The Mirror of History and Images of the Nation: the Invention of a National Identity in Brazil and its Contrasts with Similar Enterprises in Mexico and Argentina

  • Eliana Freitas de Dutra
Chapter

Abstract

This chapter will examine the crucial role played by history writing in the configuration of a national imaginary and collective identity in Brazil from the second half of the nineteenth century to the first half of the twentieth century and it will contrast this with similar efforts undertaken in Argentina and Mexico. In order to produce a full account of this enterprise we have chosen to take as our first point of reference the Exhibition of Brazilian History that took place in Rio de Janeiro in 1881. This imperial-era exhibition was intended to be a showcase for the nation, and established a general inventory of archival sources for the purpose of broadening knowledge of Brazil’s past, and in particular of ‘fatherland history’. This exhibition and the catalogue that accompanied it can be seen to have become something of an emblem of the transition between two generations of constructors of national history writing in Brazil: the monarchist historians and the republican historians. Our second point of reference will be the works of those Brazilian national historians who enjoyed great acclaim during the empire and at the start of the republican period, and who included Francisco Adolfo de Varnhagen, Capistrano de Abreu and João Ribeiro. Their interpretations contributed to the establishment of the founding myth of Brazilian history: the myth of the ‘three races’.

Keywords

Nineteenth Century Indigenous People National Identity National History History Writing 
These keywords were added by machine and not by the authors. This process is experimental and the keywords may be updated as the learning algorithm improves.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in to check access.

Preview

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

Select Bibliography

  1. Abreu, Capistrano, Capitulos de Historia Colonial (1500–1800), 5th edn (Rio de Janeiro, 1969).Google Scholar
  2. Aguiar, Ronaldo Conde, O Rebelde Esquecido. Tempo, Vida e Obra de Manoel Bon fim (Rio de Janeiro, 2000).Google Scholar
  3. Anderson, Benedict, Naçâo e Consciência Nacional (Sao Paulo, 1989).Google Scholar
  4. Andrews, George Reid, The Afro-Argentines of Buenos Aires, 1800–1900 (Wisconsin, 1980).Google Scholar
  5. Araûjo, Ricardo Benzaquen, ‘Ronda Noturna. Narrativa, Critica e Verdade em Capistrano de Abreu’, Estudos Histôricos 1 (1988).Google Scholar
  6. Araûjo, Ricardo Benzaquen, Guerra e Paz — Casa Grande & Senzala e a Obra de Gilberto Freyre (Rio de Janeiro, 1994).Google Scholar
  7. Benites, Augustin Basave, México Mestizo:Anâlisis del Nacionalismo Mexican en tomo a la mestzofiiia de Andrés Molina Henriquez (Mexico, 1992).Google Scholar
  8. Blancarte, Roberto (ed.), Cultura e Identidad Nacional (Mexico, 1994).Google Scholar
  9. Bonfim, Manuel, América Latina. Males de Origem (Rio de Janeiro, 1993; 1st edn, 1905).Google Scholar
  10. Bonfim, Manuel, O Brasil Napo (Rio de Janeiro, 1996; 1st edn, 1931).Google Scholar
  11. Botana, Natalio R., El Orden Conservador. La Politica Argentina entre 1888 y 1916 (Buenos Aires, 1986).Google Scholar
  12. Donghi, Tulio Halperin, ‘Mitre e a Formulaçäo de uma Historia Nacional para a Argentina’, Estudos Avançados 8 (1994).Google Scholar
  13. Dutra, Eliana de Freitas, ‘La fusion des races comme lieu de mémoire’, Diogène 191 (2000), 32–46.Google Scholar
  14. Dutra, Eliana de Freitas, Rebeldes Literârios da Republica. Historia e Identidade Nacional no Almanque Brasileiro Gamier (1903–1914) (Belo Horizonte, 2005).Google Scholar
  15. Fell, Eve Marie, ‘Primeras reformulations del pensamiento racista al despertar de la consciencia revolucionâria’, in Ana Pizarro (ed.), América Latina: Palavra, Literatura e Cultura (São Paulo, 1994), vol. 2.Google Scholar
  16. Florescano, Enrique, El Nuevo Pasado Mexicano (Mexico, 1991).Google Scholar
  17. Franco, Stella Maris Scatena, Luzes e Sombras na Construçâo da Napo Argentina: Os Manuais de Historia Nacional (Bragança Paulista, 2003).Google Scholar
  18. Freyre, Gilberto, Casa Grande & Senzala — Formaçâo da Familia Brasileira sob o Regime Patriarcal (Rio de Janeiro, 1969; 1st edn, 1933).Google Scholar
  19. Gellner, Ernest, Nations et Nationalisme (Paris, 1989).Google Scholar
  20. Gomes, Angela Maria de Castro, Historia e Historiadores (Rio de Janeiro, 1996).Google Scholar
  21. Guimaräes, Manoel Luis Salgado, ‘Naçao e Civilizaçao nos Tropicos’, Estudos Historicos 1 (1988), 5–27.Google Scholar
  22. Guimaräes, LGcia Maria Paschoal, Debaixo da Proteçao de Sua Magestade Imperial. O Instituto Historico GeogrOflco Brasileiro (1838–1889) (Rio de Janeiro, 1997), vol. 1.Google Scholar
  23. Guimaräes, Lacia Maria Paschoal, ‘Um Olhar sobre o Continente: O Instituto Historico e Geogrâfico brasileiro e o Congresso Internacional de Historia da América’, Estudos Historicos 20 (1997).Google Scholar
  24. Hobsbawm, Eric, Napes e Nacionalismo desde 1780 (Rio de Janeiro,1990).Google Scholar
  25. Lafforge, Edmund, La Escuela popular: su évolution y proyeccion (Buenos Aires, 1980).Google Scholar
  26. Lima, Oliveira, Formation de la Nationalité Brésilienne (Paris, 1911).Google Scholar
  27. Llorens, Antonia Pi-Sumer, ‘Una Gran Empresa Cultural de Mediados del siglo XIX: el Diccionario Universal de Historia y Geografla’, in Laura Beatriz Suarez de la Torre (ed.), Empresa y Cultura en Tinta y Papel (1800–1860) (Mexico, 2001), pp. 409–18.Google Scholar
  28. Maristany, José, Las Ficciones el Pasado en los Manueles de la Historia Argentina: 1880–1910 (www.univ-tours.fr /Maristany-29-01-2005).Google Scholar
  29. Martius, Friedrich Philipp von, Como se deve escrever a Historia do Brasil (Rio de Janeiro, 1991).Google Scholar
  30. Mitre, Antônio, O Dilema do Centauro. Ensaios de tôria da Historia e pensamento latinoamericano (Belo Horizonte, 2003).Google Scholar
  31. Mitre, Bartolomé, Historia de Belgrano y de la Independencia Argentina, 5th edn (Buenos Aires, 1902).Google Scholar
  32. Mora, Arturo Soberon, ‘Las Armas de la Ilustracion: folhetos, catecismos, cartilhas y dicionarios en la construction del México moderno’, in Laura Beatriz Suarez de la Torre (ed.), Empresa y Cultura en Tinta y Papel (1800–1860) (Mexico, 2001).Google Scholar
  33. Mora, José Maria Luis, México y sus revoluciones (Mexico, 1950).Google Scholar
  34. Odalia, Nilo (ed.), Varnhagen (Sao Paulo, 1979).Google Scholar
  35. O’Gorman, Edmund, ‘La Revolucion Mexicana y la Historiographie en México’, in México, 50 anos de Revoluçâo (Mexico, 1960).Google Scholar
  36. Ortega y Medina, Juan A., ‘Indigenismo e Hispanismo en la Consciencia Historiogrâfica Mexicana’, in Roberto Blancarte (ed.), Cultura e Identidad Nacional (Mexico, 1994).Google Scholar
  37. Quijada, Monica, Carmen Bernand and A. Schneider (eds), Homogeneidad y Nation: Conun Estudio de Caso: Argentina, Siglos XIX y XX (Madrid, 2000).Google Scholar
  38. Reis, José Carlos, As Identidades do Brasil de Varnhagen à FHC (Rio de Janeiro, 1999).Google Scholar
  39. Ribeiro, Joao, Historia do Brasil, Curso Superior, 14th edn (Rio de Janeiro, 1953, 1st edn, 1900).Google Scholar
  40. Rodrigues, José HonOrio, ‘Varnhagen: Mestre da Historia Geral do Brasil’, Revista do IHGB (April/June 1967).Google Scholar
  41. Romero, Jose Luis, Las Ideas Politico en Argentina (Buenos Aires, 1975).Google Scholar
  42. Romero, Silvio, Historia da Literatura Brasileira, 3rd edn (Rio de Janeiro, 1943; 1st edition, 1888).Google Scholar
  43. Rouanet, Maria Helena, Eternamente em Berço Esplêndido: a Fundaçao de uma Literatura Nacional (Sao Paulo, 1991).Google Scholar
  44. Schwarcz, Lilia Moritz, O Espetâculo das Raças. Cientistas, Instituiçöes e Questdo Racial no Brasil, 1870–1930 (Sao Paulo, 1993).Google Scholar
  45. Schwarcz, Lilia Moritz, As Barbas do Imperador (Sao Paulo, 1998).Google Scholar
  46. Skidmore, Thomas, Preto no Branco. Raça e Nacionalidade no Pensamento Brasileiro (Rio de Janeiro, 1976).Google Scholar
  47. Smith, A. D., Theories of Nationalism (London, 1983).Google Scholar
  48. Smith, A. D., ‘O Nacionalismo e os Historiadores’, in Gopal Balakrishnan (ed.), Um Mapa da Questào Nacional (Rio de Janeiro, 2000).Google Scholar
  49. Solari, Horacio, Historia de la educaciOn argentina (Buenos Aires, 1949).Google Scholar
  50. Sommer, Doris, Ficçiies de Fundaçdo. Os Romances Nacionais da América Latina (Belo Horizonte, 2004).Google Scholar
  51. Southey, Robert, Historia do Brasil (Rio de Janeiro, 1862).Google Scholar
  52. Suarez de la Torre, Laura Beatriz, ‘Lectores-actores mexicanos, lecturas extranjeras: influencias para la formaciOn de una cultura nacional’, in Eliana Freitas de Dutra and Jean-Yves Mollier (eds), Politica, Napo e Ediçâo (Sao Paulo, 2006).Google Scholar
  53. Süsskind, Flora, O Brasil nâo é Longe Daqui: o Narrador, a Viagem (Sao Paulo, 1990).Google Scholar
  54. Süsskind, Flora and Roberto Ventura, Historia, e Dependência. Cultura e Sociedade em Manoel Bonfim (Sao Paulo, 1984).Google Scholar
  55. Varnhagen, Adolfo Francisco, Historia Geral do Brasil, 5 vols, 6th edn (Sao Paulo, 1957).Google Scholar
  56. Ventura, Roberto, Estilo Tropical (Sao Paulo, 1991).Google Scholar
  57. Vianna, Oliveira, Evoluçâo do Povo Brasileiro (Sao Paulo, 1923).Google Scholar
  58. Vianna, Oliveira, Raça e Assimilaçào (Sao Paulo, 1938).Google Scholar
  59. Wehling, Arno, A Invençâo da Historia.Estudos Sobre o Historicismo (Rio de Janeiro, 1994).Google Scholar
  60. Zavala, Lorenzo, Ensayo Historico de las Revolutiones de México (Mexico, 1985).Google Scholar

Copyright information

© Eliana de Freitas Dutra 2007

Authors and Affiliations

  • Eliana Freitas de Dutra

There are no affiliations available

Personalised recommendations