Designing a Learning Progression for Teaching and Learning About Matter in Early School Years
Our overarching goal is to engage students and teachers in long-term and in-depth scientific knowledge constructions across different years of school. In this context, we present part of our ongoing work for designing a learning progression (LP) to support young children, from pre-k to 4th grade, to start learning about matter through their experiences with materials from their physical environment. In this progression, students gradually develop increasingly complex models of the internal invisible structure of materials while they engage in interpreting properties and transformations in these materials. We select three interwoven elements of design: children’s articulations of particular intuitive ideas, materials that contextualize these articulations, and teacher acts promoting and sustaining children’s gradual articulations of ideas. We report our design work by providing first a rationale for the design elements chosen that also represent our units of analysis; second, we briefly describe the context of our work; third, we illustrate refinements in our LP with descriptions of some lessons learned in different classrooms. We conclude by delineating our idea of progression and possible ways to continue with our work to finally identify some coincidences with other LP frameworks in similar areas of research.
KeywordsBreak Water Learn Progression Instructional Goal Complex Articulation Classroom Event
We wish to offer our heartfelt thanks to teachers Anna Aiolfi and Marika Quaglietta, Scuola dell’ Infanzia Andersen 1 Circolo di Spinea, Italy. We also wish to thank Lisa Kenyon and Maria Evagorou for first revisions of this manuscript and anonymous reviewers for their suggestions.
- Acher, A., & Arcà, M. (2009). Children’s representations in modeling scientific knowledge construction. In A. Teuval (Ed.), Representational systems and practices as learning tools in different fields of knowledge (pp. 109–133). New Jersey: Sense Press. Chapter VIII.Google Scholar
- Acher, A., & Arcà, M. (2009). Modeling materials in early school years. Paper presented at the annual meeting of AERA, San Diego, USA. Symposium: Developing and refining a learning progression for matter from pre-K to Grade 12: Commonalities and contrasts among four current projects. Chair: Carol Smith. Discussants: Joe Krajcik & Clark Chinn.Google Scholar
- Arcà, M., & Acher, A. (2005). Children’s Models in Scientific Knowledge Construction. In: Children’s drawing: Its relation to learning and instruction in kindergarten and primary Education. Symposium. N. Scheuer (Chair). 11th EARLI Conference Proceedings. Nicosia, Cyprus.Google Scholar
- National Research Council – USA. (2007). Taking science to school: Learning and teaching science in grades K-8. Washington, DC: The National Academies Press.Google Scholar
- Schwarz, C. V., Reiser, B. J., Acher, A., Kenyon, L. O., & Fortus, D. (2012). Issues and challenges in defining a learning progression for scientific modeling. In A. Gotwals & A. Alonso (Eds.), Learning progressions for science. New Jersey: Sense Press.Google Scholar
- Selmi, L. (1982). La Sezione dei cinque anni. [The classroom of 5-year-old children]. Milano: Fabbri Eds.Google Scholar
- Wiser, M., & Smith, C. (2008). Teaching about matter in grades K-8: When should the atomic molecular theory be introduced? In S. Vosniadou (Ed.), International handbook of research on conceptual change (p. 205). Mahwah: Lawrence Erlbaum.Google Scholar