Intellectual Excellences of the Judge
Aspects of legal cases hinge on understanding the situation of the disputants. While categories such as feeling, empathy, law and politics have limited discriminating capacity here, I propose to draw upon the Aristotelian scheme of intellectual virtues. Specifically, I look at how the judge exercises discernment (gnômê) and the comprehension of what others say (synesis). In the context of practical wisdom, Hursthouse has argued that discernment requires experience of exceptions. I add that the judge exercises her discernment by suspending the application of principles to an individual, while listening. Furthermore, I add that the exceptions include experiences lived through, which Hursthouse’s technical view neglects. When using her comprehension to absorb the details of the situation based upon testimony, the judge will have to be open to different perspectives, able to move between them, and yet courageous enough to stand by what she deems right. I conclude with a hypothetical about the judge’s involvement in the process contributing to a better understanding of the other in a global environment.
KeywordsScientific Knowledge Practical Wisdom Virtuous Person Legal Process Intellectual Virtue
- Aristotle. 1998. The Nicomachean ethics. Trans. David Ross. Revised J.L. Ackrill, and J.O. Urmson. Oxford/New York: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
- Aristotle. 2002. Nicomachean ethics. Trans. Christopher Rowe. Oxford/New York: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
- Baker, P., and N.A. Lewis. 2009. Sotomayor vows ‘fidelity to the law’ as hearings start. The New York Times, July 14, 2009. http://www.nytimes.com/2009/07/14/us/politics/14confirm.html.
- Broadie, S. 2002. Philosophical introduction. In Nicomachean ethics, 9–91. Trans. Christopher Rowe. Oxford/New York: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
- Broadie, S. 2006. Aristotle and contemporary ethics. In The Blackwell guide to Aristotle’s Nicomachean ethics, ed. R. Kraut, 342–361. Malden/Oxford: Blackwell Publishing.Google Scholar
- Damasio, A.R. 1994. Descartes’ error: Emotion, reason and the human brain. London: Picador.Google Scholar
- France, A. 1912/2007. The gods are athirst. Project Gutenberg EBook. http://www.gutenberg.org/ebooks/24010.
- Gadamer, H.-G. 1960/2004. Truth and method. London/New York: Continuum.Google Scholar
- Günther, K. 1993. The sense of appropriateness: Application discourses in morality and law. Albany: State University of New York Press.Google Scholar
- Howse, R., and K. Nicolaïdis. 2008. Democracy without sovereignty: The global vocation of political ethics. In The shifting allocation of authority in international law: Considering sovereignty, supremacy and subsidiarity, ed. T. Broude and Y. Shany, 163–191. Oxford/Portland: Hart Publishing.Google Scholar
- Kagan, R.A. 2001. Adversarial legalism: The American way of law. Cambridge, MA/London: Harvard University Press.Google Scholar
- Kundera, M. 2010. Encounter. New York: Harper.Google Scholar
- Livingston, A., and M. Murray. 2009. Context of Obama’s ‘empathy remark.’ First read from NBC News, May 1, http://firstread.msnbc.msn.com/_news/2009/05/01/4430634-context-of-obamas-empathy-remark.
- McDowell, J. 1979/1998. Virtue and reason. In McDowell, Mind, value, and reality, 50–73. Cambridge, MA/London: Harvard University Press.Google Scholar
- Murdoch, I. 1964/1999. The idea of perfection. In Murdoch, Existentialists and mystics: Writings on philosophy and literature, ed. P. Conradi, 299–336. London: Penguin.Google Scholar
- Posner, R.A. 2008. How judges think. Cambridge, MA/London: Harvard University Press.Google Scholar
- Preston, S.D., and F.B.M. de Waal. 2002. Empathy: Its ultimate and proximate bases. Behavioural and Brain Sciences 25: 1–72.Google Scholar
- Solum, L.B. 1994. Equity and the rule of law. In The rule of law: NOMOS XXXVI, ed. I. Shapiro, 120–147. New York: New York University Press.Google Scholar
- Wai, R. 2005. Transnational private law and private ordering in a contested global society. Harvard International Law Journal 46(2): 471–488.Google Scholar