Republican Fragmentation in the Face of Enduring Partition

  • Anthony McIntyreEmail author


McIntyre looks at the widespread fragmentation within republicanism and examines the more salient causes. He contends that within the nationalist constituency, constitutional nationalism has a hegemonic position that is virtually unassailable from within. The chapter questions what—if any—potential there exists for republicanism to overcome its disparate composition to the point where it can challenge the current nationalist hegemon.


  1. Adams, G. (1986). The politics of Irish freedom. Dingle: Brandon/Mount Eagle Publications.Google Scholar
  2. Adams, G. (2017). Irish unity is achievable and winnable. Available at
  3. Bean, K. (2007). The new politics of Sinn Fein. Liverpool: Liverpool University Press.Google Scholar
  4. Bresnahan, S. (2017). Interview with Author.Google Scholar
  5. Bresnahan, S. (2018). And what of the Irish republic? Available at
  6. Carson, N., & Hoey, P. (2012). The bell and the blanket: Journals of Irish republican dissent. New Hibernia Review, 16(1), 75–93.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  7. Clarke, B. (2013). Marian price media blackout. Blogspot. Available at
  8. Clarke, L., & Jones, M. (1999, March 28). Trimble shows more flexibility over IRA arms. The Sunday Times.Google Scholar
  9. Collins, J. (2017). Sinn Féin and coalition with Fine Gael. Available at
  10. De Bréadun, D. (2000, February 9). Time has come for last roll of dice. The Irish Times.Google Scholar
  11. Edwards, A., & Brennan, S. (2016). Can peace building be made more effective in Northern Ireland? Presented at Political Studies Association Ireland Annual Conference.Google Scholar
  12. Ferguson, P. (2008). The new politics of Sinn Fein by Bean, K. Reviewed on The Irish Revolution. Wordpress. Available at
  13. Hodgins, G. (2017). Interview with Author.Google Scholar
  14. Kelly, G. (2017, August 7). PSNI stance on legacy matters; The British Government Turn a Blind Eye. Available at
  15. Kelly, S. (2017). Failed political entity. Dublin: Merrion Press.Google Scholar
  16. McCann, E. (2007). Photocalls do not reflect street level reality. Available at
  17. McDonald, H., & Holland, J. (2010). Deadly divisions. Poolbeg Press.Google Scholar
  18. McGlinchey, D. (2017). Interview with Author.Google Scholar
  19. McIntyre, A. (1999). A structural analysis of modern Irish republicanism 1969–1973. Unpublished Ph.D. QUB.Google Scholar
  20. McIntyre, A. (2003). A secret history gets told in galway. Available at
  21. McIntyre, A. (2010). Great hatred little room by Powell, J. Reviewed in The Pensive Quill. Available at
  22. McKearney, T. (2017a). Sinn Fein edging towards social democracy. Available at
  23. McKearney, T. (2017b). Interview with Author.Google Scholar
  24. Millar, F. (2009). Northern Ireland: A triumph of politics. Dublin: Irish Academic Press.Google Scholar
  25. Mooney, J., & O’Toole, M. (2003). Black operations: The secret war against the real IRA. Dunboyne: Maverick House.Google Scholar
  26. Morrison, D. (1999, July 13). Stretching republicans too far. The Guardian.Google Scholar
  27. Morrison, D. (2002, October 14). Get on with the business of peace. The Guardian.Google Scholar
  28. Murray, G., & Tonge, J. (2005). Sinn Fein and the SDLP: From alienation to participation (p. 234). London: Hurst & Company.Google Scholar
  29. O’Donghalie, D. (2017). Interview with Author.Google Scholar
  30. O’Rawe, R. (2011, December 12). Provo bosses let hunger-strikers die—They know who they are and so do I. Available at
  31. O’Rawe, R. (2016). Blanketmen. Dublin: New Island Books.Google Scholar
  32. O’Rawe, R. (2017). Interview with Author.Google Scholar
  33. Perry, N. (2017). Saoradh: Are the politics of republican dissent back in vogue? Available at
  34. Reddit. (2017). Will the ‘Constitutional Question’ ever go away? Available at
  35. Spencer, B. J. (2015). Sinn Fein revisionism. Available at
  36. Staff Journalist. (1998, September 7). New arena of struggle. An Phoblacht. Available at
  37. Staff Journalist. (2007, January 26). Sinn Fein pledges to put manners on PSNI. Belfast Telegraph. Available at
  38. Staff Journalist. (2007, September 12). The Nick Stadlen interview with Gerry Adams: Part II. The Guardian.Google Scholar
  39. Staff Journalist. (2010, February 8). INLA confirms decommissioning move. RTÉ News. Available at
  40. Staff Journalist. (2013, June 6). Ruairi O’ Bradaigh, Irish republican dies. The Guardian. Available at
  41. Staff Journalist. (2014, December 2). SF disputes on-air resignation of claimed party member after Kelly backs informers. News Letter. Available at
  42. Staff Journalist. (2015, August 22). Kevin McGuigan murder: Provisional IRA still exists, says PSNI chief. BBC News. Available at
  43. Staff Journalist. (2016, February 24). Do not worry about Gerry Adams and Sinn Féin. The Irish Times. Available at
  44. Staff Journalist. (2016, March 12). Leading republican Tony Taylor returned to prison after licence revoked. The Irish News. Available at
  45. Staff Journalist. (2017, January 5). Northern Ireland’s peace process not too big to fail. New Statesman. Available at
  46. Staff Journalist. (2017, January 10). Grassroots revolt as the Sinn Féin leadership at last playing catch-up. The Irish Independent. Available at
  47. Staff Journalist. (2017, January 14). Arlene Foster’s tarnished image could see DUP battered at the polling booths. Belfast Telegraph. Available at
  48. Staff Journalist. (2017, April 20). The murky world of spying during the troubles. The Irish Times. Available at
  49. Staff Journalist. (2017, July 2). Sinn Féin can’t demand 10-0 win in Stormont talks, says DUP. BBC News. Available at
  50. Staff Journalist. (2017, July 19). Why republican dissidents have not—And will not—Go away. The Irish Times. Available at
  51. Staff Journalist. (2017, August 4). Taking the plunge: McDonald wants full coalition deal for Sinn Féin. The Irish Times. Available at
  52. Staff Journalist. (2017, September 16). Sinn Féin demeans women and is ‘power and money mad’, ex-councillor claims. The Irish Times. Available atéin-demeans-women-and-is-power-and-money-mad-ex-councillor-claims-1.3223795#.Wb011hhcCIk.twitter.
  53. Staff Journalist. (2017, December 12). PSNI are wary of ‘severe’ dissident republican threat. The Newry Democrat. Available at
  54. Staff Journalist. (2018, January 8). Is three-month suspension from Sinn Fein with full pay adequate for Barry McElduff? The Belfast Telegraph. Available at
  55. Tonge, J. (2014). A campaign without end? ‘Dissident’ republican violence in Northern Ireland. Political Insight. Available at Scholar
  56. Treacy, M. (2017a). Interview with Author.Google Scholar
  57. Treacy, M. (2017b). A tunnel to the moon: The end of the Irish republican army. Dublin: Brocaire Books.Google Scholar
  58. Twomey, C. (2017). The bare face of fascism. Available at
  59. White, L. W. (2005). Peadar O’Donnell, ‘real republicanism’ and the bell. The Republic: Culture in the Republic, Part II. Issue 4. pp. 80–99. Available at
  60. White, R. (2017). Out of the ashes. Dublin: Merrion Press.Google Scholar
  61. Wordpress. (n.d.). Volunteer Joseph O’Connor. Available at
  62. Young, D. (2017). Gerry Adams: DUP guilty of “deliberate provocation, arrogance, and disrespect”. Available at

Copyright information

© The Author(s) 2018

Authors and Affiliations

  1. 1.Independent ResearcherBelfastNorthern Ireland

Personalised recommendations