Abstract
For many foreigners, talk of Victory Day in Moscow will immediately call to mind rocket launchers, tanks, and files of soldiers parading on Red Square. Yet, for many Russians there is another side to Victory Day, which is known as the ‘holiday with tears in your eyes’ (prazdnik so slezami na glazach). It is not only a celebration but also a time to remember the enormous sacrifices and tragedy, individual and collective, endured during the Great Patriotic War (GPW), as the Russians call the Soviet experience of World War Two. However, not all sacrifices are remembered equally, or at all, raising the question of ‘whose tears’ count. Posing this question immediately problematises the notion that there is a one-sizefits- all narrative of the GPW accepted and acceptable to the diverse population of the Russian Federation. This chapter examines this tension, asking to what extent the government’s GPW narrative can be understood as unifying in the context of Kalmykia, the indigenous population of which was deported during the war.
Access this chapter
Tax calculation will be finalised at checkout
Purchases are for personal use only
Preview
Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.
References
Alexopoulos, Golfo: Stalin and the Politics of Kinship: Practices of Collective Punishment, 1920s–1940s’. In: Comparative Studies in Society and History, 50.1 (2008), pp. 91–117.
Amos, Howard: Prisoners of a Myth. Soviet POWs and the Politics of Memory in Russia under Vladimir Putin, 2000–2019. MA 2019.
Bashkova, Anna: Otčet o dejatel’nosti 2013–2017. Moskva, RVIO, 2017.
Beumers, Birgit; Hutchings, Stephen; Rulyova, Natalia: The Post-Soviet Russian Media: Conflicting Signals. London 2009.
Biurchiev, Badma: Kalmykia’s Long Goodbye. In: OpenDemocracy, 2016, URL: https://www.opendemocracy.net/en/odr/kalmykia-s-long-goodbye/ [accessed 09.12.2020].
Brunstedt, Jonathan: The Soviet Myth of the Great Fatherland War and the Limits of Inclusionary Politics under Brezhnev: The Case of Chalmaevist Literature. In: Nationalities Papers, 41.1 (2013), pp. 146–165.
Byzov, Leontij: Novoe konservativnoe bol’šinstvo kak social’no-političeskij fenomen. In: Mir Rossii, 23.4 (2014), pp. 6–34.
Centre for Conservative Social Policy, Rossijskij Konservatizm – ideologija partii “Edinaja Rossija”. Moscow: Centre for Conservative Social Policy, 2009.
Delegacija iz Kalmykii učastvuet v patriotičeskom forume! In: Ėlista Bezformata, 2019, URL: https://elista.bezformata.com/listnews/kalmikii-uchastvuet-v-patrioticheskom-forume/73985310/ [accessed 10.12.2020].
Dve školy v Kalmykii stali prizerami konkursa “Lučšij škol’nyj muzej Pamjati VOV”. In: Ėlista Bezformata, 2020, URL: https://elista.bezformata.com/listnews/konkursa-luchshiy-shkolniy-muzey/87866527/ [accessed 09.12.2020].
Edinorossy proveli meroprijatie po perezachoroneniju ostankov bojcov 28 armii. In: Ėlista Bezformata, 2017, URL: https://elista.bezformata.com/listnews/meropriyatie-poperezahoroneniyu-ostankov/62886800/ [accessed 09.12.2020].
Fedor, Julie: Memory, Kinship, and the Mobilization of the Dead: The Russian State and the “Immortal Regiment” Movement. In: Fedor, Julie [et. al.] [Ed.]: War and Memory in Russia, Ukraine and Belarus. Cham 2017, pp. 307–345.
Gabowitsch, Mischa: Victory Day: The Biography of a Soviet Holiday. In: Eurozine, 2020, URL: https://www.eurozine.com/victory-day-the-biography-of-a-soviet-holiday/ [accessed 09.12.2020].
Geroi Sovetskogo Sojuza – urožency Kalmykii. In: Roskazna. URL: https://kal-mykia.roskazna.gov.ru/o-kaznachejstve/istoriya-ufk/stranitsy-nashey-istorii/detail.php?id=1090160 [accessed 09.12.2020].
Gessen, Masha: Russia’s Only Independent TV Channel Has Felt the Full Force of Censorship. In: The Guardian, 2014, URL: https://www.theguardi-an.com/commentisfree/2014/jan/30/russia-independent-tv-channel-censorship-tv-rain-leningrad [accessed 31.08.2020].
Guchinova, El’za-Bair: “Everyone has one’s own Siberia”: Two stories of the Kalmyk deportation (Interviews with S. M. Ivanov and S. E. Naranova). In: Oriental Studies, 43.3 (2019), pp. 397–422.
Guchinova, El’za-Bair: Deportation of the Kalmyks (1943–1956): Stigmatized Ethnicity’, 34.
Gučinova, Ėl’za-Bair: ‘Pamjat’’ v nasledstvo: deportacija Kalmykov v škol’nych sočinenijach. SPb 2005.
Guchinova, El’za-Bair: The Kalmyks. New York 2013.
Gučinova, Ėl’za-Bair, Pomnit’ nel’zja zabyt’: antropologija deportacionnoj travmy Kalmykov. Stuttgart 2005.
Kalinin, Il’ja: Nostalgic Modernization: The Soviet Past as “Historical Horizon”. In: Slavonica, 17.2 (2011), pp. 156–166.
Kalinin, Il’ja: Gosudarstvennyj prazdnik: obrjady edinstva i ritualy različij. In: Neprikosnovennyj Zapas, 2.100 (2015).
Kalinina, Ekaterina: Beyond Nostalgia for the Soviet Past: Interpreting Documentaries on Russian Television. In: European Journal of Cultural Studies, 20.3 (2017), pp. 285–306.
Koposov, Nikolay: Memory Laws, Memory Wars. Cambridge 2018.
Malinova, Ol’ga: Aktual’noe prošloe: simvoličeskaja politika vlastvujuščej ėlity i dilemmy rossijskoj identičnosti. In: Političeskaja ėnciklopedija. Moskva 2015.
Malinova, Ol’ga: Constructing the “Usable Past”: The Evolution of the Official Historical Narrative in Post-Soviet Russia. In: Bernsand, Niklas; Tornquist-Plewa, Barbara [Ed.]: Cultural and Political Imaginaries in Putin’s Russia. Leiden 2019, pp. 85–104.
Malinova, Ol’ga: Political Uses of the Great Patriotic War. In: War and Memory in Russia, Ukraine and Belarus. Springer 2017, pp. 43–70; Pearce, James: The Use of History in Putin’s Russia. Delaware 2020.
McGlynn, Jade: Historical Framing of the Ukraine Crisis through the Great Patriotic War: Performativity, Cultural Consciousness and Shared Remembering. In: Memory Studies, 2018 https://doi.org/10.1177/1750698018800740.
McGlynn, Jade: Living Forms of Patriotism: Engaging Young Russians in Military History? In: Friess, Nina; Krawatzek, Félix [Ed.]: Defining the Past, Shaping the Future: Memory for Young People. Berlin (Forthcoming).
McGlynn, Jade: Own interview with Sergej Lapenkov, founding member of Bessmertnyj Polk, 2018.
McGlynn, Jade: Reliving the Past. How the Russian Government and Media Use History to Frame the Present. Oxford 2020, pp. 191–195.
McGlynn, Jade: United by History: Government Appropriation of Everyday Nationalism during Vladimir Putin’s Third Term. In: Nationalities Papers, 48.6 (2020), pp. 1069–1085.
Medinskij, Rostislav: Voenno-istoričeskie maršruty Rossii. In: Hist.rf, URL: https://histrf.ru/biblioteka/b/voienno-istorichieskiie-marshruty-rossii [accessed 09.12.2020.
Medinskij, Rostislav: Voenno-istoričeskie maršruty Rossii. Moskva, RVIO, 2016.
Meždunarodnyj subbotnik po blagoustrojtsvu pamjatnych mest i voinskich zachoronenij. In: Ėlista Bezformata, 2020, URL: https://elista.bezformata.com/listnews/pamyatnih-mest-i-voinskih-zahoronenij/85011132/ [accessed 09.12.2020].
Miller, Aleksej: Politika pamjati v Rossii. Rol’ negosudarstvennych agentov. In: Gefter, 2017, URL: http://gefter.ru/archive/20967 [accessed 09.05.2020].
Nelson, Todd H.: Bringing Stalin Back In: Memory Politics and the Creation of a Useable Past in Putin’s Russia. Lanham 2019.
Oushakine, Serguei Alex: Postcolonial Estrangements: Claiming a Space between Stalin and Hitler. In: Buckler, Julie; Johnson, Emily [Ed.]: Rites of Place: Public Commemoration in Russia and Eastern Europe. Evanston 2013, pp. 285–315.
Petro, Nicolai N.: How the West Lost Russia: Explaining the Conservative Turn in Russian Foreign Policy. In: Russian Politics, 3.3 (2018), pp. 305–332, https://doi.org/10.1163/2451-8921-00303001.
Polian, P. M.: Against Their Will: The History and Geography of Forced Migrations in the USSR. Budapest 2004; Martin, Terry: The Origins of Soviet Ethnic Cleansing. In: The Journal of Modern History, 70.4 (1998), pp. 813–861.
Pravnuki Pobeditelej. Proekt napravlennyj na obespečenie preemstvennosti Pamjati’. In: Ėlista Bezformata, 2019, URL: https://elista.bezformata.com/listnews/pravnuki-pobeditelej-proekt-napravlennij/73790989/ [accessed 09.12.2020].
Prestupleniya nacistov na territorii Kalmykii otraženy v knige “Bez sroka davnosti”. In: SM. News, 2020, URL: https://elista.sm.news/prestupleniya-nacistov-na-territorii-kalmykii-otrazheny-v-knige-bez-sroka-davnosti-62271/ [accessed 09.12.2020].
Proekt “Istoričeskaja Pamyat’” partii Edinaya Rossija, Edinaja Rossija, URL: https://proekty.er.ru/node/6599 [accessed 09.12.2020].
Proekt “Krepkaja Sem’ja” partii Edinaja Rossija, Edinaja Rossija, URL: https://proekty.er.ru/krepkaya-semya [accessed 09.12.2020].
Putin, Vladimir: The Real Lessons of the 75th Anniversary of World War II. In: The National Interest (The Center for the National Interest, 2020), URL: https://nationalinterest.org/feature/vladimir-putin-real-lessons-75th-anniversary-world-war-ii-162982 [accessed 15.07.2020].
Realizacija vserossijskogo proekta “Bez sroka davnosti”. In: RVIO, 2020, URL: https://rvio.histrf.ru/soobshestvo/post-14855 [accessed 09.12.2020].
Russia’s Assault on Freedom of Expression, HRW, 2018, URL: https://www.hrw.org/report/2017/07/18/online-and-all-fronts/russias-assault-freedom-ex-pression [accessed 04.08.2019].
Sharafutdinova, Gulnaz: The Pussy Riot Affair and Putin’s Démarche from Sovereign De-mocracy to Sovereign Morality. In: Nationalities Papers, 42.4 (2014), pp. 615–621.
Sinelschikova, Yekaterina; Karagodina, Anastasiya: Real-Life Horror Stories of the Kalmyks Who Survived Stalin’s Deportation. In: Russia behind the Headlines, 2017, URL: https://www.rbth.com/multimedia/history/2017/07/12/real-life-horror-stories-of-the-kalmyks-who-survived-genocide_801192 [accessed 10.12.2020].
Smith, Kathleen E.: Mythmaking in the New Russia: Politics and Memory during the Yeltsin Era. Ithaca 2002.
Teper, Yuri: Official Russian Identity Discourse in Light of the Annexation of Crimea: National or Imperial? In: Post-Soviet Affairs, 32.4 (2016), pp. 378–396.
Tumarkin, Nina: The Living & the Dead: The Rise and Fall of the Cult of World War II in Russia. New York 1994.
Upravlenie FSIN Kalmykii podgotovili vystavku v čest’ 75-letija Pobedy. In: Ėlista Bezformata, 2020, URL: https://elista.bezformata.com/listnews/fsin-kalmikii-podgotovili-vistavku/83655852/ [accessed 09.12.2020].
Uroki Mužestva. In: Ėlista Bezformata, 2020, URL: https://elista.bezformata.com/listnews/elisti-bili-provedeni-uroki/81846924/ [accessed 10.12.2020].
V nojabre v Moskve sostoitsja prezentacija izdanija dokumentov “Bez sroka davnosti”. In: Vesti Kalmykija, 2020, URL: https://vesti-kalmykia.ru/news/v-noyabre-v-moskve-sostoitsya-prezentaciya-izdaniya-dokumentov-bez-sroka-davnosti [accessed 09.12.2020].
V pamyat’ o zemlyakach, učastvovavšich v parade Pobedy’, RVIO Kalmykija, 2015, URL: https://rvio.histrf.ru/soobshestvo/post-1691 [accessed 10.12.2020].
Walker, Shaun: The Long Hangover: Putin’s Russia and the Ghosts of the Past. Oxford 2017.
Yurchak, Alexei: Everything Was Forever, until It Was No More: The Last Soviet Generation. Princeton 2005.
Editor information
Rights and permissions
Copyright information
© 2022 Frank & Timme GmbH
About this chapter
Cite this chapter
McGlynn, J. (2022). The Great Unifier? Promoting State-Sponsored War Narratives in Kalmykia. In: Khrushcheva, D., Schwindt, M., Zabirko, O. (eds) Figurationen des Ostens. Slawistik. Frank & Timme, Berlin. https://doi.org/10.57088/978-3-7329-9164-8_17
Download citation
DOI: https://doi.org/10.57088/978-3-7329-9164-8_17
Publisher Name: Frank & Timme, Berlin
Online ISBN: 978-3-7329-9164-8
eBook Packages: Social Science and Law (German Language)