The Implications of Graduate Labor Market Performance in Designing a Student Loan Scheme for Malaysia
This chapter examines graduate labor market performance and its implications in the design of a student loan scheme for higher education in Malaysia. The current mortgage-type loan scheme under the National Higher Education Fund Corporation (NHEFC) creates a major problem in terms of loan defaults which contribute to high implicit subsidies and concerns related to the sustainability of this scheme. With high unemployment among fresh graduates and where over-education is found to be prominent among employed graduates, it is likely that the current mortgage-type loan scheme creates a heavy burden on many graduates with relatively low incomes. The important concept relates to what is known as the ‘repayment burden’, the proportion of a debtor’s income that is required to meet repayment obligations. To understand the extent of repayment burdens, age-earnings profiles are estimated for Malaysia and it is found that the earning ability of graduates varies by level and field of study. The current mortgage-type student loans are shown to impose quite high repayment burdens, particularly for graduates in arts and social sciences, with the results helping us to understand the extent of loan defaults. Adjusting the data to include unemployed graduates, which results in a more informed repayment burden calculation, adds very considerably to our assessment of the average repayment difficulties. In assessing the efficacy of the current loan scheme, we compare the implicit subsidies under the current mortgage-type student loans with a proposed (hypothetical) income contingent loan (ICL).
KeywordsStudent Loan Unemployment Duration Loan Amount Collection Cost Loan Repayment
Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.
- Baum, S., and S. Schwartz (2006) ‘How Much Debt is Too Much? Defining Benchmarks for Manageable Student Debt’, The Project on Student Debt and the College Board. Online at http://research.collegeboard.org/sites/default/files/publications/2012/9/researchinreview-2006-12-benchmarks-manageable-student-debt.pdf.Google Scholar
- Chapman, B. and Y. C. Liu (2013) ‘Repayment Burdens of Student Loans for Vietnamese Higher Education’, Crawford School Working Paper No. 13–06, Crawford School of Public Policy, The Australian National University.Google Scholar
- Department of Statistics, Malaysia (2011a) ‘Labour Force Survey 2011’ (Putrajaya: Percetakan Nasional Malaysia Berhad (PNMB)).Google Scholar
- Department of Statistics, Malaysia (2011b) ‘Salaries and Wage Survey 2011’ (Putrajaya: PNMB).Google Scholar
- Department of Statistics, Malaysia (2012) ‘Salaries and Wage Survey 2012’ (Putrajaya: PNMB).Google Scholar
- Loo, S. (2012) ‘Despite RM45bil Bad Debt, PTPTN Doing it the “Nice Way”’. Online at http://www.freemalaysiakini2.com/?p=55808. Viewed 10 March 2012.
- Ministry of Finance, Malaysia (2005) ‘Economic Report 2005/06’ (Kuala Lumpur: PNMB).Google Scholar
- Ministry of Finance, Malaysia (2012) ‘Economic Report 2012/13’ (Kuala Lumpur: PNMB).Google Scholar
- Ministry of Higher Education, Malaysia (2009) ‘Study on the Financial Sustainability of PTPTN’, Unpublished consultation report, Putrajaya.Google Scholar
- Ministry of Higher Education, Malaysia (2010) ‘Higher Learning Institution Tracer Study 2010’, Putrajaya.Google Scholar
- Salmi, J. (2003) ‘Student Loans in an International Perspective: The World Bank Experience’, Working Paper No. 27295, The World Bank.Google Scholar
- Sergio F., N. M. Fortin and T. Lemieux (2007) ‘Unconditional Quantile Regressions’, NBER Technical Working Paper 0339, National Bureau of Economic Research.Google Scholar