Advertisement

Introduction

  • Zhen Meng
Chapter
Part of the Perspectives in Law, Business and Innovation book series (PLBI)

Abstract

The location of ownership of trust property has been an issue of debate among Chinese scholars since Chinese Trust Law was enacted in 2001. Almost every possible interpretation as to this issue has been presented by Chinese lawyers. Under the frustrating circumstances regarding this issue in China, this book describes various conventional interpretations of Chinese Trust Law submitted by legal scholars, and compares diverse approaches regarding the location of ownership of trust property provided by jurisdictions globally. In order to resolve this question, instead of directly answering the question “who is the owner of trust property in China?”, this book develops a new but more practical way to explain what has been facilitating the thriving Chinese trust industry in spite of the ambiguity of the Trust Law, using a social capital perspective. This book also further tries to predicts under what conditions is the time ripe to clarify the location of the ownership of trust property in China.

References

  1. Banakas S (2006) Understanding trusts: a comparative view of property rights in Europe. InDret 323(1):1–9Google Scholar
  2. Bolgár V (1953) Why no trusts in the civil law? Am J Comp Law 2(2):204–219CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  3. D’Angelo N (2014) Commercial trusts. LexisNexis, New YorkGoogle Scholar
  4. Evans-Jones R (1998) Receptions of law, mixed legal systems and the myth of the genius of scots private law. LQR 114:228Google Scholar
  5. Graham T, Steeny P (2012) The Chinese trust. Trusts Trustees 18(1):36–42CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  6. Gretton GL (2000) Trusts without equity. Int Comp Law Q 49:599–620CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  7. Hansmann H, Mattei U (1998) The functions of trust law: a comparative legal and economic analysis. N Y Univ Law Rev 73(2):434–479Google Scholar
  8. He B (2005) Xintuofa yuanli yanjiu (Research on the principles of the trust law). China Legal Publishing House, BeijingGoogle Scholar
  9. Ho L (2012) Trust laws in China. In: Smith Lionel (ed) Re-imaging the trust: trusts in civil law. CUP, New York, pp 183–221CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  10. Ho L, Lee R (2013) Reception of the trust in Asia: a historical perspective. In: Ho L, Lee R (eds) Trust law in Asian civil law jurisdictions: a comparative analysis. CUP, New York, pp 10–26CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  11. Honoré T (1997) Obstacles to the deception of trust law? The examples of South Africa and Scotland. In: Rabello AM (ed) Aequitas and equity: equity in civil law and mixed jurisdictions. Hebrew University of Jerusalem, JerusalemGoogle Scholar
  12. Honoré T (2008) On fitting trusts into civil law jurisdictions. http://ssrn.com/abstract=1270179. Accessed 17 June 2015
  13. Hu G, Chen Q (2006) Quanneng fenge: lun woguo xintuofa zhi xintuo caichan suoyouquan (Separating the right and the power: trust property proprietary rights in Chinese trust law). J Zhengzhou Univ 39(6):84–88Google Scholar
  14. Koessler J (2012) Is there room for the trust in a civil law system? the French and Italian perspective. http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=2132074. Accessed 25 June 2015
  15. Lou J (2012) Xintuo caichan de dulixing yu xintuocaichan guishu de guanxi (Relationship between the trust property segregation and the ownership of trust property). J Guangdong Soc Sci 2:242–250Google Scholar
  16. Lupoi M (ed) (2000) Trust laws of the world: a collection of original texts, 2 vols. ETI, RomeGoogle Scholar
  17. McKinsey (2014) Global Wealth Management Survey 2014: an attractive sector in transition. http://www.mckinsey.com/~/media/mckinsey%20offices/france/pdfs/global_wealth_management_survey_2014.ashx. Accessed 29 Aug 2015
  18. Qu C (2003) The doctrinal basis of the trust principles in China’s trust law. Real Prop Probate Trust J 38(2):345–376Google Scholar
  19. Teramoto M (2007a) Chikujou kaisetsu shin shintakuhou (Commentaries on the new trust law article by article). Shojihomu, TokyoGoogle Scholar
  20. Teramoto S (2007b) Kaisetsu shin shintakuhou (Commentaries on the new trust law). Koubundou Publishers, TokyoGoogle Scholar
  21. Tetley W (1999) Mixed jurisdictions: common law vs. civil law (codified and uncodified) (Part I). Unif Law Rev 3:591–618CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  22. von Bar C, Clive E (eds) (2010) Principles, definitions and model rules of European private law: draft common frame of reference. OUP, OxfordGoogle Scholar
  23. Walton FP (1980) The scope and interpretation of the civil code. Butterworths, TorontoGoogle Scholar
  24. Wang Y (2008) Lun xintuofa yu wuquanfa de guanxi: xintuofa zai minfa faxi zhong de wenti (Relationship between trust law and property law: toward the questions of trust law in civil law system). J Peking Univ (Philos Soc Sci) 6:93–101Google Scholar
  25. Wang W-Y, Wang C-C, Shieh J-S (2013) Trust law in Taiwan: history, current features and future prospects. In: Ho L, Lee R (eds) Trust law in Asian civil law jurisdictions: a comparative analysis. CUP, New York, pp 63–79Google Scholar
  26. Watanabe H (2010) ‘Trusts without equity’ and prospects for the introduction of trusts into European civil law systems. Q Rev Corp Law Soc 7:187–200Google Scholar
  27. Waters D (2006) The future of the trust (Part I). J Int Trust Corp Plan 13(4):179–223Google Scholar
  28. Waters D (2007) The future of the trust (Part II). J Int Trust Corp Plan 14(1):1–22Google Scholar
  29. Wen S, Feng X (2005) Lun xintuo caichan suoyouquan (Ownership of trust property). Wuhan Univ J (Philos Soc Sci) 58(2):203–209Google Scholar
  30. Yu H (2010) Lun yingmei xintuo caichan shuangchong suoyouquan zai zhongguo de bentuhua (Localization of dual ownership of trust property in China). Mod Law Sci 32(3):159–168Google Scholar
  31. Zhang C (2007a) Woguo xintuo caichan suoyouquan guishu de taidu jiqi fali shenshi (An examination of the Chinese attitude towards the ownership of trust property). J Gansu Inst Polit Sci Law 91:7–14Google Scholar
  32. Zhang C (2007b) Lun you shoutuoren xiangyou de xintuo caichan suoyouquan (Trust properties owned by trustee). J Jianghai Acad 5:124–130Google Scholar

Copyright information

© Springer Nature Singapore Pte Ltd. 2017

Authors and Affiliations

  1. 1.Department of Law, School of Intellectual PropertyNanjing University of Science and TechnologyNanjingChina

Personalised recommendations