Gender Dysphoria and the Medical Gaze in Anglo-American Carceral Regimes

  • Kyle KirkupEmail author


Anglo-American carceral spaces are invariably segregated on the basis of sex. Drawing on the stories of Katherine Johnson and Synthia Kavanagh—two transgender women who launched complaints against the Correctional Service of Canada—this chapter analyzes the ways in which non-normative genders are constituted using biomedical discourses in carceral spaces. By segregating individuals on the basis of sex, using diagnostic categories such as “gender dysphoria,” and imposing surgical requirements on those who refuse to be subjugated by essentialist gender norms, carceral spaces participate in a larger corporeal project. The chapter concludes by arguing that changes to prison policies, along with a broader commitment to decarceration, constitute important sites of resistance to the imposition of biomedical discourses on transgender people.


  1. American Psychiatric Association. 2013. Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders. 5th ed. Washington, DC: American Psychiatric Association.Google Scholar
  2. Arbour, L. 1996. Commission of Inquiry into Certain Events at the Prison for Women in Kingston. Ottawa: Public Works and Government Services Canada.Google Scholar
  3. Arkles, G. 2009. Safety and Solidarity Across Gender Lines: Rethinking Segregation of Transgender People in Detention. Temple Political & Civil Rights Law Review 18 (2): 515–560.Google Scholar
  4. Butler, J. 1999. Gender Trouble: Feminism and the Subversion of Identity. 10th anniversary ed. New York: Routledge.Google Scholar
  5. Chenier, E. 2012. The Criminal Sexual Psychopath in Canada: Sex, Psychiatry, and the Law at Mid-Century. In Queerly Canadian: An Introductory Reader in Sexuality Studies, ed. M. Fitzgerald and S. Rayter, 171–190. Toronto: Canadian Scholars’ Press.Google Scholar
  6. Connell, R.W. 1987. Gender and Power: Society, the Person, and Sexual Politics. Cambridge: Polity Press.Google Scholar
  7. Cooley, D. 1993. Criminal Victimization in Male Federal Prisons. Canadian Journal of Criminology 35 (4): 479–496.Google Scholar
  8. Correctional Investigator Canada. 2016. 2015–2016 Annual Report of the Correction of the Correctional Investigator. June 30. Accessed January 15, 2017.
  9. Correctional Service of Canada. 1997. Health Service Policy, Directive 800. Ottawa: Correctional Service of Canada.Google Scholar
  10. ———. 2001. Health Service Policy, Directive 800. Ottawa: Correctional Service of Canada.Google Scholar
  11. ———. 2008. Women in Prison in Canada: The Early Years. Accessed March 6, 2018.
  12. ———. 2016. Commissioner’s Guidelines No 800-5. Ottawa: Correctional Service of Canada.Google Scholar
  13. Davy, Z. 2010. Transsexual Agents: Negotiating Authenticity and Embodiment Within the UK’s Medicolegal System. In Transgender Identities: Towards a Social Analysis of Gender Diversity, ed. S. Hines and T. Sanger, 106–126. New York: Routledge.Google Scholar
  14. Drescher, J. 2012. The Removal of Homosexuality from the DSM: Its Impact on Today’s Marriage Equality Debate. Journal of Gay and Lesbian Mental Health 16 (2): 124–135.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  15. Foucault, M. 1973. The Birth of the Clinic: An Archeology of Medical Perception. Translated by A.M. Sheridan. London: Tavistock.Google Scholar
  16. Frances, A. 2013. Saving Normal: An Insider’s Revolt Against Out-of-Control Psychiatric Diagnosis, DSM-5, Big Pharma, and the Medicalization of Ordinary Life. New York: William Morrow.Google Scholar
  17. Grassian, S. 2006. Psychiatric Effects of Solitary Confinement. Washington University Journal of Law & Policy 22: 325–383.Google Scholar
  18. Haney, C. 2003. Mental Health Issues in Long-Term Solitary and ‘Supermax’ Confinement. Crime & Delinquency 49 (1): 124–156.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  19. Harris, K. 2017. Correctional Service Flip-Flops on Transgender Inmate Placement Policy. CBC News, January 13. Accessed January 15, 2017.
  20. Heilpern, D. M. 1998. Fear or Favour: Sexual Assault of Young Prisoners. Lismore: Southern Cross University Press.Google Scholar
  21. Jackson, M. 2002. Justice Behind the Walls: Human Rights in Canadian Prisons. Madeira Park: Douglas & McIntyre.Google Scholar
  22. Johnson, K., and S. Castle. 1997. Prisoner of Gender: A Transsexual and the System. Vancouver: Perceptions Press.Google Scholar
  23. Kavanagh v. Canada (Attorney General), [2001] 41 CHRR 119.Google Scholar
  24. Kirkup, K. 2009. Indocile Bodies: Gender Identity and Strip Searches in Canadian Criminal Law. Canadian Journal of Law and Society 24 (1): 107–125.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  25. ———. 2016. How Ontario’s Prisons Pioneered Sensitivity to Transgender Inmates. TVO, January 26. Accessed January 15, 2017.
  26. ———. 2018. The Origins of Gender Identity and Gender Expression in Anglo-American Legal Discourse. University of Toronto Law Journal 68 (1): 80–117.Google Scholar
  27. Kutchins, H., and S. A. Kirk. 1997. Making us Crazy: DSM; The Psychiatric Bible and the Creation of Mental Disorders. New York: The Free Press.Google Scholar
  28. Lamble, S. 2013. Queer Necropolitics and the Expanding Carceral State: Interrogating Sexual Investments in Punishment. Law and Critique 24 (3): 229–253.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  29. Linander, I., E. Alm, A. Hammarström, and L. Harryson. 2017. Negotiating the (Bio)Medical Gaze – Experiences of Trans-Specific Healthcare in Sweden. Social Science & Medicine 174: 10–11.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  30. Metcalfe, J. 2014. Transgender Prisoners – Access to Sex Reassignment Surgery. Prisoners’ Legal Services, March 20. Accessed January 15, 2017.
  31. Pemberton, S. 2013. Enforcing Gender: The Constitution of Sex and Gender in Prison Regimes. Signs 39 (1): 151–175.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  32. R. v. Kavanagh, [1989] OJ no 2620 (QL) (Ont H Ct J).Google Scholar
  33. Shaylor, C. 2008. Neither Kind Nor Gentle: The Perils of ‘Gender Responsive Justice’. In The Violence of Incarceration, ed. P. Scraton and J. McCulloch, 145–163. New York: Routledge.Google Scholar
  34. Shrage, L. J., ed. 2009. You’ve Changed: Sex Reassignment and Personal Identity. Oxford: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
  35. Spade, D. 2011. Normal Life: Administrative Violence, Critical Trans Politics, and the Limits of Law. Brooklyn: South End Press.Google Scholar
  36. ———. 2012. The Only Way to End Racialized Gender Violence in Prisons Is to End Prisons: A Response to Russell Robinson’s ‘Masculinity as Prison’. California Law Review Circuit 3: 184–195.Google Scholar
  37. Stanley, E. A., and N. Smith, eds. 2011. Captive Genders: Trans Embodiment and the Prison Industrial Complex. Edinburgh: AK Press.Google Scholar
  38. United Nations Special Rapporteur. 2011. Torture and Other Cruel, Inhuman or Degrading Treatment or Punishment. Geneva: United Nations.Google Scholar
  39. Wynn, J. R., and A. Szatrowski. 2004. Hidden Prisons: Twenty-Three House Lockdown Units in New York State Correctional Facilities. Pace Law Review 24 (2): 497–525.Google Scholar

Copyright information

© The Author(s) 2018

Authors and Affiliations

  1. 1.Faculty of LawUniversity of OttawaOttawaCanada

Personalised recommendations