Advertisement

Aggressive Nationalism: Utilising the Yuanmingyuan Incident

  • Robert Weatherley
  • Qiang Zhang
Chapter

Abstract

This chapter provides the first of our two cases studies on aggressive nationalism, focusing on the official propagation of the Anglo-French destruction of Yuanmingyuan in 1860. Here we trace the different ways in which the party has reminded the Chinese public about this traumatic incident. The underlying objective has been to enhance the CCP’s status as the party which liberated China from the Century of Humiliation and established the PRC as a major international power. However, this has not always materialised. Instead, some members of the public have been critical of the CCP, accusing it of being no better at standing up for Chinese interests than the much-hated Qing dynasty during the Century of Humiliation, as epitomised by the Yuanmingyuan incident.

References

  1. BBC. (2009, March 2). China “Patriot” sabotages auction. Retrieved from http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/world/asia-pacific/7918128.stm.
  2. BBC. (2015a, February 2). The palace of shame that makes China angry. Retrieved from http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/magazine-30810596.
  3. BBC. (2015b, November 5). South China sea: US defence chief Ash Carter wades into row. Retrieved from http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-asia-34737051.
  4. Beijing Review. (2011, December 15). Is it necessary to reconstruct the Yuanmingyuan? Retrieved from http://www.bjreview.com.cn/forum/txt/2011-12/12/content_411014.htm.
  5. Benniu007. (2012, May 27). Yuanmingyuan de Huimie [The destruction of the Yuanmingyuan]. Xinlang Boke [Sina Blog]. Retrieved from http://blog.sina.com.
  6. Bickers, R. (2011). China’s age of fragility. History Today. Retrieved from http://www.historytoday.com/robert-bickers/chinas-age-fragility.
  7. BJRB. (2011, June 14). Si Jian Yuanmingyuan Shou Shou Jiang Jushou Wuhan [Four old summer palace animal head statues will ‘Meet’ in Wuhan]. Beijing Ribao [Beijing Daily]. Retrieved from http://www.bjd.com.
  8. Bloomberg. (2013, April 27). Pinault family gives China $40 million disputed bronze. Retrieved from https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2013-04-26/christie-s-pinault-donates-40-million-bronzes-to-china.
  9. Broudehoux, A.-M. (2004). The making and selling of post-Mao Beijing. London: Routledge.Google Scholar
  10. Cedar. (2012, March 24). Zhongguoren de Shi Yao Zhongguoren Ziji Ban - Yao Gan yu Shihang Baogao [Chinese matters need Chinese self-management - responding to the world bank report]. Xinlang Boke [Sina Blog]. Retrieved from http://blog.sina.com.
  11. China Beat. (2009, February 24). James Hevia on summer palace relics. Retrieved from http://www.thechinabeat.org/?p=372.
  12. China.org. (2006, September 27). Yuanmingyuan Park to be Rebuilt? China.org.cn. Retrieved from http://www.china.org.cn http://www.china.org.cn/english/travel/182412.htm.
  13. China.org. (2007, December 21). Netizens against rebuilding the old summer palace. China.org.cn. Retrieved from http://www.china.org.cn/english/China/236455.htm.
  14. China View. (2009). Lawyers abroad form alliance for return of lost cultural relics. Xinhua News Agency. Retrieved from http://news.xinhuanet.com/english/2009-03/04/content_10942816.htm.
  15. CNTV. (2010a, October 20). 1.6 Million Chinese relics held by 47 museums worldwide. Retrieved from http://english.cntv.cn/program/china24/20101020/100840.shtml.
  16. CNTV. (2010b, October 20). Arduous journey to recovering relics. Retrieved from http://english.cntv.cn/program/china24/20101019/101180.shtml.
  17. CNTV. (2010c, October 20). New Zealander returns looted Yuanmingyuan treasures. Retrieved from http://english.cntv.cn/program/cultureexpress/20101019/101188.shtml.
  18. CQWB. (2010, December 17). Babai Zhuangshi Zuihou Laobing Yang Yangzheng Zou le [Yang Yangzheng, the last of the eight hundred heroes, passed away yesterday]. Chongqing Wanbao [Chongqing Evening News]. Retrieved from http://www.cqwb.com.cn/NewsFiles/201012/17/20100017120000412114.shtml.
  19. CQWB. (2011, November 28). Yuanmingyuan Shifou Chongjian Yin Zhengyi [The continuing restoration debate regarding Yuanmingyuan]. Chongqing Wanbao [Chongqing Evening News]. Retrieved from http://news.cqwb.com.
  20. Dai35408. (2010, October 23). Du Junli: Fang Bu Xia De Yuanmingyuan Qingjie [Unable to let go of the Yuanmingyuan complex]. Xinlang Boke [Sina Blog]. Retrieved from http://blog.sina.com.
  21. DFRB. (2010, January 15). Huoshao Yuanmingyuan 150 Nian Yao Qinlue Guo Chuxi Jinian [Invitation to the invading countries to attend the commemoration of the 150th anniversary of the burning of the Yuanmingyuan]. Dongfang Ribao [Oriental Daily News]. Retrieved from http://global.factiva.com.
  22. dgc5. (2015, January 26). Retrieved from http://www.weibo.com/1829885151/C1qaUyNkT.
  23. Han, G., & Zhang, A. (2009). Starbucks is Forbidden in the Forbidden City: Blog Circuit of Culture and Informal Public Relations Campaign in China. Public Relations Review, 35, 395–401.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  24. Global Times. (2014, December 8). US, China can work together to cool disputes. Retrieved from http://www.globaltimes.cn/content/895600.shtml.
  25. Global Times. (2015, May 13). Zhejiang businessman attempts to recreate old summer palace, turn it into theme park. Retrieved from http://www.globaltimes.cn/content/921513.shtml.
  26. GZRB. (2009, November 3). Yanzhe Beijing Si Hao Xian Chihe Wanle [Food and amusements along the Beijing number 4 line]. Guangzhou Ribao [Guangzhou Daily]. Retrieved from http://gzdaily.dayoo.com.
  27. JFJB. (1990, September 23). Zhongguo: Zouxiang 21 Shiji [China: Moving towards the 21st century]. Jiefangjun Bao [People’s Liberation Army Daily]. Retrieved from http://dlib.eastview.com.
  28. JFJB. (1995, January 16). Yuguo Shuxin Jielu Liang ge Qiangdao Zuilian [Hugo letter exposes the face of the two robbers]. Jiefangjun Bao [People’s Liberation Army Daily]. Retrieved from http://dlib.eastview.com.
  29. JFJB. (1997, July 2). Junmin Gongqing Xianggang Huigui [Together the military and civilians celebrate the return of Hong Kong]. Jiefangjun Bao [People’s Liberation Army Daily]. Retrieved from http://dlib.eastview.com.
  30. JFJB. (1998, February 9). Dangdai Zibenzhuyi Guojia Gongren Jieji de Bianhua Deng [Working class changes in a contemporary capitalist country]. Jiefangjun Bao [People’s Liberation Army Daily]. Retrieved from http://dlib.eastview.com.
  31. JFJB. (2002, May 20). Yuguo de Zhongguo Xin [Hugo’s China heart]. Jiefangjun Bao [People’s Liberation Army Daily]. Retrieved from http://dlib.eastview.com.
  32. JFJB. (2009a, February 28). Guobao Huigui Lu Manman [The road to returning the national treasures is very slow]. Jiefangjun Bao [People’s Liberation Army Daily]. Retrieved from http://dlib.eastview.com.
  33. JFJB. (2009b, February 25). Yi Renquan wei Qihao Qinfan Zhongguo Renmin de Jiben Wenhua Quanli shi Huangmiu de [To use the banner of human rights to infringe on the Chinese people’s basic cultural rights is absurd]. Jiefangjun Bao [People’s Liberation Army Daily]. Retrieved from http://dlib.eastview.com.
  34. Jia, C. (2011, November 17). Yuanmingyuan de Wanxi [The regret of the Yuanmingyuan]. Xinlang Boke [Sina Blog]. Retrieved from http://blog.sina.com.
  35. Kutcher, N. (2003). China’s palace of memory. Wilson Quarterly, 27(1), 30–39.Google Scholar
  36. Lee, H. (2009). The ruins of Yuanmingyuan or how to enjoy a national wound. Modern China, 35(4), 155–190.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  37. Leonard, M. (2008). What does China think? London: Fourth Estate.Google Scholar
  38. Li, S., & Wen, Z. (2010, November 2). Mingji Lishi, Mianxiang Weilai [Remember history and face the future]. Zhongguo Shehui Kexue Bao [Chinese Social Sciences Today]. Retrieved from http://news.ifeng.com/history/shixueyuan/detail_2010_11/19/3167937_0.shtml.
  39. Li, W. (2012, September 17). Zai Minguo [In the Republic]. Xinlang Boke [Sina Blog]. Retrieved from http://blog.sina.com.
  40. Lovell, J. (2011). The opium war: Drugs, dreams and the making of China. London: Picador.Google Scholar
  41. Milkrangers. (2010, November 15). Bu Neng Wangque de Jinian [Never forget to commemorate]. Xinlang Boke [Sina Blog]. Retrieved from http://blog.sina.com.
  42. Miriam. (2012, February 27). Beijing, Beijing: Jiyi Zhong de Yuanmingyuan [Beijing, Beijing: The memory of Yuanmingyuan]. Xinlang Boke [Sina Blog]. Retrieved from http://blog.sina.com.
  43. New York Times. (2009, February 26). China fails to halt sale of looted relics at Paris auction. Retrieved from http://www.nytimes.com/2009/02/27/world/europe/27auction.html.
  44. New York Times. (2014, February 9). Despite frigid relations, Chinese relics coming home from Norway. Retrieved from http://sinosphere.blogs.nytimes.com/2014/02/09/despite-frigid-relations-chinese-relics-coming-home-from-norway/?_r=0.
  45. Nmghongjing. (2011, November 20). Shenme shi Guochi? [What is national humiliation?]. Xinlang Boke [Sina Blog]. Retrieved from http://blog.sina.com.
  46. Opoku, K. (2009, October 23). Chinese research artefacts looted in Anglo-French attach on summer palace in 1860: Do Great museums not keep records? Modern Ghana. Retrieved from https://www.modernghana.com/news/245039/1/chinese-research-artefacts-looted-in-anglo-french-.html.
  47. PLANavy. (2012, March 29). Nandao Yao Muyi Tianxia, Zhongguo Cai Hui Suxing Ma? [Is it possible to be the mother under heaven and earth, until China is able to wake up?]. Xinlang Boke [Sina Blog]. Retrieved from http://blog.sina.com.
  48. RMRB. (1999a, May 12). Zhongguo bu shi Yibai Jiujiu [This is not the China of 1899]. Renmin Ribao [People’s Daily]. Retrieved from http://huylpd.twinbridge.com.
  49. RMRB. (1999b, May 25). Zhengyi de Nahan [Righteous cry]. Renmin Ribao [People’s Daily]. Retrieved from http://huylpd.twinbridge.com.
  50. RMRB. (2008a, April 11) Wangmin Reyi de Xinwen: Aoyun Shenghuo Chuandi Zao Xirao’ [Netizens hot news: Olympic torch relay disrupted]. Renmin Ribao [People’s Daily]. Retrieved from http://news.xinhuanet.com.
  51. RMRB. (2008b, May 17). Cong Faguo Kan Xifang Minzhu yu Guojia Liyi de Beilun [From France we see a western democracy and national interest paradox]. Renmin Ribao [People’s Daily]. Retrieved from http://world.people.com.
  52. RMRB. (2009, January 13). Jiu zai Nin de Xingxiang li [Only in your image]. Renmin Ribao [People’s Daily]. Retrieved from http://huylpd.twinbridge.com.
  53. RMRB. (2010a, October 18). Daguo Mianzi: Yuanmingyuan 150 Nian Jiachou yu Guochi [Great power honour: Yuanmingyuan’s 150th anniversary of animosity and humiliation]. Renmin Ribao [People’s Daily]. Retrieved from http://www.people.com.
  54. RMRB. (2010b, November 19). Wenwu Zhuisuo Shi bu Wo Dai [Cultural relic recourse waits for no one]. Renmin Ribao [People’s Daily]. Retrieved from http://huylpd.twinbridge.com.
  55. UPI. (2006, January 26). China closes another liberal publication. Retrieved from http://www.upi.com/China-closes-another-liberal-publication/74971138267495/.
  56. Wang, D. (1999). Yuanmingyuan: Lishi, Xianzhang, Lunzheng [Yuanmingyuan: Debates past and present]. Beijing: Beijing Chubanshe.Google Scholar
  57. Wang, C. (2008). Recent research on republican Chinese history. Journal of Modern Chinese History, 2(1), 89–97.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  58. Wei, G. (2008, April 17). Aoyunhui, bu shi Yuanmingyuan [The olympic games are not the Yuanmingyuan]. Xinlang Boke [Sina Blog]. Retrieved from http://blog.sina.com.
  59. Wei, Y. (2012, April 3). Huoshao Yuanmingyuan de Guochi Hai Hui Zhongyan Ma? [Is the humiliation of the burning of Yuanmingyuan repeating itself?]. Xinlang Boke [Sina Blog]. Retrieved from http://blog.sina.com.
  60. Weil, R. (2013). Yuanmingyuan revisited: The confrontation of China and the west. Socialism and Democracy, 27(1), 99–135.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  61. WHB. (2010, January 15). Yuanmingyuan Linan 150 Zhounian Huo Yao Yingfa Zhengyao Chuxi [British and French officials might be invited to attend the 150th anniversary of the Yuanmingyuan]. Wenhui Bao [Wenhui Newspaper]. Retrieved from http://global.factiva.com.
  62. Wolseley, J. (1862). Narrative of the war with China in 1860; to which is added the account of a short residence with the Tai-ping rebels at nanking and a voyage from Thence to Hankow. London: Longman.Google Scholar
  63. XHW. (2008, April 14) Aoyun Huoju Chuandi Bali Shouzu Wangmin Zhenglun “Dizhi Faguo Huo” [Olympic torch relay in Paris blocked, internet users argue for ‘French goods boycott’]. Xinhua Wang [Xinhua Network]. Retrieved from http://news.xinhuanet.com.
  64. XZX. (2008, March 4). Aoyun Shenghuo Caiji yu Chuandi Quwen [Olympic torch lighting and relay story]. Xinhuashe Zhongwen Xinwen [Xinhua News Agency]. Retrieved from http://global.factiva.com.
  65. XZX. (2010a, September 25) Yuanmingyuan Jiang Qidong Lijie 150 Zhounian Xilie Jinianhuodong [Yuanmingyuan is launching 150th anniversary commemoration events]. Xinhuashe Zhongwen Xinwen. Retrieved from http://global.factiva.com.
  66. XZX. (2010b, January 18). Zhongguo Zhuanjia Cheng Haiwai Faxian Xin de Yuanmingyuan Liushi Wenwu [China expert goes abroad to discover new lost Yuanmingyuan relics]. Xinhuashe Zhongwen Xinwen. Retrieved from http://global.factiva.com.
  67. Yan, C. (2014, July 22). Why don’t you ask why Yuanmingyuan was burnt? Retrieved from http://yanchh.blogchina.com/2214016.html.
  68. Yike de Weibo. (2015, November 5). Retrieved from http://www.weibo.com/1204278217/D2pkVyFkh.
  69. Yuan, W. (2006, January 11). Xiandaihua yu Lishi Jiaokeshu [Modernisation and history textbooks]. Bingdian Weekly [Freezing Point]. Retrieved from http://edu.people.com.cn/GB/1055/4016350.html.
  70. Yuan, W. (2010a, October 1). Yuanmingyuan Lijie 150 Zhounian Ji - Kunan Laiziyu Luohou he Fengbi [Marking the 150th anniversary of the Yuanmingyuan catastrophe - suffering comes from backwardness and insularity]. Wenshi Cankao [History Reference]. Retrieved from http://www.people.com.cn/GB/198221/198819/204160/12859078.html.
  71. Yuan, W. (2010b, November 1). Mao Yushi Deng: Huishou Xinhai Bainian, [Mao Yushi et al: Reviewing the century since the 1911 revolution]. Zhongguo Gaige Luntan [China Reform Website]. Retrieved from http://www.chinareform.org.cn/explore/explore/201011/t20101101_49427.htm.
  72. ZGSB. (2004, September 11). Xiufu Tuanhe Xingong Weihe Meiyou Zhengyi [Why the restoration of the Tuanhe temple is not controversial]. Zhongguo Shangbao [China Business News]. Retrieved from http://global.factiva.com.
  73. Zhexuejia gua le. (2014, June 10). Retrieved from http://www.weibo.com/1215029183/B8jJP3t7I?type=comment.
  74. ZHTB. (2010, May 27). Xuannao de Zhong Cai Wusheng De Baimiao: Xie Zai Yuanmingyuan Lijie 150 Zhounian Zhiji [Noisy colouring, silent lines: Written during the 150th anniversary of the destruction of the Yuanmingyuan]. Zhongguo Hangtian Bao [China Aviation News]. Retrieved from http://global.factiva.com.
  75. Zijia Yuanzi Li Xiongwei. (2013, December 7). Retrieved from http://www.weibo.com/3873998774/AmbdebhZU.
  76. ZJCB. (2010, July 10). Jinian Yuanmingyuan Lijie 150 Zhounian You Jiang Zhengwen Huodong Juban [To commemorate the 150th anniversary of the Yuanmingyuan calamity an essay writing contest will be held]. Zhongguo Jiancai Bao [China Building Materials Daily]. Retrieved from http://global.factiva.com.
  77. ZQB. (2009, October 27). Yuanmingyuan Wenwu Mo Di You Duoshao Mohu Jidai Qingxi [Assessing the Yuanmingyuan cultural relics and the need to be clear how many there are]. Zhongguo Qingnian Bao [China Youth Daily]. Retrieved from http://zqb.cyol.com.
  78. ZQZX. (2010, October 20). Yuanmingyuan Linan 150 Zhounian: Keyi Kuanshu Dan bu Neng Yiwang [The 150th anniversary of the destruction of the Yuanmingyuan: Possible to forgive but not to forget]. Zhongqing Zaixian [Youth Daily Online]. Retrieved from http://zqb.cyol.com.
  79. Zui‚ H. (2010, November 6). Weile Wangque de Jiyi [For forgotten memories]. Wo de Sohu [Sohu Blog]. Retrieved from http://guguzgz.blog.sohu.com.
  80. ZXS. (2010, February 26). Taiwan Zhanchu Yong Yan Diaosu de Yuanmingyuan shi Er Shou Shou [Taiwan exhibit uses salt statues of Yuanmingyuan’s twelve zodiac animals]. Zhongguo Xinwenshe [China News Service]. Retrieved from http://global.factiva.com.
  81. ZZX. (2002, December 13). Beijing Yuanmingyuan Bainian Daxiu Zhengshi Qidong [Beijing old summer palace’s one hundred year official overhaul launched]. Zhongyangshe Zhongwen Xinwen [Central News Agency]. Retrieved from http://global.factiva.com.
  82. ZZX. (2010, January 19). Shangkou Sayan? Yuanmingyuan Mengnan 150 Zhounian Ban Huodong Zaopi [Salt in the wound? The 150th anniversary activities of the destruction of the Yuanmingyuan meets with criticism]. Zhongyangshe Zhongwen Xinwen [Central News Agency]. Retrieved from http://global.factiva.com.

Copyright information

© The Author(s) 2017

Authors and Affiliations

  1. 1.University of CambridgeCambridgeUK
  2. 2.University of OxfordOxfordUK

Personalised recommendations