Abstract
This chapter focuses on the question, “Which norms should govern the practice and practitioner of medicine—and why those?,” and critically examines the partially overlapping, yet competing, answers given to this question by two rival paradigms: (1) “secular academic medical ethics,” and (2) medical professionalism. After clarifying the nature of both paradigms, the chapter presents a multifaceted case for favoring the norms of secular academic medical ethics. This case emphasizes professionalism’s tendency toward medical paternalism, its encouragement of a “peace in the house” of medicine culture that resists accountability to those outside of medicine, and its insistence on fiduciary standards that are overly demanding and perhaps unworkable in our current era of medicine.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution.
Buying options
Tax calculation will be finalised at checkout
Purchases are for personal use only
Learn about institutional subscriptionsReferences
Accreditation Council for Graduate Medical Education (ACGME). 2002. Competency requirements [On-line]. Available at http://www.acgme.org/acWebsite/irc/irc_compIntro.asp. Accessed 24 Sep 2012.
Anonymous. 2011. ‘Octomom’ doctor’s license to be revoked, state medical board rules. L. A. Times (local) June 1 [On-line]. Available at http://latimesblogs.latimes.com/lanow/2011/06/a-matter-octomom-doctor-michael-kamrava.html. Accessed 24 Sep 2012.
Appelbaum, P.S., and T.G. Gutheil. 1979. “Rotting with their rights on”: Constitutional theory and clinical reality in drug refusal by psychiatric patients. The Bulletin of the American Academy of Psychiatry and the Law 7(3): 306–315.
Bahrapmour, T. 2004. Ex-Beatle’s oncologist to lose post at Staten Island Hospital. New York Times January 9 [On-line]. Available at http://query.nytimes.com/gst/fullpage.html?res=9A02E2DE1F31F93AA35752C0A9629C8B63&sec=&spon=&pagewanted=print. Accessed 24 Sep 2012.
Beauchamp, T.L., and J.F. Childress. 1979. Principles of biomedical ethics. New York: Oxford University Press.
Brainard, A.H., and H.C. Brislen. 2007. Viewpoint: Learning professionalism—A view from the trenches. Academic Medicine 82: 1010–1014.
Breen, K. 2002. Letter to the editor. The Lancet 359: 2042 [On-line]. Available at http://www.thelancet.com/journals/lancet/article/PIIS0140-6736(02)08809-8/fulltext. Accessed 24 Sep 2012.
Brody, H. 1992. The healer’s power. New Haven: Yale University Press.
Buchanan, A. 1996. Is there a medical profession in the house? In Conflicts of interest in clinical practice and research, ed. R.G. Spece, D.S. Shimm, and A. Buchanan, 105–136. New York: Oxford University Press.
Clouser, K.D. 1973. The sanctity of life: An analysis of a concept. Annals of Internal Medicine 78: 119–125.
Coulehan, J., and P.C. Williams. 2003. Conflicting professional values in medical education. Cambridge Quarterly of Health Care Ethics 12: 7–20.
Crabbe, N. 2007. Doctor: Execution not medical work. Gainesville Sun, February 20 [On-line]. Available at http://www.fadp.org/news/gs-20070220/. Accessed 16 Feb 2009.
Cruess, S.R., S. Johnston, and R.L. Cruess. 2002. Professionalism for medicine: Opportunities and obligations. The Medical Journal of Australia 177: 208–211.
Doris, J.M. 2002. Lack of character: Personality and moral behavior. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Dworkin, R. 1984. Rights as trumps. In Theories of rights, ed. J. Waldron, 153–167. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Eliot, T.S. n.d. The four quartets [On-line]. Available at http://www.coldbacon.com/poems/fq.html. Accessed 24 Sep 2012.
Engelhardt Jr., H.T. 1986. Foundations of bioethics. New York: Oxford University Press.
Erde, E.L. 1989. Studies in the explanation of issues in biomedical ethics: (II) On ‘on play[ing] god’ etc. The Journal of Medicine and Philosophy 16: 593–615.
Erde, E.L. 1996. Conflicts of interests in medicine: A philosophical and ethical morphology. In Conflicts of interest in clinical practice and research, ed. R.G. Spece, D.S. Shimm, and A. Buchanan, 12–41. New York: Oxford University Press.
Erde, E.L. 2008. Professionalism’s facets: Ambiguity, ambivalence and nostalgia. The Journal of Medicine and Philosophy 33: 6–26.
Glendon, M.A. 1991. Rights talk: The impoverishment of political discourse. New York: The Free Press.
Hafferty, F.W. 1998. Beyond curriculum reform: Confronting medicine’s hidden curriculum. Academic Medicine 73: 403–407.
Hafferty, F.W., and D. Levinson. 2008. Moving beyond nostalgia and motives. Perspectives in Biology and Medicine 51: 599–615.
Hemingway, E. 1922. The earnest liberals’ lament. In several collections (for example, Gerogiannis, N. (ed.). 1979. 88 poems. New York: Harcourt Brace Jovanovich, Inc. Available at http://books.google.com/books?id=Ic4nHr_6JXMC&pg=PA52&lpg=PA52&dq=ernest+hemingway+poems+monks+bite&source=bl&ots=J0wu8AqoIt&sig=zmdKilsTf5pICccg4DH7I18EDh8&hl=en&ei=−W2VSYqfPI-EtgeO05GhCw&sa=X&oi=book_result&resnum=1&ct=result). Accessed 24 Sep 2012.
Henig, R.M. 2005. At war with their bodies, they seek to sever limbs. New York Times, March 22 [On-line]. Available at http://www.nytimes.com/2005/03/22/health/psychology/22ampu.html?_r=1&scp=1&sq=seek+to+sever+limbs&st=nyt. Accessed 24 Sep 2012.
Hofstadter, D.R. 2007. I am a strange loop. New York: Basic Books.
Holmes, O.W. 1897. The path of the law. 10 Harvard Law Review 457. Available at http://www.constitution.org/lrev/owh/path_law.htm. Accessed 24 Sep 2012.
Johansen, J. 2002. The charter on medical professionalism: The new Hippocratic Oath? “Pregnant pause”—A blog. Available at http://www.pregnantpause.org/ethics/medprof.htm. Accessed 24 Sep 2012.
Jonsen, A.R., and A.E. Hellegers. 1976. Conceptual foundations for an ethics of medical care. In Ethics and health policy, ed. R.M. Veatch and R. Branson, 17–34. Cambridge, MA: Ballinger Publishing Company.
Kass, L. 1989. Neither love nor money: Why doctors must not kill. The Public Interest 94: 43–44.
Kuhn, T. 1962. The structure of scientific revolutions. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Levy, A.W. 1974. Philosophy as social expression. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Lundberg, G.D. 1983. Boxing should be banned in civilized countries. Journal of the American Medical Association 249: 250.
MacIntyre, A. 1981. After virtue. Notre Dame: University of Notre Dame Press.
Malone, M.E. 1993. Kuhn reconstructed: Incommensurability without relativism. Studies in History and Philosophy of Science 24: 69–93.
Martinez, R. 2005. A model for boundary dilemmas: Ethical decision making in the professional-patient relationship. Ethical and Human Sciences and Services 2: 43–61.
McCullough, L.B. 1998. John Gregory and the invention of professional medical ethics and the profession of medicine. Dordrecht: Kluwer Academic Publishers.
Medical Professionalism Project: ABIM Foundation. 2002. Medical professionalism in the new millennium: A physician charter. Annals of Internal Medicine 136: 243–246.
Metzinger, T. 2009. The ego tunnel: The science of the mind and the myth of the self. New York: Basic Books.
National Board of Medical Examiners (NBME). 2009. Assessment of professional behaviors [On-line]. Available at http://professionalbehaviors.nbme.org/index.html. Accessed 24 Sep 2012.
NJADHC. New Jersey Advance Directive for Health Care Act 26: H2-53 paragraph d. Available on line at: http://lis.njleg.state.nj.us/cgi-bin/om_isapi.dll?clientID=211591960&Depth=4&TD=WRAP&advquery=%22Advance%20Directive%20for%20health%20care%22&headingswithhits=on&infobase=statutes.nfo&rank=&record={A927}&softpage=Doc_Frame_Pg42&wordsaroundhits=2&x=50&y=16&zz=. Accessed 24 Sep 2012.
Novack, D.H., B.J. Detering, R. Arnold, L. Forrow, M. Ladinsky, and J.C. Pezzullo. 1989. Physicians’ attitudes toward using deception to resolve difficult ethical problems. Journal of the American Medical Association 261: 2980–2985.
Nozick, R. 1974. Anarchy, state and utopia. New York: Basic Books.
O’Reilly, K.B. 2009. Doctor quits prison job over execution. American Medical News [On-line]. Available at http://www.amaassn.org/amednews/2009/02/09/prsc0209.htm. Accessed 24 Sep 2012.
Pear, R. 2005. Panel seeks better disciplining of doctors. New York Times, January 24 [On-line]. Available at http://query.nytimes.com/gst/fullpage.html?res=9F07E6DA1339F936A35752C0A9639C8B63. Accessed 24 Sep 2012.
Peeno, L. 1996. Testimony before the US House of Representatives. May 30. Available at http://www.thenationalcoalition.org/drpeenotestimony.html. Accessed 24 Sep 2012.
Pellegrino, E.D. 1987. Altruism, self-interest, and medical ethics. Journal of the American Medical Association 258: 1939–1940.
Pellegrino, E.D. 1993. The metamorphosis of medical ethics: A 30 year perspective. Journal of the American Medical Association 269: 1158–1162.
Pianigiani G., and A. Cowell. 2012. Divers suspend underwater search of stricken Italian liner. New York Times, January 31 [On-line]. Available at http://www.nytimes.com/2012/02/01/world/europe/divers-suspend-underwater-search-of-costa-concordia-in-italy.html?scp=1&sq=costa%20concordia%20captain%20arrested&st=cse. Accessed 24 Sep 2012.
Public Citizen. 2007. Public citizen issues annual ranking of state medical boards [On-line]. Available at http://www.citizen.org/pressroom/release.cfm?ID=2450. Accessed 24 Sep 2012.
Relman, A.S. 1980. The new medical-industrial complex. The New England Journal of Medicine 303: 963–970.
Sammons, J.T. 1989. Why doctors should oppose boxing: An interdisciplinary history perspective. Journal of the American Medical Association 261: 1484–1485.
Savage, D.G. 2008. President Bush unveils conscience rule for health-care industry: Last-minute declaration lets providers refuse to participate in care. Chicago Tribune, December 19 [On-line]. Available at http://articles.chicagotribune.com/2008-12-19/news/0812180751_1_right-to-refuse-rule-includes-abortion-health-care-health-care. Accessed 24 Sep 2012.
Skloot, R. 2010. The immortal life of Henrietta Lacks. New York: Broadway Books.
Sox, H.C. 2002. Editor’s introduction to “medical professionalism in the new millennium: A physician charter”. Annals of Internal Medicine 136: 243.
Spece, R.G., D.S. Shimm, and A.E. Buchanan (eds.). 1996. Conflicts of interest in clinical practice and research. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Stewart, J.B. 1979. Blind eye: The terrifying story of a doctor who got away with murder, 1999. New York: Touchstone.
Tomycz, N.D. 2006. A profession selling out: Lamenting the paradigm shift in physician advertising. Journal of Medical Ethics 32: 26–28.
US Government. 2010. Overview EMTLA [On-line]. Available at https://www.cms.gov/EMTALA/. Accessed 24 Sep 2012.
Veatch, R.M. 1981. Theory of medical ethics. New York: Basic Books.
Veatch, R.M. 1995. Abandoning informed consent. The Hastings Center Report 25(2): 5–12.
Watkins, T., and N. Neergaard. 2009. Octuplets spur debate over ethics. By the Associated Press, Saturday January 31 [On-line]. Available at http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/28939439/. Accessed 24 Sep 2012.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Editor information
Editors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
Copyright information
© 2013 Springer Science+Business Media Dordrecht
About this chapter
Cite this chapter
Erde, E.L. (2013). Professionalism vs. Medical Ethics in the Current Era: A Battle of Giants?. In: Garrett, J., Jotterand, F., Ralston, D. (eds) The Development of Bioethics in the United States. Philosophy and Medicine, vol 115. Springer, Dordrecht. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-94-007-4011-2_11
Download citation
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/978-94-007-4011-2_11
Published:
Publisher Name: Springer, Dordrecht
Print ISBN: 978-94-007-4010-5
Online ISBN: 978-94-007-4011-2
eBook Packages: Humanities, Social Sciences and LawPhilosophy and Religion (R0)