Advertisement

The Special Court for Sierra Leone: ‘Crystallisation’ and Child Soldiers

  • Julie McBride
Chapter

Abstract

While it is the contention of the author that the crime of child soldier recruitment entered into existence in 1998 when the Rome Statute was drafted—as it was not until then that the crime obtained a clear mens rea and actus reus—the Special Court, in the Preliminary Motion in Prosecutor v Sam Hinga Norman, ruled that the crime had already ‘crystallised’ as a crime in international customary law. This issue of crystallisation had direct relevance for the question of individual criminal responsibility, and, in attempting to determine when the mens rea and actus reus of the crime were formulated, marks a critical moment in the development of the crime. It therefore also has implications for international criminal law more generally, as it concerns the precise moment when a treaty provision can be regarded as an international crime. This chapter also provides a background to the Sierra Leone civil war and the establishment of the Special Court, in particular the drafting of Article 4 of its Statute, providing for the war crime of child recruitment. It also assesses the approach of the Special Court towards the question of prosecuting child soldiers, and its treatment of child soldier witnesses.

Keywords

Security Council International Criminal Court Appeal Chamber Rome Statute Trial Chamber 
These keywords were added by machine and not by the authors. This process is experimental and the keywords may be updated as the learning algorithm improves.

References

  1. Amann D (2002) Calling children to account: the proposal for a juvenile justice chamber in the Special Court for Sierra Leone. Pepperdine Law Rev 29:167Google Scholar
  2. Bakker C (2010) Prosecuting international crimes against children: the Legal Framework. Innocenti Working Paper 2013, p. 6Google Scholar
  3. Bald SH (2003) Searching for a lost childhood: will the Special Court for Sierra Leone find justice for its children? Am Univ Int Law Rev 18:537Google Scholar
  4. Baxter RR (1970) Treaties and custom. Recueil des Cours de L’Academie de La Haye 129:27Google Scholar
  5. Berliner L, Barbieri (1984) The testimony of the child victim of sexual assault. J Soc Issues 40:125Google Scholar
  6. Bhuwanee K et al (2006) A review of the impact of the Cape Town principles on policy on the ground and on practice amongst child protection organisations (UNICEF and Justice Africa, Development Studies Institute, London School Of Economics, April 2006), p. 10Google Scholar
  7. Bright D (2000) Implementing the Lomé Peace Agreement, Conciliation Resources. http://www.c-r.org/our-work/accord/sierra-leone/implementing-lome.php. Accessed 28 March 2013
  8. Burchard C (2006) The Nuremberg trial and its impact on Germany. J Int Crim Justice 4:800Google Scholar
  9. Cassese A (2008) International criminal law. 2nd edn. Oxford University Press, OxfordGoogle Scholar
  10. Côté L (2005) Prosecuting child related crimes at the Special Court for Sierra Leone: a mid term assessment. UNICEF Innocenti Research Centre, expert discussion on transitional justice and childrenGoogle Scholar
  11. Crane DM (2005) Prosecuting children in times of conflict: the West African experience. Human Rights Brief 15:11Google Scholar
  12. Custer M (2005) Punishing child soldiers: the Special Court for Sierra Leone and the lessons to be learned from the United States’ Juvenile justice system. Temple Int Comp Law J 19:449Google Scholar
  13. Dougherty BK (2004) Searching for answers: Sierra Leone’s truth and reconciliation. Afr Stud Q 8:39Google Scholar
  14. Du Plessis M (2004) Children under international criminal Law. Afr Secur Rev 13:103Google Scholar
  15. Ellison L (2001) The adversarial process and the vulnerable witness. Oxford University Press, OxfordGoogle Scholar
  16. Francis DJ (2005) Civil Militia: Africa’s intractable security menace? Ashgate Publishing, LondonGoogle Scholar
  17. Gallant K (2009) The principle of legality in international and comparative criminal law. Cambridge University Press, CambridgeGoogle Scholar
  18. Grossman N (2007) Rehabilitation or revenge: prosecuting child soldiers for human rights violations. Georgetown J Int Law 38:323Google Scholar
  19. Guibert N, Blumenstock T (2007) The first judgement of the Special Court for Sierra Leone: a missed opportunity? Law Pract Int Courts Tribunals 6:367Google Scholar
  20. Happold M (2005) International humanitarian law, war criminality and child recruitment. Leiden J Int Law 18:283. http://www.justiceafrica.org/wp-content/uploads/2006/10/Cape_Town_Principles_Report.pdf. Accessed 16 March 2013Google Scholar
  21. Keiseng PR (2002) Is the Sierra Leonean Amnesty Law compatible with international law? menschenrechtsmagazin 3:5. http://opus.kobvde/ubp/volltexte/2010/4419/html/mrm13-1.htm. Accessed 28 March 2013Google Scholar
  22. IRIN (2011) Analysis: should child soldiers be prosecuted for their crimes? www.irinnews.org/Report/93900/Analysis-Should-child-soldiers-be-prosecuted-for-their-crimes. Accessed 10 April 2013
  23. Milanovic M (2010) Was Nuremberg a violation of the principle of legality? EJIL Talk. www.ejiltalk.org/was-nuremberg-a-violation-of-the-principle-of-legality. Accessed 16 March 2013
  24. Monforte TM (2007) Razing child soldiers. J Comp Poetics 27:169Google Scholar
  25. Novicki MA (2000) Saving a war’s traumatised children—Sierra Leone camps try to rehabilitate child victims And soldiers. Afr Recovery 14:10Google Scholar
  26. Novogrodsky N, Goldstein M (2006) Small steps: prosecuting the recruitment of child soldiers—the case of Sam Hinga Norman. Interights Bull 15:148Google Scholar
  27. Novogrodsky NB (2005) Litigating child recruitment before the Special Court for Sierra Leone. San Diego Int Law J 7:421Google Scholar
  28. Parmar S et al (2009) Children and transitional justice: truth-telling, accountability, and reconciliation. Harvard University Press, CambridgeGoogle Scholar
  29. Peters K, Richards P (1998a) Why we fight: voices of youth combatants in Sierra Leone. J Int Afr Inst 68:183Google Scholar
  30. Peters K, Richards P (1998b) Fighting with open eyes: youth combatants talking about war in Sierra Leone. In: Bracken P, Petty C (eds) Rethinking the Trauma of war. Free Association Books, LondonGoogle Scholar
  31. Röling BVA, Rüter CF (eds) (1977) The Tokyo Judgment. Amsterdam University Press, AmsterdamGoogle Scholar
  32. Romero JA (2004) The Special Court for Sierra Leone and the juvenile soldier dilemma. Northwestern University Journal of International. Hum Rights 8:2Google Scholar
  33. Rosen DM (2010) The legal conundrum of child soldiers. Chicago J Int Law 25:105Google Scholar
  34. Sands P (ed) (2003) From Nuremberg to The Hague: the future of international criminal justice. Cambridge University Press, CambridgeGoogle Scholar
  35. Sanin K, Stirnemann A (2006) Child witnesses at the Special Court for Sierra Leone. War Crimes Studies Center, University of California, Berkeley. http://socrates.berkeley.edu/~warcrime/documents/ChildWitnessReport_000.pdf. Accessed 21 March 2013
  36. Schabas W (2001) An introduction to the International Criminal Court. Cambridge University Press, CambridgeGoogle Scholar
  37. Shanker T (2007) Sexual violence. In: Gutman R et al (eds). Crimes of War. W.W. Norton & Company, New YorkGoogle Scholar
  38. Sivakumara S (2010) War crimes before the Special Court for Sierra Leone: child soldiers, hostages, peacekeepers and collective punishments. J Int Crim Justice 8:1009Google Scholar
  39. Smith A (2004) Child recruitment and the special court for Sierra Leone. J Int Crim Justice 2:1141Google Scholar
  40. Spiga V (2010) Indirect victims’ participation in the Lubanga trial. J Int Crim Justice 8:1Google Scholar
  41. Troxel N et al (2009) Child witnesses in criminal court. In: Goodman GS et al (eds) Child victims, child offenders: psychology and the law. Guilford Press, New YorkGoogle Scholar
  42. Villanueva Sainz-Pardo P (2008) Is child recruitment as a war crime part of customary international law? Int J Hum Rights 12:555Google Scholar
  43. Villiger ME (1977) Customary international law and treaties, 2nd edn. Springer, New YorkGoogle Scholar
  44. Werle G (2005) Principles of international criminal law. T.M.C Asser Press, The HagueGoogle Scholar
  45. Wharton S (2011) The evolution of international criminal law: prosecuting ‘New’ crimes before the Court for Sierra Leone. Int Crim Law Rev 11:217Google Scholar

Copyright information

© T. M. C. Asser press, The Hague, The Netherlands, and the author 2014

Authors and Affiliations

  1. 1.AmsterdamThe Netherlands

Personalised recommendations