Medical Risk and Benefit in Renal Donors: The Use of Living Donation Reconsidered

  • P. Michielsen

Abstract

Opinions are divided on the ethical acceptability of using living kidney donors. Everybody will, however, agree on the absolute necessity of a free decision of the donor after complete and objective information. In this short survey, we will first examine the difficulties in avoiding coercion and the unreliability of the data, on the basis of which objective information of the donor is supposed to be given. We will then critically review the alleged advantages of living donor versus cadaver kidney transplantation.

Keywords

Phosphorus Hepatitis Depression Albumin Europe 

Preview

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

References

  1. Bachman U, Biava C, Amend W, Feduska N, Melzer J, Salvatierra O, Vincenti F (1986) The clinical course of IgA nephropathy and Henoch-Schönlein purpura following renal transplantation. Transplantation 42: 511–515.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  2. Berger J, Noël LH, Nabarra B (1984) Recurrence of mesangial IgA nephropathy after renal transplantation. Contrib Nephrol 40: 195–197.Google Scholar
  3. Bertolatus JA, Friedlander MA, Scheidt C, Hunsicker LG (1985) Urinary albumin excretion after donor nephrectomy. Am J Kidney Dis 5: 165–169.Google Scholar
  4. Bonomini V, Gozzetti G (1990) Is living donation still justifiable? Nephrol Dial Transplant 5: 407–409.Google Scholar
  5. Canton F, Dubernard JM, Gelet A, Codas H, Martin X, Kamel G, Devonec M, Henriet M, Chabrol B, Mongin-Long D (1985) Surgical complications of living donor nephrectomy. In: Touraine JL et al. (eds) Transplantation and clinical immunology XVI. Excerpta Medica, Amsterdam, pp. 3–5.Google Scholar
  6. Cave MH, Doherty CC, Douglas JF, Mceown MG, Donaldson RA, Kennedy JA, Middleton D (1989) Live donor renal transplantation — the experience of the Belfast Renal Unit. Ir J Med Sci 158: 267–268.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  7. Cosimi AB (1988) The donor and donor nephrectomy. In: Morris PJ (ed) Kidney transplantation. Saunders, Philadelphia, pp. 93–121.Google Scholar
  8. Council of Europe (1987) Third Conference of European Health Ministers, Paris.Google Scholar
  9. Department of Clinical Epidemiology and Biostatistics, McMaster University Health Science Center (1981) How to read clinical journals: III. To learn the clinical course and prognosis of disease. Can Med Assoc J 124: 866–872.Google Scholar
  10. Dunn JF, Nylander WA, Richie RE, Johnson HK, Mac onnell RC, Sawyers JL (1986) Living related donors. A 14-year experience. Ann Surg 203: 637–643.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  11. Engset J, Youngson GG (1987) Surgical aspects of renal transplantation. In: Catto GRD (ed) Clinical transplantation. MTP Press, Lancaster, pp. 31–55.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  12. Fehrman I, Widstam U, Lundgren G, Bergström J (1985) Renal donation. Long-term consequences in man. In: Touraine JL et al. (eds) Transplantation and clinical immunology XVI. Excerpta Medica, Amsterdam, pp. 31–38.Google Scholar
  13. Ferran NL, Delano BG, Beyer MM, Uribarri J, Friedman EA (1985) Hypertension and proteinuria post renal donation (PDx). Kidney Int 27: 137.Google Scholar
  14. Friedlander MA, Lemke JH (1986) Divalent ion handling in human kidney donors with increased blood pressure after uninephrectomy. Am J Med 80: 1079–1085.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  15. Glassock RJ, Feldman D, Reynolds FS, Dammin GJ, Merrill JP (1968) Human renal isografts: a clinical and pathological analysis. Medicine 47: 411–454.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  16. Haag BW, Stuart FP (1989) The organ donor: brain death, selection criteria, supply and demand In: Flye MW (ed) Principles of organ transplantation. Saunders, Philadelphia, pp. 176–193.Google Scholar
  17. Hakim RM, Goldszer RC, Brenner BM (1984) Hypertension and proteinuria: long-term sequelae of uninephrectomy in humans. Kidney Int 25: 930–936.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  18. Kiprov DD, Colvin RB, Mc luskey (1982) Focal and segmental glomerulosclerosis and proteinuria associated with unilateral renal agenesis. Lab Invest 46: 275–281.Google Scholar
  19. Kramer P, Broyer M, Brunner F, Brynger H, Donckerwolcke RA, Jacobs C, Seiwood NH, Wing AJ (1982) Combined report on regular dialysis and transplantation in Europe XII 1981. Proceedings of the EDTA 19: 27. Pitman Medical, London.Google Scholar
  20. Liounis B, Roy LP, Thompson JF, May J, Sheil AG (1988) The living, related kidney donor: a follow-up study. Med J Aust 148: 436–437, 440-444.Google Scholar
  21. Miller IJ, Suthanthiran M, Riggio RR, Williams JJ, Riehle RA, Vaughan ED, Stubenbord WT, Mouradian J, Cheigh JS, Stenzel KH (1985) Impact of renal donation. Long-term clinical and biochemical follow-up of living donors in a single center. Am J Med 79: 201–208.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  22. Obermiller LE, Hoy WE, Eversole M, Sterling WA (1985) Recurrent membranous glomerulonephritis in two renal transplants. Transplantation 40: 100–102.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  23. O’Meara Y, Green A, Carmody M, Donohoe E, Campbell E, Browne O, Walshe J (1989) Recurrent glomerulonephritis in renal transplants: fourteen years’ experience. Nephrol Dial Transplant 4: 730–734.Google Scholar
  24. Parfrey PS, Hollomby DJ, Gilmore NJ, Knaack J, Schur PH, Guttmann RD (1984) Glomerular sclerosis in a renal isograft and identical twin donor. Transplantation 38: 343–346.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  25. Robitaille P, Mongeau JG, Lortie L, Sinnassamy P (1985) Long-term follow-up of patients who underwent unilateral nephrectomy in childhood. Lancet: 1297-1299.Google Scholar
  26. Sakellariou G (1985) Long-term follow-up of living donors. In: Touraine JL et al. (eds) Transplantation and clinical immunology XVI. Excerpta Medica, Amsterdam, pp. 23-30.Google Scholar
  27. Sampson MJ, Drury PL (1990) Development of nephropathy in a diabetic patient with a single kidney. Diabetic Med 7: 258–260.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  28. Schmitz A, Christensen CK, Christensen, Soiling K (1989) No microalbuminuria or other adverse effects of long-standing hyperfiltration in humans with one kidney. Am J Kidney Dis 13: 1312–1316.Google Scholar
  29. Schwarz A, Offermann G (1989) Vorteile und Risiken der Nierentransplantation von verwandten Spendern. Klin Wochenschr 67: 929–935.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  30. Simmons RG, Anderson CR (1985) Social-psychological problems in living donor transplantation. In: Touraine JL et al. (eds) Transplantation and clinical immunology XVI. Excerpta Medica, Amsterdam, pp. 47–57.Google Scholar
  31. Smith S, Laprad P, Grantham J (1985) Long-term effect of uninephrectomy on serum creatinine concentration and arterial blood pressure. Am J Kidney Dis 6: 143–148.Google Scholar
  32. Talseth T, Fauchald P, Skrede S, Djoseland O, Berg KJ, Stenstrom J, Heilo A, Brodwall EK, Flatmark A (1986) Long-term blood pressure and renal function in kidney donors. Kidney Int 29: 1072–1076.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  33. Tilney NL, Hollenberg NK (1985) Considerations of kidney donation using living related sources. In: Touraine JL et al. (eds) Transplantation and clinical immunology XVI. Excerpta Medica, Amsterdam, pp. 207–213.Google Scholar
  34. Tilney NL, Kirkman RL (1986) Surgical aspects of kidney transplantation. In: Garovoy MR, Guttmann RD (eds) Renal transplantation. Churchill Livingstone, New York, pp. 93–123.Google Scholar
  35. Torres VE, Offord KP, Anderson CF, Velosa JA, Frohnert PP, Donadio JV, Wilson DM (1987) Blood pressure determinants in living-related allograft donors and their recipients. Kidney Int 31: 1383–1390.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  36. Vincenti F, Amend WJC, Kaysen G, Feduska N, Birnbaum J, Duca R, Salvatierra O (1983) Long-term renal function in kidney donors. Transplantation 36: 626–629.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  37. Weiland D, Sutherland DER, Chavers B, Simmons RL, Ascher NL, Najarian JS (1984) Information on 628 living-related kidney donors at a single institution, with long-term follow-up in 472 cases. Transplant Proc 16: 5–7.Google Scholar
  38. Williams SL, Oler J, Jorkasky DK (1986) Long-term renal function in kidney donors: a comparison of donors and their siblings. Ann Int Med 105: 1–8.Google Scholar
  39. Wynn JJ, Pfaff WW, Patton PR, Peterson JC, Salomon DR, Fennell RS, Scornik JC, Howrd RJ (1988) Late results of renal transplantation. Transplantation 45: 329–333.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  40. Yasumura T, Nakai I, Oka T, Ohmori Y, Aikawa I, Nakaji K, Yoshimura N, Nakane Y (1988) Experience with 247 living-related donor nephrectomy cases at a single institution in Japan. Jpn J Surg 18: 252–258.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  41. Zucchelli P, Cagnoli L, Casanova S, Donini U, Pasquali S (1983) Focal glomerulosclerosis in patients with unilateral nephrectomy. Kidney Int 24: 649–655.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

Copyright information

© Springer-Verlag Berlin Heidelberg 1991

Authors and Affiliations

  • P. Michielsen
    • 1
  1. 1.Department of NephrologyUniversitair Ziekenhuis GasthuisbergLeuvenBelgium

Personalised recommendations