Textual analysis and scientometric mapping of the dynamic knowledge in and around the IFSA community
Using the proceedings of six European IFSA Symposia, we analysed the themes that were central in these Symposia as well as trends from a number of papers and authors. We then assessed the wider domain of agricultural research based on a corpus extracted from the CAB and SCI databases of the Web of Knowledge. The co-word analysis allows the generation of maps which graphically represent how keywords are linked, and allows the identification of thematic clusters. The dynamic of keywords in the period 1991–2007 was also analysed, thus allowing the identification of keywords which were of central importance during different periods. This showed how themes such as sustainability emerged, disappeared and re-emerged under different guises. The various analyses are provided to further the reflexivity of the IFSA community, especially regarding its publication practices and thus its efforts to make results from Farming Systems Research more widely available.
KeywordsScience Citation Index Scientific Context Bibliographic Notice Agronomic Research Science Citation Index Database
We thank especially Benoit Dedieu, Bernard Hubert and Marianne Cerf for their availability in the hectic times of their own activities. We also want to thank Jean-Marc Meynard, the Head of the SAD Department of INRA, who brought a financial support to this research. Thanks also to those who proposed comments and critics during the Clermont-Ferrand symposium, and to the Board of IFSA, which has welcome the results of this research. We would like to thank Ika Darnhofer for her careful editorial work, which considerably helped to clarify the presentation of our work. The final thank you is for Jean-Philippe Cointet, who does a lot to design new algorithms and methodology of visualising graphs like in the Map 4.2.
- Barbier, M. (2010). The ecologization of agricultural development and the treadmill of sustainable development, a critique in a state of transition. Przeglad Socjologiczny (Sociological Review), 59, 9–28.Google Scholar
- Barbier, M., François-Moll, F., Vichnevskaia, T., & Mogoutov, A. (2008, April 8). Figures de la “soutenabilité” dans des bases de données scientifiques du “Web of Science”. Exploration et discussion de traitements scientométriques. Presentation at the Seminar ‘Changement climatique, expertise et fabrications du futur: Modèles et scénarios, politique et gouvernance’ held in Paris.Google Scholar
- Callon, M., Law, J., & Rip, A. (1986). Mapping the dynamics of science and technology. London: Macmillan.Google Scholar
- Cambrosio, A., Cotterau, P., Popowycz, S., Mogoutov, A., & Vichnevskaia, T. (2010). Analysis of heterogenous networks: The ReseauLu project. In C. Brossaud & B. Reber (Eds.), Digital cognitive technologies. Epistemology and knowledge society (pp. 137–152). London: ISTE/Wiley.Google Scholar
- Ding, Y., & Foo, S. (2002). Ontology research and development. A review of ontology mapping and evolving. Part 1. Journal of Information Science, 28, 123–136.Google Scholar
- Granjou, C., & Barbier, M. (2010). Les métamorphoses de l’expertise. Versailles: Quæ.Google Scholar
- Jones, D. S., Cambrosio, A., & Mogoutov, A. (2011). Detection and characterization of translational research in cancer and cardiovascular medicine. Journal of Translational Medicine, 9, 57 [http://www.translational-medicine.com/content/9/1/57].Google Scholar
- Ollivier, G., & Bellon, S. (2010, February 24–26). Scientometric mapping of agroecology: Looking for a legend? In: P. Stassart & P. Baret (Eds.), The potential of agroecology to contribute to ecological transitions in agriculture. Proceedings of an EU Exploratory Workshop held in Arlon, Belgium.Google Scholar
- Tari, T., Breucker, P., & Barbier, M. (2010). Characterising the localisation of projects collaborations in research dynamics: Methodological requirements and results for new visualisations of heterogeneous networks. In Proceedings of the ENID Conference Held in Paris, 2010.Google Scholar
- Turenne, N., & Barbier, M. (2004). BELUGA: Un outil pour l’analyse dynamique des connaissances de la littérature scientifique d’un domaine. Première application au cas des maladies à prions. In G. Hébrail & L. Lebart (Eds.), Proceedings of extraction et gestion de connaissances, Clermont-Ferrand, France.Google Scholar