Abstract
Since Bryan Norton first advocated an American pragmatist reading of Aldo Leopold’s work in 1988, he has been debating with J. Baird Callicott over interpretation of Leopold’s development of the land ethic. In this chapter I give an overview of this debate, defending the general outlines of Norton’s position by bringing in new interpretative work of my own. I argue firstly that Norton is correct to see a Jamesian pragmatist influence on Leopold, but maintain that this is best read as deriving from William James’ own work rather than from the secondary source, Arthur Twining Hadley, and that Norton may have exaggerated the immediacy and strength of the influence. Secondly, I demonstrate how strands of evidence suggest that Leopold read James, and that elements of James’ thought chimed with Leopold’s own perspective sufficiently to support Norton’s claim of a pragmatist influence. Thirdly, I show that aspects of Callicott’s interpretation of Leopold do not exclude a pragmatist reading, and argue that Callicott has misunderstood Jamesian pragmatism in ways that undermine his case. Finally, I suggest that Jamesian pragmatic naturalism has far more radical potential than Callicott allows, and that the wider framing of the debate within the environmental philosophy community as setting pragmatist managerialism against radical ethical innovation has itself been misleading. I conclude that Norton is correct to argue that the American pragmatist tradition is a powerful positive contributor to environmental philosophy and policy, provided that the breadth of pragmatic naturalism itself is sufficiently recognized across the board.
Access this chapter
Tax calculation will be finalised at checkout
Purchases are for personal use only
References
Callicott, J.Baird. 2015. Introductory palinode. At http://jbcallicott.weebly.com/introductory-palinode.html. Accessed 28 June 2015.
Callicott, J.Baird. 1989. The conceptual foundations of the land ethic. In Defense of the land ethic: Essays in environmental philosophy, ed. J. Baird Callicott, 75–99. Albany, NY: SUNY Press.
Callicott, J.Baird. 1999. Beyond the land ethic: More essays in environmental philosophy. Albany, NY: SUNY Press.
Callicott, J.Baird. 2002. My Reply. In Land, value, community: Callicott and environmental philosophy, ed. Wayne Ouderkirk, and Jim Hill, 291–329. Albany, NY: SUNY Press.
Callicott, J.Baird. 2011. The worldview concept and Aldo Leopold’s project of ‘world view’ remediation. Journal for the Study of Religion, Nature & Culture 5: 510–29.
Callicott, J.Baird. 2013. Thinking like a planet: The land ethic and the earth ethic. New York: Oxford University Press.
Callicott, J.Baird, and Eric T. Freyfogle. 1999. Introduction. In For the health of the land, Aldo Leopold, ed. J. Baird Callicott and Eric T. Freyfogle, 3–26. Washington DC: Island Press.
Callicott, J.Baird, William Grove-Fanning, Jennifer Rowland, Daniel Baskind, Robert Heath French, and Kerry Walker. 2009. Was Aldo Leopold a pragmatist? Rescuing Leopold from the imagination of Bryan Norton. Environmental Values 18: 453–86.
Callicott, J.Baird, William Grove-Fanning, Jennifer Rowland, Daniel Baskind, Robert Heath French, and Kerry Walker. 2011. Reply to Norton, re: Aldo Leopold and pragmatism. Environmental Values 20: 17–22.
Cannavò, Peter F. 2012. Ecological citizenship, time, and corruption: Aldo Leopold’s green republicanism. Environmental Politics 21: 864–81.
Dooley, Patrick Kieran. 1974. Pragmatism as humanism: The philosophy of William James. Chicago: Nelson-Hall.
Edie, James M. 1987. William James and phenomenology. Bloomington: Indiana University Press.
Frankenberry, Nancy. 1987. Religion and radical empiricism. Albany: SUNY Press.
Fuller, Robert C. 1992. American pragmatism reconsidered: William James’s ecological ethic. Environmental Ethics 14: 159–76.
Gale, Richard M. 1999. The divided self of William James. New York: Cambridge University Press.
Goodman, Russell B. 1990. American philosophy and the romantic tradition. New York: Cambridge University Press.
Hadley, Arthur Twining. 1913. Some influences on modern philosophic thought. New Haven: Yale University Press.
James, William. 1912. Memories and studies. New York: Longmans, Green & Co.
James, William. 1918. The principles of psychology, vol. 2. London: Macmillan & Co., Ltd.
James, William. 1952. The varieties of religious experience. London: Longmans, Green & Co.
James, William. 1968. Pragmatism and four essays from the meaning of truth. Cleveland: Meridian Books.
James, William. 1977. A Pluralistic Universe. Cambridge, Mass: Harvard University Press.
James, William. 1979. The moral philosopher and the moral life. In The will to believe and other essays in popular philosophy, ed. William James, 141–162. Cambridge, Mass: Harvard University Press.
James, William. 2010. On a Certain Blindness in Human Beings. In The heart of William James, ed. Robert Richardson, 145–163. Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard University Press.
Lekan, Todd. 2012. A Jamesian approach to environmental ethics. Contemporary Pragmatism. 9: 5–24.
Leopold, Aldo. 1921. The wilderness and its place in forest recreational policy. Journal of Forestry 19: 718–21.
Leopold, Aldo. 2013. Some Fundamentals of Conservation in the Southwest. In Thinking like a planet: The land ethic and the earth ethic, ed. J. Baird Callicott, 303–311. New York: Oxford University Press.
Leopold, Aldo. 1987. A sand county almanac and sketches here and there. New York: Oxford University Press.
Lorbiecki, Marybeth. 1996. Aldo Leopold: A fierce green fire. Montana: Helena and Billings.
Meine, Curt. 1988. Aldo Leopold: His life and work. Madison, WI: University of Wisconsin Press.
Miller, Joshua I. 1997. Democratic temperament: The legacy of William James. Lawrence, KS: University Press of Kansas.
Millstein, Roberta A. 2015. Re-examining the Darwinian basis for Aldo Leopold’s land ethic. Ethics, Policy and Environment 18: 301–17.
Minteer, Ben. 2006. The landscape of reform: Civic pragmatism and environmental thought in America. Cambridge, Mass: MIT Press.
Norton, Bryan G. 1991. Toward unity among environmentalists. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Norton, Bryan G. 1996. The constancy of Leopold’s land ethic. In Environmental pragmatism, ed. Andrew Light, and Eric Katz. London: Routledge.
Norton, Bryan G. 2005. Sustainability: A philosophy of adaptive ecosystem management. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Norton, Bryan G. 2011. What Leopold learned from Darwin and Hadley: Comment on Callicott. Environmental Values 20: 7–16.
Norton, Bryan G. 2013. Leopold, Hadley and Darwin: Darwinian epistemology, truth and right. Contemporary Pragmatism 10: 1–28.
Ouspensky, P.D. 1965. Tertium organum: The third canon of thought. Translated by Nicholas Bessaraboff and Claude Bragdon. London: Routledge and Kegan Paul.
Perry, Ralph Barton. 1935. The thought and character of William James, vol. 2 Vols. Boston: Little, Brown & Co.
Pryor, Ashley. 2011. Thinking like a mystic: The legacy of P.D. Ouspensky’s Tertium Organum on the development of Aldo Leopold’s ‘Thinking Like a Mountain’. Journal for the Study of Religion, Nature & Culture 5: 465–90.
Starkey, Charles. 2007. The land ethic, moral development and ecological rationality. Southern Journal of Philosophy XLV: 149–175.
Stephens, Piers H.G. 2007. Sustainability, democracy and pragmatism: Bryan Norton’s philosophy of ecosystem management. Organization and Environment 20: 386–92.
Stephens, Piers H.G. 2009. Toward a Jamesian environmental philosophy. Environmental Ethics 31: 227–44.
Stephens, Piers H.G. 2012. The turn of the skew: Pragmatism, environmental philosophy and the ghost of William James. Contemporary Pragmatism 9: 25–52.
Taylor, Bob Pepperman. 2002. Aldo Leopold’s Civic Education. In Democracy and the claims of nature, eds. Ben A Minteer and Bob Pepperman Taylor, 173–187. Lanham, MD: Rowman & Littlefield.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Editor information
Editors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
Copyright information
© 2018 Springer International Publishing AG, part of Springer Nature
About this chapter
Cite this chapter
Stephens, P.H.G. (2018). Norton Versus Callicott on Interpreting Aldo Leopold: A Jamesian View. In: Sarkar, S., Minteer, B. (eds) A Sustainable Philosophy—The Work of Bryan Norton. The International Library of Environmental, Agricultural and Food Ethics, vol 26. Springer, Cham. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-319-92597-4_8
Download citation
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-319-92597-4_8
Published:
Publisher Name: Springer, Cham
Print ISBN: 978-3-319-92596-7
Online ISBN: 978-3-319-92597-4
eBook Packages: Religion and PhilosophyPhilosophy and Religion (R0)