The Jewish Indian Theory and Protestant Use of Catholic Thought in the Early Modern Atlantic

  • Andrew Crome
Part of the Christianities in the Trans-Atlantic World, 1500–1800 book series (CTAW)


It is tempting to accuse Thomas Thorowgood’s Jewes in America, or, Probabilities that the Americans are of that Race (1650) of a narrow parochialism. ‘Britain’, he began, ‘has woon [sic] the gospel glory from all other countries … it was the first of all the provinces that established Christianity by law … our Lucius was the first Christian king … our K. Henry the Eight was the first of all princes who brake that yoke of Antichrist’.1 Aside from betraying its author’s high view of monarchy (Charles I’s execution forced Thorowgood to delay publication and choose a new dedicatee), the passage reveals confidence in a nation blessed by God and enjoying international pre-eminence in the gospel.2 It is easy to see how Thorowgood’s position could be used to support the idea of England as an elect nation, a new Israel leading the world into a Protestant utopia. Yet Thorowgood did not stop with Henry’s breaking of Antichrist’s yoke. Instead, he fixed his historical lens further into the past, reminding readers of the many European supports that English faith had received. The English were not natives of their own land, instead being a collection of Jutes and Angles who emigrated from Germany. It was in this continental setting that they were educated in the faith. Following the English Catholic antiquarian Richard Verstegan, Thorowgood reminded his readers that these original immigrants, who constituted a ‘first England’ in ancient Germany, were initially converted to Christianity through interactions with the Jewish community on the continent.


Seventeenth Century Jewish Community Original Immigrant People Group English Context 
These keywords were added by machine and not by the authors. This process is experimental and the keywords may be updated as the learning algorithm improves.


Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.


  1. 1.
    Thomas Thorowgood, Iewes in America or, Probabilities that the Americans are of that Race (1650), sig. bv.Google Scholar
  2. 4.
    For example, Claire Jowitt, ‘Radical Identities? Native Americans, Jews and the English Commonwealth’, Seventeenth Century 10:1 (1995), pp. 101–19.Google Scholar
  3. Ronnie Perelis, ‘‘Those Indians are Jews!”: Lost Tribes, Crypto-Jews, and Jewish Self-fashioning in Antonio de Montezinos’s Relatiμn of 1644’, in Richard L. Kagan and Philip D. Morgan (eds), Atlantic Diasporas: Jews, Converso and Crypto-Jews in the Age of Mercantilism, 1500–1800 (Baltimore, 2009), pp. 195–9.Google Scholar
  4. 5.
    Jorge Cañizares-Esguerra, Puritan Conquistadors: Iberianizing the Atlantic, 1550–1700 (Stanford, 2006), pp. 83–119.Google Scholar
  5. 6.
    See Andrew Crome, The Restoration of the Jews: Early Modern Hermeneutics, Eschatology, and National Identity in the Works of Thomas Brightman (Cham, 2014), pp. 29–58.Google Scholar
  6. David Katz, Philo-Semitism and the Readmission of the Jews to England, 1603–1655 (Oxford, 1982), pp. 90–126.Google Scholar
  7. Robert O. Smith, More Desired than our Owne Salvation: The Roots of Christian Zionism (Oxford, 2013), pp. 47–69.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  8. 7.
    William Perkins, ‘A Fruitfull Dialogue … Concerning the End of the World’, in Works (1631), iii. 470.Google Scholar
  9. 8.
    See Richard W. Cogley, ‘The Fall of the Ottoman Empire and the Restoration of Israel in the “Judeo-Centric” Strand of Puritan Millenarianism’, Church History 72 (2003), pp. 304–22.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  10. Andrew Crome, ‘‘The proper and naturall meaning of the prophets”: The Hermeneutic Roots of Judeo-centrism in Puritan Eschatology’, Renaissance Studies 24:5 (2010), pp. 725–41.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  11. 10.
    Alec Ryrie, Being Protestant in post-Reformation Britain (Oxford, 2013), pp. 281–92.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  12. 11.
    For details on the development of this tradition see Crawford Gribben, The Puritan Millennium: Literature and Theology, 1550–1682, second edition (Milton Keynes, 2008), pp. 21–58.Google Scholar
  13. 13.
    See Cañizares-Esguerra, Puritan Conquistadors, pp. 24–6, 52–5, and Bernard Bailyn, Atlantic History: Concept and Contours (Cambridge, MA, 2005), pp. 76–9.Google Scholar
  14. 14.
    A thorough history of the Jewish and Christian attempts to locate the tribes can be found in Zvi Ben-Dor Benite, The Ten Tribes: A World History (Oxford, 2009).CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  15. For the history of Christian speculation in particular see Tudor Parfitt, The Lost Tribes of Israel: The History of a Myth (London, 2002), pp. 1–25.Google Scholar
  16. 15.
    Giles Fletcher, Israel Redux or the Restauration of Israel (London, 1677).Google Scholar
  17. see, for example, Thorowgood, Iewes in America (1650), p. 39.Google Scholar
  18. 16.
    Amy Sturgis, ‘Prophesies and Politics: Millenarians, Rabbis, and the Jewish Indian Theory’, Seventeenth Century 14 (1999), pp. 15–23. However, Lee Earnest Huddleston argues that Martyr did not fully espouse the theory; Origins of the American Indians: European Concepts, 1492–1729 (Austin, TX, 1967), p. 33. Acosta argued that the Indians were so far from Hebrew ceremonies that they could not be Jews, unless they had experienced a cataclysmic degeneration. Garcia was much more positive, granting the theory a great deal of space and attempting to rebut Acosta’s objections. He did not espouse one particular opinion above others, however. On this see Huddleston, Origins, pp. 48–76.Google Scholar
  19. 17.
    The most that Mede can hope for from the plantations is that the English will not degenerate and make up the hordes of Gog and Magog assaulting the New Jerusalem. This is laid out in a letter to William Twisse dated 23 March 1634/5; see Joseph Mede, The Works of the Pious and Profoundly Learned Joseph Mede (1672), pp. 798–803. On Torquemada’s influence see Canizares-Esguerra, Puritan Conquistadors, pp. 100–4.Google Scholar
  20. 19.
    A section of Brerewood’s work is dedicated to the question of the location of the tribes, and a denial of claims that they were amongst the Tartars, or that the Tartars (and thus tribes) had populated America. See Edward Brerewood, Enquiries Touching the Diversity of Languages and Religions through the Chiefe Parts of the World (1614), pp. 92–112.Google Scholar
  21. 36.
    Thomas Thorowgood, Moderation Justified, and the Lords being at Hand Emproved (1645).Google Scholar
  22. 37.
    Thorowgood, Iewes in America (1650), pp. 60–87.Google Scholar
  23. 38.
    Thorowgood, Jews in America (1660), sigs. *v-*2r.Google Scholar
  24. 39.
    Thorowgood, Jews in America (1660), sig. *2iir.Google Scholar
  25. 40.
    For more on this see Warren Johnston, Revelation Restored: The Apocalypse in Later Seventeenth-century England (Woodbridge, 2011).Google Scholar
  26. For an example see Arise Evans, Light for the Jews, or, the Means to Convert Them (1664).Google Scholar
  27. 42.
    John Dury, ‘Discourse’, in Thorowgood, Iewes in America (1650), sig. e2r. Thorowgood’s work was the first to print a translation of Montezinos’ report, taken from Menasseh’s French copy and translated by Dury; see ‘The Relation of Master Antonie Monterinos, translated out of the French copie sent by MANASEH BEN ISRAEL’, in Thorowgood, Iewes in America (1650), pp. 129–39.Google Scholar
  28. 44.
    Menassehben Israel, ‘The Relation of Master Antonie Monterinos’, in Thorowgood, Iewes in America (1650), p. 136.Google Scholar
  29. 46.
    For more on this see Richard H. Popkin, ‘The Rise and Fall of the Jewish Indian Theory’, in Yosef Kaplan, Henry Méchoulan and Richard H. Popkin (eds), Menasseh ben Israel and his World (Leiden, 1989), pp. 68–71.Google Scholar
  30. 50.
    Michael Hoberman, New Israel/New England: Jews and Puritans in Early America (Amherst, MA, 2011), pp. 13–17.Google Scholar
  31. 51.
    Carla Gardina Pestana, Religion and the Making of the British Atlantic World (Philadelphia, PA, 2009), pp. 71–7.Google Scholar
  32. 52.
    Laura M. Stevens, The Poor Indians: British Missionaries, Native Americans and Colonial Sensibility (Philadelphia, PA, 2004), pp. 62–83.Google Scholar
  33. 53.
    Susan Hardman Moore, Pilgrims: New World Settlers and the Call of Home (New Haven, CT, 2007), and idem, Abandoning America: Life Stories from Early New England (Woodbridge, 2013).Google Scholar
  34. 55.
    John Sadler, Rights of the Kingdom (1649), pp. 37–8.Google Scholar
  35. 56.
    John Eliot in Henry Whitfield, The Light Appearing More and More Towards the Perfect Day, or a Further Discovery of the Present State of the Indians in New England (1650), p. 14.Google Scholar
  36. 57.
    Lisa Voigt, Writing Captivity in the Early Modern Atlantic: Circulations of Knowledge and Authority in the Iberian and English Imperial Worlds (Chapel Hill, 2009), pp. 255–319.Google Scholar
  37. 62.
    John Eliot in Thorowgood, Jews in America (1660), p. 2.Google Scholar
  38. 63.
    For more on this see Crawford Gribben, Evangelical Millennialism in the Transatlantic World, 1500–2000 (Basingstoke, 2011), pp. 20–36.Google Scholar
  39. 64.
    Carla Gardina Pestana, ‘Cruelty and religious justifciations for conquest in the mid-seventeenth century English Atlantic’, in Linda Gregerson and Susan Juster (eds), Empires of God: Religious Encounters in the Early Modern Atlantic (Philadelphia, PA, 2011), pp. 37–57.Google Scholar
  40. 65.
    Thomas Gage in Thorowgood, Jews in America (1660), pp. 35–6.Google Scholar
  41. 66.
    Thorowgood, Jews in America (1660), pp. 21–2.Google Scholar
  42. 67.
    José de Acosta, The Naturall and Morall Historie of the East and West Indies (1604), pp. 74–7.Google Scholar
  43. 71.
    David Armitage, ‘Three Concepts of Atlantic History’, in David Armitage and Michael J. Braddick (eds), The British Atlantic World, 1500–1800 (Basingstoke, 2002), pp. 11–27.Google Scholar

Copyright information

© Andrew Crome 2015

Authors and Affiliations

  • Andrew Crome

There are no affiliations available

Personalised recommendations