The Principle of Fairness in the Lex Sportiva of CAS Awards and Beyond

  • James A. R. Nafziger
Chapter
Part of the ASSER International Sports Law Series book series (ASSER)

Abstract

The issues discussed in this contribution might suggest that the principle of fairness is still too unsettled to be effective as a core principle of international sports law. However, on the basis of accepted attributes of fairness = impartiality, equity, good faith, coherence, and so on—the principle can be readily adapted to a broad range of sports and sports-related issues. Fairness should be fundamental in the future of sports and the growth of a creditable regime of international sports law. The challenge is to take the principle seriously and further develop it within a definitional and institutional framework that already exists.

Keywords

Strict Liability International Olympic Committee Major League Baseball Arbitral Tribunal Arbitral Award 
These keywords were added by machine and not by the authors. This process is experimental and the keywords may be updated as the learning algorithm improves.

References

  1. 2009 Annual Survey: Recent Developments in Sports Law (2010) 20 Marq Sports L Rev, p 497Google Scholar
  2. Berlin P (2009) Irish blood up after the French hand ball. Int Herald Trib (20 Nov)Google Scholar
  3. Black’s Law Dictionary (2004) 8th ednGoogle Scholar
  4. Blackshaw I (2009) The rules of natural justice: what are they and why are they important in sports disciplinary cases? Int Sports Law J 2009/1–2Google Scholar
  5. Blackshaw I, Siekmann RCR, Soek J (eds) (2006) The court of arbitration for sport 1984–2004Google Scholar
  6. Boylan JF (2008) The XY games. New York Times, New York (3 Aug)Google Scholar
  7. Burns JF (2009) Renault team escapes expulsion for fixing race. New York Times, New York (22 Sept)Google Scholar
  8. Despite Uproar, FIFA Rejects Irish Call for Replay (2009) Int Herald Trib Nov, pp 21–22Google Scholar
  9. Dittmore SW et al. (2009) Examining fairness perceptions of financial allocation in U.S. Olympic sportGoogle Scholar
  10. Drape J, Thomas K (2010) As athletic directors compete, big money flows to all sports. New York Times, New York (3 Sept)Google Scholar
  11. Dreger A (2009a) Seeking simple rules in complex gender realities. New York Times, New York (25 Oct)Google Scholar
  12. Dreger A (2009b) Swifter, higher, stronger? Science adds a variable. New York Times, New York (13 Sept)Google Scholar
  13. Espinoza J (2010) Formula 1 is racing to bridge a gap with fans. Asian Wall St J (24–26 Sept)Google Scholar
  14. Franck TM (1995) Fairness in international law and institutionsGoogle Scholar
  15. Gardiner S et al. (2001) Sports law, 2nd ednGoogle Scholar
  16. Goldstein RR (2007) An American in Paris: the legal framework of international sport and the implications of the world anti-doping code on [sic] accused athletes. 7 Va. Sports Ent L J, p 149Google Scholar
  17. Gymnast Only 13, Xinhua Said in ’07 (2008) Int Herald Trib, 16–17 AugGoogle Scholar
  18. Haas U (2007) Die Vereinbarung von “Rechtsregeln” in Berufungs – Schiedsverfahren vor dem Court of Arbitration for Sport, Causa Sport, 3/2007Google Scholar
  19. Halt J (2009) Where is the privacy in WADA’s “whereabouts” rule? 20 Marq Sports L Rev, p 267Google Scholar
  20. Hawkey I (2009) Fallen idol. The Sunday Times, 22 NovGoogle Scholar
  21. Hill D (2008) The fix: soccer and organized crimeGoogle Scholar
  22. Hill D (2009) The usual suspects: Fixers’ actions and FIFA’s inaction. New York Times, New York (6 Dec)Google Scholar
  23. Hughes R (2009) Soccer found riddled with corruption in Europe. Int Herald Trib, 21–22 NovGoogle Scholar
  24. International Olympic Committee (2004) Evaluation criteria for sports and disciplines, 11 AugGoogle Scholar
  25. International Olympic Committee (2010) Olympic movement directory, passimGoogle Scholar
  26. Klein JZ (2010) FIFA may add extra officials. New York Times, New York (29 June)Google Scholar
  27. Kolev B (2008) Lex Sportiva and Lex Mercatoria. Int Sports L J, pp 1–2Google Scholar
  28. Latty F (2007) La lex sportiva: Recherche sur Le Droit TransnationalGoogle Scholar
  29. Leicester J (2009) IOC sets up system to watch for illegal betting. Pittsburgh Post-Gazette (4 Oct)Google Scholar
  30. Mackey R (2009) South Africa says gender controversy is over. The Lede (New York Times News Blog), New York (19 Nov)Google Scholar
  31. Macur J (2008) IOC is seeking proof of Chinese gymnasts’ ages. New York Times, New York (23 Aug)Google Scholar
  32. Macur J (2009) I.O.C. may eliminate Phinney’s best event. New York Times, New York (10 Dec)Google Scholar
  33. Macur J (2010) Medal of underage Chinese gymnast revoked. New York Times, New York (27 Feb, at Sports)Google Scholar
  34. Maynard M (2010) Good sportsmanship and a lot of good will. New York Times, New York (4 June)Google Scholar
  35. McIlvanney H (2009) Video refs can catch the cheats, Sunday Times (22 Nov)Google Scholar
  36. McLaren RH (2001) The court of arbitration for sport: an independent arena for the world’s sports disputes. 35 Val. U. L. Rev, p 379Google Scholar
  37. McLaren RH (2010) Twenty-five years of the court of arbitration for sport: a look in the rear-view mirror. 20 Marq Sports L Rev, p 305Google Scholar
  38. Nafziger JAR (1992) International sports law: A replay of characteristics and trends. 86 Am J Int L, p 489Google Scholar
  39. Nafziger JAR (2004) International sports law, 2nd ednGoogle Scholar
  40. Nafziger JAR (2005) Circumstantial evidence of doping: BALCO and beyond. 16 Marq Sports L Rev, p 45Google Scholar
  41. Nafziger JAR (2006) The future of international sports law. 42 Willamette L Rev, p 861Google Scholar
  42. Nafziger JAR, Wei L (1998) China’s sports law. Am J Comp L 46:453Google Scholar
  43. Record-setting Swimsuits Fail to Win FINA’s Approval (2009) Global times (May 21)Google Scholar
  44. Referee System Faces Changes in 2014 (2010) China daily (10–11 July)Google Scholar
  45. Schwarz A (2010) Replay gets another look after a gaffe seen by all. New York Times, New York (4 June)Google Scholar
  46. Silance L (1998) Les Sports et le DroitGoogle Scholar
  47. Smith R (2009) Premier league must not be complacent on match-fixing, expert warns, Sunday Telegraph (22 Nov)Google Scholar
  48. Spurgeon B (2010) Closing of formula one season is race around the world. New York Times, New York (26 Sept)Google Scholar
  49. Vecsey G (2008) A hint of doubt in every shiny medal. New York Times, New York (23 Aug)Google Scholar
  50. Vecsey G (2010) Worst call ever? Sure. Kill the umpires? Never. New York Times, New YorkGoogle Scholar
  51. Weatherill S (2010) Fairness, openness and the specific nature of sport: does the lisbon treaty change EU sports law?. In: Paper presented at the Tangerang conference, union of European football associations (UEFA) club licensing and financial fair play regulationsGoogle Scholar
  52. World Anti-Doping Agency (2010) World anti-doping codeGoogle Scholar
  53. Zinser L (2009) Jones’s gold in 100 meters won’t go to Greek sprinter. N.Y. Times (10 Dec)Google Scholar

Copyright information

© T.M.C. ASSER PRESS, The Hague, The Netherlands, and the authors/editors  2012

Authors and Affiliations

  • James A. R. Nafziger
    • 1
  1. 1.SalemUSA

Personalised recommendations