Abstract
Neutral hydrogen line observations of the extended rotation curves of spiral galaxies imply that there exist significant discrepancies between the luminous and dynamical mass beyond the bright optical discs. This means either that galaxies contain significant quantities of non-luminous matter (matter with a mass-to-light ratio very much higher than that of ordinary stars), or that the law of gravity on the scale of galaxies is not the usual Newtonian inverse square law. Attempts to account for the observed discrepancy in the context of these two explanations are reviewed here with emphasis given to the second and less conventional alternative. It is argued that the standard picture of spiral galaxy halo and disc formation in the context of cold dark matter cannot account for the observed systematics of the discrepancy — notably rotation curves which are seen to be flat and featureless from the bright inner regions where the visible matter dominates the dynamics (in some cases overwhelmingly) to the outer regions where the dark halo dominates. It is demonstrated that in those galaxies with well-observed rotation curves, the discrepancy apparently appears below a critical acceleration. Any dark matter explanation of the discrepancy must account for this fact. Moreover, this would also eliminate empirically motivated modifications of Newton's law in which the deviation from 1/r occurs beyond a fundamental length scale. The suggestion by Milgrom in which the force law becomes essentially 1/r below a critical acceleration (MOND) can account for most of the observed systematics of galaxy rotation curves and, significantly, leads to the observed luminosity-velocity relationship in spiral galaxies (the Tully-Fisher law). Generally covariant theories of gravity which predict this phenomenology in the weak-field limit are described. Although there is not yet a theory which obviously meets all of the requirements for a physically viable alternative to dark matter, a generalized scalar-tensor theory of the form suggested by Bekenstein (phase coupling gravitation) is the currently leading candidate and has the advantage of being testable locally.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Aaronson, M.: 1986, inNearly Normal Galaxies, ed. S.M. Faber, Springer-Verlag, New York, p. 57
Aaronson, M., Huchra, J., Mould, J.: 1979,229, 1
Aaronson, M., Huchra, J., Mould, J., Tully, R.B., Fisher, J.R., van Woerden, H., Goss, W.M., Chamaraux, P., Mebold, U., Siegman, B., Berriman, G., Perrson, S.E.: 1982,Astrophys. J. Suppl.,50, 241
Albada, T.S. van: 1982,Monthly Notices Roy. Astron. Soc.,201, 939
Albada, T.S. van, Bahcall, J.N., Begeman, K., Sancisi, R.: 1985,Astrophys. J.,295, 305
Albada, T.S. van, Sancisi, R.: 1986,Phil. Trans. Roy. Soc. London. A,320, 447
Bahcall, J.N., Casertano, S.: 1985,Astrophys. J. Lett.,293, L7
Bardeen, J.M., Bond, J.R., Kaiser, N., Szalay, A.S.: 1986,Astrophys. J.,304, 15
Barnes, J.: 1987, inNearly Normal Galaxies, ed. S.M. Faber, Springer-Verlag, New York, p. 154
Barnes, J., Efstathiou, G.: 1987,Astrophys. J.,319, 575
Barrow, J.D.: 1987, inA Unified View of the Macro- and Micro-Cosmos, eds. A. De Rújula, D.V. Nanopoulos, P.A. Shaver, World Scientific, Singapore, p. 487
Begeman, K.G.: 1988, Doctoral Dissertation, Univ. of Groningen
Bekenstein, J.D.: 1977,Phys. Rev. D15, 1458
Bekenstein, J.D., Milgrom, M.: 1984,Astrophys. J.,286, 7
Bekenstein, J.D.: 1988 a, inSecond Canadian Conference on General Relativity and Relativistic Astrophysics, eds. A. Coley, C. Dyer, T. Tupper, World Scientific, Singapore, p. 64
Bekenstein, J.D.: 1988b,Phys. Lett. B.,202, 497
Bekenstein, J.D.: 1990,N. Rosen Festschrift, eds. F. Cooperstock, L. Horwitz, J. Rosen, Israel Physical Society (in press)
Bergmann, P.G.: 1968,Int. J. Theor. Phys.,1, 25
Blumenthal, G.: 1987, inNearly Normal Galaxies, ed. S.M. Faber, Springer-Verlag, New York, p. 401
Blumenthal, G., Faber, S., Primack, J., Rees, M.: 1984,Nature 301, 584
Blumenthal, G., Fabler, S.M., Flores, R.A., Primack, J.R.: 1986,Astrophys. J.,301, 27
Bosma, A.: 1978, Doctoral Dissertation, Univ. of Groningen
Brans, C., Dicke, R.H.: 1961,Phys. Rev.,124, 925
Carignan, C.: 1985,Astrophys. J.,299, 59
Carignan, C., Freeman, K.C.: 1985,Astrophys. J.,294, 494
Carignan, C., Sancisi, R., van Albada, T.S.: 1988,Astron. J.,95, 37
Casertano, S., van Gorkom, J.H.: 1989, preprint
Dekel, A., Shaham, J.: 1980,Astron. Astrophys.,85, 154
Efstathiou, G., Jones, B.J.T.: 1979,Monthly Notices Roy. Astron. Soc.,186, 133
Faber, S.M., Jackson, R.E.: 1976,Astrophys. J.,204, 668
Fabricant, D., Gorenstein, P.: 1983,Astrophys. J.,267, 535
Fall, S.M., Efstathiou, G.: 1980,Monthly Notices Roy. Astron. Soc.,193, 189 Mass discrepancies in galaxies 27
Felten, J.E.: 1984,Astrophys. J.,286, 3
Felten, J.E.: 1985,Comments Astrophys. Sp. Sc.,11, 53
Finzi, A.: 1963,Monthly Notices Roy. Astron. Soc.,127, 21
Fillmore, J.A., Goldreich, P.: 1984,Astrophys. J.,281, 1
Forman, W., Jones, C., Tucker, W.: 1985,Astrophys. J.,293, 102
Freeman, K.C.: 1970,Astrophys. J.,160, 881
Freeman, K.C.: 1987, inDark Matter in the Universe, IAU. Symp. 117, eds. G.R. Knapp, J., Kormendy, Reidel, Dordrecht, p. 119
Frenk, C.S., White, S.D.M., Davis, M., Efstathiou, G.: 1988,Astrophys. J., bf327, 507
Gunn, J.E.: 1977,Astrophys. J.,218, 592
Gunn, J.E.: 1982, inAstrophysical Cosmology, eds. H.A. Brück, G.V. Coyne, M.S. Longair, Pontifica Academia Scientiarum, Cittá del Vaticano, p. 233
Gunn, G.E., Gott, J.R.: 1972,Astrophys. J.,176, 1
Hernquist, L., Quinn, P.J.: 1987,Astrophys. J.,312, 17
Hoffman, Y., Shaham, J.:Astrophys. J.,297, 16
Hoyle, F.: 1949, inProblems of Cosmological Aerodynamics, International Union of Theoretical and Applied Mathematics and IAU, eds. J.M. Burger, H.C., van de Hulst, Ohio, p. 195
Jeans, J.: 1923,Monthly Notices Roy. Astron. Soc.,84, 60
Kalnajs, A.: 1983, inThe Internal Kinematics and Dynamics of Galaxies, ed. E. Athanassoula, Reidel, Dordrecht, p. 87
Kalnajs, A.: 1987, inDark Matter in the Universe, eds. G.R. Knapp, J. Kormendy, Reidel, Dordrecht, p. 289
Kent, S.M.: 1986,Astron. J.,91, 1301
Kent, S.M.: 1987a,Astron. J.,93, 816
Kent, S.M.: 1987b, inNearly Normal Galaxies, ed. S.M. Faber, Springer-Verlag, New York, p. 81
Kruit, P.C. van der: 1987,Astron. Astrophys. 173, 59
Kuhn, J.R., Kruglyak, L.: 1987,Astrophys. J.,313, 1
Lake, G.: 1989,Astrophys. J.,345, L17
Lake, G., Skillman, E.: 1989,Astron. J.,98, 1274
Milgrom, M.: 1983a,Astrophys. J.,270, 365
Milgrom, M.: 1983b,Astrophys. J.,270, 371
Milgrom, M.: 1983c,Astrophys. J.,270, 384
Milgrom, M.: 1984,Astrophys. J.,287, 571
Milgrom, M.: 1986,Astrophys. J.,302, 617
Milgrom, M.: 1988,Astrophys. J., bf 333, 684
Nordvedt, K., Jr.: 1970,Astrophys. J.,161, 1059
Ostriker, J.P., Peebles, P.J.E.: 1973,Astrophys. J.,186, 467
Pagel, B.J.E.: 1987, inA Unified View of the Macro- and Micro-Cosmos, eds. A. De Rújula, D.V. Nanopoulos, P.A. Shaver, World Scientific, Singapore, 399
Peebles, P.J.E.: 1969,Astrophys. J., bf 155, 393
Peebles, P.J.E.: 1984,Astrophys. J., bf 277, 470
Primack, J.R., Blumenthal, G.R.: 1984, inFormation and Evolution of Galaxies and Large Scale Structures in the Universe, eds. J. Audouze, J. Tran Tranh Van, Reidel, Dordrecht, p. 163
Quinn, P.J., Salmon, J.K., Zurek, W.H.: 1986,Nature 322, 329
Rindler, W.: 1969,Essential Relativity, Van Nostrand Reinhold, New York, p. 222
Roberts, M.S., Whitehurst, R.N.: 1975,Astrophys. J.,201, 327
Rubin, V.C.: 1986, inDark Matter in the Universe, IAU Symp. 117, eds. G. Knapp, J. Kormendy, Reidel, Dordrecht, p. 51
Rubin, V.C., Ford, W.K, Thonnard, N.: 1980,Astrophys. J.,238, 471
Rubin, V.C., Ford, W.K., Thonnard, N., Burstein, D.: 1982,Astrophys. J.,261, 439
Rubin, V.C., Burstein, D., Ford, W.K., Jr., Thonnard, N.: 1985,Astrophys. J.,289, 81
Ryden, B.S., Gunn, J.E.: 1987,Astrophys. J.,318, 15
Sackett, P.D., Sparke, L.S.: 1989, preprint
Sanders, R.H.: 1984,Astron. Astrophys. 136, L21
Sanders, R.H.: 1986,Monthly Notices Roy. Astron. Soc.,223, 539
Sanders, R.H.: 1987, inA Unified View of the Macro- and Micro-Cosmos, eds. A. de Rújula, D.V. Nanopoulos, P.A. Shaver, World Scientific, Singapore, p. 349
Sanders, R.H.: 1988,Monthly Notices Roy. Astron. Soc.,235, 105
Sanders, R.H.: 1989,Monthly Notices Roy. Astron. Soc.,241, 135
Schweizer, F., Whitmore, B.C., Rubin, V.C.: 1983,Astron. J., bf88, 909
Schweizer, F., van Gorkom, J.H., Seitzer, P.: 1989,Astrophys. J.,338, 770
Silk, J.: 1987, inA Unified View of the Macro- and Micro-Cosmos, eds. A. De Rújula, D.V. Nanopoulos, P.A. Shaver, World Scientific, Singapore, p. 277
Tohline, J.E.: 1983, inThe Internal Kinematics and Dynamics of Galaxies, ed. E. Athanassoula, Reidel, Dordrecht, p. 205
Trimble, V.: 1987,Ann. Rev. Astron. Astrophys. 25, 425
Tully, R.B., Fisher, J.R.: 1977,Astron. Astrophys. 54, 661
Wagoner, R.V.: 1970,Phys. Rev. D, 1, 3209
Weinberg, S.: 1972,Gravitation and Cosmology, Wiley, New York
Wevers, B.M.H.R.: 1984, Doctoral Dissertation, Univ. of Groningen
Will, C.M.: 1979, inGeneral Relativity, An Einstein Centenary, eds. S.W. Hawking, W. Israel, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, p. 24
Will, CM.: 1986,Theory and Experiment in Gravitational Physics, University of Cambridge, Cambridge
Zwicky, F.: 1933,Helv. Phys. Acta,6, 110
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Sanders, R.H. Mass discrepancies in galaxies: dark matter and alternatives. The Astron Astrophys Rev 2, 1–28 (1990). https://doi.org/10.1007/BF00873540
Received:
Revised:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/BF00873540