Abstract
This paper reports a contingent valuation study to value the economic benefits of a post-mining lake-district in East Germany. Lusatia Region faces serious water scarcity problems as the closure of mining pits in 1990 led to the termination of groundwater discharge into rivers. The water conflict centres around traditional water users whose water demand is no longer met and the rehabilitation of mining pits in form of a new lake-district. Current water allocation policy for the Elbe catchment places lowest priority on filling mining pits with river water, even though freshwater is essential for good lake water quality. Commissioned by the government, this study aims to determine the non-market benefits that would be generated by good water quality in the lake-district in order to re-assess the distribution of water among all water users in the Elbe catchment. Our findings show that the annual non-market benefits of the lake-district is significant and lies between 10.4 and 16.2 million euros. Apart from recreational benefits, people also obtain non-use values for the lake-district. Furthermore, two challenges for CV became apparent: fuzzy future benefits (potential improvement to the regional economy) significantly influenced WTP estimates, and WTP stated by users interviewed on site and at home varied significantly.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Barrick KA, Beazley RI (1990) Magnitude and distribution of option value for the Washakie Wilderness, Northwest Wyoming, USA. J Environ Manag 14:367–380
BBR (2004) Demografische Entwicklungen 1999–2020. CD ROM
Bernath K, Elsasser P, Roschewitz A (2007) Reduktion systematischer und zufallsbedingter Fehler in Zielgebietsdaten: Theorie und empirische Ergebnisse einer Waldbesucherbefragung in Zürich. Allg Forst Jagdztg 178:109–120
BUND (2001) Die Braunkohle in der deutschen Energiewirtschaft. BUND, Berlin
Cordell HK, Bergstrom JC (1993) Comparison of recreation use values among alternative reservoir water levels management scenarios. Water Resour Manag 29:247–258
Diekmann A (2003) Empirische Sozialforschung. Rowohlt, Hamburg
Friese K, Schultze M, Wendt-Potthoff K (2001) Limnological studies and remediation strategies for the acidic open pit lakes of Germany. Mine Water Environ 20:103–150
Garrod G, Willis K (1999) Economic valuation of the environment. Edward Elgar, Cheltenham
Grünewald U (2005) Probleme der integrierten Wasserbewirtschaftung im Spree-Havel-Gebiet im Kontext des globalen Wandels. In: Wechsung F, Becker A, Gräfe P (eds) Auswirkungen des globalen Wandels auf Wasser, Umwelt und Gesellschaft im Elbegebiet. Weißensee Verlag, Berlin
Huszar EJ, Netusil NR, Shaw WD (2001) Contingent valuation of some externalities from mine dewatering. J Water Resour Plan Manage 127:369–377
Koch H, Kaltofen M, Grünewald U, Messner F, Karkuschke M, Zwirner O, Schramm M (2005) Scenarios of water resources management in the Lower Lusatian mining district, Germany. Ecol Eng 24:49–57
Lienhoop N, Healy J (2005) Der Einsatz von Zahlungsbereitschaftsanalysen in der Politikberatung-Beispiele aus Großbritannien und Irland. In: Bräuer I, Fischer A, Marggraf R, Menzel S, Stratmann U, Suhr A (eds) Ökonomische Bewertung bei umweltrelevanten Entscheidungen-Einsatzmöglichkeiten von Zahlungsbereitschaftsanalysen in Politik und Verwaltung, Metropolis, Marburg
Loomis JB (2000) Environmental valuation techniques in water resource decision making. J Water Resour Plan Manage 126:339–344
Loomis JB, Smith A, Huszar P (2005) Estimating the economic benefits of maintaining residential lake levels at an irrigation reservoir: a contingent valuation study. Water Resour Res 41:1–9
Messner F, Koch H, Kaltofen M (2007) Integration of economic evaluation into water management simulation. In: Erickson J, Messner F, Ring I (eds) Ecological economics of sustainable watershed management. Advances in the economics of environmental resources, vol 7. Elsevier, Amsterdam, pp. 229–263
Mitchell RC, Carson RT (1989) Using surveys to value public goods: the contingent valuation method. Resources for the Future, Washington
OECD (2000) The economic appraisal of environmental projects and policies. OECD, Paris.
Smith K (1994) Natural resource damage assessments and the mineral sector: valuation in the courts. In: Martin WE (ed) Environmental economics and the mining industry. Kluwer Academic, Boston
LMBV (2006) The Lusatian and Central-German Mining Administration Company. www.lmbv.de. Viewed 6 February 2006
Lausitzer Seenland (2006) The Lusatian lake-district. www.lausitzerseenland.de. Viewed 18 April 2006
Wechsung F (2005) Herausforderungen des globalen Wandels für die Elberegion. In: Wechsung F, Becker A, Gräfe P (eds) Auswirkungen des globalen Wandels auf Wasser, Umwelt und Gesellschaft im Elbegebiet. Weißensee Verlag, Berlin
Whitehead J (1990) Measuring willingness to pay for wetland preservation using contingent valuation. Wetlands 10:187–201
WILL (Wirtschaftsförderung Leipziger Land) (2004) Ganzheitliche Untersuchung zur wirtschaftlichen Lage und touristischen Entwicklung des Seenverbundes im Südraum Leipzig. SL Südraum Leipzig, Borna
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Lienhoop, N., Messner, F. The Economic Value of Allocating Water to Post-Mining Lakes in East Germany. Water Resour Manage 23, 965–980 (2009). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11269-008-9309-x
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11269-008-9309-x