Epistemic Complexity from an Objective Bayesian Perspective
Evidence can be complex in various ways: e.g., it may exhibit structural complexity, containing information about causal, hierarchical or logical structure as well as empirical data, or it may exhibit combinatorial complexity, containing a complex combination of kinds of information. This paper examines evidential complexity from the point of view of Bayesian epistemology, asking: how should complex evidence impact on an agent’s degrees of belief? The paper presents a high-level overview of an objective Bayesian answer: it presents the objective Bayesian norms concerning the relation between evidence and degrees of belief, and goes on to show how evidence of causal, hierarchical and logical structure lead to natural constraints on degrees of belief. The objective Bayesian network formalism is presented, and it is shown how this formalism can be used to handle both kinds of evidential complexity – structural complexity combinatorial complexity.
This research was carried out as a part of the project progicnet: Probabilistic logic and probabilistic networks, supported by the Leverhulme Trust.
- Fridlyand J, Snijders A, Ylstra B, Li H, Olshen A, Segraves R, Dairkee S, Tokuyasu T, Ljung B, Jain A, McLennan J, Ziegler J, Chin K, Devries S, Feiler H, Gray J, Waldman F, Pinkel D, Albertson D (2006) Breast tumor copy number aberration phenotypes and genomic instability. BMC Cancer 6:96CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Haenni R, Romeijn J-W, Wheeler G, Williamson J (2010) Probabilistic logic and probabilistic networks. SpringerGoogle Scholar
- Howson C, Urbach P (1989) Scientific reasoning: The Bayesian approach, 2nd edn. Open Court, Chicago, ILGoogle Scholar
- Nagl S, Williams M, Williamson J (2008) Objective Bayesian nets for systems modelling and prognosis in breast cancer. In: Holmes D, Jain L, (eds) Innovations in Bayesian networks: Theory and applications. Springer, BerlinGoogle Scholar
- Paris JB (1994) The uncertain reasoner’s companion. Cambridge University Press, CambridgeGoogle Scholar
- Williamson J (2005) Bayesian nets and causality: Philosophical and computational foundations. Oxford University Press, OxfordGoogle Scholar
- Williamson J (2007) Motivating objective Bayesianism: From empirical constraints to objective probabilities. In: Harper WL, Wheeler GR (eds) Probability and inference: Essays in honour of Henry E. Kyburg Jr., College Publications, London, 151–179Google Scholar
- Williamson J (2008) Objective Bayesianism, Bayesian conditionalisation and voluntarism Synthese DOI 10.1007/s11229-009-9515-7Google Scholar