Abstract
Whether the food movement is most likely to transform the food system through ‘alternative’ or ‘oppositional’ initiatives has been the focus of considerable scholarly debate. Alternative initiatives are widespread but risk reinforcing the conventional food system by supporting neoliberal discourse and governance mechanisms, including localism, consumer choice, entrepreneurialism and self-help. While oppositional initiatives such as political advocacy have the potential for system-wide change, the current neoliberal political and ideological context dominant in Canada poses difficulties for initiatives that explicitly oppose the conventional food system. As such, some argue that the food movement requires convergence between alternative and oppositional initiatives. In this paper, we investigate convergence using survey results from 143 food movement organizations in four Canadian provinces. Results based on cluster analysis and descriptive statistics on organizational discourse, activities and visions of sustainable food systems demonstrate convergence around neoliberal discourse and governance mechanisms. Localism and consumer education characteristics are particularly prominent, with a majority of respondents describing their organizations as ‘local’, engaging in consumer education activities, and stating the importance of consumer education activities, indicating convergence around alternative, rather than oppositional, initiatives. While convergence around these discourse and strategies may limit the transformative potential of the food system when interpreted as neoliberalisation of the movement, such a reading does not demonstrate their full potential, as survey results also indicate trends of transformative visions of change and political engagement, particularly at the municipal level. This research demonstrates that the movement can work simultaneously within, and opposed to, the conventional food system, and provides understanding of both neoliberal leanings and the politics of the possible of the food movement.
Similar content being viewed by others
Abbreviations
- AFMA:
-
Alberta farmers’ market association
- AFM:
-
Alberta food matters
- BCAFM:
-
British Columbia association of farmers’ markets
- BCFSN:
-
British Columbia food systems network
- FMNS:
-
Farmers’ markets of Nova Scotia
- FMO:
-
Farmers’ markets Ontario
- FSC:
-
Food secure Canada
- NSFSN:
-
Nova Scotia food security network
- SO:
-
Sustain Ontario
References
AAFC. 2012. An overview of the canadian agriculture and agri-food system 2012. Ottawa, Canada: Strategic Policy Branch Research and Analysis Directorate.
Abergel, E. 2012. The canadian biotechnology advisory committee: legitimacy, participation and attempts to improve gm regulation in canada. In Health and sustainability in the Canadian food system: Advocacy and opportunity for civil society, eds. R. MacRae, and E. Abergel, 97–126. Vancouver, BC: UBC Press.
Allen, P. 2014. Divergence and Convergence in Alternative Agrifood Movements: Seeking a Path Forward. Alternative agrifood movements: Patterns of convergence and divergence, ed. D. Constance, M-C. Renard, and M.G. Rivera-Ferre, 49–68. Published Online: Emerald Group Publishing Limited. http://www.emeraldinsight.com/doi/book/10.1108/S1057-1922201421. Accessed 6 Jan 2015.
Allen, P., M. FitzSimmons., M. Goodman, and K. Warner, 2003. Shifting plates in the agrifood landscape: The tectonics of alternative agrifood initiatives in California. Journal of Rural Studies 19 (1): 61–75.
Andrée, P., Ballamingie, P., and B. Sinclair-Waters. 2014. Neoliberalism and the making of food politics in Eastern Ontario. Local Environment 20 (12): 1452–1472.
Authority of the Speaker of the House of Assembly Halifax. 2013. Environmental Goals and Sustainable Prosperity Act: Chap. 7 of the Acts of 2007.
Beckie, M., E. H. Kennedy, and H. Wittman. 2012. Scaling up alternative food networks: farmers’ markets and the role of clustering in western Canada. Agriculture and Human Values 29 (3): 333–345.
Blay-Palmer, A. 2012. Alternative land use services and the case for multifunctional policy in Canada. In Health and sustainability in the Canadian food system: Advocacy and opportunity for civil society, eds. R. MacRae, and E. Abergel, 39–69. Vancouver, BC: UBC Press.
Blay-Palmer, A., Sonnino, R., and Custot, J. 2015. A food politics of the possible? Growing sustainable food systems through networks of knowledge. Agriculture and Human Values 33 (1): 27–43.
Born, B., and Purcell, M. 2006. Avoiding the local trap: Scale and food systems in planning research. Journal of Planning Education and Research 26 (2): 195–207.
Burns, R. and R. Burns. 2008. Cluster Analysis. In Business research methods and statistics using SPSS, 552–567. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage Publications.
Cameron, J., and Wright, S. 2014. Researching diverse food initiatives: from backyard and community gardens to international markets. Local Environment 19 (1): 1–9.
Constance, D.H., W.H, Friedland., M-C. Renard, and M.G Rivera-Ferre, eds. 2014a. Alternative agrifood movements: Patterns of convergence and divergence: Emerald Group Publishing Limited. http://www.emeraldinsight.com/doi/book/10.1108/S1057-1922201421. Accessed 6 Jan 2015.
Constance, D.H., W.H, Friedland., M-C. Renard, and M.G Rivera-Ferre. 2014b. The discourse on alternative agrifood movements. In Alternative agrifood movements: Patterns of convergence and divergence, eds. D.H Constance., W.H Friedland., M-C. Renard, and M.G Rivera-Ferre, 3–46. Published Online: Emerald Group Publishing Limited. http://www.emeraldinsight.com/doi/book/10.1108/S1057-1922201421. Accessed 6 Jan 2015.
Desmarais, A. A., and Wittman, H. 2014. Farmers, foodies and First Nations: getting to food sovereignty in Canada. Journal of Peasant Studies 41 (6): 1153–1173.
Dolhinow, R. 2005. Caught in the middle: the state, NGOs, and the limits to grassroots organizing along the US–Mexico border. Antipode 37 (3): 558–580.
Donald, B. 2010. Food systems planning and sustainable cities and regions: The role of the firm in sustainable food capitalism. In Imagining sustainable food systems: Theory and practice, ed. A. Blay-Palmer, 115–133. Farnham: Ashgate.
Eaton, E. 2013. Growing resistance: Canadian farmers and the politics of genetically modified wheat. Winnipeg: University of Manitoba Press.
ECCC. 2016. Federal sustainable development strategy. Ottawa, Canada: ECCC
Fairbairn, M. 2012. Framing transformation: the counter-hegemonic potential of food sovereignty in the US context. Agriculture and Human Values 29: 217–230.
Food Secure Canada. 2015. Federal Elections: 4 parties are in favour of a national food policy. http://foodsecurecanada.org/federal-elections-4-parties-are-favour-national-food-policy. Accessed 23 Dec 2016.
Food Secure Canada. 2016. Who We Are. http://foodsecurecanada.org/who-we-are. Accessed 26 Sept 2016.
Friedland, W. H. 2010. New ways of working and organization: alternative agrifood movements and agrifood researchers. Rural Sociology 75 (4): 601–627.
Friedmann, H. 2005. From colonialism to green capitalism: social movements and the emergence of food regimes. In New directions in the sociology of global development. Research in rural sociology and development, eds. F. H. Buttel, and P. McMichael, 229–264. Oxford: Elsevier.
Gibson-Graham, J. K. 2006. A Postcapitalist Politics. Minneapolis, MN: University of Minnesota Press.
Gibson-Graham, J. K., and Cameron, J. 2007. Community enterprises: Imagining and enacting alternatives to capitalism. Social Alternatives 26 (1): 20–25.
Goodman, D., and DuPuis, E. M. 2002. Knowing food and growing food: Beyond the production-consumption debate in the sociology of agriculture. Sociologia Ruralis 42 (1): 5–22.
Goodman, D., DuPuis, E. M., and Goodman, M. 2014. Alternative food networks: Knowledge, practice, and politics. London: Routledge.
Guthman, J. 2008a. Neoliberalism and the making of food politics in California. Geoforum 39 (3): 1171–1183.
Guthman, J. 2008b. Thinking inside the neoliberal box: The micro-politics of agro-food philanthropy. Geoforum 39 (3): 1241–1253.
Harris, E. 2009. Neoliberal subjectivities or a politics of the possible? Reading for difference in alternative food networks. Area 41 (1): 55–63.
Hassanein, N. 2003. Practicing food democracy: A pragmatic politics of transformation. Journal of Rural Studies 19 (1): 77–86.
Hinrichs, C. C. 2003. The practice and politics of food system localization. Journal of Rural Studies 19 (1): 33–45.
Hinrichs, C. C., and Eshleman, J. 2014. Agrifood movements: Diversity, aims, and limits. In Rural America in a globalizing world: Problems and prospects for the 2010s, eds. C. Bailey, L. Jensen, and E. Ransom, 138–155. Morgantown, WV: West Virginia University Press.
Holt-Giménez, E., and Shattuck, A. 2011. Food crises, food regimes and food movements: Rumblings of reform or tides of transformation? Journal of Peasant Studies 38 (1): 109–144.
Holt-Giménez, E., and Y. Wang. 2011. Reform or transformation? The pivotal role of food justice in the food movement. Race/Ethnicity: Multidisciplinary Global Contexts 5(1): 83–102.
Kloppenburg, J., and Hassanein, N. 2006. From old school to reform school? Agriculture and Human Values 23 (4): 417–421.
Kloppenburg, J., S. Lezberg., K. De Master., G. Stevenson., and Hendrickson, J. 2000. Tasting food, tasting sustainability: Defining the attributes of an alternative food system with competent, ordinary people. Human Organization 59 (2): 177–186.
Kneen, C. 2011. Food Secure Canada: Where agriculture, environment, health, food and justice intersect. In Food Sovereignty in Canada: Creating just and sustainable food systems, eds. H. Wittman., A.A. Desmarais., and N. Wiebe, 80–96. Black Point, Nova Scotia: Fernwood Publishing.
Koc, M., and Bas, J. A. 2012. Canada’s action plan for food security: The interactions between civil society and the state to advance food security in Canada. In Health and sustainability in the Canadian food system, eds. R. MacRae, and E. Abergel, 173–203. Vancouver, BC: UBC Press.
Legislative Assembly of British Columbia. 2015. Bill M 222–2015: British Columbia Local Food Act. Victoria, Canada: Legislative Assembly of British Columbia
Levkoe, C. Z. 2011. Towards a transformative food politics. Local Environment 16 (7): 687–705.
Levkoe, C. Z. 2014. The food movement in Canada: A social movement network perspective. Journal of Peasant Studies 41 (3): 385–403.
Levkoe, C., and Wakefield, S. 2014. Understanding contemporary networks of environmental and social change: complex assemblages within Canada’s ‘food movement’. Environmental Politics 23 (2): 302–320.
MacRae, R. 2011. A joined-up food policy for Canada. Journal of Hunger & Environmental Nutrition 6 (4): 424–457.
MacRae, R., E. Abergel., and Koc, M. 2012a. Introduction. In Health and sustainability in the Canadian food system, eds. R. MacRae, and E. Abergel, 1–14. Vancouver, BC: UBC Press.
MacRae, R., J. Langer., and Cuddeford, V. 2012b. Lessons from twenty years of CSO advocacy to advance sustainable pest management in Canada. In Health and sustainability in the Canadian food system: Advocacy and opportunity for civil society, eds. R. MacRae, and E. Abergel, 129–152. Vancouver, BC: UBC Press.
Magnan, A. 2011. The limits of farmer control: Food sovereignty and conflicts over the Canadian Wheat Board. In Food sovereignty in Canada: Creating just and sustainable food systems, eds. H. Wittman, A.A. Desmarais, and N. Wiebe, 114–133. Black Point, Nova Scotia: Fernwood Publishing.
Marsden, T., and Franklin, A. 2013. Replacing neoliberalism: Theoretical implications of the rise of local food movements. Local Environment 18 (5): 636–641.
McInnes, A., and Mount, P. 2017. Actualizing sustainable food systems. In Critical perspectives in food studies, ed. M. Koc., J. Sumner., and A. Winson, Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Members and Collaborators of the Coalition for Healthy School Food. 2015. For a universal healthy school food program,. http://foodsecurecanada.org/sites/default/files/coalitionforhealthyschoolfood.sm_.pdf. Accessed 26 Sept 2016.
Mendes, W. 2008. Implementing social and environmental policies in cities: the case of food policy in Vancouver, Canada. International Journal of Urban and Regional Research 32 (4): 942–967.
Monsanto. 2013. Labeling Food and Ingredients Developed from GM Seed. http://www.monsanto.com/newsviews/pages/food-labeling.aspx. Accessed 26 Sept 2016.
Mooney, P.H., K. Tanaka, and G. Ciciurkaite. 2014. Food policy council movement in North America: A convergence of alternative local agrifood interests? In Alternative agrifood movements: Patterns of convergence and divergence, eds. D.H. Constance., M-C. Renard., and M.G. Rivera-Ferre, 229–255. Emerald Group Publishing Limited. http://www.emeraldinsight.com/doi/book/10.1108/S1057-1922201421. Accessed 6 Jan 2015.
Mount, P. 2012. Growing local food: Scale and local food systems governance. Agriculture and Human Values 29 (1): 107–121.
Mount, P., and Andrée, P. 2013. Visualising community-based food projects in Ontario. Local Environment 18 (5): 578–591.
Mount, P., S. Hazen., S. Holmes., E. Fraser., A. Winson., I. Knezevic., E. Nelson., L. Ohberg., P. Andre., and Landman, K. 2013. Barriers to the local food movement: Ontario’s community food projects and the capacity for convergence. Local Environment 18(5).
OMAFRA. 2015. Local Food. http://www.omafra.gov.on.ca/english/about/localfood.htm. Accessed 12 Aug 2015.
Qualman, D. 2011. Advancing agriculture by destroying farms? The state of agriculture in Canada. In Food sovereignty in Canada: Creating just and sustainable food systems, eds. H. Wittman., A.A Desmarais., and N. Wiebe, 20–42. Black Point, Nova Scotia: Fernwood Publishing.
Rivera-Ferre, M.G., D.H. Constance., and M-C. Renard. 2014. Convergence and divergence in alternative agrifood movements. In Alternative agrifood movements: Patterns of convergence and divergence, eds. D.H. Constance, M-C. Renard., and M.G. Rivera-Ferre, 313–322. Emerald Group Publishing Limited. http://www.emeraldinsight.com/doi/book/10.1108/S1057-1922201421. Accessed 6 Jan 2015.
Romesburg, C. 1984. Cluster analysis for researchers. Belmont: Lifetime Learning Publications.
Rosset, P. 2008. Food sovereignty and the contemporary food crisis. Development 51 (4): 460–463.
Schiff, R., and Levkoe, C. Z. 2014. From disparate action to collective mobilization: Collective action frames and the Canadian food movement. In Occupy the earth: Global environmental movements, ed. L. Leonard., and S. Kedzior, 225–253. Bingley: Emerald Group Publishing Limited.
Stevenson, G.W., K. Ruhf., S. Lezberg., and K. Clancy. 2007. Warrior, builder, and weaver work: Strategies for changing the food system. In Remaking the North American food system: Strategies for sustainability, eds. C. Hinrichs., and T.A. Lyson, 33–62. Lincoln, Nebraska: University of Nebraska Press.
The Legislative Assembly of Alberta. 2015. Bill 202: Alberta Local Food Act. Edmonton, Canada: Legislative Assembly of Alberta.
Wiebe, N., and Wipf, K. 2011. Nurturing food sovereignty in Canada. In Food sovereignty in Canada, eds. H. Wittman., A.A. Desmarais., and N. Wiebe, 1–19. Black Point, Nova Scotia: Fernwood Publishing.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
McInnes, A., Fraser, E., Gedalof, Z. et al. A quantitative analysis of food movement convergence in four Canadian provinces. Agric Hum Values 34, 787–804 (2017). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10460-017-9775-y
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10460-017-9775-y