How Has the Role of Newspaper-Based TV Critics Been Redefined in a Digital Media Landscape?

  • Paul RixonEmail author


In this chapter, I present an analysis of how TV critics working for the British press are redefining their role for the digital era. This is achieved by exploring the interplay occurring between critics, newspapers, online digital platforms, and the wider contextual environment. As I do this, I reflect on what this tells us about how the role taken by critics is changing and where these developments are leading. To provide a framework for this analysis, I use the five orientations utilized by Jaakkola et al. (2015) for their work exploring change happening in cultural journalism: knowledge orientation, audience orientation, power orientation, time orientation and ethical orientation. For each of these, I explore different aspects of change happening within the new online TV coverage. This includes looking at the role of the comment sections found on most online pages, the conflation of previews into reviews, the rise of the episodic review and shifts in the underlying values of critics. I end by raising the question of whether a new form of liquid criticism is developing, one which is more suitable for the new television and online press environments.


Liquid criticism Online criticism Service journalism Tastemakers Television criticism Television critic 

Main Television Pages Analyzed

  1. (49,150 total articles. 20 articles linked to top page). Initial access 13 Sept 2019.
  2. (201 articles linked to main TV-Radio page). Initial access 10 Sept 2019.
  3. (78 articles linked to page). Initial access 13 Sept 2019.
  4. (141 articles linked to page). Initial access 11 Sept 2019.
  5. (111 articles linked to page). Initial access 11 Sept 2019.
  6. (7935 total articles. 20 linked to top page). Initial access 13 Sept 2019.


  1. Béliard, A. S. (2015). When Cultural Criticism Blurs Cultural Hierarchies. Journalism Practice, 9(6), 907–923.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  2. Bielby, D. D., & Harrington, C. L. (2008). Global TV: Exporting Television and Culture in the World Market. New York: New York University Press.Google Scholar
  3. Bielby, D. D., Moloney, M., & Ngo, B. (2005). Aesthetics of Television Criticism: Mapping Critics’ Reviews in an Era of Industry Transformation. In C. Jones & P. Thornton (Eds.), Research in the Sociology of Organizations: Transformations in Cultural Industries (Vol. 23, pp. 1–43). Greenwich, CT and London, UK: JAI Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  4. Bourdieu, P. (1984). Distinction: A Social Critique of the Judgement of Taste (trans: R. Nice). London: Routledge.Google Scholar
  5. Broadcasters’ Audience Research Board. (2019). The Viewing Report. Accessed 28 Oct 2019.
  6. Broadcasting Press Guild. (2019). Accessed 18 Oct 2019.
  7. Brown, H. (2019, September 13). Gallic Goth Gore with a Bloody, Female Twist. Daily Telegraph. Accessed 20 Sept 2019.
  8. Brundson, C. (2010). Bingeing on the Box-Sets: The National and the Digital In Television Crime Drama. In J. Gripsrud (Ed.), Relocating Television: Television in the Digital Context (pp. 63–75). London: Routledge.Google Scholar
  9. Cassidy, M. (2019, September 18). Crisis mode: Deep Water Is on ITV Tonight at 9 pm. Sun. Accessed 12 Sept 2019.
  10. Crisell, A. (1997). An Introductory History of British Broadcasting. London: Routledge.Google Scholar
  11. Curran, J., & Seaton, J. (2018). Power Without Responsibility: Press, Broadcasting and the Internet in Britain. London: Routledge.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  12. Curtin, M. (2003). From Network to Neo-Network Audience. In M. Hilmes (Ed.), The Television History Book (pp. 122–125). London: BFI.Google Scholar
  13. Daily Express. (2019). TV and Radio. Accessed 13 Sept 2019.
  14. Daily Telegraph. (2009, April 2). The Wire: Arguably the Greatest Television Programme Ever Made. Accessed 19 Sept 2019.
  15. Deuze, M. (2007). Media Work. Cambridge: Polity Press.Google Scholar
  16. Eide, M., & Knight, G. (1999). Public/Private Service: Service Journalism and the Problems of Everyday Life. European Journal of Communication, 14(4), 525–547.
  17. Gillan, J. (2011). Television and New Media: Must-Click TV. New York and London: Routledge.Google Scholar
  18. Guardian. (2019a). Television. Accessed 13 Sept 2019.
  19. Guardian. (2019b). Episode Recaps. Accessed 11 Sept 2019.
  20. Hogan, M. (2019, September 17). The Great British Bake Off 2019 Episode 4 Recap—Dairy Week Was Really Milking the Show’s Format. Daily Telegraph, Accessed 20 Sept 2019.
  21. Hughes, S. (2019, September 15). Peaky Blinders Recap: Series Five, Episode Five—Back to Its Best at last! Guardian. Accessed 30 Oct 2019.
  22. Jaakkola, M., Hellman, H., Koljonen, K., & Väliverronen, J. (2015). Liquid Modern Journalism with a Difference: The Changing Professional Ethos of Cultural Journalism. Journalism Practice, 9(6), 811–826.Google Scholar
  23. Janssen, S., Kuipers, G., & Verboord, M. (2008). Cultural Globalization and Arts Journalism: The International Orientation of Arts and Culture Coverage in Dutch, French, German, and U.S. Newspapers, 1955 to 2005. American Sociological Review, 73(5): 719–740.Google Scholar
  24. Jefferies, M. (2014, June 19). Why Twitter Is the New TV Reviewer? Radio Times. Accessed 7 Oct 2017.
  25. Jenkins, H. (1992). Textual Poachers: Television, Fans and Participatory Culture. New York and London: Routledge.Google Scholar
  26. Jenkins, H. (2008). Convergence Culture: Where Old and New Media Collide. London: New York University Press.Google Scholar
  27. Kammer, A. (2015). Post-Industrial Cultural Criticism. Journalism Practice, 9(6), 872–889.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  28. Kristensen, N. N., & From, U. (2015). Cultural Journalism and Cultural Critique in a changing Media Landscape. Journalism Practice, 9(6), 760–772.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  29. Kristensen, N. N., Hellman, H., & Riegert, K. (2019). Cultural Mediators Seduced by Mad Men: How Cultural Journalists Legitimized a Quality TV Series in the Nordic Region. Television & New Media, 20(3), 257–274.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  30. Lobato, R. (2019). Netflix Nations: The Geography of Digital Distribution. New York: New York University Press.Google Scholar
  31. Lotz, A. D. (2008). On “Television Criticism”: The Pursuit of the Critical Examination of a Popular Art. Popular Communication: the International Journal of Media and Culture, 6(1), 20–36.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  32. Lotz, A. D. (2017). Portals: A Treatise on Internet-Distributed Television. Michigan: Michigan Publishing.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  33. MailOnline. (2019a). Love Island. Accessed 12 Sept 2019.
  34. MailOnline. (2019b, September 18). Strictly’s Kevin Clifton Reveals It Took Him THREE Times to Get on Show as He Looked Like a ‘Gothic Scarecrow’ in New Documentary… While Fans Get a Glimpse of How Dancers Used to Look. Accessed 12 Sept 2019.
  35. Mangan, L. (2019, September 15). Inside Cadbury: Chocolate Secrets Unwrapped Review—Sickeningly Dull. Guardian. Accessed 20 Sept.
  36. McArthur, C. (1980). Point of Review: Television Criticism in the Press. Screen Education, 35, 59–61.Google Scholar
  37. Mitchell, M. (2019, September 15). Fear The Walking Dead Season 6: Will There be Another Series? Daily Express. Accessed 20 Sept 2019.
  38. Nelson, R. (2007). Quality TV Drama: Estimations and Influences Through Time and Space. In J. McCabe & K. Akass (Eds.), Quality TV: Contemporary American Television and Beyond (pp. 38–51). London: I.B. Tauris.Google Scholar
  39. Ofcom. (2019a). News Consumption in the UK. Accessed 10 Sept 2019.
  40. Ofcom. (2019b). Adults: Media Use and Attitudes Report 2019. Accessed 5 Sept 2019.
  41. Pengelly, M. (2019, September 16). SNL Drops Shane Gillis from Cast Over Racist Comments. Guardian. Accessed 21 Oct 2019.
  42. Poole, M. (1984). The Cult of the Generalist: British Television Criticism 1936–83. Screen, 25, 41–61.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  43. Rees, J. (2019, September 11). Who Do You Think You Are, Review: Mark Wright Did Not Expect the Spanish Inquisition. Daily Telegraph. Accessed 15 Sept 2019.
  44. Rixon, P. (2006). American Television on British Screens: A Story of Cultural Interaction. London: Palgrave.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  45. Rixon, P. (2011). TV Critics and Popular Culture: A History of British Television Criticism. London: I.B. Tauris.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  46. Rixon, P. (2017a). The Impact of New Forms of Digital Communication on Press-Based TV Critics and the Emergence of New Forms of Critical Debate. Journalism, 18(2), 226–240.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  47. Rixon, P. (2017b). The Interaction of Broadcasters, Critics and Audiences in Shaping the Cultural Meaning and Status of Television Programmes: The Public Discourse Around the Second Series of Broadchurch. The Journal of Popular Television, 5(2), 225–243.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  48. Rixon, P. (2018). Radio Critics and Popular Culture: A History of British Radio Criticism. London: Palgrave Macmillan.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  49. Rixon, P. (2019). Contextualising “Quality” US Television Programs for the United Kingdom: The Guardian’s Media Blog and the Role of Critics. In M. Hills, M. Hilmes, & R. Pearson (Eds.), Transatlantic Television Drama: Industries, Programs, and Fans (pp. 239–255). Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  50. Samadder, R. (2019, September 18). The Great British Bake Off 2019: Episode Four—As It Happened. Guardian. Accessed 25 Oct 2019.
  51. Sparre, K., & From, U. (2017). Journalists as Tastemakers: An Analysis of the Coverage of the TV Series Borgen in a British, Swedish and Danish Newsbrand. In N. N. Kristensen & K. Riegert (Eds.), Cultural Journalism in Nordic Countries (pp. 159–178). Götebord: Nordicom.Google Scholar
  52. Spary, S. (2019, August 28). Great British Bake-Off Series Opener Scores Highest Audience Share on Channel 4. Campaign. Accessed 19 Sept 2019.
  53. Spencer, S. (2019, September 10). Power Season 6, Episode 3: What Happened in Forgot About Dre? Daily Express. Accessed 12 Sept 2019.
  54. Strover, S., & Moner, W. (2014). The Contours of On-Demand Viewing. In J. Holt & K. Sanson (Eds.), Connected Viewing: Selling, Streaming, and Sharing Media in the Digital Era (pp. 234–253). London: Routledge.Google Scholar
  55. Sun. (2019a). Eastenders. Accessed 11 Sept 2019.
  56. Sun. (2019b). TV and Showbiz. Accessed 18 Sept 2019.
  57. Tempesta, E., & Drohan, F. (2019, September 11). ‘Is She Using Air?’ Millie Bobby Brown Comes Under Fire Over Video for Her New Beauty Brand That Appears to Show Her FAKING Use of the Skincare Products While Modelling a Full Face of Makeup. MailOnline. Accessed 17 Sept 2019.
  58. Teurlings, J. (2018). Social Media and the New Commons of TV Criticism. Television & New Media, 19(3), 208–224.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  59. The Times. (2019). Television. Accessed 15 Sept 2019.
  60. Thurman, N., Cornia, A., & Kunert, J. (2016). Journalists in the UK. Reuters Institute, Oxford University Press. Accessed 18 Oct 2019.
  61. Vernon, P. (2019, September 12). Why Are We Still Laughing at Friends? The Times. Accessed 13 Sept 2019.
  62. Vonow, B. (2019, September 12). TRUE PRUE What Is Prue Leith’s Net Worth, What Is She Paid for Bake Off and Who’s Her Husband Rayne Kruger? Sun. Accessed 13 Sept 2019.
  63. Wahl-Jorgensen, K., Williams, A., Sambrook, R., Harris, J., Garcia-Blanco, I., Dencik, L., et al. (Eds.). (2016). The Future of Journalism. Digital Journalism, 4(7), 809–815.
  64. Watson, F. (2019, September 13). Top Boy Season 3 Netflix Release Time: What Time Is Top Boy on Netflix? Daily Express. Accessed 14 Sept 2019.
  65. Williams, K. (2010). Read All About It! A History of the British Newspaper. London: Routledge.Google Scholar
  66. Worsley, T. C. (1970). Television: The Ephemeral Art. London: Alan Ross.Google Scholar

Copyright information

© The Author(s) 2021

Authors and Affiliations

  1. 1.University of RoehamptonLondonUK

Personalised recommendations