Positive and Negative Signals: A Conceptual History

  • G. E. Berrios
Conference paper

Abstract

The terms “positive” and “negative”, used to categorize the symptoms of schizophrenia, have “burst in the horizon as a recurrent comet” (Zubin 1985). More popular, perhaps, amongst researchers than clinicians, they have thrived almost beyond the reach of evaluation. Unimpressed by fashion, the conceptual historian must ask:
  1. 1.

    What do these terms contribute (that others do not) to the understanding of the symptoms of schizophrenia? In the past, it must be remembered, other (less successful) pairs of words have been used for the same purpose: primary versus secondary, first rank versus second rank, florid versus deficit, active versus passive, etc.

     
  2. 2.

    What would be lost if the terms “positive” and “negative” were replaced, say, by some meaningless initials?

     
  3. 3.

    Are the categories “positive” and “negative” symptom-specific to schizophrenia? Would understanding of other mental disorders be improved by their use? If so, could this extra-understanding be specified? and

     
  4. 4.

    Is their popularity due only to scientific reasons? In this regard, scientific or “internal” reasons (i.e. those pertaining to the facts of observation), must be distinguished from “external factors” (extra-scientific, non-cognitive, social, etc.) which reflect the power structures controlling fashion in the psychiatric community. Terms may become fashionable not because they add anything to knowledge, but because they are favoured by forceful individuals or by “invisible Colleges” controlling funds, research and publications (Blashfield 1982; Latour 1988).

     

Keywords

Depression Dementia Schizophrenia Gall Trench 

Preview

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

References

  1. Albernhe T and Roux J (1990) La pensée de Henri Ey. Scripta, ParisGoogle Scholar
  2. Angel RW (1961) Jackson, Freud and Sherrington on the relation of brain and mind. Am J Psychiatry 118:193–197PubMedGoogle Scholar
  3. Anguera P (1984) Un psychiatre de légende: G G de Clérambault. Perspect Psychiatr 22:142–147Google Scholar
  4. Anguera P (1989) G G de Clérambault, L’Infirmerie spéciale et al psychose hallucinatoire chronique. In: Grivois H (ed) La Psychose hallucinatoire chronique. Masson, Paris, pp. 55–58Google Scholar
  5. Bailey P (1927) The syndrome of mental automatism and its role in the formation of the chronic systematized psychosis. A Review. J Nerv Ment Dis 65:345–352CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  6. Baillarger J (1848) De l’influence de l’état intermediaire a la veille et au sommeil sur la production et la marche des hallucinations. Mem Acad R Med 12:476–516Google Scholar
  7. Balan B (1989) Les fondements psychologiques de la notion d’automatisme mental chez John Hughlings Jackson. Inf Psychiatr 69:609–619Google Scholar
  8. Baldwin JM (1901) Dictionary of philosphy and psychology. Churchill, LondonGoogle Scholar
  9. Baruk H (1967) La psychiatrie française de Pinel à nos jours. Presses Universitaires de France, ParisGoogle Scholar
  10. Benrubi J (1933) Les sources et les courants de la philosophie contemporaine en France, vol 1. Alcan, ParisGoogle Scholar
  11. Berrios GE (1977) Henry Ey, Jackson, et les idées obsédantes. Evol Psychiatr 42: 685–699Google Scholar
  12. Berrios GE (1981) Stupor revisited. Compr Psychiatry 22:466–478PubMedCrossRefGoogle Scholar
  13. Berrios GE (1984) Descriptive psychopathology: conceptual and historical aspects. Psychol Med 14:303–313PubMedCrossRefGoogle Scholar
  14. Berrios GE (1985) Positive and negative symptoms and Jackson. Arch Gen Psychiatry 42:95– 97PubMedCrossRefGoogle Scholar
  15. Berrios GE (1987) Historical aspects of the psychoses: 19th century issues. Br Med Bull 43:484–498PubMedGoogle Scholar
  16. Berrios GE (1988) Historical background to abnormal psychology. In: Miller E, Cooper PJ (eds) Adult abnormal psychology, Livingstone, Edinburgh, pp. 26–51Google Scholar
  17. Blashfield R, Feighner K et al. (1982) Invisible colleges, and the Matthew effect. Schizophr Bull 8:1–12PubMedGoogle Scholar
  18. Brau JL (1974) J Moreau (de Tours) ou le drogue qui faillit entrer a l’institut. In: Moreau de Tours (ed) Du hachisch et de l’aliénation mental. Kesselring, ParisGoogle Scholar
  19. Brousseau A (1934) Nécrologie. G. G. de Clérambault. Encephale 29:738–739Google Scholar
  20. Brown-Séquard CE (1889) Inhibition. In: Dechambre A, Lereboullet L (eds) Dictionnaire encyclopédique des sciences médicales, vol 52. Masson, Paris, pp. 1–19Google Scholar
  21. Carlet G (1878) Fonction. In: Dechambre A, Lereboullet L (eds) Dictionnaire encyclopédique des sciencies médicales, vol 34. Masson, Paris, pp. 365–368Google Scholar
  22. Clark MJ (1983) A plastic power ministering to organization: interpretations of the mind-body relationship in late nineteenth-century British Psychiatry. Psychol Med 13:487–497PubMedCrossRefGoogle Scholar
  23. Cleparède E (1916) Théodule Ribot. Arch Psychol 16:194–96Google Scholar
  24. Cooter R (1984) The cultural meaning of popular science. Phrenology and the organization of consent in nineteenth century Britain. Cambridge University Press, CambridgeGoogle Scholar
  25. Coseriu E (1978) Sincronía, diacronía e historia. Gredos, MadridGoogle Scholar
  26. Dallenbach KM (1915) The history and derivation of the word ‘function’ as a systematic term in psychology. Am J Psychol 26:473–484CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  27. De Clérambault GG (1987) Oeuvres psychiatriques. Frénésie, ParisGoogle Scholar
  28. Delay J (1942) Les dissolutions de la mémoire. Presses Universitaires de France, ParisGoogle Scholar
  29. Delay J (1953) Le Jacksonisme et l’oeuvre de Ribot. In: Delay J (ed) Études de psychologie medicale. Presses Universitaires de France, Paris, pp. 83–108Google Scholar
  30. Denton GB (1921) Early psychological theories of Herbert Spencer. Am J Psychol 32:5–15CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  31. Dewhurst K (1982) Hughlings Jackson on psychiatry. Sandford, OxfordGoogle Scholar
  32. Ducrot O, Todorov T (1972) Dictionnaire encyclopédique des sciences du langage. Seuil, ParisGoogle Scholar
  33. Edelheit H (1976) Complementarity as a rule in psychological research. Int J Psychoanal 57:23–29PubMedGoogle Scholar
  34. Ellenberger H (1970) The discovery of the unconscious. The history and evolution of dynamic psychiatry. Lane, LondonGoogle Scholar
  35. Engelhardt HT (1975) JH Jackson and the mind-body relation. Bull Hist Med 49:137–151PubMedGoogle Scholar
  36. Ey H (1962) Hughlings Jackson’s principles and the organo-dynamic concept of psychiatry. Psychiatry 118: 673–682Google Scholar
  37. Ey H (1952) Une théorie mécaniciste. La doctrine de G. de Clérambault. Études Psychiatriques, vol 1. Desclée de Brouwer, Paris, pp. 83–102Google Scholar
  38. Ey H (1952a) Le rêve ‘fait primordial’ de la psychopathologie. Etud Psychiatr 1:187–277Google Scholar
  39. Ey H (1975) Des idées de Jackson à un modèle organodynamique en psychiatrie. Privately published, ParisGoogle Scholar
  40. Ey H, Rouart J (1938) Essai d’application des principes de Jackson à une conception dynamique de la neuro-psychiatrie. Doin, ParisGoogle Scholar
  41. Evans P (1972) Henri Ey’s concepts of the organization of consciousness and its disorganization: an extension of Jacksonian theory. Brain 95:413–440PubMedCrossRefGoogle Scholar
  42. Fenwick P (1990) Automatism. In: Bluglass R, Bowden P (eds) Principles and practice of forensic psychiatry. Livingstone, Edinburgh, pp. 271–290Google Scholar
  43. Fodor JA (1983) The modularity of mind. MIT Press, CambridgeGoogle Scholar
  44. Fournet M (1867) Expose d’un doctrine organo-psychique de la folie. Ann Med Psychol (Paris) 10:296–315Google Scholar
  45. Garcia C (1987) Die Schichtenregel als Grundsatz der Psychopathologie. Nervenarzt 58:589–594PubMedGoogle Scholar
  46. Gasser J (1988) La notion de mémoire organique dans l’oeuvre de T. Ribot. Hist Philos Life Sci 10:293–313PubMedGoogle Scholar
  47. Gibbons RD, Lewine RRJ, Davis JM, et al. (1985) An empirical test of a Kraepelinian vs Bleulerian view of negative symptoms. Schizophr Bull 11:390–395PubMedGoogle Scholar
  48. Goudge TA (1973) Evolutionism. In Wiener PP (ed) Dictionary of the History of Ideas, vol 2, New York, Scribner’s sons, pp. 174–189Google Scholar
  49. Gourceix A (1989) La notion d’automatisme psychologique d’Aristo te à Janet. Ann Med Psychol 147: 944–945Google Scholar
  50. Greimas AJ, Courts J (1979) Sémiotique. Dictionnaire raisonné de la théorie du language. Hachette, ParisGoogle Scholar
  51. Grinker RR (1939) A comparison of psychological ‘repression’ and neurological ‘inhibition’. J Nerv Ment Dis 89: 765–781CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  52. Guiraud P (1950) Psychiatrie générale. Le François, ParisGoogle Scholar
  53. Hecaen H, Lanteri-Laura G (1978) Evolution des connaissances et des doctrines sur les localisations cérébrales. Desclée de Brouwer, ParisGoogle Scholar
  54. Herrick CL (1901) Inhibition. In: Baldwin JM (ed) Dictionary of philosophy and psychology, voll. Churchill, London, pp. 547–548Google Scholar
  55. Iager AC, Kirsch DG, Wyatt RJ (1985) A negative symptom rating scale. Psychiatr Res 16:27–36CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  56. Jackson JH (1931) Selected writings of J. H. Jackson. 2 vols. Hodder and Stoughton, LondonGoogle Scholar
  57. Janet P (1889) L’Automatisme psychologique. Alcan, ParisGoogle Scholar
  58. Kennard C, Swash M (eds) (1989) Hierarchies in neurology. A reappraisal of a Jacksonian concept. Springer, Berlin Heidelberg New Yord TokyoGoogle Scholar
  59. Koerner EFK (1982) Ferdinand de Saussure. Génesis y evolución de su pensamiento en el marco de la linguística occidental. Gredos, MadridGoogle Scholar
  60. Lanteri-Laura G (1966) Les rapports de la linguistique à la psychiatrie contemporaine. Masson, ParisGoogle Scholar
  61. Latour B (1988) The pasteurization of France. Harvard University Press, CambridgeGoogle Scholar
  62. Levin M (1960) The mind-brain problem and Hughlings Jackson’s doctrine of concomitance. Am J Psychiatr 116: 718–722PubMedGoogle Scholar
  63. López Piñero JM (1973) John Hughlings Jackson (1835–1911) Evolucionismo y neurología. Editorial Moneda y Crédito, MadridGoogle Scholar
  64. Malmberg B (1986) Análisis del lenguaje en el siglo XX. Gredos, MadridGoogle Scholar
  65. Marshall J (1984) Multiple perspectives on modularity. Cognition 17:209–242PubMedCrossRefGoogle Scholar
  66. Maurel H (1989) Approche historique de la notion d’automatisme en psychiatrie. Ann Med Psychol 147:946–950Google Scholar
  67. Mayne RG (1860) An expository lexicon of the terms, ancient and modern, in medical and general science. Churchill, LondonGoogle Scholar
  68. Mayr E (1982) The growth of biological thought. Harvard University Press, CambridgeGoogle Scholar
  69. McPherson J (1889) On the dissolution of the functions of the nervous system in insanity, with a suggestion for a new basis of classification. Am J Insanity 45:387–394Google Scholar
  70. Monro H (1851) Remarks on insanity: its nature and treatment. Churchill, LondonGoogle Scholar
  71. Mourgue R (1931) L’oeuvre et la personnalité du Professeur Constantin Von Monakow (1835-1930). Encephale 26:417–428Google Scholar
  72. Nayrac P (1974) Mental automatism. In: Hirsch SR, Shepherd M (eds) Themes and variations in European Psychiatry. Wright, Bristol, pp. 405–429Google Scholar
  73. Oldenquist A (1967) John Fiske. In: Edwards P (ed) Encyclopedia of philosphy, vol 3. Macmillan, London, pp. 204–205Google Scholar
  74. Paulus J (1941) Le problème de l’hallucination et l’évolution de la psychologie d’Esquirol à Pierre Janet. Les Belles Lettres, ParisGoogle Scholar
  75. Pichot P (1984) A century of psychiatry. Dacosta, ParisGoogle Scholar
  76. Porot A (1975) Manuel alphabétique de psychiatrie. Presses Universitaires de France, ParisGoogle Scholar
  77. Prince M (1891) Hughlings-Jackson on the connection between the mind and the brain. Brain 14:250–269CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  78. Quain R (1894) A dictionary of medicine. 2 vols. Longmans and Green, LondonGoogle Scholar
  79. Ravaisson F (1984) Rapport sur la philosophie en France au dix-neuvième siècle. Fayard, ParisGoogle Scholar
  80. Reynolds JR (1896) Essays and addresses. Macmillan, LondonGoogle Scholar
  81. Ribot T (1882) Diseases of memory. An essay in the positive psychology. Kegan Paul, Trench, LondonCrossRefGoogle Scholar
  82. Richards RJ (1987) Darwin and the emergence of evolutionary theories of mind and behaviour. University of Chicago Press, ChicagoGoogle Scholar
  83. Riese W (1942) The principle of integration. J Nerv Ment Dis 96:296–312CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  84. Riese W (1943) The principle of evolution of nervous function. J Nerv Ment Dis 98:255–266CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  85. Riese W (1944) The principle of compensation of nervous function. J Nerv Ment Dis 100:263–274CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  86. Riese W (1954) Hughlings Jackson’s doctrine of consciousness. Sources, versions and elaborations. J Nerv Ment Dis 120:331–337Google Scholar
  87. Riese W (1955) Hughlings Jackson’s doctrine of aphasia and its significance today. J Nerv Ment Dis 122:1–13PubMedCrossRefGoogle Scholar
  88. Riese W (1965) The sources of Hughlings Jackson’s view on aphasia. Brain 88:811–822PubMedCrossRefGoogle Scholar
  89. Rosen WG, Mohs RC, Johns CA, et al. (1984) Positive and negative symptoms in schizophrenia. Psychiatr Res 13:277–284CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  90. Rouart J, Ey E (1938) Essai d’application des principles de Jackson a une conception dynamique de la neuropsychiatrie. Doin, ParisGoogle Scholar
  91. Rouart J (1950) Janet et Jackson. Evol Psychiatr 25:485–501Google Scholar
  92. Ruckmich CA (1913) The use of the term function in English textbooks of psychology. Am J Psychol 24:99–123CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  93. Saussure F de (1945) Curso de linguistica general (translation of the 1916 edition by C Bally and A Sechehaye by A Alonso). Losada, Buenos AiresGoogle Scholar
  94. Savage G (1917) Dr Hughlings Jackson on mental disorders. J Ment Sci 63:315–328Google Scholar
  95. Segal JH (1989) Erotomania revisited: from Kraepelin to DSM-III-R. Am J Psychiatr 146:1261–1266PubMedGoogle Scholar
  96. Shallice T (1988) From neuropsychology to mental structure. Cambridge University Press, CambridgeCrossRefGoogle Scholar
  97. Smith CUM (1982) Evolution and the problem of mind: part II. John Hughlings Jackson. J Hist Biol 15:241–262PubMedCrossRefGoogle Scholar
  98. Smokier HE (1967) WK Clifford. In: Edwards P (ed) The encyclopedia of philosophy, vol 2. Macmillan, London, pp. 123–125Google Scholar
  99. Sommers AA (1985) Negative symptoms: conceptual and methodological problems. Schizophr Bull 11:364–379PubMedGoogle Scholar
  100. Soubrier JP, Gourevitch M (1984) Recherches aux archives de la préfecture de police sur les origins de l’infirmerie spéciale. Perspect Psychiatr 22:129–136Google Scholar
  101. Spencer H (1904a) An autobiography. 2 vols. Williams and Norgate, LondonGoogle Scholar
  102. Spencer H (1904b) First Principles. Williams and Norgate, LondonGoogle Scholar
  103. Stengel E (1963) Hughlings Jackson’s influence in psychiatry. Br J Psychiatr 109:348–355CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  104. Strauss JS, Carpenter WT, Bartko JJ (1974) Part III. Speculations on the processes that underlie schizophrenic symptoms and signs. Schizophr Bull 1:61–69Google Scholar
  105. Strauss JS (1885) Negative symptoms: future developments of the concept. Schizophr Bull 11:457–460Google Scholar
  106. Taine H (1901) Les philosophes classiques du XIXe siècle en France. Hachette, ParisGoogle Scholar
  107. Taylor J (1925) Biographical memoir. In: Jackson JH (ed) Neurological fragments. Oxford University Press, London, pp. 1–26Google Scholar
  108. Trimble M (1982) Functional diseases. Br Med J 285:1768–1770CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  109. Tuke DH (1882) Chapters in the history of the insane on the British Isles. Kegan Paul, Trench, LondonGoogle Scholar
  110. Von Monakow C, Mourgue R (1928) Introduction biologique à l’étude de la neurologie et de la psychopathologie. Alcan, ParisGoogle Scholar
  111. Walker N (1968) Crime and insanity in England. I. A historical perspective. University Press, EdinburghGoogle Scholar
  112. Walser HH (1974) Über Theorien des Gedächtnisses in den letzten Dezenninen des 19. Jahrhunderts und ihre Bedeutung für die Entstehung der Psychoanalyse. In: Proceedings of the 23th International Congress of the History of Medicine, vol 2. Wellcome Institute of the History of Medicine, London, pp. 1227–1232Google Scholar
  113. Yakovlev PI (1970) Constantin Von Monakow. In: Haymaker W, Schiller F (eds) The founders of neurology. Thomas, Springfield, pp. 484–488Google Scholar
  114. Young RM (1970) Mind, Brain and Adaptation in the nineteenth century. Clarendon, OxfordGoogle Scholar
  115. Zubin J (1985) Negative symptoms: are they indigenous to schizophrenia? Schizophr Bull 11:461–469PubMedGoogle Scholar

Copyright information

© Springer-Verlag Berlin Heidelberg 1991

Authors and Affiliations

  • G. E. Berrios
    • 1
  1. 1.Department of PsychiatryUniversity of Cambridge, Addenbrooke’s Hospital (Level 4)CambridgeUK

Personalised recommendations