Correlation functions in scalar field theory at large charge

We compute general higher-point functions in the sector of large charge operators ϕn,ϕ¯n\documentclass[12pt]{minimal} \usepackage{amsmath} \usepackage{wasysym} \usepackage{amsfonts} \usepackage{amssymb} \usepackage{amsbsy} \usepackage{mathrsfs} \usepackage{upgreek} \setlength{\oddsidemargin}{-69pt} \begin{document}$$ {\overline{\phi}}^n $$\end{document} at large charge in O(2) ϕ¯ϕ2\documentclass[12pt]{minimal} \usepackage{amsmath} \usepackage{wasysym} \usepackage{amsfonts} \usepackage{amssymb} \usepackage{amsbsy} \usepackage{mathrsfs} \usepackage{upgreek} \setlength{\oddsidemargin}{-69pt} \begin{document}$$ {\left(\overline{\phi}\phi \right)}^2 $$\end{document} theory. We find that there is a special class of “extremal” correlators having only one insertion of ϕ¯n\documentclass[12pt]{minimal} \usepackage{amsmath} \usepackage{wasysym} \usepackage{amsfonts} \usepackage{amssymb} \usepackage{amsbsy} \usepackage{mathrsfs} \usepackage{upgreek} \setlength{\oddsidemargin}{-69pt} \begin{document}$$ {\overline{\phi}}^n $$\end{document} that have a remarkably simple form in the double-scaling limit n →∞ at fixed g n2 ≡ λ, where g ~ ϵ is the coupling at the O(2) Wilson-Fisher fixed point in 4 − ϵ dimensions. In this limit, also non-extremal correlators can be computed. As an example, we give the complete formula for ϕx1nϕx2nϕ¯x3nϕ¯x4n\documentclass[12pt]{minimal} \usepackage{amsmath} \usepackage{wasysym} \usepackage{amsfonts} \usepackage{amssymb} \usepackage{amsbsy} \usepackage{mathrsfs} \usepackage{upgreek} \setlength{\oddsidemargin}{-69pt} \begin{document}$$ \left\langle \phi {\left({x}_1\right)}^n\phi {\left({x}_2\right)}^n\overline{\phi}{\left({x}_3\right)}^n\overline{\phi}{\left({x}_4\right)}^n\right\rangle $$\end{document}, which reveals an interesting structure.


Introduction
Recently it has been appreciated that sectors with large charge under a global symmetry of a given quantum field theory enjoy remarkable simplification properties, which allow a systematic and analytic study [1][2][3]. A prototypical example is the O(2) model in d = 3, where, if one is interested in the sector of operators with large charge n under the global symmetry, it is possible to write an effective field theory governing their dynamics. This allows to compute their anomalous dimensions, which are found to scale as ∆ ∼ n This approach in fact uncovers a rich structure, as the sector of operators at fixed charge n is described by an effective theory depending on both n and g (recall that at the WF fixed point, g ∼ ǫ), in such a way that, depending on how the large charge limit is taken, a different behavior emerges. Some aspects of the large n expansion were recently investigated in [4][5][6][7], where the two-point function of the operators φ n ,φ n was computed at large n.
In particular, a general way to organize the expansion was discussed in [5][6][7] (generalizing earlier work in [8][9][10]). The effective description of the large n sector naturally depends on n and g n =λ, in such a way that a 't Hooft-like double expansion emerges. For the dimension of the operator φ n one has In the strong coupling regime -which overlaps with the regime of validity of the large charge effective theory-, one finds ∆ ∼λ 4−ǫ 3−ǫ + · · · , thus recovering the expected scaling ∆ ∼ n d d−1 ,

JHEP01(2020)171
with the extra bonus of providing an analytic expression for the actual coefficients in the large charge expansion [5][6][7].
On the other hand, at weak coupling and in the large n limit, the dominant term is ∆ −1 (λ), which must admit a perturbative expansion for smallλ. This gives [4][5][6] ∆ −1 (λ) = 1 +λ In [4], the leading correction was obtained by a full resummation of the dominant Feynman diagrams -dubbed Kermit L-loop diagrams-that survive in a double scaling limit with n → ∞ at fixed g n 2 ≡ λ. In this limit the sum over Feynman diagrams exponentiates, giving the result This result can also be derived by a saddle-point evaluation of the two-point function, which becomes exact in the double scaling limit with fixed λ = gn 2 [4].
In the double-scaling limit of [4] at fixed λ, the O λ 2 terms are given by Feynman diagrams which are suppressed by powers of 1/n. Thus, from this point of view, the result (1.4) can be viewed as the leading term of the more general double expansion in n,λ.
Large charge expansions also exist in general CFT's with a marginal coupling. An example of a CFT depending on an exactly marginal parameter g YM is N = 2 supersymmetric four-dimensional QCD with gauge group SU(N ) and 2N fundamental flavors. The large charge limit of this theory was first introduced in [11] and studied using supersymmetric localization. Localization leads to exact formulas for a special class of correlation functions of superconformal chiral primary operators, called "extremal correlators". These are correlation functions with an arbitrary number of insertions of operators Tr φ n and only one insertion of Trφ n and they enjoy special properties because of supersymmetry (φ being the adjoint scalar in the vector multiplet of unit R-charge). It was shown that the perturbative expansion of correlators of (Tr φ 2 ) n has a well-defined large n limit provided one takes a double-scaling limit of large n and fixed g 2 YM n. This limit ensures that all terms in the perturbative expansion are finite and non-vanishing. Further aspects were studied in detail in [12,13]. Subsequently, the existence of a double-scaling limit was understood in terms of a "hidden" matrix model description in [14].
The mere fact that it is possible to compute observables of a QFT in a closed form in the large charge sector is remarkable per se. Motivated by this, in this paper, we study higher point functions in the O(2) theory in the sector of operators with large charge. Focusing in the weak coupling regime in the double expansion in 1/n,λ, we compute "extremal" correlators (of the form φ n 1 · · · φ nrφm ) as well as 4-point functions in the "non-extremal" case. As discussed above, in the double scaling limit, these results become exact. We shall use the saddle point method employed in [4].

JHEP01(2020)171 2 Higher point functions in the O(2) model
We will follow the approach of [4], where the two-point function was computed in a doublescaling limit, n → ∞, g → 0 at fixed g n 2 ≡ λ. This limit yields the exact exponentiation of the the leading non-trivial term in the more general n,λ expansion in the large n and weak λ regime. In the case of higher-point functions, we are interested in general correlation functions of the form (2.1) We will assume the following scaling and fixed a i , b j . In the case of the two-point function φ(x) nφ (y) n , it was shown in [4] that in the double-scaling limit all higher loop diagrams vanish except those with a particular topology (the "Kermit the frog" L-loop diagram), corresponding to the case where two lines of each of the L vertices join two of the n lines of the operator φ n and the other two lines join two of the n lines of the operatorφ n . In particular, Feynman diagrams having lines joining one vertex to another one vanish in the double-scaling limit. As a result, the two-point function can be exactly computed by a complete resummation of the surviving L-loop Feynman diagrams. Alternatively, the double-scaling limit can be understood from a saddle-point calculation. This can be easily generalized to the general correlation function (2.1). We first introduce the scaled scalar field (2. 2) The general correlation function (2.1) is then given by where the Euclidean action, including source terms, is given by

JHEP01(2020)171
The saddle-point equations are given by In the double-scaling g → 0, n → ∞, with fixed λ = n 2 g, the cubic term vanishes. The equations simply becomē

Extremal correlators
We shall first consider a special class of correlation functions where the resulting expressions in the double-scaling limit are conspicuously simple. These are the "extremal" correlators The name "extremal" correlators is borrowed from N = 2 supersymmetric gauge theories, where, as explained earlier, correlation functions of this form are special by virtue of supersymmetry. In the present case, there is of course no supersymmetry. Yet, for extremal correlators of the form (2.7), the double-scaling limit is specially simple, singling out the particular topologies generalizing the Kermit diagrams of [4] with the two lines of each vertex being distributed among the r different points. The reason of the simplicity of this correlator is more transparent in the saddle-point calculation, which for this case admits a simple solution. The solution to (2.6) is Note that the factorσ 0 (y) =σ(y) cancels out in computing the action. Substituting this solution into the free part of the action, we obtain This gives The factor m m e −m is the leading approximation for m! (the Gaussian integration in the saddle-point approximation completes the standard form of the de Moivre-Stirling formula m! ≈ √ 2πm m m e −m ).
being µ is a reference mass scale, which in what follows will be set to one (see comments in appendix A).
Combining the free and the interacting part, we finally obtain (2.13) We can now check that this structure is consistent with the expected structure dictated by conformal symmetry. Consider first the particular case of the three-point function, that is, r = 2. With no loss of generality, we can set y = 0. The result can be written in the equivalent form where m = n 1 + n 2 and Higher-point extremal correlators are given explicitly by the remarkably simple formula (2.13). When r ≥ 3, the exponents in the formula (2.13) can no longer be expressed purely in terms of the dimensions {∆ i ,∆} as in the three-point function (2.14). Summarizing, we found the exact "extremal" correlators in the double-scaling limit where all charges go to infinity scaling in the same way. The result represents the resummation of the infinite number of L-loop Feynman diagrams that survive the limit. These are shown in figure 1 and generalize the "Kermit the frog" diagrams described in detail in [4]. The existence of the limit can be understood from the saddle-point analysis, which led to finite expressions that become exact at n = ∞. For large, but finite, charges, the JHEP01(2020)171 double-scaling limit can be viewed as the leading result in a 1/n expansion. The next O(1/n) terms in the expansion may be systematically derived from corrections to the saddle point approximations, obtained from the Taylor expansion of the action around the saddle-point.

Non-extremal correlators
Let us now discuss general ("non-extremal") correlation functions. The general solution to (2.6) is given by One can check that these equations are consistent provided r i=1 n i = s j=1 m j . General correlation functions can be obtained by substituting (2.15) into the action (2.4), (2.5). In what follows we shall focus on the four-point function.
(2. 16) In addition, in this subsection we shall consider the particular case so that n i = m i = n. Then The factor σ 0 (x 2 ) = σ(x 2 ) cancels out when computing the action. Substituting the solution into the free part of the action, given in (2.4), we obtain (2.20)

JHEP01(2020)171
It is convenient to rename (y 1 , y 2 ) → (x 3 , x 4 ) and define r ij ≡ |x i − x j |. Thus we obtain n 2n e −2n (4π 2 ) 2n 1 r 14 r 23 + 1 r 13 r 24 2n . (2.21) Let us now compute the interaction term. Substituting the solutions (2.18), (2.19) for σ andσ into (2.5), we get an expression with nine integrals. Using the formulas (2.11), (2.12) and the integral computed in [16] (see also [17][18][19][20])  The final expression (2.27) has the symmetries under the exchanges x 1 ↔ x 2 and x 3 ↔ x 4 . These symmetries are not manifest in the term with H, but they can be shown to hold using standard properties of Li 2 (x) (see discussion in appendix C of [16]). The four-point function (2.27) also has the expected singular behavior in the channels x 1 = x 3 , , with a power governed by the full scaling dimension ∆ of the operators, including the anomalous dimension. Here we have used the property that S ′ int is regular at any coinciding points, as can be shown using the above formula for H. While the free part (2.21) does not contain any singularity in the channels r 12 = 0 and r 34 = 0 because of charge conservation, due to the interaction there is a behavior (r 12 r 34 ) λ 16π 2 . This behavior was already present in the extremal correlators. The terms with log r 12 and log r 34 in S ′ int exactly cancel out with similar terms originating from H in the limit where either JHEP01(2020)171 r 12 → 0 or r 34 → 0, so there is no extra contribution to this behavior. As a non-trivial check, we must recover the extremal three-point function (2.14) in the limit x 4 → x 3 . We obtain lim where ℓ = r 34 → 0. This reproduces (2.14) for n 1 = n 2 = n, m = 2n, with an extra factor ℓ multiplying r 12 . This factor is to be absorbed into the reference scale µ; see discussion in appendix A. The important prediction of the double-scaling limit is that the O(λ) correction exponentiates. The saddle-point method exactly computes the full resummation of the surviving multiloop Feynman diagrams in the double-scaling limit. The saddle point approximation receives 1/n corrections that we are not computing and reorganize into a more general expansion in powers of 1/n and λ.

Generating functional for the free part
Here we shall compute general higher-points correlation functions for the free theory by computing the generating functional. This will also serve as a cross-check of the free (λ = 0) part of the previous results. We consider the following correlation function: (2.29) The desired (free) correlator (2.1) is then obtained by expanding the generating functional in powers of α i and β j and isolating the term with the required powers n i , m j . Including the source terms, the action is given by The functional integral is Gaussian and can be computed exactly, with no need of taking any large charge limit, by solving the saddle-point equations. These are given by The advantage of working with exponential operators is that the equations have now the straightforward solutions Substituting these solutions into the action we obtain

JHEP01(2020)171
Using this formula, we reproduce the previous results for the free part of the extremal correlators in a straightforward way.
Let us now consider non-extremal correlators. These have a more complicated structure involving several sums of terms, which originate from many new possible contractions arising in Feynman diagrams. As an example, here we consider the four-point correlation function (2.34) We have Expanding in powers of α i , β j and isolating the terms with given powers α n 1 1 α n 2 β m 1 1 β m 2 2 , we find 35) Thus far this is exact, valid for any values of n 1 , n 2 , m 1 , m 2 , with the sum over k restricted to k ≥ 0, k ≤ m 1 , k ≥ m 1 − n 2 , k ≤ n 1 .
Obtaining the correct asymptotic large charge behavior requires some care, as the approximation (n − k)! ≈ n! n −k cannot be applied in (2.35) because this holds for k ≪ n and terms with k ∼ n give a relevant contribution to the sum. To illustrate this, let us consider in particular the case n 1 = n 2 = m 1 = m 2 ≡ n. Then we get where we renamed (y 1 , y 2 ) → (x 3 , x 4 ). This formula is in agreement with the results presented in [21] for the cases n = 1 and n = 2, given by (6.17) and (6.21) in [21] (for a real scalar field). Explicitly, 1 r 2n 14 r 2n The missing term "1" in (6.2) of [21] is easily understood, as it comes from the identity operator which in the present O(2) case cannot be exchanged in the φ(x 1 ) φ(x 2 ) fusion due to charge conservation. As a further consistency check, in the limit x 4 → x 3 we find φ(x 1 ) n φ(x 2 ) nφ (x 3 ) 2n free = (2n)! (4π 2 ) 2n which is precisely the free part of the 3-point function (cf. eq. (2.14) for λ = 0).

JHEP01(2020)171
The exact result (2.36) can be used to cross-check the free part computed earlier in (2.21). The asymptotic large n behaviour can be obtained from the integral representation of the hypergeometric function, which at large n is dominated by a saddle-point (see e.g. [22]). This gives Substituting this formula into (2.36), we obtain (2.39) For large n, this coincides with (2.21).
Open Access. This article is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (CC-BY 4.0), which permits any use, distribution and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author(s) and source are credited.