Models of God and Alternative Ultimate Realities pp 543-565 | Cite as
The God Insight: Vengeance or Destiny?
Abstract
My God is neither a Creator, much less an avenger, but rather the ultimate final cause (telos)—the end for the sake of which the cosmos works and our lives are lived out (partly in striving, as well as in pain and disappointment). This God is what Sartre denied—the meaning of life and of natural phenomena. To Aristotle’s problem of the uniqueness of the Prime Mover: if two Gods were per impossibile to exist, one would have to embrace the other’s telos. So God’s existence is to be taken for granted, but not as proven or empirically necessitated. Such a God is essential to us, but He is not detritus of the Big Bang, nor incarnate of the Virgin Mary, not omnipotent, nor comforting, nor prayer-accessible. Although such a God is undeniably a kind of let-down, He still explains the fundamental importance and value of the religious impulse in us.
Keywords
Good Explanation Meaningful Life Intentional Object Childbed Fever Conversation PartnerReferences25
- Aristotle. 1941. Phsyica. In The basic works of Aristotle, ed. Richard McKeon. New York: Random House [Oxford University Press], ch 6, 198a-198b et seq.Google Scholar
- Bacon, John. 1991. “Real beauty”, Sydney Society of Literature and Aesthetics (colloquium, 4 Oct. 1991) 11:30 am. [Greeted with polite silence.]Google Scholar
- Bacon, John, and Richters Juliet. 1990. What shall we live for? A dialogue. In On being human: Meditations on experience, ed. Nelson Venetia, 9–17. Melbourne: David Lovell.Google Scholar
- Brams, Steven. 2003. Biblical games: Game theory and the Hebrew Bible. Cambridge: MIT Press.Google Scholar
- Brentano, Franz. 1874. Psychologie vom empirischen Standpunk. Leipsic: Dunker & Humblot. [Interestingly for our purposes here: Another book of ex-priest Brentano’s was Die Lehre Jesu and ihre bleibende Bedeutung!]Google Scholar
- Buber, Martin. 1950. Zwei Glaubensweisen. Zürich: Manesse Verlag.Google Scholar
- Costigan, Mairéad F. 1998. Ironic irony in the Phaidros, Honors thesis, Department of Trad. & Mod. Philosophy, School of Philosophy, University of Sydney, November 1998. [Eugenio E. Benítez, supervisor.]Google Scholar
- Dawkins, Richard. 2006. The God delusion. London: Bantom Press pbk. [Provoked this paper.]Google Scholar
- Dickens, Charles. Little Dorrit. London: Caxton, undated; orig. 1855–1857. [Amy Dorrit, protagonist; her father William Dorrit, “the Father of the Marshalsea”; her intended Arthur Clennam; his mother Mrs. Clennam.]Google Scholar
- Dickenson, Emily. 1999. The poems of Emily Dickenson, ed. R.W. Franklin. Belknap Press/Harvard University Press. [the definitive ed.]Google Scholar
- Dostoyevski, Fyodor. 1963–1969. Brat’ya Karamazov’ [The brothers Karamazov]. Moscow: B. V. Voronestkiy. Trans. Constance Garnett and Ralph E. Matlaw. New York: Norton, 1976; Harmondsworth: Penguin pbk, 1958.Google Scholar
- Edwards, Jonathan. 1995. Sinners in the hands of an angry God. In A Jonathan Edwards reader, ed. E. John Smith et al. New Haven: Yale University Press. orig. 1741.Google Scholar
- Einstein, Albert. 1972. Letter quoted in Banesh Hoffman. In Albert Einstein, creator and rebel. New York: Viking. p. 195 [Other Einstein quotes op. cit.].Google Scholar
- Eliot, George. Adam Bede. London: Dent/Everyman, 1906; Harmondsworth: Penguin pbk, 1980. [Adam Behe, protagonist; his intended Dinah Morris; Arthur Donnithorne, local “squire”; Hetty Sorrel, his mistress, unwed mother and suicide.]Google Scholar
- Eliot, George. 1973. Middlemarch. London: Pan Books pbk; orig. 1871. [Dorothea Brooke, protagonist; her first husband Edward Casaubon; her intended Will Ladislaw; Mr. Lydgate the doctor; pretty airhead Rosamond Vincy.]Google Scholar
- Eliot, George. Silas Marner, the weaver of Raveloe. Edinburgh/London: Blackwood, undated; orig. 1861. [Silas Marner, protagonist; his ward Hephzibah (“Eppie”).]Google Scholar
- Franklin, James. 2007. Letter to Ed. Quadrant, vol. 51.6 (Junde 2007) p. 9 (re Hodgson, 2007)Google Scholar
- Gellar, Sarah Michelle: see Whedon.Google Scholar
- General Assembly of the Presbyterian Church in the USA (ed.). 1933. The hymnal, 275. Philadelphia: Presbyterian Board of Christian Education.Google Scholar
- Handel, George Frederick. 1742. The Messiah, dir Handel. Dublin: Premier.Google Scholar
- Hardy, Thomas. 1975. Life and death of the mayor of Casterbridge: A story of a man of character. London: Macmillan; orig. 1878. [Mayor Richard Henchart, protagonist; his wife Susan; their fancied daughter Elizabeth-Jane Newson.]Google Scholar
- Hempel, Carl.G. 1966. Philosophy of natural science. Englewood Cliffs: Prentice-Hall.Google Scholar
- Herberg, Will. 1960. Judaism and modern man: An interpretation of Jewish religion. New York: Meridian.Google Scholar
- Hodgson, David. 2007. Dawkins and the morality of the Bible. Quadrant 51(5): 38–43. Review of The God delusion.Google Scholar
- Holschneider, Andreas. 1960. Zauberspuk and und philosophishce Oper” in program notes to recording of Die Zauberflöte, Karl Böhm, dir., Berliner Philharmonkier RIAS Kammerchor (Deutsche Grammophon #138 982, unplaced, undated; ca. 1960) pp. 7f. [Eng. Pp. 12f.]Google Scholar
- Hugo, Victor. 1862. Les misérables. Brussels: Lacroix & Verboeckhoven. [Jean Valjean, protagonist; his daughter Cossette; her boyfriend Marius.]Google Scholar
- Jacobs, Mary C. [“Watty Piper”]. 1910. The little engine that could. Daughters of the American Revolution; repr. New York: Platt & Monk, 1954. [A classic, wildly popular American childrens’ book.]Google Scholar
- Job [’lov] in K e tuvim, in Tanach (q.v.).Google Scholar
- Kaplan, Mordecai Menachem. 1957. Judaism as a civilization: Toward a reconstruction of American-Jewish life. Philadelphia: Jewish Publishing Society.Google Scholar
- Maler, Johan. 1978. Jesus von Nazareth in der Tamudischen Überlieferung. Darmastadt: Wissenschaftliche Buchgesellschaft. [An invaluable critical compendium of Jewish-Christian historical and theological encounters from post-New-Testament times to the 20th C.]Google Scholar
- Mozart, Wolfgang A. (composer), and Emmanuel Schikaneder (librettist & Papageno). Die Zauberflöte. Theatre an der Wien, Vienna: Premier, 30 September 19710. [Prince Tamino and his intended Pamina, co-protagonists; Sarastro, Masonic CEO; Queen of the Night; sundry supporting cast.]Google Scholar
- Oxford Wolfson College. 1998. College record 1997-98. Oxford: Wolfson College.Google Scholar
- Pagels, Elaine. 1995. The origin of Satan. New York: Random House.Google Scholar
- Plato. Phaidros, 369–367. oral pub, Athens: Academy Press. [A dialogue from Plato’s third or mature period, presumably before the second Sicilian trip] [Socrates, Phaidros; Lysias in absentia.]Google Scholar
- Richerts, Juliet Coleman: see Bacon.Google Scholar
- Stifter, Aldabert. 1948. Brigitta. Stuttgart: Reclam pbk. [Mag. Stefan Murai, protagonist; his intended Brigitte; and edified youth as narrator.]Google Scholar
- Taylor, Richard. 1970. Good and evil: A new direction. New York/London: Macmillan.Google Scholar
- Edited: Tol e dot Yeshu [Antecedents of Jesus]; see Maler [nasty anti-Christian stories].Google Scholar
- Tomasso di Aquino. 1972. [The five ways of proving God’s existence] An Aquinas reader, ed. Mary T. Clarck, from Summa theological I, quaestio 2, a. 3; pp. 122f et seq. Garden City: Doubleday Image pbk.Google Scholar
- Edited: K e tuvim Book 3, in Tanach [trans. Holy Bible, Old Testament, Book 18]. Philadelphia: Jewish Publication Society, 5759; trans. Toronto/New York/Edinburgh: Thomas Nelson & Sons, 1953.Google Scholar
- Whedon, Joss [Joseph Hill Whedon], prod. 1997–2003. Buffy the vampire slayer. Los Angeles/Hollywood: Warner Bros. TV Network. [Featuring the brilliant Sarah Michelle Gellar as Buffy Anne Summers, the Slayer, and the “Scoobies,” her loyal circle of friends at UC Sunnydale.]Google Scholar
- Wine, Sherwin T. 1995. Judaism beyond God: A radical new way to be Jewish. Michigan: Ktav Publishing House/Society for Humanistic Judaism/Milan Press.Google Scholar
- Zemach, Eddy M. 1991. Real beauty. Midwest Studies in Philosophy 16: 249–265.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Zemach, Eddy M. 1997. Real beauty. College Park: Pennsylvania State University Press.Google Scholar