Inter-Population Variability of Endosymbiont Densities in the Asian Citrus Psyllid (Diaphorina citri Kuwayama)

The Asian citrus psyllid (Diaphorina citri Kuwayama) is an insect pest capable of transmitting Candidatus Liberibacter asiaticus (CLas), the causal agent of citrus greening in North America. D. citri also harbors three endosymbionts, Wolbachia, Candidatus Carsonella ruddii, and Candidatus Profftella armatura, which may influence D. citri physiology and fitness. Although genomic researches on these bacteria have been conducted, much remains unclear regarding their ecology and inter-population variability in D. citri. The present work examined the densities of each endosymbiont in adult D. citri sampled from different populations using quantitative PCR. Under field conditions, the densities of all three endosymbionts positively correlated with each other, and they are associated with D. citri gender and locality. In addition, the infection density of CLas also varied across populations. Although an analysis pooling D. citri from different populations showed that CLas-infected individuals tended to have lower endosymbiont densities compared to uninfected individuals, the difference was not significant when the population was included as a factor in the analysis, suggesting that other population-specific factors may have stronger effects on endosymbiont densities. To determine whether there is a genetic basis to the density differences, endosymbiont densities between aged CLas-negative females of two D. citri populations reared under standardized laboratory conditions were compared. Results suggested that inter-population variability in Wolbachia infection density is associated with the genotypes of the endosymbiont or the host. Findings from this work could facilitate understanding of D. citri-bacterial associations that may benefit the development of approaches for managing citrus greening, such as prevention of CLas transmission. Electronic supplementary material The online version of this article (doi:10.1007/s00248-016-0733-9) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.


Introduction
Bacterial endosymbionts of insects can profoundly influence their host's biology [1][2][3]. Some bacteria provide nutritional or protective benefits to the host, while others can affect an insect vector's efficiency in transmitting viruses [4][5][6][7][8]. Such findings suggest that insect-microbe associations may be exploited for managing insect pests or insect-transmitted diseases.
Citrus greening is a destructive plant disease caused by the Alphaproteobacterium Candidatus Liberibacter asiaticus (CLas) and other closely related species [9][10][11][12]. The Asian citrus psyllid (Diaphorina citri Kuwayama) transmits CLas in North America, Asia, and Brazil [10]. The sap-sucking D. citri can acquire CLas while feeding on infected citrus. After entering the vector insect, the bacteria can colonize and propagate in its digestive tract. Thereafter, the pathogen may cross the gut barrier and invade the salivary gland, thereby enabling D. citri to transmit the pathogen to another plant Electronic supplementary material The online version of this article (doi:10.1007/s00248-016-0733-9) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users. [13,14]. In addition to this host-microbe association, D. citri also harbors three endosymbionts: (1) a species of Wolbachia, a group of Alphaproteobacteria commonly found in arthropod species [2,7,8,15,16], (2) the Gammaproteobacterium Candidatas Carsonella ruddii, an endosymbiont which may provide nutritional benefits to its host [17,18] and (3) Candidatus Profftella armatura, a Betaproteobacterium capable of producing a defensive polyketide (diaphorin) [19]. In addition to their potential influence on D. citri biology, Profftella and Wolbachia's relative abundances in D. citri correlate with abundance of CLas [20], suggesting that uncharacterized, direct or indirect, interactions may exist among CLas and these endosymbionts.
Infection density contributes to an endosymbiont's influence on its host [21]. Previous studies on D. citri endosymbionts have either measured the endosymbionts' relative abundance (rather than absolute densities), compared endosymbiont abundance without normalization against D. citri DNA, focused on single populations or only targeted one endosymbiont species [16,20,22]. Thus, much of the associations among endosymbionts, their host, and other ecological factors remain unclear. Characterizing host-microbe associations in field D. citri is important not only for understanding its general biology but also for application purposes; the possibility of exploring host-bacterial interactions for CLas control (i.e., paratransgenic approaches) has been proposed and studied [23,24]. Interestingly, a previous study showed that Wolbachia density could vary among field populations of D. citri [16]. Although we could not rule out the possibility that D. citri age and gender contribute to such variation [22], it is unknown whether other population-specific factors (i.e., CLas infection, genetic variation) are also associated with these patterns and whether other D. citri endosymbionts may exhibit similar density variability across populations.
The present study investigated whether insect-microbe associations vary across D. citri populations by comparing the densities of Wolbachia, Carsonella, and Profftella in D. citri adults sampled from three locations in Florida. This research also hypothesized that either: (1) high endosymbiont densities exclude CLas in D. citri, or (2) endosymbiont presence facilitates colonization of D. citri by CLas. To evaluate these hypotheses, the effects of gender, population (locality), and infection by CLas on endosymbionts densities was examined. Alternatively, this study also investigated (3) whether genetic differences among D. citri or endosymbiont populations contribute to the inter-population variability of endosymbiont densities. These variations were evaluated using aged D. citri cultures from geographically separated populations reared under standardized conditions. Results from this study indicated that the densities of all three endosymbionts are population dependent, and that there is a genetic basis to the population effect on Wolbachia density. CLas infection in D. citri was also found more associated with the population differences than with the endosymbiont densities. Findings from this study could improve general and applied understanding of D. citri biology to manage the worldwide and devastating citrus greening disease.
Comparisons of endosymbiont densities were made between two laboratory cultures collected from Lake Alfred and Clermont Florida (Table 1) in order to control for variation associated with age, diet, and environment. The two cultures were reared on Murraya koenigii for over 2 months (approximately three generations) to reduce the proportion of CLasinfected psyllids. M. koenigii is a host plant of D. citri, but not CLas [25]. Adult D. citri from these colonies were allowed to oviposit on 'Swingle' citrumelo [Citrus paradisi MacFaden × Poncirus trifoliata (L.) Raf.] placed in separate screen cages (24 × 12 × 12 in.) in a greenhouse at 28 ± 1°C, 50 ± 10 % RH to reflect typical field conditions. The original (parent) D. citri adults were removed following egg hatch. One-day-old adult female offspring were sampled daily over for 6 days. Females were sampled because they tend to exhibit greater inter-population difference in endosymbiont densities compared to males, as described below. Each individual was flash frozen and stored at −80°C as described above.
Laboratory-reared insects that were not infected with CLas (Lake Alfred, n = 12; Clermont, n = 10; Table 1) were used in the experiments described below. DNA from each sample was extracted following a brief wash with 70 % alcohol using the DNeasy Blood & Tissue Kit (QIAGEN, Inc., Valencia, CA). DNA samples were quantified using a NanoDrop 2000 spectrophotometer (Thermo Fisher Scientific, Lafayette, CO) and diluted to 15 ng μl −1 for subsequent quantitative real-time polymerase chain reaction (qPCR) analysis.

Construction of qPCR Standard Curves
Template DNA was prepared for conserved genes of D. citri and each of its endosymbionts, including the D. citri wingless gene, the 16S rDNA of CLas, Profftella, and Carsonella, and the Wolbachia ftsZ gene (Table 2). To obtain DNA templates required for qPCR standard curves, plasmids containing the targeted gene fragments were constructed. 16S rDNA and ftsZ gene fragments were amplified using primers and PCR conditions described previously (Table 2) [22,[26][27][28]. Gene fragments were cloned into the pGEM-T easy vector (Promega, Inc., Madison, WI, USA) and transformed into E. coli strain JM109 following the manufacturer's instructions. Plasmids for the CLas 16S rDNA and D. citri wingless gene were prepared as described in Coy et al. [26] using pGEM-T easy vectors. Plasmids were purified from overnight cultures of transformed JM109 strains using the QIAprep Spin Miniprep Kit (QIAGEN, Inc., Valencia, CA). Afterwards, 1 μg of each plasmid was digested using PstI (New England Biolabs, Inc., Beverly, MA) following the manufacturer's instructions (in 50 μl reactions). Linearized plasmids were purified from the digestion reactions using the QIAquick PCR Purification Kit (QIAGEN, Inc., Valencia, CA) and underwent serial dilutions for qPCR standard curve assays.

Quantitative PCR Assays
Both the Taqman probe (CLas and wingless, multiplex qPCR) and SYBR green methods (Carsonella, Profftella, Wolbachia) were used in this work ( Table 2). To assure that quantifications of the same target genes were comparable across different qPCR plates, all samples were analyzed using standard curves constructed from the same preparation of linearized plasmid template. Quantitative PCR assays were conducted using an Applied Biosystems 7500 Fast Real-Time PCR System and the SYBR Green PCR Master Mix (Applied Biosystems, Inc., Foster City, CA) or the PerfeCTa qPCR ToughMix, Low ROX (Quanta BioSciences, Inc., Gaithersburg, MD; for Taqman assays). Final primer and probe concentrations were 0.2 μM (for Carsonella and Profftella measurements) or 0.1 μM (for wingless, CLas and Wolbachia assays). One microliter (15 ng) of D. citri template DNA was used in a 25 μl qPCR reaction volume. Three technical replicates were performed for each

Data Analysis
For each sample, the copy numbers of the five target genes in the template DNA were calculated using a previously described method [29]. Subsequently, the endosymbiont copy number was divided by the wingless gene copy number in the same sample. Many of the D. citri samples had extremely low CLas infection levels and were therefore difficult to accurately quantify using standard curves. Thus, CLas density across samples was compared by dividing infected D. citri into high infection and low infection samples using a density threshold (0.02 copies of CLas 16S rDNA per copy of wingless). Correlations among the densities of different endosymbionts and the effects of locality, gender, and CLas infection on endosymbiont densities were determined/analyzed using SPSS 23 (IBM, Inc.). Statistical analyses (correlation analysis, chi-square test of homogeneity, analysis of variance) were conducted on the endosymbiont densities (measured as copies of endosymbiont per copy of wingless). Endosymbiont densities among field-collected D. citri were transformed for statistical analysis using log(1 + x) (Wolbachia) or log (Carsonella and Profftella) to satisfy the condition of normality for analysis of variance (ANOVA). In some ANOVA tests where the test assumptions were violated after data transformation, a more stringent significant threshold was used (P < 0.01); significant factors in these tests were only reported if they meet this threshold. In ANOVA tests where test assumptions were satisfied or only mildly violated, the significant factors were reported when P < 0.05.

Presence and Densities of Different Endosymbionts in Field D. citri Samples
Carsonella and Profftella were detected among all 123 D. citri tested. Only three individuals tested negative for the presence of Wolbachia: one male and one female from Lake Alfred, and one male from Clermont. Additional testing of these three samples using a previously described nested conventional PCR assay [15] also failed to detect the endosymbiont (Fig. S1). Overall, Carsonella, Profftella, and Wolbachia were  Factors significantly associated with each endosymbiont's density are shown on the right. The error bars indicate standard error population exhibited the lowest infection densities as compared with the Lake Alfred and LaBelle populations (Fig. 2). D. citri gender was significantly associated with the densities of Carsonella and Profftella (Carsonella: F = 163.02, df = 1, 117, P < 0.0001; Profftella: F = 15.61, df = 1, 117, P = 0.0001). Infection densities were higher in females as compared to male D. citri (Fig. 2). Wolbachia densities were not significantly associated with D. citri gender (P > 0.05).

Infection Prevalence and Density of CLas Among Field D. citri
Among the 123 field D. citri adults sampled, 72 individuals tested positive for the presence of CLas. The three Wolbachianegative individuals (described above) all carried CLas.
Cross-population comparisons of the CLas measurements revealed that both the prevalence and the density of CLas infection were population dependent (X 2 = 31.97, df = 4, P < 0.05; Fig. 3). Individuals from the LaBelle population had the lowest CLas infection rate while those from the Clermont population had the highest (Fig. 3). Although the Lake Alfred population had fewer CLas-positive individuals than the Clermont population, there was a higher proportion of D. citri infected with high densities of CLas in the Lake Alfred population (high and low infection samples only, Lake Alfred vs Clermont, X 2 = 9.54, df = 1, P < 0.05). When comparing CLas densities across population within each gender, similar patterns were observed (Fig. S2).

Associations Between CLas Infection and Endosymbiont Densities
To investigate associations between CLas infection and the densities of D. citri endosymbionts, D. citri samples were categorized according to their CLas infection status (positive or negative) and their endosymbiont densities were compared (Fig. 4). The densities of Carsonella and Wolbachia were significantly higher in CLas-negative compared to CLas-positive D. citri when 123 samples were pooled for two-way ANOVA using gender and infection status as fixed factors (Carsonella: F = 4.96, df = 1, 119, P = 0.0278; Wolbachia: F = 7.97, df = 1, 119, P = 0.0056). There was also a significant interaction effect for gender and infection status on Profftella density (Fig. 4) (F = 10.5, df = 1, 119, P = 0.0015); CLas-infected females had a lower density of Profftella as compared to uninfected females, while the opposite pattern was observed in male D. citri (Fig. 4b). When analyzed in a three-way ANOVA (population × gender × infection status), there was a significant population effect across all three endosymbionts (Carsonella: F = 15.96, df = 2, 111, P < 0.0001; Profftella: F = 5.1, df = 2, 111, P = 0.0076; Wolbachia: F = 26.5, df = 2, 111, P < 0.0001), yet the effect of the CLas infection status was no longer significant (P > 0.05). When categorizing samples based on the CLas infection density (low, high, or ND) instead of their infection status, the ND (no CLas detected) females tended to have higher endosymbiont densities than the low and high infected females (Table S1). Similar to infection status, the effect of CLas infection density on endosymbiont densities was not significant (P > 0.05) when the data were analyzed using a three-way ANOVA including the population factor. Details of the endosymbiont density values can be found in the supplementary material (Table S1).

Endosymbiont Densities in D. citri Populations Reared Under Standardized Conditions
Laboratory D. citri cultures exhibited Wolbachia densities similar to the patterns observed among field D. citri populations. Wolbachia densities were higher in the Lake Alfredderived D. citri culture compared to the Clermont D. citri culture (one-tailed t test; t = 1.73, df = 20, P < 0.05; Fig. 5). The densities of Carsonella and Profftella did not differ significantly between the D. citri cultures from these locations (Fig. 5).

Discussion
Characterizing factors associated with infection densities of D. citri endosymbionts is a necessary step for understanding these bacteria's influence on the psyllid host. Using qPCR and absolute quantitation methods, the present study investigated the ecology of D. citri endosymbionts across different field populations. The densities of Wolbachia, Profftella, and Carsonella were positively correlated with each other among the field D. citri populations, indicating that the growth of an individual endosymbiont is not significantly inhibited by the growth of others. Among the three endosymbionts, there was a stronger correlation (higher coefficient, lower P value) between the densities of Profftella and Carsonella. It is possible that the growth of Profftella and Carsonella, which both inhabit the bacteriomes of D. citri, may be more synchronized with each other than with Wolbachia. Unexpectedly, even when assessed using the most sensitive nested-PCR assay, Wolbachia was not detectable in three out of the 123 D. citri analyzed. Previous studies reported 100 % Wolbachia infection among D. citri populations in Florida and Brazil [15,16]; however, the present work suggests that rare failures of vertical transmission may occur in the field. Examining larger sample sizes or sampling insects during different times of the year may be necessary to detect their occurrence. The finding of D. citri individuals infected with CLas, but not Wolbachia, also suggests that Wolbachia infection is not a requirement for CLas acquisition. The higher density of Profftella and Carsonella in D. citri females may reflect these bacteria's higher rate of abundance increase with age in females relative to males [22]. It is therefore possible that such effects could contribute to the positive correlations and between-gender differences among endosymbiont densities observed in the field samples.
Although the D. citri gender and age could be factors affecting the endosymbionts' densities, it does not completely explain the inter-population variability observed among the field D. citri samples. For example, if they were the sole factors determining endosymbiont density, one would expect that the density differences among populations (within gender) would be consistent across all three endosymbionts, since all three endosymbiont densities should gradually increase as their host age [22]. Instead, the data showed that while Carsonella and Profftella densities were similar among the males from all three populations tested, the Wolbachia densities were variable. The CLas infection status of D. citri and genotypic variations in D. citri and its endosymbionts are possible factors associated with endosymbiont density. Although the possibility that unique endosymbiont-D. citri associations (originating from genetic differences) across populations might influence D. citri's efficiency to acquire CLas could not be ruled out, the present study falsified the hypotheses that high endosymbiont densities per se either exclude or facilitate CLas acquisition in D. citri (i.e., suggesting that there is no competitive exclusion occurring among endosymbionts and CLas). The results indicated that, although an analysis pooling D. citri from different populations suggested that CLas-infected individuals tend to have lower endosymbiont densities compared to uninfected individuals, the same difference was not observed when the population factor was considered (three-way ANOVA model). This finding suggests that populationspecific factors, such as genetic background, may have a stronger effect on the endosymbiont densities.
Interestingly, we found that differences between Wolbachia densities of the Lake Alfred and Clermont D. citri were consistent between field samples and those reared under laboratory conditions (standardized diet, age, and environment), which supports the hypothesis of a genetic basis underlying Wolbachia density. In other insect systems, genotypes of the insect and bacteria can determine Wolbachia infection density [21,30]. The present study indicates that host-endosymbiont interactions could vary among field D. citri populations and may have different repercussions on their biology.
CLas infection prevalence and density varied among the D. citri populations tested. A recent study indicated that D. citri from southern Florida (e.g., LaBelle) had lower CLas infection prevalence compared to northern Florida populations (e.g., Lake Alfred) [31]. Here, the present study not only detected similar differences in the CLas infection prevalence among the three Florida populations, but also showed that the infection intensity also differ among them. A systemic infection by CLas, followed by invasion of the salivary gland could be necessary for D. citri to become capable of transmitting the bacteria to healthy plants [14]. A recent study also suggested that CLas density in D. citri correlates to their transmission efficiency [32]. Therefore, determining both the density and prevalence of CLas infection in field D. citri may allow more accurate monitoring of citrus greening in the field.
Overall, findings from this work indicate that variations between D. citri populations appear more important than endosymbiont density in predicting CLas infection. Recognizing the heterogeneous host-microbe interactions in field D. citri and different CLas infection densities across populations could provide venues for investigating D. citri biology and developing strategies for citrus greening management, such as methods to intervene in the pathogen transmission process.