Advertisement

Hybrid Justice (i): Indigenous Sentencing and Justice Planning

  • Harry Blagg
  • Thalia Anthony
Chapter
Part of the Critical Criminological Perspectives book series (CCRP)

Abstract

This chapter considers how the operation of the “third space” (Bhabha 1994) between the Global South and the Global North is enlivened to deepen Indigenous place-based and place-centred forms of political, social and legal organisation. It asks whether sentencing—as a site of punishment, rehabilitation and integration—can do more than further objectives of state law and order, and instead augment Indigenous social orders? Can Indigenous innovations in sentencing embody inter-cultural struggle and negotiation or are they at the mercy of state control? It suggests that Indigenous Law and Justice planning, rather than sentencing, exhibits indicia of inter-cultural struggle that countermands the dictates of the state and white laws. Whatever its form, inter-cultural spaces remain fragile to the colonial project and its persistent drive for hegemony.

References

  1. Alfred T (1999) Peace, Power, Righteousness. An Indigenous Manifesto. Don Mills: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
  2. ——— (2005) Wasáse: Indigenous Pathways of Action and Freedom. Toronto: University of Toronto Press.Google Scholar
  3. Allison F and Cunneen C (2010) “The Role of Indigenous Justice Agreements in Improving Legal and Social Outcomes for Indigenous People”. Sydney Law Review 32: 645–669.Google Scholar
  4. Anthony T (2013) Indigenous People, Crime and Punishment. Oxon: Routledge.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  5. ——— (2015) “Two Laws: Indigenous Justice Mechanisms in Context”. Journal of Australian Indigenous Issues 18(1): 99–115.Google Scholar
  6. ——— (2017) “The Limits of Reconciliation in Criminal Sentencing”. In S Maddison, T Clark and R de Costa (eds) The Limits of Settler Colonial Reconciliation Non-Indigenous People and the Responsibility to Engage. Singapore: Springer, 249–270.Google Scholar
  7. ——— (2018) “Policing in Redfern: Histories and Continuities”. Court of Conscience 12(10): 46–55.Google Scholar
  8. Anthony T and Chapman R (2008) “Unresolved Tensions: Warlpiri Law, Police Powers and Land Rights”. Indigenous Law Bulletin 7(5): 9–18.Google Scholar
  9. Anthony T and Crawford W (2014) “Northern Territory Indigenous Community Sentencing Mechanisms: An Order for Substantive Equality”. Australian Indigenous Law Review 17(2): 79–99.Google Scholar
  10. Anthony T and Grant E (2016) “Courthouse Design Principles to Dignify Spaces for Indigenous Users: Preliminary Observations”. International Journal for Court Administration 8(1): 43–59.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  11. Anthony T, Marchetti E, Behrendt L and Longman C (2017) “Individualised Justice Through Indigenous Community Reports in Sentencing”. Journal of Judicial Administration 26(3): 121–140.Google Scholar
  12. April S and Orsi M (2013) Gladue Practices in the Provinces and Territories. Ottawa, ON: Department of Justice.Google Scholar
  13. Austin-Broos D (1996) “‘Two Laws’, Ontologies, Histories: Ways of Being Aranda Today”. The Australian Journal of Anthropology 7(1): 1–20.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  14. Australian Capital Territory Government and Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Elected Body (2019) ACT Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Agreement 2019—2028: Delivering Equitable Outcomes for Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Peoples. https://www.communityservices.act.gov.au/__data/assets/pdf_file/0015/1323132/ACT-Aboriginal-and-Torres-Strait-Islander-Agreement-2019-2028.pdf
  15. Beranger B, Weatherburn D and Moffatt S (2010) “Reducing Indigenous Contact with the Court System”. NSW Bureau of Crime Statistics and Research: Crime and Justice Statistics Bureau Brief 54: 1–4.Google Scholar
  16. Bern J (1979) “Ideology and Domination: Toward a Reconstruction of Australian Aboriginal Social Formation”. Oceania 50: 118–132.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  17. Bhabha H K (1994) The Location of Culture. London: Routledge.Google Scholar
  18. Black C (2011) The Land is the Source of the Law: A Dialogic Encounter with Indigenous Jurisprudence. London: Routledge.Google Scholar
  19. Blagg H (2008) “Colonial Critique and Critical Criminology: Issues in Aboriginal Law and Aboriginal Violence”. In T Anthony and C Cunneen (eds) The Critical Criminology Companion. Sydney: Hawkins Press, 129–146.Google Scholar
  20. Blokland J (2007) “The Northern Territory Experience”. Paper presented at Australian Institute of Judicial Administration Indigenous Courts Conference at Mildura, 7 September.Google Scholar
  21. Borowski A (2010) “Indigenous Participation in Sentencing Young Offenders: Findings from an Evaluation of the Children’s Koori Court of Victoria”. Australian and New Zealand Journal of Criminology 43: 465–484.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  22. Bradley H M (2005) Community Court Darwin Guidelines, and the General Sentencing Provisions in the Sentencing Act 2005 (NT). Darwin: Northern Territory Department of Justice.Google Scholar
  23. Cunneen C (2008) “Understanding Restorative Justice Through the Lens of Critical Criminology”. In T Anthony and C Cunneen (eds) The Critical Criminology Companion. Sydney: Hawkins Press, 249–266.Google Scholar
  24. ——— (2018) “Sentencing, Punishment and Indigenous People in Australia”. Journal of Global Indigeneity 3(1). https://ro.uow.edu.au/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1047&context=jgi
  25. Daly K and Marchetti E (2012) “Innovative Justice Processes: Restorative Justice, Indigenous Justice and Therapeutic Jurisprudence.” In M Marmo, W de Lint and D Palmer (eds) Crime and Justice: A Guide to Criminology. Sydney: Lawbook Co, 455–481.Google Scholar
  26. Davies L, Whaanga J and Kaipuke Limited (2012) “Evaluation of the Early Outcomes of Ngā Kooti Rangatahi”. Submitted to the Ministry of Justice. Wellington, Ministry of Justice.Google Scholar
  27. Douglas H (2005) “Customary Law, Sentencing and the Limits of the State”. Canadian Journal of Law and Society 20(1): 141–156.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  28. Finnane M (2006) “The Tides of Customary Law”. ANZLH E-Journal, Keynote speech.Google Scholar
  29. Fitzgerald J (2008) “Does Circle Sentencing Reduce Aboriginal Offending?” Crime and Justice Bulletin: Contemporary Issues in Crime and Justice 115: 1–12.Google Scholar
  30. Gaykamangu J G (2012) “Ngarra Law: Aboriginal Customary Law from Arnhem Land”. Northern Territory Law Journal 2: 236–248.Google Scholar
  31. Gaymarani G (2011) “An Introduction to the Ngarra Law of Arnhem Land”. Northern Territory Law Journal 1(6): 283–304.Google Scholar
  32. Gosford B (2014) “The Northern Myth: Djambuy’s Case and the Recognition of Aboriginal Customary Law”. Crikey (online), 6 February 2014. http://blogs.crikey.com.au/northern/2014/02/06/djambuys-case-and-the-recognition-of-aboriginal-customary-law/
  33. Hannah-Moffat K and Maurutto P (2010) “Recontextualising Pre-sentence Reports: Risk and Race”. Punishment and Society 12(3): 262–286.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  34. Hannam H (2013) “Current Issues in Delivering Indigenous Justice: Challenges for the Courts”. Paper presented at Australian Institute of Judicial Administration Conference, University of South Australia, Adelaide, 18 July.Google Scholar
  35. Jackson M (1995) “Justice and Political Power: Reasserting Mãori Legal Processes”. In K Hazlehurst (ed) Legal Pluralism and the Colonial Legacy. Aldershot: Avebury, 243–263.Google Scholar
  36. ——— (2016) “The Abolition of Prisons and Indigenous Self Determination”. Presentation to the Forum for Indigenous Research Excellence Symposium, University of Wollongong. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mPnf0cbFIuo
  37. Jeffries S and Stenning P (2014) “Sentencing Aboriginal Offenders: Law, Policy, and Practice in Three Countries”. Canadian Journal of Criminology and Criminal Justice 56: 447–494.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  38. Johnson S (2014) “Developing First Nations Courts in Canada: Elders as Foundational to Indigenous Therapeutic Jurisprudence”. Journal of Indigenous Social Development 3(2): 1–14.Google Scholar
  39. Kuortti J and Nyman J (2007) “Introduction: Hybridity Today”. In Joel Kuortti and Jopi Nyman, Reconstructing Hybridity: Post-colonial Studies in Transition. Amsterdam: Rodopi, 1–18.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  40. Lajamanu Law and Justice Group (2014) “Kurdiji: Shield—To Protect and Discipline”. http://www.clc.org.au/files/pdf/KurdijiNEbook-6.pdf
  41. LaPrairie C (1995) “Altering Course, New Directions in Criminal Justice: Sentencing Circles and Family Group Conferences”. Australian and New Zealand Journal of Criminology. Special Supplementary Issue: 78–99.Google Scholar
  42. Law Reform Commission of Western Australia (2006) Aboriginal Customary Law Discussion Paper. Discussion Paper No. 94. Perth, Australia: Law Reform Commission, February.Google Scholar
  43. Lilles H (2002) “Circle Sentencing: Part of the Restorative Justice Continuum”. Paper presented at the “Dreaming of a New Reality,” the Third International Conference on Conferencing Circles and other Restorative Practices, Minneapolis, MN, August 8–10.Google Scholar
  44. Loy D (2010) “Bush Law”. Message Stick Transcript, Australian Broadcasting Corporation, 28 March.Google Scholar
  45. Maddock K (1977) “Two Laws in One Community”. In R Berndt (ed) Aborigines and Change: Australia in the 70s. Canberra: Australian Institute of Aboriginal Studies, 13–32.Google Scholar
  46. Mahony A (2014) “The Day the Pintupi Nine Entered the Modern World”. BBC News, 23 December 2014. https://www.bbc.com/news/magazine-30500591
  47. Marchetti E (2010) “Indigenous Sentencing Courts and Partner Violence: Perspectives of Court Practitioners and Elders on Gender Power Imbalances During the Sentencing Hearing”. The Australian and New Zealand Journal of Criminology 43(2): 263–281.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  48. Marchetti E and Anthony T (2016) “Sentencing Indigenous Offenders in Canada, Australia, and New Zealand”. In M Tonry (ed) Oxford Handbooks Online: Criminology and Criminal Justice. Oxon: Oxford University Press, 1–30.Google Scholar
  49. Marchetti E and Daly K (2007) “Indigenous Sentencing Courts: Towards a Theoretical and Jurisprudential Model”. Sydney Law Review 29(3): 415–443.Google Scholar
  50. Merlan F (1998) Caging the Rainbow: Places, Politics and Aborigines in a North Australian Town. Honolulu: University of Hawaii Press.Google Scholar
  51. Morgan A and Louis E (2010) Evaluation of the Queensland Murri Court: Final Report. Canberra: Australian Institute of Criminology.Google Scholar
  52. National Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Legal Services (2019) “What We Do”. http://www.natsils.org.au/AboutUs/Whatwedo.aspx
  53. National Criminal Justice Reference Service (2001) “Circle Sentencing”. Juvenile Justice Bulletin. https://www.ncjrs.gov/html/ojjdp/2001_2_1/page4.html
  54. New Zealand Ministry of Justice (2010) “Principal Youth Court Judge’s Newsletter: Issue 47”. http://www.justice.govt.nz/courts/youth/publications-and-media/principalyouth-court-newsletter/issue-47
  55. Northern Territory Government (2019) “Northern Territory Aboriginal Justice Agreement (Draft Agreement—for consultation)”. https://justice.nt.gov.au/attorney-general-and-justice/northern-territory-aboriginal-justice-agreement
  56. Pawu-Kurlpurlurnu W J, Holmes M and Box L. 2008. Ngurra-kurlu: A Way of Working with Warlpiri People, DKCRC Report 41. Desert Knowledge CRC, Alice Springs.Google Scholar
  57. Reconciliation Australia (2013) “Two Way Governance”. 31 May. http://www.reconciliation.org.au/governance/toolkit/2-2-two-way-governance
  58. Roach K (2009) “One Step Forward, Two Steps Back: Gladue in the Courts of Appeal”. Criminal Law Quarterly 54: 470–505.Google Scholar
  59. Royal Commission into Aboriginal Deaths in Custody (1991) National Report. Canberra: Australian Government Publishing Service.Google Scholar
  60. Said E (1978) Orientalism. New York: Pantheon.Google Scholar
  61. ——— (1993) Culture and Imperialism. London: Vintage.Google Scholar
  62. Sepahvand H (2012) “Hybridity as Instrument of Decolonization in Herman Melville‘s Moby Dick”. Theory and Practice in Language Studies 2(5): 895–901.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  63. Shepherd S M and Anthony T (2018) “Popping the Cultural Bubble of Violence Risk Assessment Tools”. Journal of Forensic Psychiatry and Psychology 29(2): 211–220.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  64. Shohat E (1992) “Social Text”. Third World and Postcolonial Issues 31/32: 99–113.Google Scholar
  65. Spiers Williams M (2013) “Why are There No Adult Community Courts Operating in the Northern Territory of Australia?” Indigenous Law Bulletin 8(4): 7–11.Google Scholar
  66. Sutherland J (2002) “Colonialism, Crime, and Dispute Resolution: A Critical Analysis of Canada’s Aboriginal Justice Strategy”. Online article. Mediate.com. http://www.mediate.com/articles/sutherlandJ.cfm.
  67. Tauri J (1998) “Family Group Conferencing: A Case Study of the Indigenisation of New Zealand’s Justice System”. Current Issues in Criminal Justice 10(2): 168–182.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  68. ——— (2016) “The State, the Academy and Indigenous Justice: A Counter-Colonial Critique”. PhD Thesis, University of Wollongong.Google Scholar
  69. Tonkinson R (1978) “Aboriginal Community Autonomy: Myth and Reality”. In M Howard (ed) “Whitefella Business”: Aborigines in Australian Politics. Philadelphia: Institute for the Study of Human Issues, 93–103.Google Scholar
  70. Victoria State Government and Aboriginal Justice Caucus (2019) “The Aboriginal Justice Agreement Phase 4”. Victorian Aboriginal Justice Agreement. https://www.aboriginaljustice.vic.gov.au/the-agreement/the-aboriginal-justice-agreement-phase-4
  71. Walsh C (2010) “Development as Buen Vivir: Institutional Arrangements and (De)Colonial Entanglements”. Development 53(1): 15–21.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  72. Wild R and Anderson P (2007) Ampe Akelyernemane Meke Mekarle ‘Little Children are Sacred’: Final Report of the Board of Inquiry into the Protection of Aboriginal Children from Sexual Abuse. Darwin: Northern Territory Government.Google Scholar
  73. Yaxley L (2006) “High Court Rejects Appeal Based on Customary Law”. PM Program, ABC Radio, 19 May. http://www.abc.net.au/pm/content/2006/s1643178.htm
  74. Yunupingu G (1998) Third Vincent Lingiari Memorial Lecture, 20 August, Darwin.Google Scholar

Legal Materials

  1. Aboriginal Areas Protection Authority v S & R Building and Construction Pty Ltd [2011] NTSC 3.Google Scholar
  2. Amagula v White [1998] NTSC 61.Google Scholar
  3. Bugmy v The Queen (2013) 249 CLR 571.Google Scholar
  4. Goldsmith v R (1995) 65 SASR 373.Google Scholar
  5. Jabaltjari v Hammersley (1977) 15 ALR 94.Google Scholar
  6. Jadurin v R (1982) 7 Crim R 182.Google Scholar
  7. Juli v R (1990) 50 A Crim R 31.Google Scholar
  8. Mika v The Queen [2013] NZCA 648.Google Scholar
  9. Munungurr v The Queen (1994) 4 NTLR 63.Google Scholar
  10. Neal v The Queen (1982) 149 CLR 305.Google Scholar
  11. Northern Territory National Emergency Response Act 2007 (Cth).Google Scholar
  12. Queen v Bara [2006] NTCCA 17 at 11.Google Scholar
  13. R v Bulmer ((1986) 25 A Crim R 155).Google Scholar
  14. R v Ceissman (2001) 119 A Crim R 53.Google Scholar
  15. R v Davey (1980) 2 A Crim R 254.Google Scholar
  16. R v Fernando (1992) 76 A Crim R 58.Google Scholar
  17. R v Friday (1984) 14 A Crim R 471.Google Scholar
  18. R v Fuller-Cust (2002) 6 VR 496.Google Scholar
  19. R v Gladue [1999] 1 SCR 688.Google Scholar
  20. R v Huata & Huata (Unreported CD, Auckland District Court, CRI-2003-041-5606, 30 September 2005).Google Scholar
  21. R v Ipeelee [2012] 1 SCR 433.Google Scholar
  22. R v Mamarika (1982) 5 A Crim R 354.Google Scholar
  23. R v Minor (1992) 105 FLR 180.Google Scholar
  24. R v Miyatatawuy (1996) 87 A Crim R 574.Google Scholar
  25. R v Morgan (2003) 57 NSWLR 533.Google Scholar
  26. R v Moses ([1992] 71 CCC (d) 347.Google Scholar
  27. R v Mustey [2001] VSC 68.Google Scholar
  28. R v Nathan (1989) 4 CRNZ 369.Google Scholar
  29. R v Poulson (2001) 122 A Crim R 388.Google Scholar
  30. R v Shannon (1991) 56 A Crim R 56.Google Scholar
  31. R v Wunungmurra [2009] NTSC 24.Google Scholar
  32. R v Yakayaka and Djambuy (2012, Unreported, Supreme Court of Northern Territory, Riley CJ, 17 December).Google Scholar
  33. R v Yougie (1987) 33 A Crim R 301.Google Scholar
  34. Rogers & Murray v R (1989) 44 A Crim R 301.Google Scholar
  35. The Queen v Rawiri and Others (2009, High Court of New Zealand CRI-2007-032-5294, Simon France J, 14 August).Google Scholar
  36. Walden v Hensler (1987) 163 CLR 561.Google Scholar
  37. Walker v New South Wales (1994) 182 CLR 45.Google Scholar
  38. Wurramara (1999) 105 A Crim R 512.Google Scholar

Copyright information

© The Author(s) 2019

Authors and Affiliations

  • Harry Blagg
    • 1
  • Thalia Anthony
    • 2
  1. 1.Faculty of LawUniversity of Western AustraliaCrawleyAustralia
  2. 2.Faculty of LawUniversity of Technology SydneySydneyAustralia

Personalised recommendations