Abstract
The 2004 Indian Ocean (Boxing Day) tsunami destroyed an 800 km long by 2–3 km wide area along the coast of Aceh Province along with coastal areas and islands of the neighboring South Sumatera Province. Hundreds of lives were lost and more were never found. Three months later, a powerful earthquake ferociously shook a group of islands known as Nias, also causing significant devastation. These large-scale disasters prompted the Indonesian Government to establish a reconstruction agency—the BRR (Badan Rehabilitasi dan Rekonstruksi—Rehabilitation and Reconstruction Agency).
This chapter begins with a brief description of the socio-cultural and economic conditions of Aceh and Nias, before discussing the way the BRR operates. The chapter then identifies several lessons the BRR learned during its four and a half year tenure. After drawing comparisons with the Great East Japan Earthquake reconstruction process in Tohoku region, this chapter concludes with discussion of lessons learned for future use.
Keywords
These keywords were added by machine and not by the authors. This process is experimental and the keywords may be updated as the learning algorithm improves.
This chapter draws from 10 Management Lessons for Host Governments Coordinating Post-disaster Reconstruction (2009), which is part of the BRR Book Series, a set of unpublished manuscripts prepared by the BRR Book Writing Team of which the author was a member.
Access this chapter
Tax calculation will be finalised at checkout
Purchases are for personal use only
Notes
- 1.
For example, in 2005, Transparency International, ranked Indonesia 137 out of 159 countries on its Corruption Perceptions Index: Transparency International (2005). Since 2007, with banking sector improvements and domestic consumption, the national economic growth has been 6 % annually, helping the country weather the 2008–2009 global recession.
- 2.
BRR (2009b).
- 3.
BRR (2009d).
- 4.
BRR (2009b).
- 5.
BRR (2009b).
- 6.
BRR Nias (2008).
- 7.
BRR (2009b).
- 8.
Kuntoro Mangkusubroto has made this point repeatedly, including during a casual conversation (March 2012) after I presented the draft version of this chapter in a staff seminar at the Indonesian President’s Delivery Unit.
- 9.
The HDI data for South Nias in 2005 is not available since this administrative area was only established in 2003. Previous HDI is for the whole island: see World Bank (2007).
- 10.
World Bank (2007).
- 11.
BPS Sumatera Utara (2005).
- 12.
UNDP Bappenas (2008).
- 13.
Presidential Regulation No. 83 of 2005 on the National Coordinating Agency on Disaster Management.
- 14.
BRR (2009a).
- 15.
The Vice President, ex officio, was the Chairman of the Coordinating Body for Disaster Mitigation and Refugee Management (Bakornas PBP), established the National Team for Aceh Disaster Management, and appointed the Coordinating Minister of Public Welfare Alwi Shihab as its head. Subsequently, the head of this National Team appointed military general Bambang Darmono as its Executive Commander.
- 16.
Japan allowed its self-defence force to become involved in reconstruction only after its experience with the Hanshin-Awaji earthquake (1995): see Norio et al. (2011). On 13 April 2011, Japanese Prime Minister Naoto Kan sent 100,000 self-defence officers to participate in the Great East Japan Earthquake rescue work. The total number of troops mobilised, including those providing logistics, was 180,000—the largest number of self-defence forces dispatched by Japan since World War II.
- 17.
In a meeting between the BRR Institute and Kyoto University (17 October 2012), Eddy Purwanto, former Chief Operating Officer of BRR and executive director of the reconstruction operation, said metaphorically that he would kill anyone who tried to sell the idea of community participation approach during the first semester of the reconstruction since the speed of construction works was, at that stage, much more important than quality. During that crucial semester, professional contractors and experienced construction workers were needed to bring a semblance of normalcy. In the subsequent reconstruction stage, more community participation was sought.
- 18.
Comparing a number of post-disaster reconstructions, including Aceh–Nias, Fengler et al. (2008) concluded that an independent agency with substantial powers was only a ‘second-best’ solution. The best solution was for the local government to deal with such an operation. In the context of Aceh–Nias, however, there was no better alternative because existing institutions would have had significant difficulties managing the reconstruction process successfully. An extreme example of a government’s lack of capacity would be the post-disaster reconstruction of Haiti, where not only the local government was paralysed, but the national government was overwhelmed to the point of being incapable of conducting a swift and coordinated recovery effort: see, for example, Bellerive and Clinton (2009).
- 19.
Interim Law No. 2 of 2005, issued by the Indonesian President.
- 20.
Law No. 10 of 2005.
- 21.
The President used the Javanese term ‘dirusuhi’, which I have translated as ‘interference’. The President’s simple remark is actually a statement of support. Kuntoro Mangkusubroto had initially intended to decline the BRR leadership. At the National Development Planning Agency office, where Sri Mulyani—the then head of the Agency—had invited the ambassadors of Japan and the United States and USAID Director William M. Frej to a meeting, she asked the ambassadors what they thought if Kuntoro Mangkusubroto did not lead the BRR. The two envoys adamantly rejected the prospect. They were most fearful of uncertainties and distrust from the international community toward the Aceh and Nias recovery efforts. Sri Mulyani did not react immediately but rather called the President in front of the ambassadors. She described the mood of the meeting to the President. He answered, ‘Well, give Kuntoro what he needs’. See BRR (2009a).
- 22.
Iwate Prefecture has 4.75 million tons of debris, the equivalent of 11 years of garbage produced by its households. By March 2012 it had managed to dispose of only 8 % of the debris: Sumikawa (2012). Miyagi Prefecture has 15.69 million tons of debris, the equivalent of 19 years of household trash. Only 5 % of the debris had, at time of writing, been removed. Fukushima Prefecture is left with 2.08 million tons.
- 23.
Sumikawa (2012).
- 24.
Iwaasa and Nakane (2012).
- 25.
Iwaasa and Nakane (2012).
- 26.
Curtis (2011).
- 27.
Law No. 76 of 2011.
- 28.
See Norwegian Environment Technology Center (2012).
- 29.
Zakoda (2012).
- 30.
Shi et al. (2009).
- 31.
Jayasuria and McCawley (2011).
- 32.
BRR (2009c).
- 33.
BRR (2009b).
- 34.
This was a special treasury office located at the provincial level, temporarily established for service during the reconstruction period. The format of the service was later adopted as a standard regular service for the treasury offices throughout Indonesia.
- 35.
See Jha et al. (2010).
- 36.
BRR (2009c).
- 37.
The reconstruction budget for 2011–2015 is ¥19 trillion, and in November 2011, the Diet approved a tax increase on individual incomes and corporate profits that will be in effect for 25 years to cover at least ¥10.5 trillion, the rest coming from government spending cuts.
- 38.
Reconstruction Headquarters (2011), p. 8.
- 39.
Norwegian Environment Technology Center (2012).
- 40.
Nikkei (2012).
- 41.
Giles (2012).
- 42.
Brasor (2012).
- 43.
- 44.
References
Bellerive J-M, Clinton WJ (2009) Finishing Haiti unfinished works. The New York Times, August 2010. http://canadahaitiaction.ca/node/460. Accessed 17 Aug 2010
BPS Sumatera Utara (2005) Statistik kesejahteraan rakyat Propinsi Sumatera Utara 2004. BPS Propinsi Sumatera Utara, Medan
Brasor P (2012) Scrutiny of Tohoku reconstruction needed. The Japan Times Online. http://www.japantimes.co.jp/text/fd20120923pb.html. Accessed 15 Oct 2012
BRR (2009a) Book 0: Tsunami. Limited publication to mark the closing of the BRR. Aceh-Nias, Jakarta
BRR (2009b) Book 1: Story. Limited publication to mark the closing of the BRR. Aceh-Nias, Jakarta
BRR (2009c) Book 2: Finance. Limited publication to mark the closing of the BRR. Aceh-Nias, Jakarta
BRR (2009d) Book 5: Nias. Limited publication to mark the closing of the BRR. Aceh-Nias, Jakarta
BRR Nias (2008) Winding down the recovery, paving the way towards a sustainable development. BRR Nias, Gunungsitoli
Cabinet Secretariat (2012a) FutureCity Initiative. Cabinet Secretariat. http://futurecity.rro.go.jp/en/about/. Accessed 21 June 2012
Cabinet Secretariat (2012b) Rebirth of Japan: a comprehensive study. Cabinet Secretariat. http://npu.go.jp/policy/pdf/20120821/20120821_en.pdf. Accessed 15 Oct 2012
Curtis G (2011) Japanese leadership fails at post-disaster reconstruction test. East Asia Forum. http://www.eastasiaforum.org/2011/08/14/japanese-leadership-fails-at-post-disaster-reconstuction-test/. Accessed 2 Oct 2012
Executing Agency for Rehabilitation and Reconstruction (BRR) of Aceh-Nias (2009) 10 management lessons for host governments managing post-disaster reconstruction. Limited publication to mark the closing of the BRR Aceh-Nias. Jakarta
Fengler W, Ihsan A, Kaiser K (2008) Managing post-disaster reconstruction: international experience in public financial management. World Bank, Washington. doi:10.1596/1813-9450-4475
Giles DW (2012) Rebuilding Aceh: Indonesia’s BRR spearhead post-tsunami recovery. Harvard Kennedy School, August 2013. http://www.hks.harvard.edu/var/ezp_site/storage/fckeditor/file/pdfs/centers-programs/programs/crisis-leadership/Harvard%20BRR%20Case%20Study_PrePub_2012%2010%2020.pdf. Accessed 12 Aug 2013
Iwaasa K, Nakane K (2012) Tohoku understaffed for reconstruction work. The Yomiuri Shimbun, September 2012. http://www.yomiuri.co.jp/dy/national/T120911004289.htm. Accessed 24 Sept 2012
Jayasuria S, McCawley P (eds) (2011) Asian Tsunami: aid and reconstruction. Edward Elgar, Cheltenham
Jha AK, Barenstein JD, Phelps PM, Pittet D, Sena S (2010) Safer homes, stronger communities: a handbook for reconstructing after natural disasters. World Bank, Washington
Nikkei (2012) Locals worry reconstruction agency can’t cut red tape. https://recoveringtohoku.wordpress.com/2012/02/10/locals-worry-reconstruction-agency-cant-cut-red-tape-nikkei-21012/. Accessed 15 Oct 2012
Norio O, Ye T, Kajitani Y, Shi P, Tatano H (2011) The 2011 Eastern Japan Great Earthquake Disaster: overview and comments. Int J Disaster Risk Sci 2(1):34–42. doi:10.1007/s13753-011-0004-9
Norwegian Environment Technology Center (2012) Rebuilding Japan: Tohoku reconstruction awaits a gov’t that can make decisions. http://www.netc.no/netc/archives/1151. Accessed 24 Sept 2012
Reconstruction Headquarters (2011) Basic guidelines of reconstruction of the Great East Japan Earthquake. Cabinet Office, Tokyo
Shi PJ, Liu LY, Wang JA, Xu W, Fang WH, Wang M (2009) Experiences and lessons of large-scale disaster governance in China: perspective to the response of Wenchuan earthquake disaster. In: Paper presented at the International Human Dimensions Program (IHDP) 2009 Open Meeting, Bonn, 26–30 April 2009
Sumikawa T (2012) Stricken prefectures stuck with mountains of quake debris. The Asahi Shimbun, March 2012. http://ajw.asahi.com/article/0311disaster/analysis/AJ201203100013. Accessed 3 Oct 2012
Transparency International (2005) Corruption perceptions index 2005. http://www.transparency.org/policy_research/surveys_indices/cpi/2005. Accessed 15 Oct 2012
Tsunami Global Lesson Learned Project (2012) Handbook for disaster recovery practitioner. TGLLP (in press)
UNDP, Bappenas (2008) Inisiatif harmonisasi hukum untuk desentralisasi perencanaan pembangunan dalam penanggulangan bencana. UNDP dan Bappenas, Jakarta
World Bank (2007) Managing resources to build back and create a better future for Nias: Nias public expenditure analysis 2007. World Bank, Jakarta
Zakoda E (2012) Report: 40% of Tohoku rebuilding budget remains unused. The Asahi Shimbun, June 2012. http://ajw.asahi.com/article/0311disaster/recovery/AJ201206290076. Accessed 24 Sept 2012
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Editor information
Editors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
Copyright information
© 2014 Springer-Verlag Berlin Heidelberg
About this chapter
Cite this chapter
Samadhi, T.N. (2014). BRR Aceh–Nias: Post-Disaster Reconstruction Governance. In: Butt, S., Nasu, H., Nottage, L. (eds) Asia-Pacific Disaster Management. Springer, Berlin, Heidelberg. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-642-39768-4_8
Download citation
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-642-39768-4_8
Published:
Publisher Name: Springer, Berlin, Heidelberg
Print ISBN: 978-3-642-39767-7
Online ISBN: 978-3-642-39768-4
eBook Packages: Humanities, Social Sciences and LawLaw and Criminology (R0)