Abstract
Discrimination in the labor market can fairly be listed among the handful of issues commanding the greatest policy and research attention. The contributions of economists in this extensive scrutiny have been myriad but the most common theoretical framework builds on the nearly forty year old insights of Gary Becker (1957). Becker contends that the source of discrimination is personal prejudice. This prejudice might be held by the customer (Borjas and Bronars, 1989), or by the coworker (Buffum and Whaples 1995), or by the employer. While each of these three possibilities may result in equally productive workers receiving different labor market treatment because of their demographic group, it is prejudice by the employer that has received the greatest attention and which is mostly clearly seen as generating earnings differences between employees. The substance of this chapter begins with a description of how employer prejudice is presumed to generate discriminatory earnings differences. The model presented emphasizes the crucial role played by the absence of competitive product markets. That role follows from Becker’s view that discrimination is costly to employers. There exists, in his view, a trade-off between satisfying prejudices and earning profits. Thus, this popular model of discrimination differs from the two other broad models proposed by economists: first, that discrimination is an information problem, statistical discrimination, and second, that discrimination is a profitable tool in which firms engage as a matter of explicit strategy as suggested by some renderings of the dual labor market hypothesis.
Article FootNote
James Peoples deserves heartfelt thanks for routinely fine suggestions and the strongest of moral support. William Shepherd also should be thanked. It was he who first interested me in this subject when serving as my outside examiner at Swarthmore College in 1979.
Access this chapter
Tax calculation will be finalised at checkout
Purchases are for personal use only
Preview
Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.
References
Alchian, Armen and Kessel, Ruben. “Competition, Monopoly and the Pursuit of Pecuniary Gain,” in Aspects of Labor Economics, Universities-National Bureau Committee for Economic Research. Princeton, New Jersey: Princeton University Press: Princeton, 1962.
Ashenfelter, Orley and Hannan, Timothy “Sex Discrimination and Product Market Structure: The Case of Banking,” Quarterly Journal of Economics. 101 (1986): 149–74.
Becker, Gary. The Economics of Discrimination, Chicago, Illinois: The University of Chicago Press, 1957.
Belman, Dale. “Concentration, Unionism and Labor Earnings: A Sample Selection Approach,” Review of Economics and Statistics. 70 (1988): 391–97.
Belzer, Michael. “Collective Bargaining After Deregulation: Do the Teamsters Still Count?” Industrial and Labor Relations Review. 48 (1995): 636–55.
Bergmann, Barbara and King, Jill. “Diagnosing Discrimination.” In Equal Employment Opportunity and the AT&T Case, Edited by Phyllis Wallace, Cambridge, Massachusetts: MIT Press, 1976.
Blau, Francine and Kahn, Lawrence. “Race and Gender Pay Differentials.” National Bureau of Economic Research Working Paper, No.. 4120, Cambridge, Massachusetts (1992).
Borjas, George and Bronars, Stephen. “Consumer Discrimination and Self-Employment.” Journal of Political Economy. 97 (1989): 581–605.
Bound, John and Freeman, Richard. “What Went Wrong? The Erosion of Relative Earnings and Employment Among Young Black Men in the 1980s.” Quarterly Journal of Economics. 107 (1992): 201–31.
Buffum, David and Whaples, Robert. “Fear and Lathing in the Michigan Furniture Industry: Employee-Based Discrimination ” Economic Inquiry. 33 (1995): 234–52.
Comanor, William. “Racial Discrimination in American Industry.” Economica. 40 (1973): 363–80.
Edwards, Franklin “Managerial Objectives in Regulated Industries: Expense Preference Behavior in Banking.” Journal of Political Economy. 85 (1977): 147–61.
Fuji, Edwin and Trapani, John. “On Estimating the Relationship Between Discrimination and Market Structure.” Southern Economic Journal. 26 (1978): 556–71.
Grossman, Sanford and Hart, Oliver. “Takeover Bids, the Free-rider Problem, and the Theory of the Corporation.” Bell Journal of Economics. 10 (1980): 42–64.
Haessel, Walter and Palmer, John. “Market Power and Employment Discrimination.” Journal of Human Resources. 13 (1978): 545–59.
Hannan, Timothy. “Expense Preference in Banking: A Reexamination.” Journal of Political Economy. 87 (1979):891–1009.
Hannan, Timothy and Mavinga, Ferdinand. “Expense Preference Behavior and Managerial Control.” Bell Journal of Economics. 11 (1980): 671–82.
Hendricks, Wallace. “Deregulation and Labor Earnings.” Journal of Labor Research. 15 (1994): 207–33.
Hendricks, Wallace. “Regulation and Labor Earnings,” The Bell Journal of Economics. 8 (1977): 483–96.
Hirsch, Barry. “Trucking Regulation, Unionization and Labor Earnings: 1973 1988.,” Journal of Human Resources. 23 (1988): 296–319.
Hirsch, Barry. “Trucking Deregulation and Labor Earnings: Is the Union Premium a Compensating Differential?” Journal of Labor Economics. 11 (1993): 279–301.
Heywood, John Product Market Structure and the Labor Market, Ph.D. Dissertation, University of Michigan, Department of Economics, 1986b.
Heywood, John. “Labor Quality and the Concentration-Earnings Hypothesis.” Review of Economics and Statistics. 68 (1986b): 343–48.
Heywood, John. “Wage Discrimination and Market Structure.” Journal of Post Keynesian Economics. 9 (1987): 617–28.
Heywood, John. “Imports and Domestic Wages: Is the Relationship Consistent with Expense Preference Behavior?” Journal of Law, Economics and Organization. 7 (1991): 355–72.
Heywood, John and Peoples, James. “Deregulation and the Prevalence of Black Truck Drivers.” Journal of Law and Economics. 37 (1994): 133–55.
Johnson, William. “Racial Wage Discrimination and Industrial Structure.” The Bell Journal of Economics. 9 (1978): 71–81.
Luksetich, William. “Market Power and Sex Discrimination in White-Collar Employment.” Review of Social Economy. 37 (1979): 211–32.
Oaxaca, Ronald. “Male-Female Wage Differentials in the Telephone Industry.” In Equal Employment Opportunity and the AT&T Case. Edited by Phyllis Wallace, Cambridge, Massachusetts.: MIT Press, 1976.
ONeill, June and Polachek, Soloman. “Why the Gender Gap in Wages Narrowed in the 1980s.” Journal of Labor Economics. 11 (1993): 205–28.
Oster, Sharon. “Industry Differences in the Level of Discrimination Against Women,” Quarterly Journal of Economics. 89 (1975): 495–503.
Peoples, James. “Monopolistic Market Structure, Unionization, and Racial Wage Differentials.” Review of Economics and Statistics. 76 (1994): 207–211.
Peoples, James. “Wage Outcomes Following the Divestiture of AT&T.” Information Economics and Policy Journal. 4 (1989/90): 105–26.
Peoples, James and Robinson, Rhoda. “Market Structure and Racial and Gender Discrimination: Evidence From the Telecommunications Industry.” American Journal of Economics and Sociology, 55 (1996): 309–326.
Peoples, James and Saunders, Lisa. “Trucking Deregulation and the Black/White Wage Gap.” Industrial and Labor Relations Review. 47 (1993):. 23–35.
Rhoades, Stephen. “Monopoly and Expense Preference Behavior: An Empirical Investigation of a Behavioralist Hypothesis.” Southern Economic Journal. 47 (1980): 41–32.
Rose, Nancy. “Labor Rent Sharing and Regulation: Evidence from the Trucking Industry.” Journal of Political Economy. 95 (1987): 1146–78.
Shepherd, William. “Market Power and Racial Discrimination in White Collar Employment.” The Antitrust Bulletin. 14 (1969):141–161.
Shepherd, William. “Elements of Market Structure.” Review of Economic and Statistics. 54 (1972): 25–38.
Shepherd, William. “Long-Distance Telephone Service: Dominance in Decline?” In Industry Studies. Edited by Larry Duetsch. Englewood Cliffs, New Jersey: Prentice Hall, 1993.
Shepherd, William and Sharon, Levine. “Managerial Discrimination in Large Firms.” Review of Economics and Statistics. 55 (1973): 412–19.
Silberberg, Euguene. The Structure of Economics: A Mathematical Approach. New York, New York: McGraw-Hill, 1978.
Smirlock, Michael, and Gilligan, Thomas and Marshall, William. “Tobin’s q and the Structure-Performance Relationship.” American Economic Review. 74 (1984): 1051–63.
Stigler, George. “The Theory of Economic Regulation.” The Bell Journal of Economics. 2 (1971):. 3–21.
Walkling, Ralph and Long, Michael. “Agency Theory, Managerial Welfare and Takeover Bid Resistance.” Rand Journal of Economics. 14 (1984): 54–68.
Williamson, Oliver. “Managerial Discretion and Business Behavior.” American Economic Review. 53 (1963): 1032–57.
References
Belzer, Michael “Collective Bargaining After Deregulation: Do the Teamsters Still Count?” Industrial and Labor Relations Review. 48 (1995): 636–55.
Cappelli, Peter. “Competitive Pressures and Labor Relations in the Airlines Industry.” Industrial Relations. 24 (1985): 316–338.
Cremieux, Pierre-Yves (1996), “The Effect of Deregulation on Employee Earnings: Pilots, Flight Attendants, and Mechanics, 1959–1992.” Industrial and Labor Relations Review. 49 (1996): 223–42.
Greenwald, Bruce and Sharkey, Williams, W. (1989), “The Economics of Deregulation of Local Exchange Telecommunications.” Journal of Regulatory Economics. 1 (1989): 319–39.
Grimm, Curtis and Windle, Robert (1998) “Regulation and Deregulation in Surface Freight, Airlines and Telecommunications.” In, Regulatory Reform and Labor Markets. Edited by James Peoples. Norwell, Massachusetts: pringer Science+Business Media New York.
Hendricks, Wallace. “Deregulation and Labor Earnings.” Journal of Labor Research. 25 (1994): 207–34.
Hirsch, Barry “Trucking Regulation, Unionization and Labor Earnings: 19731985.” Journal of Human Resources. 23 (1988): 296–319.
Hirsch, Barry and Macpherson David, (1998) “Earnings and Employment in a Naturally Competitive Industry,” In, Regulatory Reform and Labor Markets. Edited by James Peoples. Norwell, Massachusetts: pringer Science+Business Media New York.
Johnson, Nancy Brown. “Airline Workers’ Earnings and Union Expenditures Under Deregulation.” Industrial and Labor Relations Review. 45 (1991): 154–65.
Johnson, Nancy Brown, Sambharya, Rakesh B. and Babko, Philip. “Deregula tion, Business Strategy, and Wages in the Airline Industry.” Industrial Relations. 28 (1989): 419–29.
Leone, Richard D. (1970), The Negro in the Trucking Industry, Report No. 15 in the series The Racial Policies of American Industry, Industrial Research Unit, Department of Industry, Wharton School of Finance and Commerce, University of Pennsylvania, Philadelphia.
Mannering, Steven A. and Winston, Clifford (1996), The Evolution of the Airline Industry, The Brookings Institution, Washington, D.C.
Northrup, Herbert R. and Larson, John A. (1979), The Impact of the AT&T-EEO Consent Decree, Report No. 20 in the series The Racial Policies of American Industry, Industrial Research Unit, Department of Industry, Wharton School of Finance and Commerce, University of Pennsylvania, Philadelphia.
Northrup, Herbert R., Thiebolt, Armand J. Jr., and Chernish, William N. (1971), The Negro in the Air Transport Industry, Report No. 16 in the series The Racial Policies of American Industry, Industrial Research Unit, Department of Industry, Wharton School of Finance and Commerce, University of Pennsylvania, Philadelphia.
Peoples, James, Jr. (1990), “Airline Deregulation and Industry Wage Levels.” Eastern Economic Journal. 16 (1990): 49–58.
Peoples, James, Jr., and Robinson, Rhoda (1996), “Market Structure and Racial and Gender Discrimination: Evidence from the Telecommunications Industry.” American Journal of Economics and Sociology. 55 (1996): 309–25.
Peoples, James, Jr., and Saunders, Lisa (1993), “Trucking Deregulation and the Black/White Wage Gap.” Industrial and Labor Relations Review. 47 (1993): 23–35.
Risher, Howard W. Jr. (1971), The Negro in the Railroad Industry, Report No. 16 in the series The Racial Policies of American Industry, Industrial Research Unit, Department of Industry, Wharton School of Finance and Commerce, University of Pennsylvania, Philadelphia.
Rose, Nancy. “Labor Rent-Sharing and Regulation: Evidence from the Trucking Industry.” Journal of Political Economy. 95 (1987): 1146–78.
Shepherd, William, G. “Market Power and Racial Discrimination in White-Collar Employment.” The Antitrust Bulletin. 14 (1969):
Talley, Wayne K. and Schwarz-Miller, Ann (1998), “Railroad Deregulation and Union Labor Earnings,” hi, Regulatory Reform and Labor Markets. Edited by James Peoples. Norwell, Massachusetts: pringer Science+Business Media New York.
Viscusi, W. Kip, and Vernon, John, M. and Harrington, Joseph, E. (1996), Economics of Regulation and Antitrust, second edition., The MIT Press, Cambridge, Massachusetts.
Wallace, Phyllis A. (editor) (1976), Equal Employment Opportunity and the AT&T Case, The MIT Press, Cambridge, Massachusetts.
Editor information
Editors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
Copyright information
© 1998 Springer Science+Business Media New York
About this chapter
Cite this chapter
Heywood, J.S., Husbands, K.G. (1998). Regulated Industries and Measures of Earnings Discrimination. In: Peoples, J. (eds) Regulatory Reform and Labor Markets. Recent Economic Thought Series, vol 61. Springer, Dordrecht. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-94-011-4856-6_7
Download citation
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/978-94-011-4856-6_7
Publisher Name: Springer, Dordrecht
Print ISBN: 978-94-010-6034-9
Online ISBN: 978-94-011-4856-6
eBook Packages: Springer Book Archive