 2007;Lugert et al. 2010): GABAergic progenitors express the Distal-less homolog homeobox gene Dlx2 and glutamatergic progenitors express the T-box transcription factor Tbr2 (Hodge et al. 2012;Lim and Alvarez-Buylla 2016). These cells are known as C cells in the SVZ and as Type-2 cells in the SGZ (Doetsch et al. 1997(Doetsch et al. , 1999Seri et al. 2004;Steiner et al. 2006;Ming and Song 2011;Bond et al. 2015;Bonaguidi et al. 2016;Lim and Alvarez-Buylla 2016). IPCs undergo mitosis generating more IPCs or two migratory neuroblasts. These neuroblasts leave the neurogenic niche and migrate to their final destinations in the brain. In the case of the SVZ, these neuroblasts are called A cells and migrate following a particular tangential pathway to the olfactory bulb called rostral migratory stream (RMS; reviewed by Lim and Alvarez-Buylla 2016). In the SGZ, these cells are referred to as Type-3 cells and migrate locally to their final destination in the hippocampus. Both neuroblasts of the SVZ and SGZ express the same lineage markers than the IPCs. The expression of neuronal lineage markers as the cytoskeletal proteins Doublecortin (DCX) and the polysialylated-neural cell adhesion molecule (PSA-NCAM) are usually used as markers of migratory neuroblasts. The absence of proliferation markers in these cells allows to differentiate postmitotic neuroblasts from progenitor cells (Hodge et al. 2012).
In mammals, adult progenitor cells from the SGZ give rise to new glutamatergic granule neurons that eventually will be integrated into the existing hippocampal circuitry. Instead, progenitors from the SVZ produce multiple lineages of new neurons that include dopaminergic, GABAergic and a recently described subset of glutamatergic neurons, all of which migrate through the RMS to populate several areas of the olfactory bulb (Brill et al. 2009;Hodge et al. 2012 and references therein).
While it was believed that the adult SVZ was restricted to the wall of the lateral ventricle facing the striatum (lateral wall), parts of the lateral ventricular wall facing the septum (medial wall), or the pallium (dorsal wall), also contain stem cells (for review, see Lledo et al. 2008). Stem cell targeting studies and cell grafting or transcription factor-based fate mapping of progenitors suggest that SVZ microdomains are derived from their embryonic counterparts and that the primary progenitors within the various domains of the SVZ are pre-programmed at birth to generate different subsets of olfactory bulb neurons (Kohwi et al. 2007;Merkle et al. 2007;Ventura and Goldman 2007;Young et al. 2007;Azim et al. 2016). Interestingly, a large fraction of postnatal SVZ progenitors derived from dorsal territories (where only glutamatergic neurons are generated during embryogenesis) participated in the generation of olfactory bulb interneurons (Kohwi et al. 2007;Merkle et al. 2007;Ventura and Goldman 2007;Cai et al. 2013;Obernier and Alvarez-Buylla 2019). It has been hypothesized that the same progenitor cell population that generates glutamatergic neurons during embryonic development can also generate GABAergic neurons during postnatal stages (see Sequerra et al. 2013).
Adult neurogenesis has also been studied in the telencephalon of other non-mammalian species such as birds (Goldman and Nottebohm 1983;Nordeen and Nordeen 1988a, b;Álvarez-Buylla et al. 1990Álvarez-Buylla et al. , 1992Álvarez-Buylla et al. , 1998Walton et al. 2012;Mazengenya et al. 2018), reptiles (Pérez-Cañellas andGarcía-Verdugo 1996;Font et al. 2001), amphibians (Simmons et al. 2008;Kirkham et al. 2014;Joven and Simon 2018) and fish (Adolf et al. 2006;Grandel et al. 2006;Zupanc 2006;März et al. 2010;Quintana-Urzainqui et al. 2015; reviewed by Ganz and Brand 2016). Similarities between mammals and these groups have been found regarding the main types of cells found in the telencephalic neurogenic niche and the molecular markers they express. However, their organization within the niche differs among vertebrates. In the SVZ of mammals, B, C, and A cells are located subventricularly lining the ventricular zone (VZ), an epithelial monolayer of non-proliferative cuboid ependymal cells that separates the SVZ from the ventricular cavity (García-Verdugo et al. 2002). In reptiles and birds, radial glia-like progenitors (B cells) and migrating precursors (A cells) have been found within the VZ (usually a pseudostratified epithelium up to four nuclei deep) intermingled with radial ependymal cells (García-Verdugo et al. 2002), but transit-amplifying or IPCs (C cells) have not been described to date. In zebrafish, dividing radial glia, IPCs and neuroblasts are found in the VZ of the telencephalon (März et al. 2010;Than-Trong and Bally-Cuif 2015), which mostly lacks ependymal-like cells.
While in mammals the distinction between progenitor radial glia and differentiated glia is clear, in fish, but also in amphibians and reptiles, the term radial glia has been used to refer both to radial glial progenitors and to radial ependymoglia, which is the main glial cell type present in the mature brain of fish and amphibians (reviewed by Cuoghi and Mola 2009;Allen and Lyons 2018). Although progenitor radial glial cells and radial ependymoglia are cells with different degree of differentiation, in anamniotes both cell types express similar astroglial markers (Kirkham et al. 2014;Than-Trong and Bally-Cuif 2015).
Adult neurogenesis in different species has been suggested to be related to regenerative capacity, learning, spatial, contextual and emotional memories (Augusto-Oliveira et al. 2019 and references therein). Comparative studies have evidenced that the neurogenic capacity in the adult becomes more restricted to anterior regions of the brain throughout the course of vertebrate evolution. Fish are the group of vertebrates with the highest neurogenic potential, which has been linked to a continuous growth of the brain and with a high regenerative capacity (Alunni and Bally-Cuif 2016;Ganz and Brand 2016). However, most studies in fish have been carried out in modern teleost fish as zebrafish, and almost none have been carried out in cartilaginous fish (Quintana-Urzainqui et al. 2015).
The telencephalon of cartilaginous fish is a large nonlayered structure that represents the 50% of the total cerebral mass (Yopak et al. 2015). Contrary to the everted telencephalon of teleost (Nieuwenhuys 2009), the telencephalon of cartilaginous fish develops by evagination as in all other jawed vertebrates, which eases comparative studies. Besides, their phylogenetic position as a sister group of gnathostomes with a bony skeleton that gave rise to land vertebrates makes them essential in assessing the ancestral condition of particular traits in the brain of jawed vertebrates (Rodríguez-Moldes et al. 2017). Developmental studies in cartilaginous fish have evidenced high similarities to mammals concerning proliferating patterns and migratory routes in the developing telencephalon (Carrera et al. 2008;Quintana-Urzainqui et al. 2015;Docampo-Seara et al. 2018). Concerning adult neurogenesis, recent studies have evidenced the existence of abundant cells expressing proliferating markers in the ventricles leading to the olfactory bulbs and in restricted areas of the adult telencephalon. These regions also expressed GFAP and markers of migrating neuroblasts as DCX, which suggest the existence of neurogenic niches similar to those described in mammals (Quintana-Urzainqui et al. 2015). However, a deep molecular characterization of different types of progenitor cells and new-born neurons and their cell organization in the adult telencephalic niche of cartilaginous fishes is lacking.
With the aim of extending the knowledge on the evolution of adult neurogenesis, we have performed a detailed analysis of the proliferating niches in the telencephalon of juvenile and adult specimens of the lesser spotted dogfish Scyliorhinus canicula or catshark, using antibodies against the proliferating cell nuclear antigen (PCNA). Then we have characterized different types of progenitor cells located in the neurogenic niches of the telencephalon. We have investigated the expression pattern of the stem cell factor ScSox2 and the radial glial markers GFAP, BLBP and GS, typically used for detecting progenitor and/or mature radial glial cells in vertebrates. We have also examined the expression of the neuronal lineage markers ScDlx2, ScTbr2 and the expression of DCX to determinate the possible existence of IPCs and neuroblasts and how are they organized within the neurogenic niche.

Experimental animals
We analyzed 15 juveniles of S. canicula from 10 to 25 cm long (early and late juveniles) and 3 adult specimens (50 cm long). Individuals were kindly provided by the aquarium of O Grove (Galicia, Spain). Catsharks were raised in seawater tanks under standard conditions of temperature (15-16 °C), pH (7.5-8.5) and salinity (35 g/L); and suitable measures were taken to minimize animal pain and discomfort. All procedures conformed to the guidelines established by the European Communities Council Directive of 22 September 2010 (2010/63/UE) and by Spanish Royal Decree 1386/2018 for animal experimentation and were approved by the Ethics Committee of the University of Santiago de Compostela.

Tissue processing
Juveniles were deeply anesthetized with 0.5% tricaine methane sulfonate Sigma,St. Louis,MO,USA) in seawater and then perfused intracardially with elasmobranch Ringer´s solution (see Ferreiro-Galve et al. 2012) followed by 4% PFA in Elasmobranch Phosphate Buffer (EPB). Brains were removed and postfixed in the same fixative for 24-48 h at 4 °C. Subsequently, they were rinsed in PB saline (PBS), cryoprotected with 30% sucrose in PBS, embedded in OCT compound (Tissue Tek, Torrance, CA, USA), and frozen with liquid nitrogen-cooled isopentane. Parallel series of sections (18-20 μm thick) were obtained in transverse planes on a cryostat and mounted on Superfrost Plus (Menzel-Glasser, Madison, WI, USA) slides.

In situ hybridization
We applied in situ hybridization (ISH) for S. canicula Sox2, Tbr2/Eomes and Dlx2 (ScSox2, ScTbr2, and ScDlx2) probes. These genes were selected from a collection of S. canicula embryonic cDNA library (mixed stages S9-22) and submitted to high throughput EST sequencing (coordinated by Dr. Sylvie Mazan). Sense and antisense digoxigenin-UTP-labeled ScSox2, ScTbr2, and ScDlx2 were synthesized directly by transcription in vitro. ISH was performed on cryostat sections of juveniles following standard protocols (Coolen et al. 2007). Briefly, sections were permeabilized with proteinase K, hybridized with sense or antisense probes overnight at 65 °C and incubated with the alkaline phosphatase-coupled anti-digoxigenin antibody (1:2000, Roche Applied Science, Manheim, Germany) overnight at 4 °C. The color reaction was performed in the presence of BM-Purple (Roche). Finally, sections were dehydrated and coverslipped. Control sense probes did not produce any detectable signal.

Immunohistochemistry
Sections were pre-treated with 0.01 M citrate buffer pH 6.0 for 30 min at 90 °C for heat-induced epitope retrieval and allowed to cool for 20 min at room temperature (RT). Sections were rinsed in 0.05 M Tris-buffered saline (TBS) pH 7.4 for 5 min and treated with 10% H 2 O 2 in TBS for 30 min at RT to block endogenous peroxidase activity. Sections were rinsed in 0.05 M TBS pH 7.4 for 5 min and incubated approximately for 15 h at RT with primary antibodies (see Table 1). Sections were rinsed three times in 0.05 M TBS pH 7.4 for 10 min each, and incubated in the appropriate secondary antibody (see Table 1) for 1 h at RT. All dilutions were made with TBS containing 15% normal goat serum (Millipore, Billerica, MA), 0.2% Triton X-100 (Sigma), and 2% bovine serum albumin (BSA, Sigma). All incubations were carried out in a humid chamber. Then, sections were rinsed three times in 0.05 M TBS pH 7.4 for 10 min each. The immunoreaction was developed with 0.25 mg/ml diaminobenzidine (DAB) tetrahydrochloride (Sigma) in TBS pH 7.4 and 0.00075% H 2 O 2 , or with SIGMAFAST™ 3.3-DAB tablets as indicated by the manufacturers. For immunohistochemistry against PCNA in adult individuals and PH3 in juveniles, 2.5 mg/ ml of nickel ammonium sulphate was added. Finally, the sections were dehydrated, and coverslipped. Information about the primary and secondary antibodies is included in Table 1.

Double in situ hybridization-immunohistochemistry
We applied double ISH-immunohistochemistry for ScSox2, ScTbr2, and ScDlx2 probes and PCNA antibody. In this procedure, ISH has been performed first, following the procedure described above. Color reaction was stopped by rinsing twice in phosphate buffer solution (PBS) for 10 min each and then in PFA 4% for 45 min. Then, immunohistochemistry was performed as described above.

Double immunofluorescence
For heat-induced epitope retrieval, sections were pretreated with 0.01 M citrate buffer (pH 6.0) for 30 min at 90 °C and allowed to cool for 20 min at RT. Sections were rinsed in 0.05 M TBS pH 7.4 for 5 min and incubated approximately for 15 h at RT with primary antibodies (see Table 1). Sections were rinsed three times in 0.05 M TBS pH 7.4 for 10 min each, and incubated in the appropriate combination of fluorescent dye-labelled secondary antibodies (see Table 1) for 1 h at RT. All dilutions were made with TBS containing 15% normal donkey serum (Millipore, Billerica, MA) 0.2% Triton X-100 (Sigma) and 2% BSA (Sigma). All incubations were carried out in a humid chamber. Sections were rinsed three times in 0.05 M TBS pH 7.4 for 10 min each and in distilled water for 30 min too. Sections were then allowed to dry for 30 min at 37 °C, and mounted in MOWIOL 4-88 Reagent (Calbiochem, MerkKGaA, Darmstadt, Germany). Information about the primary and secondary antibodies is included in Table 1. Eventually, nuclei were counterstained with blue-fluorescent DAPI nucleic acid stain (Vectashield mounting medium for fluorescence with DAPI; Vector, Burlingame, California).

BrdU experiments
BrdU pulse-chase labelling experiments were performed by incubating 1 catshark juvenile (13 cm long) with 5 mg/ml of BrdU in oxygenated artificial sea water for 24 h. Then it was anesthetized and sacrificed by intracardiac perfusion with Ringer solution and PFA 4% and postfixed by immersion in PFA 4% for 48 h. For detection of BrdU, sections were incubated in 2 N HCl for 30 min at 50 °C to denature DNA strands. HCl reaction was stopped by addition of 0.1 M sodium tetraborate and sections were then rinsed in TBS for 10 min before antibody incubation. Sections were incubated with the proper anti-BrdU antibody (see Table 1) at RT overnight and processed for immunofluorescence as described above.

Control and specificity of antibodies
The PCNA antibody has been previously used to label progenitor cells in the brain and retina of catshark (i.e.

Imaging
Fluorescent sections were photographed with the Leica TCS-SP2 scanning microscope with a combination of blue and green excitation lasers. Confocal images were acquired separately for each laser channel with steps of 1 μm along the z-axis, and collapsed images were obtained with the LITE software (Leica). On the other hand, light field images were obtained with an Olympus BX51 microscope equipped with an Olympus DP71 color digital camera. Both fluorescent and light field photographs were adjusted for contrast, brightness, and intensity using Corel Draw X7. Plates also were prepared using the same software.

Cell counting
Cell counting was performed using five juveniles (10-13 cm long) and three adults (50 cm long). The area selected was the VZ of the ventral pallium since it is the area that hosts higher numbers of proliferating cells per surface, both in juveniles and adults (see Fig. 1). In adults, cells showing either weak or intense immunoreactivity to PCNA were counted in a square box of 50 × 50 µm in two selected fields containing high density (HD) and low density (LD) of PCNA-immunoreactive (-ir) cells, respectively. In juveniles, cells were counted in two random 50 × 50 µm fields, since PCNA-ir cells are homogenously distributed. Cells were counted manually, and average and standard deviations were calculated using Microsoft Excel 2016.

Results
The telencephalon of S. canicula has been classically subdivided in three parts: the olfactory bulbs, the telencephalic hemispheres (pair ventricles, divided in pallium and subpallium) and the impar or caudal telencephalon (enclosing an impar ventricle, from the anterior commissure to the caudal part of the optic chiasm; Smeets et al. 1983). In this classic view, the telencephalic hemispheres are located topographically rostral to the impar telencephalon that, in turn, is located rostral to the hypothalamic subdivisions (see Supp. Fig. 1A-C). However, modern neuroanatomy evidences that this view does not reflect the topologically invariant organization of the telencephalon (Nieuwenhuys and Puelles 2016). According to the prosomeric model, the prosencephalon is divided in two transverse segments termed prosomeres (Supp. Fig. 1D, E). The caudal one (hp1) includes the peduncular hypothalamus and the evaginated bilateral telencephalic vesicles (divided in pallium and evaginated subpallium

Proliferation pattern
In the present study we have investigated the expression pattern of the proliferating cell nuclear antigen (PCNA) to determine the presence of cell proliferation in the telencephalon of juveniles and adults of S. canicula. PCNA is present in the interphase of the cell cycle in proliferating cells and its expression is stronger during the S phase (Zerjatke et al. 2017). In juveniles, PCNA-ir cells are mainly located in the VZ of the olfactory bulb, lateral ventricles of the telencephalic hemispheres and in the VZ of the impar telencephalon. Rostrally, in the telencephalic hemispheres, PCNA-ir cells are distributed homogeneously through the VZ of the pallial and subpallial subdivisions (not shown). In intermediate levels of the telencephalon (Fig. 1a, b), numerous PCNA-ir cells are also appreciated, but remarkable differences among different telencephalic regions are observed. First, PCNA-positive cells are considerably more abundant in the VZ of the pallium than in the subpallium ( Fig. 1b-c″).
In addition, differences in the density of PCNA-ir cells are observed along the pallial VZ: the dorsal, lateral and ventral regions of the pallial subdivision exhibit considerably more PCNA-ir cells than the medial pallial subdivision (Fig. 1b,c,c″). Also, fusiform PCNA-ir cells can be detected close to the dorsal pallial VZ (arrows in Fig. 1d). The VZ of the olfactory bulbs have also numerous PCNA-ir cells (Fig. 1e). In the impar telencephalon (Fig. 1f), numerous PCNA-ir cells are observed in the lateral portions of ventricular surface (arrows in Fig. 1f, f′), but the medial region is devoid of PCNA immunoreactivity. Disperse adventricular PCNA-immunoreactive (-ir) cells are detected both in the pallium and subpallium, as well as in the olfactory bulb ( Fig. 1b-e), and their amount decreases in the impar telencephalon (Fig. 1f, f′). In addition, immunoreactive cells can be appreciated in the choroid plexus, specially concentrated in the region that contacts the VZ (arrow in Fig. 1g). Similar patterns of proliferation can be observed in adult specimens (50 cm long; Fig. 1h, i). ◂ Since PCNA expression can be detected not only during the interphase in proliferating cells but also for a few hours after induced cell quiescence (Zerjatke et al. 2017), we have additionally investigated the presence of dividing cells by analyzing the expression of PH3, a mitosis marker. As expected, PH3-ir cells are found along the VZ of the telencephalic hemispheres and they are more numerous in the pallium than in the subpallium (arrows in Fig. 1j).
To evaluate possible variations in proliferation rates as maturation progresses, PCNA-ir cells were counted within the VZ of the ventral pallium both in juveniles and adults. We selected the VZ of the ventral pallium since it exhibits high numbers of PCNA-ir cells. While the density of PCNApositive cells per surface decreases in adult specimens, there are not significative differences in the absolute number of PCNA-ir cells in the VZ between juveniles and adults (see Supp. Fig. 2) and therefore we have used juvenile specimens in what follows.

Sox2 expression pattern
In the adult mammalian brain, two subpopulations of progenitor cells (radial glia and early IPCs) retain the expression of the stem cell marker Sox2 (Bonaguidi et al. 2016). In addition, previous studies in adult zebrafish have reported that, in the VZ of the telencephalic hemispheres, most ventricular cells express Sox2 (März et al. 2010). To investigate whether Sox2 is expressed in the whole ventricular layer or it defines subpopulations of progenitor cells as in mammals, we studied the expression pattern of ScSox2 by in situ hybridization in the telencephalon of S. canicula.
In juveniles, most cells in the VZ of the olfactory bulbs (not shown) and the telencephalic hemispheres (Fig. 2a, a′) are positive for ScSox2. Also, ScSox2 expressing cells are present at the level of the impar ventricular surface (Fig. 2b). ScSox2 expressing cells were absent from the choroid plexus (arrow in Fig. 2b, b′).
Since Sox2 is a marker of progenitor cells (see above) and the presence of PCNA is commonly used to distinguish proliferating from quiescent or postmitotic cells in fixed samples (reviewed in Zerjatke et al. 2017), we then performed double ISH-immunohistochemistry for ScSox2 and PCNA. Numerous double-labeled cells for ScSox2 and PCNA can be observed in the olfactory ventricular surface (not shown) and in the VZ of all pallial areas studied, including the dorsal and lateral pallium (Fig. 2c-c″), the ventral pallium (Fig. 2d, d′, arrows) and the medial pallium (Fig. 2d, d″, arrows). A few double-labeled cells are also observed in the subpallium (not shown). However, numerous ScSox2-expressing cells were PCNA-negative in the VZ of the pallium.

Double immunofluorescence against glial markers
Studies in the adult zebrafish have established that, in addition to Sox2, most progenitor cells in the VZ express glial markers as GFAP, BLBP, and GS, though some of these glial markers are also expressed by non-progenitor glial cells including ependymal cells (reviewed by Than-Trong and Bally-Cuif 2015). Most cells in the telencephalic VZ of the catshark express ScSox2 (see above) and numerous GFAP-, BLBP-, and GS-expressing radial ependymoglia have been previously described lining the telencephalic ventricles in early juveniles of catshark (Docampo-Seara et al. 2019). To see if in the catshark, in contrast to zebrafish, the combined expression of these markers allows to differentiate different types of progenitor cells from non-progenitor cells, we have performed double immunofluorescence against the radial glial markers GS/GFAP and GS/BLBP. Then, we have combined them with PCNA to know if they correspond to quiescent or dividing cells. We have mainly focused our analysis in the medial pallium and in the ventral pallium as representative areas containing low and high densities of proliferating cells, respectively.
Double immunofluorescence against GS and GFAP shows that the vast majority of cells are double-labelled ( Fig. 3a-c″). Positive cells expressing only GS or GFAP are scarce (stars in Fig. 3c-c″) and are located close to each other. On the other hand, double immunofluorescence against GS and BLBP shows that both molecular markers colocalize in the same cells (Fig. 3d-f″), and their expression occurs in the same cell domains (Fig. 3f-f″).
Then, we have proceeded to combine glial markers with the proliferating marker PCNA. Double immunofluorescence against GFAP and PCNA revealed numerous doublelabelled cells in the VZ of the telencephalon. In the rostral telencephalon, where no differences regarding PCNA immunoreactivity were observed along the VZ, some doublelabeled cells have been observed (stars in Fig. 4a-a″). However, in medial levels of the telencephalon, where the VZ of different telencephalic regions exhibits different levels of proliferation, the number of double-labelled cells increases considerably, especially in the ventral pallium, where the VZ seems to be wider than in other pallial regions of the telencephalic ventricle (Fig. 4b-b″). Concerning BLBP, some double-labeled cells can be appreciated in rostral levels, where the VZ show similar thickness. However, at intermediate levels, both in the dorsomedial and ventral pallium numerous double-labeled cells have been found (stars in Fig. 4c-c″ and d-d″, respectively). Here we have investigated whether PCNA-ir cells express markers of IPCs and what cell lineage they generate by studying the combined expression pattern of PCNA/ScTbr2 and PCNA/ScDlx2. ScTbr2 expressing cells can be observed in the olfactory bulb, dorsal, lateral, and ventral pallial subdivisions but only in the ventral pallium they are located close to the VZ (Fig. 5a). ScTbr2-expressing cells were not observed in the medial pallium or in the subpallium. Double ScTbr2-expressing and PCNA-ir cells have not been observed in the telencephalic VZ (Fig. 5a′), though some double PCNA/ScTbr2expressing cells can be observed out of the VZ (arrowhead in Fig. 5a′). ScDlx2 expression in the telencephalon has been observed in the olfactory bulb, dorsal and medial pallium. In the subpallium, ScDlx2 is expressed in the basal superficial area (a derivative of the lateral ganglionic eminence homologue in catshark; Fig. 5b). In the VZ of the dorsal and medial pallium ScDlx2 numerous PCNA-ir cells are located (see Fig. 5b′) and scattered proliferating cells are also present in subventricular positions (arrowheads in Fig. 5b′). Double-labeled ScDlx2-PCNA cells are clearly observed in the VZ (Fig. 5c, arrows in c′, d).
Since a subset of postnatal progenitors in the pallium of rodents participate in the generation of GABAergic cells (see "Introduction"), we performed a BrdU birthdating assay to investigate if pallial progenitors in S. canicula also give rise to cells of the GABAergic lineage (Supp. Fig. 3). Double BrdU/GAD-ir cells are observed in the pallial VZ (Supp. Fig. 3a-a″). However, Double BrdU/GAD-ir cells are not present in the VZ of the subpallium in juvenile specimens (Supp. Fig. 3b-b″).

Expression of a molecular marker of neuroblasts: DCX
As part of the neurogenic niche, a population of migratory neuroblasts have been found in mammals and other species of vertebrates (i.e., Álvarez-Buylla et al. 1998;März et al. 2010;Ming and Song 2011;Kirkham et al. 2014;Bond et al. 2015;Macedo-Lima et al. 2016). For that, we have also investigated the distribution pattern of the microtubule associated protein DCX, a marker of migratory neuroblasts (Gleeson et al. 1999). DCX-immunoreactive cells were observed in both the VZ of the olfactory bulb and telencephalic hemispheres (Fig. 6a-a″). DCX-immunoreactive cells are also observed subventricularly. No immunoreactivity for DCX has been found in the caudal VZ of the telencephalon (Fig. 6b). To further characterize DCX positive cells, we have performed double immunofluorescence for DCX and PCNA. We have observed abundant double-labelled cells in the VZ of the pallium (yellow stars in Fig. 6c-c″). In addition, DCX/PCNA-ir cells are also present at subventricular positions of the pallium (yellow stars in Fig. 6d-d″).

Discussion
The study of adult neurogenesis has been a subject of interest during the past decades, not only in mammals, but also in many different species of birds (reviewed by Barnea and Pravosudov 2011)

between GS/GFAP (a-c″) and GS/BLBP (d-f″) counterstained with DAPI. Photomicrographs at low (a) and high magnification (b) of the dorsal telencephalon showing numerous double-labelled cells in the pallial ventricular zone.
Note the high amount of immunoreactive processes that are arranged radially (c-c″). Photomicrographs at higher magnification of the VZ of the ventral pallium showing the high degree of colocalization between GS and GFAP. Note also that a few cells are only positive for one of the glial markers (stars). Photomicrographs at low (d, e) and high magnification (f-f″) of the ventral pallium VZ showing numerous cells where BLBP and GS are coexpressed. Scale bars : 100 µm (a, b, d, e), 25 µm c, c′, c″, f, f′, f″). ChP choroid plexus; DP dorsal pallium; MP medial pallium; P pallium; VP ventral pallium; v ventricle ◂ types located in the neurogenic niches across vertebrates is provided in Fig. 7.

Telencephalic proliferation across evolution: the origin of adult neurogenesis
One of the most interesting facts of the neurogenic process is that the number of neurogenic niches and proliferating cells decreases considerably throughout evolution (Ganz and Brand 2016). In mammals, neurogenesis is mainly restricted to some regions of the telencephalon such as the SVZ of the lateral ventricles and the SGZ of the dentate gyrus of the hippocampus (reviewed by Bond et al. 2015). In birds, adult neurogenesis has been detected in all major subdivisions of the telencephalon including the high vocal center (HVC; Goldman and Nottebohm 1983) or the hippocampus (Barnea and Nottebohm 1994) that display conspicuous regional differences in cell organization within the niche and in neurogenic capacity (reviewed in García-Verdugo et al. 2002). While the HVC is overlaid by a relatively thin VZ, in the other regions, dividing cells in the VZ tend to cluster in the so called "hot spots", a pseudostratified epithelium which contains diverse cell types. These "hot spots" coincide with areas of the VZ that are rich in radial glial cells and are located close to regions where young migrating neurons are first seen (Álvarez-Buylla and  ). In reptiles (mainly lizards) and amphibians (frog and salamander) the telencephalic VZ exhibits proliferating cells (reptiles: reviewed by González-Granero et al. 2011;amphibians: Simmons et al. 2008;D'Amico et al. 2011;Kirkham et al. 2014). Despite proliferating cells have been found in all the ScDlx2-PCNA (b-d) in the telencephalon of catshark juveniles (Juv). a-a′ Photomicrographs at low and high magnification, respectively, of the medial telencephalon to show that ScTbr2 is not expressed in the VZ of the telencephalic hemispheres where numerous PCNA-ir cells are present. ScTbr2 is highly expressed out of the VZ in the ventral pallium, where some ScTbr2 expressing cells are also PCNA-ir (arrowhead in a′), in the dorsal and lateral pallium, and in the olfactory bulb. Panoramic view (b) and photomicrographs at high magnifications (b′-d) showing the expression pattern of ScDlx2-PCNA in the telencephalon. ScDlx2 is highly expressed in the olfactory bulb, in the VZ of the lateral, dorsal and medial pallium, and in the basal superficial area (b). Note that most of the cells located away from the ventricle only express PCNA (arrowheads in b′). Numerous ScDlx2 positive cells coexpress PCNA in the ventricular zone (arrows in c′ and d) and a few cells expressing only PCNA are present (arrowhead in c′). Scale bars: 500 µm (a, b), 100 µm (b′), 50 µm (a′, c), and 10 µm (c′, d). BSA basal superficial area; ChP chohoid plexus; DP dorsal pallium; LP lateral pallium; MP medial pallium; OB olfactory bulb; SP subpallium; v ventricle; VP ventral pallium pallial subdivisions and in the subpallium, these cells are not abundant. However, in amphibians, there are several "hot spots" (Álvarez-Buylla et al. 1990;Kirkham et al. 2014). In adult teleost fish, the proliferation pattern has been extensively studied in the telencephalon of several species like zebrafish, medaka or killyfish, among others (Ekström et al. 2001;Candal et al. 2005;Zupanc et al. 2005;Grandel et al. 2006, Kuroyanagi et al. 2010Tozzini et al. 2012; reviewed by Ganz and Brand 2016;Mueller and Wullimann 2016). In this group of fish, the number of proliferative cells is drastically higher compared to tetrapod vertebrates and are usually observed as a continuous band of cells rather than being scattered in the VZ.
In the present study, we have investigated the proliferative cell pattern in the mature telencephalon of S. canicula using antibodies against PCNA, which labels proliferating cells (reviewed in Zerjatke et al. 2017). As in teleost fish, in S. canicula the pallial and subpallial VZ exhibit a rather continuous band of proliferating cells, though the subpallium shows a considerably smaller number of proliferative cells than the pallium. Despite we cannot conclude the existence of separate neurogenic niches, we have observed differences in the density of PCNA-ir cells in the VZ of different pallial regions, with higher proliferation in the ventral pallium. Interestingly, in zebrafish, the pallium presents a smaller number of proliferating cells than the subpallium, where cells are densely grouped (Grandel et al. 2006;Mueller and Wullimann 2016). It has been proposed that structures that become postmitotic late in development become more enlarged that structures that are born earlier, that is, that the telencephalon in vertebrates tends to be disproportionally large because neurogenesis in this region is generally protracted (see Striedter and Charvet 2008 and references therein). Early vs. delayed and extended telencephalic neurogenesis in birds has been related to precociality vs. altriciality (Charvet and Striedter 2011). The altricial-precocial spectrum describes the degree of morphological maturation of offspring at the moment of hatching (Álvarez-Hernán et al. 2019). In fish, precocial species hatch at an advanced stage of development, while altricial species hatch at a less developed stage. Though S. canicula is considered a precocial fish, delayed neurogenesis in the adult telencephalon could be related to the disproportionate growth of this structure relative to brain with respect to that observed in other vertebrates (Yopak 2012). However, it remains unexplored if this difference in the proliferation pattern in different telencephalic (pallial vs subpallial) domains results in different allometric relationships of these domains to overall telencephalon size. Besides control of neurogenesis timing, other mechanisms have been proposed to be involved in adult brain size including changes in regionalization during early development and apoptosis within proliferative zones (see Charvet and Striedter 2008;Striedter and Charvet 2008).
In addition, as in other fish (Zupanc et al. 2006), we have found many scattered cells throughout the telencephalon of S. canicula in adventricular positions, which suggest that neuroblasts maintain their progenitor capacity time after they leave the VZ. The fact that sharks exhibit high levels of proliferation in the telencephalon in juveniles and adults (present results) supports the idea that the number of neurogenic niches and proliferating cells decreases in amniotes (Ganz and Brand 2016). However, in contrast to what it could be expected, in lampreys (an ancient, extant lineage of jawless fish) PCNA immunoreactivity disappears at the end of the developmental period (Villar-Cheda et al. 2006). Despite in larvae the number of proliferating cells is significant, after metamorphosis and in the adulthood no proliferating cells have been detected under normal conditions. The presence of a high number of proliferating cells in the telencephalon of the catshark and the absence of proliferation in adult lamprey point to an evolutionary origin of adult neurogenesis in vertebrates in the transition from agnathans to gnathostomes.

Radial glial progenitors in the telencephalon of juvenile sharks
In the adult neurogenic niches of mammals, many cellular types coexist. One of these cells are radial glial-like cells (B cells in the SVZ and Type-1 in the SGZ). These cells have a glial nature and act as progenitor cells in the first steps of the neurogenic process, though they are relatively quiescent (see Fig. 7 Summary of the main cell types involved in adult neurogenesis across vertebrate evolution "Introduction" and Fig. 7). They express glial markers such as GFAP, BLBP, GS, and stem cell markers such as Sox2, among others (Doetsch et al. 1997(Doetsch et al. , 1999Seri et al. 2004;Ming and Song 2011;Götz 2013;Bond et al. 2015;Bonaguidi et al. 2016;Lim and Alvarez-Buylla 2016). In birds, studies using electron microscopy, incorporation and examination of tritiated thymidine (3HT; a mitosis marker) labeled cells has allowed the identification of radial glial cells in the VZ of the telencephalon with stem cell and neurogenic capacity (Álvarez-Buylla et al. 1990(Álvarez-Buylla et al. , 1998. In reptiles, similar electron microscopy studies combined with BrdU and 3HT have identified proliferating radial glial cells in the VZ of the telencephalon of lizards (García-Verdugo et al. 1981;Pérez-Cañellas and García-Verdugo 1996;Font et al. 2001;Grandel and Brand 2013). Besides, studies in turtles also show radial glial cells in the VZ of the adult telencephalon (Clinton et al. 2014). However, these studies do not mention the proliferation rate of these cells. In amphibians, studies in newts have evidenced that the entire VZ is formed by radial glial cells containing GFAP or GS that additionally coexpressed Sox2. These cells also express proliferating markers in the "hot spots", and they have neurogenic potential (Kirkham et al. 2014). However, outside the "hot spots", radial glial cells mainly remain in a quiescent state.
In teleost fish, a detailed study in the telencephalon of zebrafish has identified numerous radial glial cells that express glial markers such as BLBP or GFAP, and Sox2 (März et al. 2010). Some of these cells are PCNA-ir and incorporate BrdU at slow rates, which means that they have proliferative capacity. However, most Sox2-expressing radial glial cells are PCNA-negative, which have been interpreted as quiescent progenitors, a feature of mammalian B cells.
In the VZ of the telencephalon of the catshark, most of the ventricular cells showed a radial morphology and contain GFAP, BLBP, and GS. As in zebrafish, we have observed numerous cells that express ScSox2 and are PCNA-positive. In addition, we also found ScSox2 expressing cells that do not show proliferative activity, which probably represent quiescent progenitor cells. Our results are quite similar to that reported in teleost where quiescent and proliferating subtypes of progenitor radial glial cells have been described (März et al. 2010).
Lampreys also exhibit radial glial-like cells in the adult telencephalon. These radial cells extend processes form the VZ to the pia (as in amphibians and fishes), but they express cytokeratins instead of glial markers such as GFAP (Merrick et al. 1995). However, no PCNA-positive cells have been found in the telencephalic VZ of this species (Villar-Cheda et al. 2006), suggesting that adult radial glial-like cells in lampreys do not have proliferative potential. Of note, studies about proliferation in larvae of lampreys have shown that seasonal changes or lesions lead to a reactivation of proliferation in cytokeratin containing cells in the rombencephalon or spinal cord (Zhang et al. 2014), supporting an ancient origin of radial glial-like cells as progenitor cells in the postnatal neurogenic process.

Heterogeneity of radial glial cells
A heterogeneous proliferation rate of adult pallial radial glia has been reported in zebrafish (März et al. 2010). Whether this heterogeneousness reflects the existence of progenitor radial glia subtypes, a hierarchy in their recruitment cascade or stochastic variations within a single cell population has not been determined (März et al. 2010). Here we have used the radial glial markers GFAP, BLBP and GS to evaluate if different subpopulations of radial glial cells present in the VZ are associated to different proliferation rates. Recently, GFAP, BLBP or GS positive cells with morphology of radial glia have been reported in this species (Docampo-Seara et al. 2019 and references therein), but their proliferative potential has never been investigated in juvenile specimens. Using double immunofluorescence in the catshark we have seen that BLBP and GS label the same population of cells. Curiously, double immunofluorescence between GFAP and GS has shown some cells that were positive for GFAP or GS alone (very rare). Due to the scarcity of these cells and their position of one respect to the other, we think that they may correspond to newborn radial glial cells that are generated to expand the VZ with the natural growth of the individual, and they are not a subtype of radial glial cells. Due the fact that PCNA immunoreactivity was found in subgroups of both GS/BLBP-ir cells and GS/BLBP/GFAP-ir cells we cannot associate a quiescent vs. a proliferative state with the expression of any of the glial markers used in this study.
Recent studies have shown that the VZ of juveniles of catshark present a considerable number of cells expressing GFAP, BLBP, and GS (Docampo-Seara et al. 2019). Surprisingly, in the present study we have found that these cells, in addition, coexpress ScSox2 (presumptive progenitor radial glia). This fact may be interpreted in two different ways: (1) either radial ependymoglia express ScSox2 (i.e., differentiated radial glial cells retain neurogenic potential as has been observed in Müller glial cells in the retina of sharks; unpublished data); (2) or all ScSox2 expressing cells in the telencephalon of juveniles are radial glia progenitor cells, and differentiated radial ependymoglia will differentiate latter in adulthood. Since in sharks, as in zebrafish (Than-Trong and Bally-Cuif 2015), GFAP, BLBP, and GS do not allow to differentiate radial glia progenitor cells from radial ependymoglia, future investigations must be directed towards the search of specific molecular markers of these cell types in this species.

Intermediate progenitor cells based on non-radial morphology, transit-amplifying features and/ or neuronal commitment
Once radial glial cells reactivate their cellular cycle and undergo mitosis, they generate fast cycling progenitors that subsequently generate neuroblasts. Fast cycling progenitors are also called IPCs, transit-amplifying cells or non-radial progenitors (Fig. 7). In mammals these IPCs are located close to the radial glial progenitors and do not leave the neurogenic niche. These fast cycling progenitors can be additionally identified by their decreased expression of glial markers and increased expression of neuronal commitment markers such as Tbr2 (glutamatergic lineage marker) or Dlx2 (GABAergic lineage marker) (Doetsch et al. 1997;Ming and Song 2011;Hodge et al. 2012;Bond et al. 2015;Lim and Alvarez-Buylla 2016). During telencephalic development, glutamatergic projection neurons are born locally in the pallial VZ from radial glial progenitors from early stages (around E11) until around E17, when pallial-born neurogenesis decays to barely undetectable levels (Englund et al. 2005;Arnold et al. 2008). GABAergic interneurons are produced in the subpallial VZ, also from radial glial progenitors, following a similar timing (between E11 and E17; Sultan et al. 2013) and migrate tangentially to the developing pallium (first described by Anderson et al. 1997).
Adult progenitor cells in mammals inherit the regional signature of embryonic radial glial progenitors, therefore the adult SGZ produce glutamatergic projection neurons and progenitors in the adult SVZ mainly produce GABAergic neurons (Fuentealba et al. 2015). However, it is noteworthy to highlight two facts. First, dorsal SVZ progenitors are not completely blocked in their capacity to generate glutamatergic neurons in vivo and give rise to a class of glutamatergic olfactory bulb interneurons known as 'short axon cells' (Brill et al. 2009). Second, while the dorsal SVZ is located in the pallium, progenitors in this region (where only glutamatergic neurons are generated during embryogenesis) have been reported to also generate a specific subset of GABAergic interneurons migrating to the olfactory bulb (see "Introduction").
IPCs have not been found in the VZ of the lateral ventricles of the brain of adult birds by means of electron microscopy and 3HT incorporation assays (Álvarez-Buylla et al. 1998;reviewed in García-Verdugo et al. 2002). In reptiles, the existence of adult IPCs has not been proved. On the contrary, in amphibians, drug treatment with AraC (an IPC killer) and BrdU incorporations have clearly evidenced the existence of cells with transit-amplifying features (Kirkham et al. 2014). In teleost fish, experiments with BrdU incorporations have evidenced the existence of fast dividing cells, that decrease their expression of glial markers and start to express neuroblast markers such as PSA-NCAM, which match the definition of IPCs (März et al. 2010), though the existence of this cell type in zebrafish is underrepresented.
In the present work we have investigated the existence of IPCs in the adult VZ of S. canicula using double IHQ against PCNA and ISH for ScTbr2 (glutamatergic IPCs) and ScDlx2 (GABAergic IPCs). As in mouse, a separation in the origin of the glutamatergic (pallial) and GABAergic (subpallial) cell lineages has been reported during early telencephalic development in S. canicula (Quintana-Urzainqui et al. 2015;Docampo-Seara et al. 2018). In the pallium of juveniles, we did not find ScTbr2 expression in the VZ of the telencephalic ventricles, but rather in the intermediate zone, being especially abundant in the ventral pallium. This contrasts with results in mammals, where dorsal SVZ progenitors give rise to a class of glutamatergic olfactory bulb neurons (Brill et al. 2009), and with results in adult zebrafish, where Tbr2 and Prox1 positive cells (both markers of glutamatergic cells) have been reported in different domains of the pallial VZ (Ganz et al. 2015). The absence of ScTbr2 in the VZ of the catshark (present results) suggests that either glutamatergic IPCs (which are located in/close the ventricle) are not present in the pallium or they do not express ScTbr2, which evidences the need of specific markers for glutamatergic IPCs. Further studies using cell-tracking are needed to clarify this point. In contrast we found ScDlx2 positive cells ventricularly, many of them also positive for PCNA, suggesting the presence of IPCs of the GABAergic lineage in the pallial VZ. BrdU birthdating assays showed some actively proliferating cells (that incorporate BrdU) both in the pallial and subpallial VZ. However, double BrdU/GAD cells were only found in the pallium. In mammals, progenitors in the dorsal SVZ (located in the pallium, where only glutamatergic neurons are generated during embryogenesis) have been reported to also generate a specific subset of GABAergic interneurons migrating to the olfactory bulb (see "Introduction"). Following these results, it has been hypothesized that the same progenitor cell population that generates glutamatergic neurons during embryonic development can also generate GABAergic neurons during postnatal stages and that the micro-environmental changes found during the embryonic to postnatal transition are fundamental for directing SVZ cells to generate olfactory bulb interneurons (see Sequerra et al. 2013). The possibility has been also considered that these postnatal progenitors derive from a subpopulation of quiescent cells that do not 1 3 produce glutamatergic cortical neurons during embryogenesis (Sequerra et al. 2013). Alternatively, the migration of progenitors from ventral to dorsal germinative zones, could also contribute to the switch in the generation of neuronal subtypes in the embryonic telencephalon. During development, extensive cell movement has been reported within the cortical VZ (Fishell et al. 1993). It has been reported that some cortical progenitors during development migrate into the striatum and populate the SVZ where they persist as postnatal striatal stem cells, though primary progenitors labeled in one brain region (including cortex) do not move to another during postnatal development (Willaime-Morawek et al. 2006;Lledo et al. 2008 and references therein). If embryonic subpallial stem cells in S. canicula migrate dorsally and persist as postnatal pallial progenitors and whether these dorsal pallial progenitors generate a specific subset of GABAergic interneurons migrating to the olfactory bulb, as in mammals, deserves further investigation.

Migratory neuroblasts
The third progenitor cell type in mammals is a population of migratory neuroblasts (Fig. 7) that, in addition to Tbr2 or Dlx2, express DCX or PSA-NCAM and can exit the neurogenic niche to reach their final destination in the telencephalon (Doetsch et al. 1997). In birds, the presence of IPCs has not been demonstrated but the increase of DCX immunoreactivity in the adult brain suggest the existence of migratory neuroblasts (type A) derived from radial glial (type B) progenitors (Barnea and Pravasudov 2011;Mazengenya et al. 2018). In reptiles, DCX positive cells have been detected in the adult brain of crocodiles (Ngwenya et al. 2017) and turtles (Macedo-Lima et al. 2016). In amphibians, the high levels of PSA-NCAM surrounding the proliferative ventricle clearly support the presence of neuroblasts (Kirkham et al. 2014). In zebrafish PSA-NCAM positive cells have been found close to the VZ, which have typical morphology and markers of neuroblasts (März et al. 2010). In this study we found both ScDlx2 and ScTbr2 out of the VZ. Besides, DCX positive cells were found in ventricular and subventricular positions, some of them also immunoreactive to PCNA. This clearly suggests that proliferating cells in the mature brain of sharks give rise to new neurons.

The neurogenic niche of sharks and mammals: continuous neurogenesis vs. reactivation of silenced progenitors
During early development the neural ectoderm is comprised of neuroepithelial cells (NECs) that undertake self-renewing symmetric divisions that increase the size of the precursor cell pool (Fig. 8a). Later in development, NECs begin to express glial molecular markers and become radial glial cells. These cells are located in the VZ where they initially undergo symmetric divisions that produce additional radial glial cells and expand the proliferative population in the VZ. Later, these cells undergo asymmetric divisions to generate one self-renewed radial glial cell and one daughter neuron (reviewed in Götz and Huttner 2005). In the cortex of mammals, they can also give rise to neurons or oligodendrocytes indirectly by generating progenitors that migrate to the SVZ, where they divide symmetrically to produce two daughter cells. Progenitors that divide in the SVZ are known as basal or intermediate progenitors. Following their final division at the VZ, radial glial cells become detached from the ventricle and subsequently are translocated towards the pial surface, where they differentiate into astrocytes (reviewed in Martínez-Cerdeño and Noctor 2018).
In mammals, radial glial cells are lost in most brain regions at the end of the neurogenic period, either by symmetric self-consuming neurogenic divisions or by becoming glial cells (Paridaen and Huttner 2014). However, reactivated progenitor cells, both in the SVZ and in the SGZ, exhibit morphologies and molecular markers typically expressed by radial glial cells and astrocytes that lead to suspect that progenitor cells in the adult brain may correspond to embryonic radial glial progenitors that persist in adulthood (see Fuentealba et al. 2015). Indeed, it has been shown that these cells are generated from a subpopulation of progenitor radial glial cells in the embryo. These cells remain quiescent until they become reactivated at different ages in the postnatal brain, leading to a neurogenic process that recapitulates the embryonic neurogenesis (Kriegstein and Alvarez-Buylla 2009;Berg et al. 2019; Obernier and Alvarez-Buylla 2019; Fig. 8a). These subpopulations of cells only persist in particular regions of the telencephalon and therefore neurogenic niches in mammals correspond to well defined areas.
This situation differs from what is observed in sharks (Fig. 8b), since abundant progenitor cells are observed through the VZ of the pallium during the whole life, resembling the situation described in teleost fish (reviewed in Than-Trong and Bally-Cuif 2015). Whether this proliferation pattern is the result of continuous neurogenesis or correspond to reactivation of silenced progenitors has not been explored. However, cell types (identified by morphology, position or neural commitment markers) observed in Fig. 8 Schema showing the cell organization of the neurogenic niche of adults and the neurogenic process from early development to adults in mammals (a) and sharks (b). The schema of the mammalian neurogenic niche was based on data from Ming and Song (2010); the information/design of the progression from embryo to adult was based on data from Kriegstein and Álvarez-Buylla (2009). aPRGC adult progenitor radial glial cell; aNSC adult neural stem cell; ePRGC embryonic progenitor radial glial cell; IPC intermediate progenitor cell; NEC neuroepithelial cell; NZ neurogenic zone; OB olfactory bulb; P pallium; RGC radial glial cell; SP subpallium; SVP subventricular position; SVZ subventricular zone; V ventricle; VZ ventricular zone ◂ 1 3 the embryo are similar to those found in the adult. In fact, we have previously shown that the VZ of the telencephalon is highly proliferative even at late stages of embryonic development (i.e., PCNA and PH3 positive cells have been described along the entire VZ of the telencephalon; Quintana- Urzainqui et al. 2015). In addition, a deep characterization of these cells has shown that most proliferating cells present in the VZ correspond to radial progenitor cells that expressed molecular glial markers as GFAP, BLBP and GS (Docampo-Seara et al. 2019). Results obtained in embryos are highly coincident with those obtained in juvenile/adults (present work), evidencing that the VZ of the posthatching catshark show a cell organization similar to that observed in embryos. This fact indicates that in contrast with mammals, radial glial cells with embryonic molecular features persist in the telencephalic VZ of the catshark, leading to a telencephalic neurogenic niche which is not restricted to a particular ventricular region, but to the entire telencephalic VZ (Fig. 8b).

Conclusions
We have investigated adult neurogenesis under an evolutive perspective by characterizing the neurogenic niche in the telencephalon of catshark. The phylogenetic position of cartilaginous make this group essential in comparative studies to infer the ancestral condition of vertebrate neurogenesis. High rates of proliferation were found in the telencephalic VZ of the catshark, in contrast to lampreys, which points to an evolutionary origin of adult neurogenesis in vertebrates in the transition from agnathans to gnathostomes. We also have shown that the VZ exhibits high numbers of progenitor cells that matches the definition of a B cell (radial and mainly quiescent cells that express ScSox2 and radial glial cell markers). Besides, we have pointed to the existence of putative C cells (IPCs of GABAergic nature). Finally, some DCX-immunoreactive neuroblasts were found to be proliferative (immunoreactive to PCNA), which matched the definition of A cells. Therefore, we show that the main types of cells found in the mammalian telencephalic niche are already present in cartilaginous fish. This study constitutes an important step in the race to unravel the evolution of adult neurogenesis in vertebrates.