Abstract
At the beginning of the 1870s, there was undoubtedly no country in which politicians and scholars had a greater tendency to overestimate the influence of education on the evolution of society than France. There were three main reasons for this. The first was that France regarded itself as the birthplace of the Enlightenment and the 1789 Revolution. As Condorcet declared to the Legislative Assembly in 1792, the liberal and legally egalitarian nature of that revolution imposed on the state a duty to constitute the education of the people as a public service. The fact that the industrial revolution began at the same time as demands for democracy were making themselves felt only made this duty all the more pressing. Victor Hugo paid particular attention to it in the chapter of Les Misérables in which the author acts as the physiologist of the ‘Paris urchin’: for him, a childhood of deprivation and destitution was ‘a disease that must be cured by light’.1 This idea was widely shared in nineteenth-century Europe. Charles Dickens expressed it with as much force as humour in 1852, when he was campaigning for the *ragged schools despite their inadequacies:
The compulsory industrial education of neglected children, and the severe punishment of neglectful and unnatural parents, are reforms to which must come, doubt it who may. We can no more hope to make any great impression upon crime, without these changes, than we could hope to extinguish Mount Vesuvius, in eruption, with a watering-pot, or stop its flow of lava with a knitting-needle.2
However, the logical connection between this question and the more general role of political institutions explains why the rapid succession of regimes and their instability ensured that only partial progress was achieved; in France more than elsewhere this was likely only to fuel debate rather than put an end to it.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution.
Buying options
Tax calculation will be finalised at checkout
Purchases are for personal use only
Learn about institutional subscriptionsPreview
Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.
Notes
V. Hugo (1863) Les Miserables, trans. C. E. Wilbour (New York: Carleton), III/1/10, ‘Ecce Paris, ecce homo’, p. 14.
C. Dickens (1963) ‘Households Words: A Weekly Journal’ in P. Collins Dickens and Education (London: Macmillan), p. 72.
F. Guizot (1860) Mémoires pour servir à l’histoire de mon temps, III (Paris: Michel Lévy frères), p. 12.
See also P. Rosanvallon (1985) Le moment Guizot (Paris: Gallimard).
A. Prost (1979) Histoire de l’enseignement en France, 1800–1967 (Paris: Armand Colin), p. 97.
Plessis, A. (1997) ‘Pouvait-on penser librement sous le Second Empire?’ in J. Tulard (ed.) Pourquoi réhabiliter le Second Empire ? (Paris: Bernard Giovanangeli), p. 102.
F. Furet and J. Ozouf (1977) Lire et écrire. L’alphabétisation des Français de Calvin à Jules Ferry, vol. 1 (Paris: Les Éditions de Minuit), p. 172.
E. Laboulaye (1869) Discours populaires (Paris: Charpentier), p. 280. Laboulaye (1811–83) was a jurist, poet and author.
C. E. Bourdin (1868) Recherches statistiques sur l’instruction primaire dans l’armée française (Strasbourg).
D. Louis (1870) Etude sur l’instruction scientifique et littéraire dans larmée française (Péronne), p. 19.
A. Claveau (1913) Souvenirs politiques et parlementaires d’un témoin, I, 1865–1870 (Paris: Plon), p. 146.
A. Crépin (2009) Histoire de la conscription (Paris: Gallimard), p. 283.
See also A. Forrest (2009) The Legacy of the French Revolutionary Wars: the Nation-in-Arms in French Republican Memory (Cambridge; New York: Cambridge University Press).
There were only 12 écoles primaires supérieures in 1870; their number then expanded radically and the number of students doubled in 20 years, from 24,200 to 55,900 between 1881 and 1901. F. Mayeur (1981) De la Révolution à l’école républicaine, vol. 3 of Louis-Henri Parias (ed.), Histoire générale de l’enseignement et de l’éducation en France (Paris: Nouvelle Librairie de France), p. 550.
J.-N. Luc (1997) L’invention du jeune enfant au XIXe siècle. De la salle d’asile à l’école maternelle (Paris: Belin), pp. 261–4. Between the late 1860s and the mid-1880s, the numbers of children enrolled in these schools increased from slightly fewer than 450,000 to almost 700,000. For an idea of how the republicans rebranded these schools, see (1885) Journal de l’instruction primaire. Revue des examens. Devoirs d’élèves. Bulletin hebdomadaire des instituteurs et des institutrices..., 15 Aug., pp. 7–8.
Gambetta, L. (1881) ‘Discours’, La Ferté-sous-Jouarre, 14 Jul. 1872 in J. Reinach (ed.) Discours et plaidoyers politiques, vol. II (Paris: G. Charpentier), p. 387.
M. Crubellier (1993) L’école républicaine, 1870–1940 (Paris: Editions Christian), pp. 40–3.
Stendhal (1977) Lucien Leuwen [1834–1835] in H. Martineau (ed.) Romans et nouvelles, (Paris: Gallimard, Bibliothèque de la Pléiade), p. 1368.
E. Goblot (1925) La barrière et le niveau. Étude sociologique sur la bourgeoisie française moderne (Paris: F. Alcan).
A. Chervel (2008) Histoire de l’enseignement du français du XVIIe au XXe siècle (Paris: Retz), p. 399.
Ozouf, M. (1984) ‘Jules Ferry et l’unité nationale’ [1982] in id. (ed.), L’École de la France. Essais sur la Révolution, l’utopie et l’enseignement (Paris: Gallimard), pp. 407–8;
P. Martel (2007) L’école française et l’occitan. Le sourd et le bègue (preface by R. Lafont, Montpellier: Presses universitaires de la Méditerranée).
J.-F. Chanet (1996) L’École républicaine et les petites patries, preface by M. Ozouf (Paris: Aubier).
J.-M. Mayeur (1997) La question laïque, XIXe–XXe siècle (Paris: Fayard), pp. 63–9.
G. Compayré (1880) Eléments d’éducation civique et morale (Paris: P. Garcet, Nisius & Co.), pp. 55–7, and id. (1890) Organisation pédagogique et législation des écoles primaires (Pédagogie pratique & administration scolaire) (Paris: Librairie classique Paul Delaplane), p. 109.
See A.-M. Thiesse (1997) Ils apprenaient la France. L’exaltation des régions dans le discours patriotique (Paris: Ed. de la Maison des sciences de l’homme), pp. 15–34.
E. Lavisse (1887) ‘Tu seras soldat’, histoire d’un soldat français, récits et leçons patriotiques d’instruction et d’éducation militaires (Paris: Armand Colin).
See A.-M. Sohn (1996) Chrysalides : femmes dans la vie privée (XIXe-XXe siècles) (2 vols., Paris: Publications de la Sorbonne).
E. Zola (1996) Vérité; ed. C. Becker and V. Lavielle (Paris: Le Livre de Poche classique), p. 16.
See J. Krop (2008) ‘Punitions corporelles et actes de brutalité dans les écoles primaires publiques du département de la Seine (1880–1914)’, Histoire de l’éducation, 118, 109–32.
M. Thivend (2006) L’école républicaine en ville: Lyon, 1870–1914 (Paris: Belin), pp. 133–44.
G. Clemenceau (1995) Le grand Pan [1896], ed. J.-N. Jeanneney (Paris: Imprimerie nationale), p. 212.
See Agulhon, M. (1984) ‘La mairie’ in P. Nora (ed.) Les lieux de mémoire, I, La République (Paris: Gallimard), p. 173.
A. Lavergne (1903) Jean Coste ou l’Instituteur de village (Paris: Paul Ollendorff), pp. 236–45.
J. Girault (1996) Instituteurs, professeurs: une culture syndicale dans la société française, fin XIXe-XXe siècle (Paris: Publications de la Sorbonne).
See F. Broudic (1997) L’interdiction du breton en 1902. La IIIe République contre les langues régionales (Spezet: Coop Breizh) and Chanet, L’École républicaine, pp. 209–10.
A. Lanfrey (2003) Sécularisation, séparation et guerre scolaire. Les catholiques français et l’école (1901–1914) (preface by Cardinal Jean Honoré, Paris: Cerf).
Y. Déloye (1994) École et citoyenneté. L’individualisme républicaine de Jules Ferry à Vichy: controverses (Paris: Presses de la FNSP), pp. 230–51.
L. Pergaud (1968) The War of the Buttons, trans. S. and E. Hochman (New York: Walker). The title of the novel refers to the fights between the pupils of two rival schools of the same village, the secular school and the Catholic one. The winners ripped out the losers’ trouser buttons.
See M. Pagnol (1986) My Father’s Glory, trans. R. Barisse (San Francisco: North Point Press). Originally 1957.
Boutry, P. (2009) ‘L’instituteur comme pouvoir spirituel au village’, in Hommage à Jacques Ozouf, Cahiers du Centre de recherches historiques, no. 43 (Paris: EHESS), pp. 77–92.
Dubet, F. (2003) ‘Paradoxes et enjeux de l’école de masse’, in O. Donnat and P. Tolila (eds) Le(s) public(s) de la culture. Politiques publiques et équipements culturels (Paris: Presses de Sciences Po), p. 36.
L. Aragon (2000) Les beaux quartiers, ed. under the direction of D. Bougnoux (Paris: Gallimard, Bibliothèque de la Pléiade), p. 85.
C. Péguy (1992) ‘Note conjointe sur M. Descartes et la philosophie cartésienne’, posthumous text (Jul. 1914), in id., Œuvres en prose complètes, ed. R. Burac, vol. III (Paris: Gallimard, Bibliothèque de la Pléiade), p. 1442.
A. Choppin (2008) ‘Le manuel scolaire, une fausse évidence historique’, Histoire de l’éducation, no. 117, p. 27.
I. Michael (1979) ‘The Historical Study of English as a Subject: a Preliminary Inquiry into some Questions of Methods’, History of Education, 8/3, 193–206, at p. 202.
C. Collodi (2006) Il Viaggio per l’Italia di Giannettino, 3 vols (Italia superiore, 1880; Italia centrale, 1883; Italia meridionale, 1886) (Bergamo: Leading edn);
Fouillée, A. (pseudonym G. Bruno) (2006) Le tour de la France par deux enfants. Devoir et patrie [1877],
in J.-P. Rioux (ed.) Tableaux de la France (Paris: Omnibus).
See also D. Maingueneau (1979) Les livres d’école de la République 1870–1914 (Paris: Le Sycomore);
Ozouf, M. and J. (1984) ‘Le tour de la France par deux enfants: le petit livre rouge de la République’, in Nora, Les lieux de mémoire, pp. 291–321;
J. Strachan (2004) ‘Romance, Religion and the Republic: Bruno’s Le tour de la France par deux enfants’, French History, 18/1, 96–118;
Pazzaglia, L. (2007) ‘I libri di testo: il caso del Giannetto di Parravicini’ in P. L. Ballini and G. Pécout (eds), Scuola e nazione in Italia e Francia nell’Ottocento. Modelli, pratiche, eredità. Nuovi percorsi di ricerca comparata (Venezia: Istituto Veneto di Scienze, Lettere ed Arti), pp. 141–88;
P. Cabanel (2007) Le tour de la nation par des enfants: romans scolaires et espaces nationaux, XIXe-XXe siècles (Paris: Belin).
R. Périé (1913) L’école du citoyen. Histoire et morale à l’usage des cours d’adultes (Paris: Gedalge), p. viii.
J. Gavoille (1981) L’école publique dans le département du Doubs, 1870–1914 (Paris: Les Belles Lettres), p. 54.
J. Lalouette (1997) La libre pensée en France1848–1940 (Paris: Albin Michel), p. 102.
J.-F. Chanet (2001) ‘Pour la Patrie, par l’École ou par l’Épée? L’école face au tournant nationaliste’, Mil neuf cent. Revue d’histoire intellectuelle, 19, 127–44.
M. Ozouf (1976) La fête révolutionnaire1789–1799 (Paris: Gallimard), pp. 317–40.
Bouglé, C. (1901) ‘Patrie’ in M. Berthelot et al. (eds) La Grande Encyclopédie, vol. 26 (Tours: E. Arrault & Co.), p. 99.
As early as August 1914, a small part of Southern Alsace was conquered and placed under military administration. 89 French schools were open. Teaching staff consisted of 113 women including 90 congregational teachers and 99 men including 65 soldiers. J. Senger and P. Barret (1948) Le problème scolaire en Alsace et en Lorraine (Paris: Temps Futur), p. 65. For the ‘first class’, see A. Balz (1914) ‘La Restauration du Français en Alsace’ and ‘Revue de la Presse. La Première Classe en français’, Manuel général de l’instruction primaire, 5 Dec., pp. 88 and 94. For the Daudet story, see A. Daudet (1930) ‘La dernière classe. Récit d’un petit Alsacien’ [Contes du lundi, 1873], in Œuvres complètes illustrées, vol. 1 (Paris: Librairie de France), pp. 1–7.
Circular of the Minister of Education Albert Sarraut, 18 Sept. 1914. See J.-J. Becker (1977) 1914. Comment les Français sont entrés dans la guerre (Paris: Presses de la FNSP), p. 262.
Buisson, F. (1915) preface to A. Moulet L‘École primaire et l’Éducation morale patriotique (Paris: Hachette), p. viii.
O. Loubes (2001) L’école et la patrie. Histoire d’un désenchantement, 1914–1940 (Paris: Belin), p. 38.
V. Hugo (1835) ‘Hymne’ 1831, Chants du crépuscule, no. III;
J. Prévert (1972) ‘Tentative de description d’un dîner de têtes à Paris-France’ [1931], in Paroles (Paris: Gallimard). Hugo wrote his poem for the first anniversary of the revolution of July 1830.
See Stéphane Audoin-Rouzeau (1993), La Guerre des enfants, 1914–1918: essai d’histoire culturelle (Paris: Armand Colin).
R. D’Enfert (2007) ‘L’introduction du travail manuel dans les écoles primaires de garcons, 1880–1900’, Histoire de l‘éducation, 113, 31–67, at p. 65.
A. Delmas (1979) Mémoires d’un instituteur syndicaliste (Paris: Albatros), p. 342.
A. Prost (1977) Les Anciens combattants et la société française, 1914–1939, vol. 2, Sociologie (Paris: Presses de la FNSP), pp. 159–60.
‘Les “Compagnons” et l’école unique’, Journal des instituteurs, 10 Jan. 1920. See B. Gamier (ed.) (2008) L’Université nouvelle. Les Compagnons (Lyon: INRP)
and John E. Talbott (1969) The Politics of Educational Reform in France, 1918–1940 (Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press).
See C. Freinet (1993) Education through Work: A Model for Child-Centered Learning, trans. J. Sivell (Lewison: E. Mellen). The main concepts in Freinet’s pedagogy are: pedagogy of work, meaning that pupils learn by making useful products or providing useful services; co-operative learning, based on co-operation in the productive process; enquiry-based learning, involving group work; the natural method, based on an inductive, global approach; centres of interest, based on children’s learning interests and curiosity.
R. Bazin (1912) Davidée Birot (Paris: Calmann-Lévy).
G. Duveau (1957) Les instituteurs (Paris: Le Seuil), p. 171.
See ‘A Frenchman Examines His Conscience’, third part of M. Bloch (1949) Strange Defeat: A Statement of Evidence Written in 1940, trans. G. C. Hopkins (New York: Oxford University Press), pp. 126–76.
A. Thibaudet (1927) La République des professeurs (Paris: Grasset), ch. x, ‘Héritiers et boursiers’, pp. 120–49.
P. Bourdieu and J.-C. Passeron (1964) Les héritiers. Les étudiants et la culture (Paris: Les Éditions de Minuit).
A. Camus (1994) Le premier homme (Paris: Gallimard), p. 163.
Editor information
Editors and Affiliations
Copyright information
© 2012 Jean-François Chanet
About this chapter
Cite this chapter
Chanet, JF. (2012). ‘Schools Are Society’s Salvation’: The State and Mass Education in France, 1870–1930. In: Brockliss, L., Sheldon, N. (eds) Mass Education and the Limits of State Building, c.1870–1930. Palgrave Macmillan, London. https://doi.org/10.1057/9780230370210_6
Download citation
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1057/9780230370210_6
Publisher Name: Palgrave Macmillan, London
Print ISBN: 978-1-349-32399-9
Online ISBN: 978-0-230-37021-0
eBook Packages: Palgrave History CollectionHistory (R0)