The Dilemma of Judicial Proof

  • Jiahong HeEmail author
Part of the Masterpieces of Contemporary Jurisprudents in China book series (MCJC)


On 20th November 2006, a 64 year-old retired woman surnamed Xu was waiting for a bus at Nanjing’s Shuiximen Square station when two buses arrived at the same time. Xu rushed towards the second bus, which had fewer passengers. As she passed the back of the first bus, a 26 year-old man, Peng Yu, was the first passenger to alight by the rear door. Peng, anxious to catch his connection, happened to glance backwards and found Xu lying on the ground. He immediately helped her up and, together with her family who were soon on the scene, took her to hospital. While there, he paid over 200RMB in medical fees on Xu’s behalf. The diagnosis found that Xu had sustained a fracture of the left femoral neck in the fall, and had to be hospitalized for hip replacement surgery, necessitating fees in the tens of thousands.


  1. Chen, Xingliang. 2001. Criminal Jurisprudence in and of Itself, 220–221, 226–227. Beijing: The Commercial Press.Google Scholar
  2. Guo, Xinyang. 2011. Analysis of Misjudged Criminal Cases. Beijing: China Renmin Public Security University Press.Google Scholar
  3. He, Jiahong, and Pinxin Liu. 2013. Evidence Law. Beijing: Law Press China.Google Scholar
  4. He, Jiahong. (ed.). 2014a. Late JusticeThe Ten Wrongful Convictions Impacting China’s Judiciary. Beijing: China Legal Publishing House.Google Scholar
  5. He, Jiahong. 2014b. Ten misleading zones in contemporary Chinese criminal justice. Tsinghua Law Review (2).Google Scholar
  6. Jiahong, He. 2016. Back from the Dead: Wrongful Convictions and Criminal Justice in China. Honolulu: University of Hawai’I Press.Google Scholar
  7. Li, Huiqun. 2013. The Zheng Futian & Fu Bing robbery case: How to handle the standard of proof that “the evidence is reliable and sufficient” in criminal cases. In Criminal Trial Reference, vol. 86, 48–54. Beijing: Law Press China.Google Scholar
  8. Liu, Zhiwei, et al. (ed.). 2013. One Book on Criminal Procedure Law. Law Press China.Google Scholar
  9. Ma, Kai, and Zhaofeng Wang. 2014. Paths to the prevention of misjudged cases in shortage of evidence. Heilongjiang Social Sciences (3).Google Scholar
  10. Zeng, Huanyang. 2014. No evidence to prove ‘man knocked down old man’. Guangzhou Daily, 15 Jan 2014, A14.Google Scholar
  11. Zuckerman, Adrian A.S. 1986. Law, fact or justice? Boston University Law Review 66: 488.Google Scholar

Copyright information

© Law Press China and Springer Nature Singapore Pte Ltd. 2018

Authors and Affiliations

  1. 1.School of LawRenmin University of ChinaBeijing, Haidian DistrictChina

Personalised recommendations