Advertisement

A Future for the Dead Sea Basin: Water Culture among Israelis, Palestinians and Jordanians

  • Clive Lipchin

Abstract

The Dead Sea basin plays a major role for regional economic development (industry, tourism and agriculture) in the Middle East. This potential is threatened by the steady disappearance of the Dead Sea. Since around 1930 the water level of the Dead Sea has fallen by about 25 m, about half of this alone in the last 20 years. The Dead Sea is a transboundary resource shared by Israel, the Palestinian Authority and Jordan. The Dead Sea is the terminal point of the Jordan River watershed and as such, it serves as a barometer for the health of the overall system. Its rapid decline reflects the present water management strategies of the riparian and upstream countries. This includes the different water cultures of the three countries.

Throughout history, the Dead Sea basin has served as a source of refuge and inspiration for followers of Judaism, Christianity and Islam. Today, the religious significance of the Dead Sea is being overshadowed by its rapid disappearance. This may be explained in part by the water cultures of the three countries that influence water policy in the region. Ideology, together with culture and tradition, such as that of Zionism in Israel, has played a central role in water development in the region. In many cases, this has been at the expense of the environment.

Elements pertaining to environmental security and water culture and tradition, whereby a sustainably managed environment provides for social, economic as well as environmental benefits are evident with regards the Dead Sea. The decline for example, undermines its potential as a tourist destination, despite the enormous investment in hotel and resort infrastructures in Israel and in Jordan. The decline also raises ethical issues about the exploitation of water resources by present generations at the expense of this natural heritage to future generations.

This paper provides an analysis of a European Union funded project whose aims are to synthesize and assess existing physical and socio-economic data and to assess options for a better future for the Dead Sea. It will identify the patterns of water supply and use in the region, and the factors that control these patterns, including those of water culture. The underlying assumption is that solutions for a more sustainable development than today scenario will not come from simply providing “more water for more development”, but from a new land and water management system, indeed ethic, that is sensitive to social, cultural and ecological resources thereby providing security and stability across cultures, economic sectors and nations.

Keywords

water culture Dead Sea stakeholder analysis 

Preview

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

References

  1. Abu-Faris, H. G.; Bromber, G.: Fariz, S.; Hoermann, S.; Turner, M., 1999: Moving Towards a Dead Sea Basin Biosphere Reserve and World Heritage Listings (Amman, Jordan: Friends of the Earth Middle East).Google Scholar
  2. Abu-Zeid. M. A., 1998: “Water and Sustainable Development: The Vision for World Water, Life and the Environment”, in: Water Policy, 1,1: 9–19.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  3. Al-Weshah, R. A., 2000: “The Water Balance of the Dead Sea: An Integrated Approach”, in: Hydrological Processes, 14,1: 145–154.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  4. Anati. D.A.; Shasha. S., 1989: “Dead Sea Surface Level Changes”, in: Israel Journal of Earth Sciences 38,11: 29–38.Google Scholar
  5. Assaf. K. K.; Ben-Zvi. M., Clarke, J. S.; El-Naser, H.; Kesselman, S,; Landers, M. N.; Nuseibeh, M. F., Wipperfurth, C. J., 1998: Overview of Middle East Water Resources: Water Resources of Palestinian, Jordanian and Israeli Interest (Washington, D.C.: US Geological Service. EXACT Middle East Water Data Banks Project).Google Scholar
  6. Baer, G.; Schattner, U.; Wachs, D.; Sandwell, D.; Wdowinski, S.; Frydman, S., 2002: “The Lowest Place on Earth is Subsiding: An InSAR Interferometric Synthetic Aperture Radar Perspective”, in: Geological Society of America Bulletin, 114: 12–23.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  7. Bowman D.; Banet-Davidovich, D.; Bruins, H. J.; Van der Plicht. J,, 2000: “Dead Sea Shoreline Facies with Seismically Induced Soft-Sediment Deformation Structures”, in: Israel Journal of Earth Sciences, 49: 197–214.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  8. Bruvold, W. H.; Cook, J., 1989: “What the Public Thinks: Reclaiming and Reusing Wastewater”, in: Journal of the American Water Works Association, 77: 10–17.Google Scholar
  9. Burmil S.; Daniel, T. C.; Hetherington, J. D., 1999: “Human Values and Perceptions of Water in Arid Landscapes”, in: Landscape and Urban Planning, 44: 99–109.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  10. Coussin, O., 2001: “Wild and Stunning and Shrinking Fast: The Dead Sea Region is being Undermined by Industry and Tourism, but is Anybody Paying Attention?”, in: Haaretz Daily Newspaper (Tel Aviv, Israel).Google Scholar
  11. Douglas M.; Wildavsky, A., 1982: Risk and Culture: An Essay on the Selection of Technological and Environmental Dangers. (University of California Press, Berkeley).Google Scholar
  12. EcoPeace. 1998: Final Symposium Report. Symposium on Promoting an Integrated Sustainable Regional Development Plan for the Dead Sea Basin (Jerusalem: EcoPeace-Middle East Environmental NGO Forum).Google Scholar
  13. Elisha, R., 2006: “Water Budget Analysis Around the Dead Sea in Israel, Jordan and the District of Jericho” (MSc thesis. Ben Gurion University of the Negev, Israel).Google Scholar
  14. Feitelson, E., 2000: The Ebb and Flow of Arab-Israeli Water Conflicts: Are Past Conflicts Likley to Resurface Water Policy, 2: 343–363.Google Scholar
  15. Falkenmark, M., 1989: “Freshwater as a Factor in Strategic Policy and Action”, in: Davis, K.; Bernstam, M. and Sellers, H. (Eds.): Population and Resources in a Changing World (Stanford, CA: Morrison Institute for Population and Resource Studies).Google Scholar
  16. Friends of the Earth Middle East, 2000: Let the Dead Sea Live-Concept Document Towards the Dead Sea Basin Biosphere Reserve and World Heritage Listings (Amman, Jordan: Friends of the Earth Middle East).Google Scholar
  17. Frederick, K. D., 2000: “Water as a Source of International Conflict”, in: Resources for the Future,: 123 (Washington, DC: RFF).Google Scholar
  18. Fry, K.; Mingledorff, N., 1996: Overcoming Cultural Biases in the Introduction of Water Saving Technology: No Need to Flush a Waterless Urinal (American Water Works Association).Google Scholar
  19. Gavrieli, I.; Lensky, N.; Gazit-Yaari, N., Oren, A., 2002: The Impact of the Proposed ‘Peace Conduit’ on the Dead Sea: Evaluation of Current Knowledge on Dead Sea-Seawater Mixing (Jerusalem: The Ministry of Regional Cooperation).Google Scholar
  20. Gebetsroither, E.,; Afaneh, A.; Lipchin, C.; Lehrer, D., 2004: “An Analysis of the Feedback Structure Driving Water Dynamics in the Dead Sea Region”, Paper for the MEDAQUA INCO-MED Water Conference, Amman, Jordan, June 14Flakenmark15, 2004Google Scholar
  21. Gertmann, L., 1999: The Hydrogeography of the Dead Sea 1999–2000 (Israel Oceanographic and Limnological Research Center.Google Scholar
  22. Gleick, P. H., 1993: “Water and Conflict: Fresh Water Resources and International Security”, in: International Security, 18: 79–112.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  23. Gleick, P. H., 1994: “Water, War and Peace in the Middle East”, in: Environment, 36: 5–41.Google Scholar
  24. Hamberg, D., 1995: The Mediterranean-Dead Sea and The Red Sea-Dead Sea Projects. Paper for the International Peace Conference on the Peace Process and the Environment (Tel Aviv: Tel Aviv University, Israel).Google Scholar
  25. Hellstrom, D.; Jeppsson, U.: Karrman, E.. 2000: “A Framework for System Analysis of Sustainable Urban Water Management”, in: Environmental Impact Assessment Review, 20: 311–321.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  26. Hillel. D., 1994: Rivers of Eden: The Struggle for Water and the Quest for Peace in the Middle East (Oxford University Press, New York).Google Scholar
  27. Hoekstra, A. Y., 1988: “Appreciation of Water: Four Perspectives”, in: Water Policy, 1: 605–622.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  28. Hoon, P.; Singh, N. W. S., 1997: Sustainable Livelihoods: Concepts, Methods and Principles for Indicator Development. UNDP Discussion Paper (New York: UNDP).Google Scholar
  29. Isaac, J.; Hrimat, N.; Rishmawi. K.; Saad, S.;, Abu Kubea, M.;, Hilal. J.; Owawi, M.; Sababa, G.; Awad, M.; Ishaq, F.; Zboun, I., 2000: An Atlas of Palestine: The West Bank and Gaza (Bethlehem, Palestine: Applied Research Institute Jerusalem).Google Scholar
  30. Jeffrey, P., 2000: Water Recycling Opportunities for City Sustainability (Cranfield University, UK: School of Water Sciences).Google Scholar
  31. Jeffrey, P.; Seaton, R., 1998: “The Theory and Practice of Exposing Public Perception of Wastewater Reuse Options. Small and Medium Size Domestic Water Conservation”, in: Waste Water Treatment and Reuse, 4,1: 33–38.Google Scholar
  32. Jeffrey, P., 2000: Cross-Cultural Valuations of Natural Resources. A Case Study in the Galilee Region of Northern Israel. A Report to the British Council under the Lord Goodman Fellowship Scheme (London: The British Council).Google Scholar
  33. Klein, C., 1985: “Fluctuations of the Level of the Dead Sea and Climatic Faluctuations in the Country during Historical Times”, Paper for the Symposium on Scientific Basis for Water Resources Management, International Association of Hydrological Sciences, Paris, 5–7 August.Google Scholar
  34. Lipchin, C., 1997: Water Scarcity, International Security and Resource Disputes-The Case of the Tigris-Euphrates and Jordan Basin River System (Ann Arbor, MI: University of Michigan).Google Scholar
  35. Lipchin, C., 2000: “Water Use in the Southern Arrava Valley of Israel and Jordan: A Study of Local Perceptions”, in: Journal of the International Institute, 11: 112–114Google Scholar
  36. Lowi, M. R., 1993: “Bridging the Divide: Transboundary Resource Disputes and the Case of West Bank Water”, in: International Security, 18: 113–138.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  37. Mancy, K. H.; Fattal, B.; Kelada, S., 2000: “Cultural Implications of Wastewater Reuse in Fish Farming in the Middle East”, in: Water Science and Technology, 42: 235–239.Google Scholar
  38. Meunier, J., 1999: Keeping the Dead Sea Alive: Toward a Regional Environmental Management Plan (Winnipeg: International Development Research Center).Google Scholar
  39. Murdock, S. H.; Albrecht, D. E.; Hamm, R. R.; Bachman, K,; Parpia, B., 1988: An Analysis of the Effects of Sociodemographic Factors on Daily per Capita Residential Water Use in Texas Cities. (Texas Water Resources Institute, Texas: A&M University).Google Scholar
  40. Oliver, M. D., 1999: “Attitudes and In-action: A Case Study of the Manifest Demographics of Urban Water Conservation”, in: Environment and Behavior, 31: 372–394.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  41. Orthofer, R.; Daoud, R.; Fattal, B.; Ghanayem, M.; Isaac, J.; Kupfersberger, H.; Safar, A.; Salameh, E,; Shuval, H,; Wollman, S., 2001: Developing Sustainable Water Management in the Jordan Valley. (Brussels: European Commission, DG Research).Google Scholar
  42. Orthofer. R., 2001: Land Use and Water Use in the Jordan Valley (Vienna: Austrian Research Centre, Environmental Planning Department).Google Scholar
  43. Pandey, J., 1990: “The Environment, Culture and Behavior”, in: Brislin, R. W. (Ed.): Applied Cross-Cultural Psychology, 14: 254–277.Google Scholar
  44. Pearce, F., 1995: “Raising the Dead Sea”, in: New Scientist, 147: 1987: 33–37.Google Scholar
  45. Postel, S. L.; Wolf, A. T., 2001: “Dehydrating Conflict”, in: Foreign Policy: 60–67.Google Scholar
  46. Postel, S. L., 1993: The Politics of Water (Washington, D.C.: World Watch Institute).Google Scholar
  47. Rabi, A., 1997: Ecological Resources of the Dead Sea Basin and Their Sustainable Use: Problems and Cooperation between the Countries of the Basin. Paper for the International Conference on Transboundary Protected Areas as a Vehicle for International Cooperation (Geneva: UNEP World Conservation Monitoring Center).Google Scholar
  48. Rishmawi, K,; Hrimat, N., 1999: “The Use of High Resolution Satellite Images to Monitor the Changes in the Rates and Directions of Desertification in the Southeastern Part of the West Bank”, Paper for the Second Palestinian Geographic Conference, Al Quds University, East Jerusalem, 26–28 April 1999.Google Scholar
  49. Schempp, C. H., 2000: “Magnesium Ions Inhibit the Antigen Presenting Function of Huma Epidermal Langerhans Cells in vivo and in vitro: Involvement of ATPase, HLA-DR, B7 Molecules, and Cytokines”, in: Journal of Investigative Dermatology, 115: 23–34.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  50. Segev, G., 1995: The Mediterranean-Dead Sea Canal and The Red Sea-Dead Sea canal. Paper for the International Peace Conference on the Peace Process and the Environment. Tel Aviv University, Israel.Google Scholar
  51. Shavit U. R., 2001: “Water Sources and Quality Along the Lower Jordan Valley”, in: Rubin, H. (Ed.): Water Resources Quality: Preserving the Quality of our Water Resources (Berlin: Springer): 127–148.Google Scholar
  52. Shannag, E.; Al-Adwan, Y., 2000: “Evaluating Water Balances in Jordan”, in: Brooks, D.; Mehmet, O. (Eds.): Water Balances in the Eastern Mediterranean (Ottawa: International Development Research Center, Canada).Google Scholar
  53. Shelef, G., 1995: “The Coming Era of Intensive Wastewater Reuse in the Mediterranean Region”, Paper for the International Conference on the Peace Process and the Environment, Tel Aviv University, Israel, 18 May.Google Scholar
  54. Simon, P., 1998: Tapped Out: The Coming World Crisis in Water and What We Can Do About it. (New York: Welcome Rain).Google Scholar
  55. Simon, R. J., 1971: “Public Attitudes Toward Population and Pollution”, in: Public Opinion Quarterly, 35: 93–99.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  56. Spaulding, I. A., 1972: “Social Class and Household Water Consumption”, in: Burch Jr., W. R.; Cheech Jr., N. H.: Taylor, L. (Eds.) (New York: Harper and Row).Google Scholar
  57. Stanhill, G., 1984: Evaporation from the Dead Sea. A summary of Research until Sept. 1984. Mediterranean Dead Sea Project, Tel Aviv, Volcani Institute.Google Scholar
  58. Tal, A., 2001: Pollution in a Promised Land (Berkeley, CA: University of California Press).Google Scholar
  59. UNDP, 2003: Mainstreaming Gender in Water Management: A Practical Journey to Sustainability: A Resource Guide (New York, USA: UNDP).Google Scholar
  60. Van Liere, K. D.; Dunlap, R. E., 1980: “The Social Bases of Environmental Concern: A review of Hypotheses, Explanations and Empirical Evidence”, in: Public Opinion Quarterly, 44: 180–197.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  61. Wardam, B., 2000: “Lowest Point on Earth is Getting Lower”, Jordan Times, 18 October (Amman, Jordan).Google Scholar
  62. Wilson, M.; Daly, M., 1998: “The Evolved Psychological Apparatus of Human Decision-Making Is One Source of Environmental Problems”, in: Caro, T. (Ed): Behavioral ecology and conservation (Oxford: Oxford University Press): 501–523.Google Scholar
  63. Wilson. M.; Daly. M.; Gordon, S.; Pratt. A., 1996: “Sex Differences in Valuations of the Environment”, in: Population and Environment: A Journal of Interdisciplinary Studies, 18: 143–159.Google Scholar
  64. Wolf. A.; Lonergan, S., 1995: “Resolving Conflicts over Water Disputes in the Jordan River Basin”, in: Dinar, A.; Loehman, E.T. (Eds.): Environmental change, adaptation, and human security (London: Praeger).Google Scholar
  65. Yechieli, Y., 1996: Influence of the Changes in Dead Sea Level on the Groundwaters around Israel (Haifa: Israel Association Water Resources).Google Scholar

Copyright information

© Springer-Verlag Berlin Heidelberg 2007

Authors and Affiliations

  • Clive Lipchin
    • 1
  1. 1.Arava Institute for Environmental Studies, Ketura, IsraelD.N. Hevel EilotIsrael

Personalised recommendations