Repicturing the Second World War pp 177-191 | Cite as
Realism, Historical Truth and the War Film: The Case of Saving Private Ryan
Abstract
Saving Private Ryan has been widely praised for bringing a heightened level of realism to the representation of war. Some even regard it as a landmark in the history of war films, praising Steven Spielberg for recreating battle so realistically as to bring truth to the representation of war. Although the cinematic techniques pioneered in this film have since been widely copied, Saving Private Ryan is still widely recognised as being the best of the ‘epic battle’ films, especially because of the visceral recreation of the landings on Omaha beach, according to one anonymous viewer — a ‘byword for war realism’. In order to faithfully recreate the battle of Normandy, Spielberg exploited an arsenal of filmmaking techniques, notably by mimicking the actuality footage that was shot by official military cameramen serving with the Allied armies during the Second World War. But how does Spielberg’s representation compare with the scenes recorded in the ‘real footage’ taken by men under fire using basic cameras?
Keywords
Saving Private Regard Private Actual Combat German Soldier Ally DeadPreview
Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.
Notes and References
- 5.Flt Lt J. Nichol, ‘It’s the Brutal Truth’, The Sun, 11 September 1998: p. 30.Google Scholar
- 6.J. Wrathall, ‘On the Beach’, Sight and Sound, 9 (September 1998): pp. 34–35.Google Scholar
- 7.S.E. Ambrose, ‘The Longest Day (U.S. 1962): “Blockbuster” History’, in John Whiteclay Chambers and David Culbert, eds, WW11: Film and History (New York: OUP, 1996): p. 102.Google Scholar
- 10.See A. Kelly, Cinema and the Great War (London: Routledge, 1997): p. 45.Google Scholar
- 10.See also J. Whiteclay Chambers, ‘All Quiet on the Western Front: The Anti-War Film and the Image of Modern War’, in Whiteclay Chambers and D. Culbert, eds, World War II, Film, and History (New York: OUP, 1996): p. 8.Google Scholar
- 11.Spielberg, War Stories, BBC2, 13 September 1998.Google Scholar
- 12.Spielberg, Return to Normandy, BBC1, 7 September 1998.Google Scholar
- 13.Spielberg, War Stories, BBC2, 13 September 1998.Google Scholar
- 14.R. Capa, Slightly Out of Focus (New York: Henry Holt, 1947): p. 151.Google Scholar
- 15.Quoted in S.E. Ambrose, D-Day (1994): p. 396.Google Scholar
- 16.James Barker, ‘D-Day: Fact of Fiction?’ Focal International 13 (Autumn 1994): p. 6.Google Scholar
- 25.P. Neushul and J.D. Neushul, ‘With the Marines at Tarawa’, Proceedings (April 1999): pp. 74–79.Google Scholar
- 26.J. and S. Combs, Film Propaganda and American Politics: An Analysis and Filmography (London: Garland Publishing, 1994): p. 78.Google Scholar
- 27.N. Ascherson, ‘Missing in Action’, The Observer, 6 September 1998: p. 7.Google Scholar