Abstract
In the fields of criminology and criminal law probably everybody can agree with two propositions. First, throughout the world, criminal and delinquent acts are observed, recorded and counted. Rates of crime are interpreted as rather important indicators of a paramount social problem. Second, we can agree that throughout the world — and independent from cultural and political systems — criminal laws as well as criminal justice systems exist, displaying (to varying degrees) successful attempts to define and classify behavior or events as requiring punishment or some other societal reactions, be it treatment or education. Offenders or delinquents are processed through various stages of criminal justice. On the other hand, it is equally easy to conclude that despite rather uniform roles and functions law has been assigned in industrialized countries (Luhmann, 1972), there do not exist universal definitions of crime and delinquency. Agreement has not been reached on what is or what should be considered to be a criminal act or delinquent behavior (neglecting here rather meaningless abstract definitions such as: a crime is an act violating criminal law without justification or excuse). The answer to the question of whether there are universal crimes thus points to the rather trivial idea that law and norms, crime and deviance, represent relative concepts which vary along the dimensions of culture and nations as well as over time (Chang & Blazichek, 1986).
Access this chapter
Tax calculation will be finalised at checkout
Purchases are for personal use only
Preview
Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Adler F: Nations Not Obsessed with Crime. Littleton, 1983
Albrecht, H-J: Criminal law and drug control: A look at Western Europe. International Journal of Comparative and Applied Criminal Justice, 10:17–40, 1986
Albrecht, H-J: Particular difficulties in enforcing the law arising out of basic conflicts between the different agencies with regard to the best suited reaction upon highly sensitive kinds of crime. In European Committee on Crime Problems (Ed.), Interactions Within the Criminal Justice System,. Strasbourg, 1987, p. 13–20.
Anttila, I: Problems of comparative research on the use of discretion in criminal justice. Annales Internationales de Criminologie, 17:43–81, 1987.
Archer, D, & Gartner, R: Violence and Crime in Cross-national Perspective. New Haven, London, 1984.
Arnold, H: Kriminelle Viktimisierung und ihre Korrelate. Zeitschrift für die Gesamte Strafrechtswissenschaft, 98:1014–1058, 1986.
Arnold, H, & Korinek, L: Kriminalitätsbelastung in der Bundesrepublik Duetschland und Ungarn: Ergehnisse einer international vergleichenden Opferbefragung. In Böhm, H et al., (Eds.), Kriminologie in Sozialistischen Ländern. Bochum, 1985, p. 65–136.
Bennett, RR: The effect of police personnel levels on crime clearance rates: A cross national analysis. International Journal of Comparative and Applied Criminal Justice, 6:177–193, 1982.
Block, CR, & Block, RL: Crime definition, crime measurement, and victim surveys. Journal of Social Issues, 40:137–160, 1984.
Burcart, JM: Measuring delinquency through self-report instruments: A bibliographic essay. Institute of Policy Analysis, 1977.
Chang, DH, & Blazicek, DL: An introduction to comparative and international criminology. Durham, 1986.
Chirol, Y et al.: Dde linquance juvenile et developpement socioeconomioue. Paris: La Haye, 1975.
Christiansen, KO: Method of using an index of crime of the kind devised by Sellin and Wolfgang. In Council of Europe (Ed.), The Index of Crime. Some Further Studies. Strasbourg, 1970, p. 7–30.
Christie, N, Andenaes, J., & Skirbekk, S: A study of self-reported crime. Scandinavian Studies in Criminology, 1:86–116, 1965.
Clinard, MB: Cities with little crime. Cambridge, 1978.
Clinard, MB, & Junger-Tas, J: Probleme und Resultate beim Vergleich ubernationaler Victim Surveys. In Kirchhoff, GBP & Sessar, K (Eds.), Das Verbrechensopfer. Bocum, 1979, p. 159–176.
Collmann, H-J: Internationale Kriminalstatistik. Geschichtliche Entwicklung unde gegenwärtiger Stand. Stuttgart, 1973
Council of Europe (Eds.): Report on decriminalization. Strasbourg, 1980.
Croft, J: Crime and comparative research. HORS 57. London, 1979.
van Dijk, JJM, & Steinmetz, CHD: The RDC victim surveys 1974–79. The Hague, 1980.
Dünkel, F & Meyer, K (eds.): Jugendstrafe und Jugendstrafvollzug. Stationäre Massnahmen der Jugendkriminalrechtspflege im internationalen Vergleich. Vol. 1, Freiburg, 1985. Vol 2, Frieburg, 1986.
Duffee, DE: Explaining Criminal Justice. Community, Theory and Criminal Justice Reform. Cambridge 1980.
Elmhorn, K: Study in self-reported delinquency among school children in Stockholm. Scandinavian Studies in Criminology, 1:117–146, 1965.
Eser, A & Koch, H-G (Eds.): Schwangerschaftsabbruch im Internationalen Vergleich. Baden-Baden, 1988.
European Group for the Study of Deviance and Social Control: Disputing deviance: Experience of youth in the eighties. Working papers in European Criminology No. 4.
Gibbs, JP: Norm, deviance, and social control. Conceptual matters. New York: Oxford, 1981.
Gross, H: A theory of criminal justice. Oxford, 1979.
Gurr, TR: Crime trends in modern democracies since 1945. Annales Internationales de Criminologie, 16:41–85, 1977.
Hauge, R: Definition and scope of comparative studies in crime trends, including a review of work carried out since about 1945. In Council of Europe (Ed.), Trends in crime: Comparative studies and technical problems. Strasbourg, 1983, p. 25–49.
Hauge, R, & Wolf, P: Criminal violence in three Scandinavian countries. Scandinavian Studies in Criminology, 5:25–33, 1974.
Heine, G: Erkennung und Verfolgung von Umweltstraftaten im Europäischen Rechtsraum. Ifawelt & Planaungsrecht, 1987, p. 281–291.
Henry, M: Etude de la comparabilite des criteres juridiques. Annales de Vaucresson. 1977, p. 61–97.
Huizinga, D, & Elliott, DS: Reassessing the reliability and validity of self-report measures. Journal of Quantitative Criminology, 2:293–327, 1986.
Joutsen, M: Computerization and the international exchange of information on crime and criminal justice. In HEUNI (Ed.), Computerization of criminal justice information systems: Realities, prospects, methods and effects. Helsinki, 1987, p. 253–266.
Junger-Tas, J: Some issues and problems in cross-cultural research in criminology. The Hague, 1978.
Kaiser, G: The comparative method in criminology. NCJRS, 1978.
Kerner, H-J: Fear of crime and attitudes towards crime. Comparative criminological reflections. Annales Internationales de Criminologie, 17:83–99, 1978.
Kirchhoff, C, & Kirchhoff, GF: Untersuchungen im Dunkelfeld sexueller Viktimisation mit Hilfe von Fragebögen. In Kerchhoff, GG, & Sessar, K. (Eds.), Das Verbrechensopfer. Bochum, 1979, p. 275–299.
Klein, MW (Ed.): Western systems of juvenile justice. Beverly Hills, Sage Publications: 1984
Landau, SF: Trends in violence and aggression: A cross-cultural analysis. Annales Internationales de Criminologie, 22:119–150, 1984.
Lejins, PP: A speculative note on the meaning of juvenile delinquency. In Brüsten, M et al., (Eds.): Youth crime, social control and prevention: Theoretical perspectives and policy implications. Studies from nine different countries. Pfaffenweiler, 1964, p. 3–8.
Luhmann, N: Rechtssoziologie. Reinbek, 1972.
Malewska, H, & Peyre, V: Delinquance juvenile, famille, ecole et societe. Vaucresson, 1973
Martin, RG, & Conger, RD: A comparison of delinquency trends: Japan and the United States. Criminology, 18:53–61, 1980.
McClintock, FH: The phenomenological and contextual analysis of criminal violence. In Council of Europe (Ed.), Violence in society. Strasbourg, 1973 p. 115–162.
Meyer, J. (Ed.): Betäubungsmittelstrafrecht in Westeuropa. Freiburg, 1987.
Moitra, S: Crimes and punishments. Freiburg, 1987.
Newman, G: Comparative deviance. Perception and law in six cultures. New York, Oxford, Amsterdam, 1976.
OECD: Social indicators: Recommended list of social concerns. In Zapf, W (Ed.): Soziale Indikatoren. Knozepte und Forschungsansätze. Frankfurt, New York, 1974, p. 229–230.
Peters, AAG: Comparative survey of juvenile delinquency in Asia and the Far East. UNAFEI, Tokyo, 1968.
Peyre, V: Technical problems in the design and execution of comparative studies. In Council of Europe (Ed.): Trends in crime: Comparative studies and technical problems. Strasbourg, 1983, p. 53–69.
le Poole, F: Law and practice concerning the counterparts of ’persons in need of supervision’ in some European countries, with a particular emphasis on the Netherlands. In Teitelbaum, LE, & Gough, HR (Eds.): Beyond Control. Status Offenders in the Juvenile Court. Cambridge, 1977, p. 115–160.
Redo, SM: The United Nations Crime Trends Surveys: Comparative criminology in the global context. Annales Internationales de Criminologie, 24:163–179, 1986.
Reiss, AJ: Probiens in developing statistical indicators of crime. In Connaitre la criminalité: Le dernier etat de la question. Aix, Marseille, 1983, p. 25–61.
Robertson, R, & Taylor, L: Deviance, Crime and Socio-Legal Control. Bristol, 1973.
Rose, GNG: The merits of an index of crime of the kind devised by Wolfgang and Sellin. In Council of Europe (Ed.): The index of crime. Some further studies. Strasbourg, 1970, p. 33–52.
Scott, JE, & Al-Thakeb, F: Perceptions of deviance cross-culturally. In Newman, G. (Ed.), Crime and deviance. A comparative perspective. Beverly Hills, London: Sage Publication, 1980, p. 42–67.
Sellin, T, & Wolfgang, ME: The measurement of delinquency. London, 1964.
Smith, LJF: Criminal justice comparisons. London: Home Office, 1983.
Stadler, H: Kirminalitat im Kanton Uri. Eine Opferbefragung. Jur. Diss, Entlebuch, 1987.
Stephan, E: Die Stuttgarter Opferbefragung. Wiesbaden, 1976.
Swanson, C: A comparison of organizational and environmental influences on arrest policies. In Meyer, FA, & Baker, R (Eds.), Determinants of law-enforcement policies. Lexington, Toronto, 1979, p. 15–33.
Teske, RHC, & Arnold, H: Comparison of the criminal statistics of the United States and the Federal Republic of Germany. Journal of Criminal Justice, 10:359–374, 1982.
UNSDRI: Juvenile social maladjustment. Rome, 1984.
UNSDRI: Action oriented research on youth crime. An international perspective. Rome, 1986.
Vaz, EW, & Casparis, J: A comparative study of youth culture and delinquency: Upper middle-class Canadian and Swiss boys. In Shelley, LI (Ed.), Readings in comparative criminology. Cabandale, Edwardsville, 1981, p. 56–77.
Vetere, E., & Newman, G: International crime statistics: An overview from a comparative perspective. Abstracts on Criminology and Penology, 17:251–267, 1977.
Villmow, B: Schwereeinschätzung von Delikten. Berlin, 1977.
Villmow, B, & Stephan, E: Jugendkriminalität in einer Gemeinde. Freiburg, 1983.
Waller, I: La criminalité au Canada et aux Etats Unis: Tendences et explications comparatives. Annales Internationales de Criminologie, 14:51–84, 1981.
Waller, I, & Okihiro, N: Burglary: The victim and the public. Toronto, 1978.
Weinberger, J-C, Jakubowicz, P. & Robert, P: Sociéte et perceptions des comportements déviants incriminiés. Paris, 1977
Wellford, LF: Crime and the dimension of nation. International Journal of Criminology and Penology, 2:1–10, 1974.
Wilkins, LT: World crime. To measure or not to measure? In Newman, GR (Ed.): Crime and deviance. A comparative perspective. Beverly Hills, London: Sage Publications, 1980, p. 17–41.
Wolf, P: Crime and development. An international comparison of crime rates. Scandinavian Criminology, 3:107–120, 1971.
Wolfgang, ME, et al.: The national survey of crime severity. Washington, D.C.: Department of Justice, 1985.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Editor information
Editors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
Copyright information
© 1989 Kluwer Academic Publishers
About this chapter
Cite this chapter
Albrecht, H.J. (1989). Comparative Research on Crime and Delinquency — The Role and Relevance of National Penal Codes and Criminal Justice Systems. In: Klein, M.W. (eds) Cross-National Research in Self-Reported Crime and Delinquency. NATO ASI Series, vol 50. Springer, Dordrecht. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-94-009-1001-0_11
Download citation
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/978-94-009-1001-0_11
Publisher Name: Springer, Dordrecht
Print ISBN: 978-94-010-6940-3
Online ISBN: 978-94-009-1001-0
eBook Packages: Springer Book Archive