Advertisement

New Archival Evidence on the 1977 Vrancea, Romania Earthquake and Its Impact on Disaster Management and Seismic Risk

  • Emil-Sever Georgescu
  • Antonios Pomonis
Conference paper
Part of the Springer Natural Hazards book series (SPRINGERNAT)

Abstract

The March 4, 1977, Vrancea earthquake was Romania’s greatest natural disaster in the 20th century. Today, forty years later, its impact, but also post-disaster actions and policies, continue to influence seismic risk. Based on lessons learnt, an improved seismic design code was introduced in 1978 for new construction, but in July 1977 for damaged buildings all strengthening projects were abruptly stopped by a high level political order that allowed only local—often cosmetic- repairs. After 1989, many state archives have been opened, helping us deepen our understanding of how disaster management was conducted in that time. This paper reveals new findings and data on building damage and human casualties. This new evidence suggests that nearly a quarter of the lives lost in Bucharest were not in collapsed multi-story buildings, but in other, yet to be investigated, locations. Also new evidence about the unidentified victims lifts popular doubts on this issue. Lastly, the authors analyze the July 4, 1977, government decision to end the seismic reinforcement of damaged buildings and the debate at the time between specialists and government officials.

Keywords

Building damage and collapse Casualties Strengthening Repair Bucharest Civic center 

Notes

Acknowledgements

The authors express their gratefulness to the NIRD URBAN-INCERC, Bucharest, Romania for providing a framework of research activity and related documentary data, as well as for the financing of Ministry of Research and Innovation within the Nucleu Programme CRESC, Project PN 16 10.01.01, “Integrated concept of seismic monitoring and instrumentation to characterize seismic safety…”, Phase 3/2017.

A first-shorter version of this paper, published in Proceedings of The 6-th National Conference on Earthquake Engineering and 2-nd National Conference on Earthquake Engineering and Seismology, Bucharest, Romania, June 14–17, 2017, was co-authored with Dr. Karin Steinbrueck, Independent Scholar, Evanston, IL, USA. Without her archive research efforts this publication would not have been possible.

References

  1. ANR, CCRCP (1977) Arhivele Naţionale ale României (ANR), Central Committee of the Romanian Communist Party (CCRCP): Section of Economics, 78/1977; Section of Economics, 41/1977 (Minutes of the meeting of March 22, 1977); Section of Administrative and Politics, 12/1977, 2/1977; Chancellery 18/1977 (Minutes of the meeting of March 5, 1977); Chancellery 21/1977 (Minutes of the meeting of March 6, 1977); Chancellery 28/1977 (Minutes of the meeting of March 10, 1977); Chancellery 42/1977 (Minutes of the meeting of March 30, 1977)Google Scholar
  2. Balan S, Cristescu V, Cornea I (coordinators) (1982) The Romania earthquake of March 1977 (in Romanian, with English abstract). Editura Academiei, Bucharest, RomaniaGoogle Scholar
  3. Berg GV, Bolt BA, Sozen MA, Rojahn C (1980) Earthquake in Romania March 4, 1977. An engineering report. National Academy Press, Washington, DCGoogle Scholar
  4. Boia L (2016) The strange history of Romanian communism (and its unhappy consequences), in Romanian—Strania istorie a comunismului românesc (şi nefericitele ei consecinţe). Humanitas Publishing House, BucharestGoogle Scholar
  5. BSSA (1978) Seismological notes—March-April 1977. Bull Seismol Soc Am 68(6):1781–1783Google Scholar
  6. Buhoiu A (Coordonator) (1977) Secunde tragice, zile eroice. Din cronica unui cutremur. Editura Junimea, IaşiGoogle Scholar
  7. CNSAS Archives (1977) Consiliul Naţional pentru Studierea Arhivelor Securităţii. Direcţia Cercetare, Dezvoltare, Publicaţii. Chancellery 9665 (D 011737/vol. 105)Google Scholar
  8. Fattal G, Simiu E, Culver C (1977) Observation on the behaviour of buildings in the Romanian earthquake of March 4, 1977. US Department of Commerce, Sept 1977, NBS Special Publication 490Google Scholar
  9. Fundaţia “Gheorghe Ursu” (2017). Accessed 1 May 2017Google Scholar
  10. Georgescu ES (2003) Earthquake engineering development before and after the March 4, 1977, Vrancea, Romania earthquake. Symposium “25 years of Research in Earth Physics”, National Institute for Earth Physics, 25–27 Sept 2002. Bucharest. St. Cerc. GEOFIZICA, Tomul 1, pp 93–107Google Scholar
  11. Georgescu ES, Kuribayashi E (1992) Study on seismic losses distribution in Romania and Japan. In: Proceedings of 10-th WCEE, Madrid, Balkema, RotterdamGoogle Scholar
  12. Georgescu ES, Pomonis A (2007) The Romanian Earthquake of March 4, 1977: new insights in terms of territorial, economic and social impacts. In: International symposium on strong Vrancea earthquakes and risk mitigation, 4–6 Oct 2007, International Conference Center of the Parliament of Romania, Bucharest. Symposium jointly organized by the UTCB Bucharest and the CRC 461 University of Karlsruhe, GermanyGoogle Scholar
  13. Georgescu ES, Pomonis A (2008) The Romanian earthquake of March 4, 1977 revisited: new insights into its territorial, economic and social impacts and their bearing on the preparedness for the future. In: Proceedings of 14th World Conference on Earthquake Engineering, Beijing, China, 12–17 Oct 2008Google Scholar
  14. Georgescu ES, Pomonis A (2010) Human casualties due to the Vrancea, Romania earthquakes of 1940 and 1977: learning from past to prepare for future events. In: Proceedings of Mizunami international symposium on earthquake casualties and health consequences, Mizunami, Gifu, Japan, 15–16 Nov 2010Google Scholar
  15. Georgescu ES, Pomonis A (2011) Emergency management in Vrancea (Romania) earthquakes of 1940 and 1977: casualty patterns vs. search and rescue needs. In: Proceedings of TIEMS 2011—The International Emergency Management Society, the 18th annual conference, Bucharest, RomaniaGoogle Scholar
  16. Georgescu ES, Pomonis A (2012) Building damage vs. territorial casualty patterns during the Vrancea (Romania) earthquakes of 1940 and 1977. In: Proceedings of 15th WCEE, Lisbon, PortugalGoogle Scholar
  17. ICCPDC (1978) Internal Report on the Romania Earthquake of 4 March 1977 “Cutremurul din Romania din 4 martie 1977 si efectele sale asupra constructiilor”. Editia interna ICCPDC, BucurestiGoogle Scholar
  18. IGSIC instructions letter (1977) The official letter of Council of Ministers/IGSIC—General State Inspectorate for Investments and Constructions to the Executive Committee of the People’s Council of Bucharest Municipality. Registration number not readable. Written after March 30, 1977. Personal photocopy of E.S. GeorgescuGoogle Scholar
  19. IGSIC Telex No. 1264 (1977) IGSIC Telex number 11264/75/15817 from July 8, 1977. Registered by hand under No. 7387/11.VII 1977 at ICB—Institutul de Constructii Bucuresti (presently UTCB-Technical University of Civil Engineering of Bucharest). Personal photocopy of E.S. GeorgescuGoogle Scholar
  20. INCERC Instructions (1975) Instrucţiuni tehnice privind folosirea pastei de ciment şi a amestecurilor pe bază de polimeri la remedieri de defecte ale lucrărilor de constructii şi la lucrări speciale, indicativ C 149-75, aprobate cu ordinul IGSIC nr.190 din 8 decembrie 1975, p 107. In: Buletinul Construcţiilor, vol 1, 1976. Editat de M. C. Ind.—INCERCGoogle Scholar
  21. INCERC Instructions (1977) Instrucţiuni tehnice privind injectarea fisurilor din elemente de beton armat cu răşini epoxidice,indicativ C 183-77, aprobate prin decizia ICCPDC nr. 88 din 12 iulie 1977, pp 118–130. In: Buletinul Construcţiilor, vol 6, 1977. Editat de: ICCPDC-INCERCGoogle Scholar
  22. Jones BG (1986) Planning and management for the prevention and mitigation of natural disasters in a metropolitan context, vol 3. Planning for Crisis Relief. United Nations Centre for Regional Development, pp 31–42, 24–30 Sept 1986, Nagoya, Shizuoka and Tokyo Sessions. UNCRD, JapanGoogle Scholar
  23. Jones BG, Avgar A (1977) A Protocol on the effects on urban systems of the earthquake in Romania of March 4 (unpublished paper)Google Scholar
  24. Law No. 8/1977 (1977) Legea nr. 8/1977 privind siguranta constructiilor. Monitorul Oficial, nr. 64, July 9, 1977. Accessed 15 May 2017. http://www.legex.ro/Legea-8-1977-630.aspx
  25. Povestea Vorbei, nr. 195 (1979) The Radio Free Europe program, Povestea Vorbei transcript based on a text from a letter sent by the engineer Gheorghe Ursu. Povestea Vorbei nr. 195, Aniversarea cutremurului by Virgil Ierunca, Sunday March 4, 1979, Romanian Broadcasting Department, box 3811, folder 2, Radio Free Europe/Radio Liberty, Romania Broadcast Department, 1960–1995, Hoover Institution ArchivesGoogle Scholar
  26. Sandi H, Pomonis A, Francis S, Georgescu ES, Mohindra R, Borcia IS (2008) Development of a nationwide seismic vulnerability estimation system. In: Proceedings of the symposium thirty years from the Romania earthquake of March 4, 1977, Bucharest, Romania, 1–3 March 2007, CONSTRUCTII, No. 1/2008, pp 38–47. Retrieved from http://constructii.incerc2004.ro/Archive/2008-1/2008-1-5.pdf
  27. Scinteia (1977) The Newspaper of Central Committee of Romanian Communist PartyGoogle Scholar
  28. Steinbrueck K (2017) Aftershocks: Nicolae Ceauşescu and the Romanian Communist Regime’s Responses to the 1977 Earthquake. Unpublished Ph.D. dissertation, Northwestern University, EvanstonGoogle Scholar
  29. Ţiu I (2014) Sfera Politicii, Nr 178/martie-aprilie 2014Google Scholar
  30. US Congress Records (1977). Foreign Assistance and Related Agencies Appropriations for 1978. 8 Sept 1977Google Scholar
  31. US Diplomatic or State Department cables (1977) Wikileaks “dump”—“US library of public diplomacy,” including telexes between the US Embassy Bucharest and the US State Department in DC and Belgrade. https://wikileaks.org/plusd/about/
  32. World Bank (1978) Report No. P-2240-RO, Report and recommendation of the president of the international bank for reconstruction and development to the executive directors on a proposed loan to the investment bank with the guarantee of the socialist Republic of Romania for a Post Earthquake Construction Assistance Project, 17 May 1978Google Scholar
  33. World Bank (1983) Report No. 4791, Project completion Report. Romania—Post Earthquake Construction Assistance Project, Loan 1581-RO, 18 Nov 1983Google Scholar

Copyright information

© Springer International Publishing AG, part of Springer Nature 2018

Authors and Affiliations

  1. 1.National Institute for Research and Development—URBAN-INCERCBucharestRomania
  2. 2.Cambridge Architectural Research LtdCambridgeUK

Personalised recommendations