Advertisement

Fishing for Trouble: The Ethics of Recreational Angling

  • Max Elder
Chapter
Part of the The Palgrave Macmillan Animal Ethics Series book series (PMAES)

Abstract

Fishing is a beloved pastime for many cultures reaching far back into history and spanning the globe. Many fish not out of necessity, but purely as a means of recreation. These people are called recreational anglers, and their ethical justifications for fishing have yet to be problematized, at least to the same extent that other forms of recreational hunting have been. This chapter explores the various types of recreational angling—namely, catch-and-release fishing and fishing to kill—in order to collapse any supposed moral distinction between the two. It also explores the psychology behind recreational angling, arguing that some of the most widely cited justifications for angling, by anglers themselves, is ultimately self-defeating. The reverence that many anglers have for nature, and its inhabitants, falls short of a justification for fish being hunted. This inconsistency is often over-looked and, once exposed, offers a novel argument against angling for fun. The chapter concludes with an exploration of alternate value frameworks through which one might assess the ethics of recreational angling in a consistent manner. Given the large scale at which angling occurs globally, and the neglect of the moral foundation upon which it stands, this chapter raises a question for both ethics and animals.

Bibliography

  1. Aas, Ø., C. E. Thailing, and R. B. Ditton. “Controversy over Catch-and-Release Recreational Fishing in Europe.” In Recreational Fisheries: Ecological, Economic, and Social Evaluation, edited by T. J. Pitcher and C. Hollingworth, 95–106. Oxford: Blackwell Science, 2002.Google Scholar
  2. Allen, C. “Fish Cognition and Consciousness.” Journal of Agricultural and Environmental Ethics 26, no. 1 (2013): 25–39.Google Scholar
  3. Arlinghaus, R. “Voluntary Catch-and-Release Can Generate Conflict within the Recreational Angling Community: A Qualitative Case Study of Specialized Carp, Cyprinus carpio, Angling in Germany.” Fisheries Management and Ecology 14 (2007): 161–71.Google Scholar
  4. Balon, E. K. “Defending Fishes against Recreational Fishing: An Old Problem to Be Solved in the New Millennium.” Environmental Biology of Fishes 57 (2000): 1–8.Google Scholar
  5. Barthel, B. L., S. J. Cooke, C. D. Suski, and D. P. Philipp. “Effects of Landing Net Mesh Type on Injury and Mortality in a Freshwater Recreational Fishery.” Fisheries Research 63 (2003): 275–82.Google Scholar
  6. Bartholomew, A., and J. A. Bohnsack. “A Review of Catch-and-Release Angling Mortality with Implications for No-Take Reserves.” Reviews in Fish Biology and Fisheries 15 (2005): 129–54.Google Scholar
  7. Baughman, M. A River Seen Right. New York: Lyons Press, 1995.Google Scholar
  8. Braithwaite, V. Do Fish Feel Pain? Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2010.Google Scholar
  9. Broom, D. “Fish Welfare and the Public Perception of Fish.” Proceedings of Aquavision (1998): 1–6.Google Scholar
  10. Campbell, P. M., T. G. Pottinger, and J. P. Sumpter. “Preliminary Evidence That Chronic Confinement Stress Reduces the Quality of Gametes Produced by Brown and Rainbow Trout.” Aquaculture 120 (1994): 151–69.Google Scholar
  11. ———. “Stress Reduces the Quality of Gametes Produced by Rainbow Trout.” Biology of Reproduction 47 (1992): 1140–50.Google Scholar
  12. Castranova, D. A., V. W. King, and L. C. Woods III. “The Effects of Stress on Androgen Production, Spermiation Response and Sperm Quality in High and Low Cortisol Responsive Domesticated Male Striped Bass.” Aquaculture 246 (2005): 413–22.Google Scholar
  13. Coleman, F. C., C. C. Koenig, A. M. Eklund, and C. B. Grimes. “Management and Conservation of Temperate Reef Fishes in the Grouper-Snapper Complex of the Southern United States.” American Fisheries Society Symposium 23 (1999): 233–42.Google Scholar
  14. Contreras-Sanchez, W. M., C. B. Schreck, M. S. Fitzpatrick, and C. B. Pereira. “Effects of Stress on the Reproductive Performance of Rainbow Trout (Oncorhynchus mykiss).” Biology of Reproduction 58 (1998): 439–47.Google Scholar
  15. Cooke, S. J., and I. G. Cowx. “The Role of Recreational Fishing in Global Fish Crises.” BioScience 54 (2004): 857–59.Google Scholar
  16. Cooke, S. J., D. P. Philipp, K. M. Dunmall, and J. F. Schreer. “The Influence of Terminal Tackle on Injury, Handling Time, and Cardiac Disturbance of Rock Bass.” North American Journal of Fisheries Management 21 (2001): 333–42.Google Scholar
  17. Cooke, S. J., J. F. Schreer, K. M. Dunmall, and D. P. Philipp. “Strategies for Quantifying Sublethal Effects of Marine Catch-and-Release Angling—Insights from Novel Freshwater Applications.” American Fisheries Society Symposium 30 (2002): 121–34.Google Scholar
  18. Cooke, S. J., and L. U. Sneddon. “Animal Welfare Perspectives on Recreational Angling.” Applied Animal Behaviour Science 104 (2007): 176–98.Google Scholar
  19. de Leeuw, A. D. “Contemplating the Interest of Fish: The Angler’s Challenge.” Environmental Ethics 18 (1996): 373–90.Google Scholar
  20. DuBois, R. B., and R. R. Dubielzig. “Effect of Hook Type on Mortality, Trauma, and Capture Efficiency of Wild, Stream-Resident Trout Caught by Active Baitfishing.” North American Journal of Fisheries Management 24 (2004): 609–16.Google Scholar
  21. Ehrenfeld, D. W. “The Conservation of Non-Resources.” American Scientist 64, no. 4 (1976): 648–56.Google Scholar
  22. Eschmeyer, R. W., and G. S. Ficher. Good Fishing. New York: Harper, 1959.Google Scholar
  23. European Anglers Alliance. “Recreational Angling—Definition.” Tenth General Assembly of the European Anglers Alliance, Dinant, Belgium, March 26–28, 2004. http://www.pescaricreativa.org/docs/sci/DEFINITION-EAA_Angling_Def_long_FINAL_EN.pdf.
  24. Evans, J. C. With Respect for Nature: Living as Part of the Natural World. Albany: State University of New York Press, 2005.Google Scholar
  25. Ferguson, R. A., and B. L. Tufts. “Physiological Effects of Brief Air Exposure in Exhaustively Exercised Rainbow Trout (Oncorhynchus mykiss): Implications for ‘Catch and Release’ Fisheries.” Canadian Journal of Fisheries and Aquatic Sciences 49 (1992): 1157–62.Google Scholar
  26. Grey, Z. Tales of Fishes. New York: Grosset & Dunlap, 1919.Google Scholar
  27. Holt, J. “Death on the Musselshell.” In On Killing: Meditations on the Chase, edited by R. F. Jones, 95–101. Guilford, CT: Lyons Press, 2001.Google Scholar
  28. Huntingford, F. A., C. Adams, V. A. Braithwaite, S. Kadri, T. G. Pottinger, P. Sandoe, and J. F. Turnbull. “Review Paper: Current Issues in Fish Welfare.” Journal of Fish Biology 68 (2006): 332–72.Google Scholar
  29. Independent (London). “Professor Patrick Wall.” August 23, 2001. http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/obituaries/1338208/Professor-Patrick-Wall.html.
  30. International Association for the Study of Pain. “IASP Taxonomy: Pain.” Last updated May 22, 2012. http://www.iasp-pain.org/Education/Content.aspx?ItemNumber=1698&navItemNumber=576#Pain.
  31. Kerasote, T. Bloodties: Nature, Culture, and the Hunt. New York: Kodansha International, 1994.Google Scholar
  32. Laureys, S., M. E. Faymonville, P. Peigneux, P. Damas, B. Lambermont, G. Del Fiore, C. Degueldre, et al. “Cortical Processing of Noxious Somatosensory Stimuli in the Persistent Vegetative State.” NeuroImage 17 (2002): 732–41.Google Scholar
  33. Linzey, A. Animal Theology. Urbana: University of Illinois Press, 1995.Google Scholar
  34. ———. Christianity and the Rights of Animals. New York: Crossroad, 1988.Google Scholar
  35. ———. Creatures of the Same God. New York: Lantern Books, 2009.Google Scholar
  36. Loftus, A. J., W. W. Taylor, and M. Keller. “An Evaluation of Lake Trout (Salvelinus namaycush) Hooking Mortality in the Upper Great Lakes.” Canadian Journal of Fisheries and Aquatic Sciences 45 (1988): 1473–79.Google Scholar
  37. Luce, A. A. Fishing and Thinking. Shrewsbury, UK: Swan Hill Press, 1959.Google Scholar
  38. Maclean, N. A River Runs through It. Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1976.Google Scholar
  39. Mazeaud, M. M., F. Mazeaud, and E. M. Donaldson. “Primary and Secondary Effects of Stress in Fish: Some New Data with a General Review.” Transactions of the American Fisheries Society 106 (1977): 201–12.Google Scholar
  40. McGuane, T. Upstream: Fly Fishing in the American West. Millerton, NY: Aperture, 2000.Google Scholar
  41. Meka, J. M. “The Influence of Hook Type, Angler Experience, and Fish Size on Injury Rates and the Duration of Capture in an Alaskan Catch-and-Release Rainbow Trout Fishery.” North American Journal of Fisheries Management 24 (2004): 1309–21.Google Scholar
  42. Mood, A. “Estimating the Number of Farmed Fish Killed in Global Aquaculture Each Year.” Fishcount.org.uk. 2012. http://fishcount.org.uk/published/std/fishcountstudy2.pdf.
  43. Mood, A., and P. Brooke. “Worse Things Happen at Sea: The Welfare of Wild-Caught Fish.” Fishcount.org.uk. 2010. http://www.fishcount.org.uk/published/standard/fishcountfullrptSR.pdf.
  44. Muoneke, M. I. “Seasonal Hooking Mortality of Guadalupe Bass Caught on Artificial Lures.” In Warmwater Fisheries Symposium I, edited by J. L. Cooper and R. H. Hamre, 273–77. USDA Forest Service Report RM-207, 1991.Google Scholar
  45. Muoneke, M. I., and W. M. Childress. “Hooking Mortality: A Review for Recreational Fisheries.” Reviews in Fisheries Science 2, no. 2 (1994): 123–56.Google Scholar
  46. Nagel, T. “What Is It Like to Be a Bat?” The Philosophical Review 83, no. 4 (1974): 435–50.Google Scholar
  47. Ortega y Gasset, J. Meditations on Hunting. Bozeman, MT: Wilderness Adventures Press, 1995.Google Scholar
  48. Ostrand, K. G., S. J. Cooke, and D. H. Wahl. “Effects of Stress on Largemouth Bass Reproduction.” North American Journal of Fisheries Management 24, no. 3 (2004): 1038–45.Google Scholar
  49. Petersen, D. Heartsblood: Hunting, Spirituality, and Wildness in America. Washington, DC: Shearwater Books, 2000.Google Scholar
  50. Plan Development Team. The Potential of Marine Fishery Reserves for Reef Fish Management in the U.S. Southern Atlantic. NOAA Technical Memorandum NMFS-SEFC-261. National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration, April 1990.Google Scholar
  51. Post, J. R., M. Sullivan, S. Cox, N. P. Lester, C. J. Walters, E. A. Parkinson, A. J. Paul, L. Jackson, and B. J. Shuter. “Canada’s Recreational Fishery: The Invisible Collapse?” Fisheries 27 (2002): 6–17.Google Scholar
  52. Quinn, S. “Hands on Catch and Release Controversy.” Fisherman 18, no. 5 (1993): 36–44.Google Scholar
  53. ———. “Trends in Regulatory and Voluntary Catch-and-Release Fishing.” American Fisheries Society Symposium 16 (1996): 152–62.Google Scholar
  54. Rachels, J. Created From Animals: The Moral Implications of Darwinism. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1990.Google Scholar
  55. Radonski, G. “History and Application of Catch-and-Release Fishing: The Good, the Bad, and the Ugly.” American Fisheries Society Symposium 30 (2002): 3–10.Google Scholar
  56. Raines, H. Fly Fishing through the Midlife Crisis. New York: William Morrow, 1993.Google Scholar
  57. Regan, T. The Case for Animal Rights. California: University of California Press, 1983.Google Scholar
  58. Rose, J. “The Neurobehavioural Nature of Fishes and the Question of Awareness and Pain.” Reviews in Fisheries Science 10 (2002): 1–38.Google Scholar
  59. Rose, J. D., R. Arlinghaus, S. J. Cooke, B. K. Diggles, W. Sawynok, E. D. Stevens, and C. D. L. Wynne. “Can Fish Really Feel Pain?” Fish and Fisheries 15 (2014): 97–133.Google Scholar
  60. Sahni, P. Environmental Ethics in Buddhism: A Virtues Approach. New York: Routledge, 2008.Google Scholar
  61. Schreck, C. B., W. Contreras-Sanchez, and M. S. Fitzpatrick. “Effects of Stress on Fish Reproduction, Gamete Quality, and Progeny.” Aquaculture 197 (2001): 3–24.Google Scholar
  62. Singer, P. Animal Liberation. New York: Avon Books, 1990.Google Scholar
  63. ———. Practical Ethics. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1993.Google Scholar
  64. ———. “Speciesism and Moral Status.” Metaphilosophy 40, no. 3–4 (2009): 567–81.Google Scholar
  65. Smit, N. J., G. Howatson, and R. Greenfield. “Blood Lactate Levels as a Biomarker for Angling-Induced Stress in Tigerfish Hydrocynus vittatus from the Okavango Delta, Botswana.” African Journal of Aquatic Science 34, no. 3 (2009): 255–59.Google Scholar
  66. Sneddon, L. “Anatomical and Electrophysiological Analysis of the Trigeminal Nerve in a Teleost Fish, Oncorhynchusmykiss.” Neuroscience Letters 319, no. 3 (2002): 167–71.Google Scholar
  67. ———. “Trigeminal Somatosensory Innervation of the Head of a Teleost Fish with Particular Reference to Nociception.” Brain Research 972, no. 1–2 (2003): 44–52.Google Scholar
  68. Sneddon, L., V. Braithwaite, and M. Gentle. “Do Fishes Have Nociceptors? Evidence for the Evolution of a Vertebrate Sensory System.” Proceedings of the Royal Society of London 270 (2003): 1115–21.Google Scholar
  69. Sneddon, L., and M. Gentle. “Receptor Types on the Head of the Rainbow Trout: Are Nociceptors Present?” Comparative Biochemistry and Physiology 32A (2002): S42.Google Scholar
  70. Steeger, T. M., J. M. Grizzle, K. Weathers, and M. Newman. “Bacterial Diseases and Mortality of Angler-Caught Largemouth Bass Released after Tournaments on Walter F. George Reservoir, Alabama/Georgia.” North American Journal of Fisheries Management 14 (1994): 435–41.Google Scholar
  71. Steffens, W., and M. Winkel. “Evaluating Recreational Fishing in Germany.” In Recreational Fisheries: Ecological, Economic and Social Evaluation, edited by T. J. Pitcher and C. E. Hollingworth, 130–36. Oxford: Blackwell Science, 2002.Google Scholar
  72. Suski, C. D., S. S. Killen, S. J. Cooke, J. D. Kieffer, D. P. Phillip, and B. L. Tufts. “Physiological Significance of the Weigh-In Time during Live-Release Angling Tournaments for Largemouth Bass.” Transactions of the American Fisheries Society 133 (2004): 1291–1303.Google Scholar
  73. Thoreau, H. D. A Week on the Concord and Merrimack Rivers. Boston: Ticknor and Fields, 1862.Google Scholar
  74. Wall, P. D. “Defining ‘Pain’ in Animals.” In Animal Pain, edited by C. F. Short and A. Van Poznak, 63–79. New York: Churchill Livingstone, 1992.Google Scholar
  75. Wedel, J. Santería Healing: A Journey into the Afro-Cuban World of Divinities, Spirits, and Sorcery. Gainesville: University Press of Florida, 2004.Google Scholar
  76. Wilkie, M. P., M. A. Brobbel, K. Davidson, L. Forsyth, and B. L. Tufts. “Influences of Temperature upon the Post-Exercise Physiology of Atlantic Salmon (Salmo salar).” Canadian Journal of Fisheries and Aquatic Sciences 54 (1997): 503–11.Google Scholar
  77. Wilkie, M. P., K. Davidson, M. A. Brobbel, J.D. Kieffer, R. K. Booth, A. T. Bielak, and B. L. Tufts. “Physiology and Survival of Wild Atlantic Salmon following Angling in Warm Summer Waters.” Transactions of the American Fisheries Society 125 (1996): 572–80.Google Scholar
  78. Wulff, L. Lee Wulff’s Handbook of Freshwater Fishing. New York: Frederick A. Stokes, 1939.Google Scholar
  79. Zimmerman, M. “Physiological Mechanisms of Pain and Its Treatment.” Klinische Anästhesiologie Intensivtherapie 32 (1986): 1–19.Google Scholar

Copyright information

© The Author(s) 2018

Authors and Affiliations

  • Max Elder
    • 1
  1. 1.Oxford Centre for Animal EthicsOxfordEngland

Personalised recommendations