Advertisement

Goethe contra Newton on Colours, Light, and the Philosophy of Science

Chapter
Part of the Synthese Library book series (SYLI, volume 388)

Abstract

Goethe carried out an enormous number of experiments before criticizing Newton’s theory of light and colours in the Farbenlehre (1810). He managed to show that Newton’s reasoning is based on a rather narrow choice of experiments, in which parameters such as the distance between the prism and the screen are fixed arbitrarily: Newton’s famous spectrum (with its green centre) occurs only at a specific distance. Once you reduce the distance, the green centre disappears, and you see the two border spectra instead. Newton can of course explain these border spectra; but things can be explained just as well the other way around: Then you start with a theory based on the two border spectra in order to derive the Newtonian spectrum. Both accounts fit many data (available in Newton and Goethe’s days) equally well. Thus by insisting that the step to theory is not forced upon us by “reason and experiments” alone (as Newton would have it), Goethe revealed our own free, creative contribution to theory construction. And surprisingly, his theory of the prismatic colours seems no worse off than Newton’s, even taking into account additional criteria of theory choice, such as simplicity or elegance.

References

  1. Amrine, F., Zucker, F. J., & Wheeler, H. (Eds.). (1987). [GS]: Goethe and the sciences. A reappraisal. Dordrecht: Reidel.Google Scholar
  2. Bjerke, A. (1963). [NBzG]: Neue Beiträge zu Goethes Farbenlehre. Erster Teil. Goethe contra Newton (L. Funk, Trans.). Stuttgart: Verlag Freies Geistesleben.Google Scholar
  3. Born, M. (1963). [BzF]: Betrachtungen zur Farbenlehre. Die Naturwissenschaften, 50(2), 29–39.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  4. Bushart, M., & Steinle, F. (Eds.). (2015). [CH]: Colour histories. Science, art, and technology in the 17th and 18th centuries. Berlin: de Gruyter.Google Scholar
  5. Corriero, E. C., & Dezi, A. (Eds.). (2013). [NRiS]: Nature and realism in Schelling’s philosophy. Turin: Accademia University Press.Google Scholar
  6. Desaguliers, J. T. (1716). [AoSE]: An account of some experiments of light and colours, formerly made by Sir Isaac Newton, and mention’d in his opticks, lately repeated before the Royal Society. Philosophical Transactions, 29(348), 433–447.Google Scholar
  7. Doncel, M. G., Hermann, A., Michel, L., & Pais, A. (Eds.). (1987). [SiP]: Symmetries in physics (1600–1980). 1st international meeting on the history of scientific ideas, Sant Feliu de Guíxols, Catalonia, Spain. September 20–26, 1983. Bellaterra: Seminari d’Història de les Ciènces, Universitat Autònoma de Barcelona.Google Scholar
  8. Duhem, P. (1954). [ASoP]: The aim and structure of physical theory. Princeton: Princeton University Press.Google Scholar
  9. Goethe, J. W. (1840). [GTC]: Goethe’s theory of colours (C. L. Eastlake, Trans.). London: Murray.Google Scholar
  10. Goethe, J. W. (1947ff). [LA]: “Leopoldina-Ausgabe”: Die Schriften zur Naturwissenschaft. 30 volumes in three sections, edited by Dorothea Kuhn, Rupprecht Matthaei, and others. Weimar: Böhlau. [All references are given in this form: Goethe [LA]/section.volume:pages resp. paragraphs].Google Scholar
  11. Goethe, J. W. (1995). [SS]: Scientific studies. The collected works. Volume 12. (D. Miller, Ed., & Trans.). Princeton: Princeton University Press.Google Scholar
  12. Goethe, J. W. [ToC]: Theory of color. Didactic section (D. Miller, Ed., & Trans.). In Goethe [SS]:157–302. [Six plates are reprinted there following p. 206].Google Scholar
  13. Hegge, H.. [ToSi]: Theory of science in the light of Goethe’s science of nature. In Amrine et al. (Eds.) [GS]:195–218.Google Scholar
  14. Helbig, H. (2004). [NO]: Naturgemäße Ordnung. Darstellung und Methode in Goethes Lehre von den Farben. Köln: Böhlau.Google Scholar
  15. Kuhn, T. (1970). [SoSR]: The Structure of scientific revolutions. Chicago: Chicago University Press.Google Scholar
  16. Mausfeld, R. (1996) [WANS]: ‘Wär’ nicht das Auge sonnenhaft… Goethes Farbenlehre: Nur eine Poesie des Chromatischen oder ein Beitrag zu einer naturwissenschaftlichen Psychologie? ZiF: Mitteilungen 4/96 pp. 3–27.Google Scholar
  17. Müller, O. (2015). [ML]: Mehr Licht. Goethe mit Newton im Streit um die Farben. Frankfurt am Main: Fischer. www.farbenstreit.de
  18. Müller, O. (2016). [PE]: Prismatic equivalence. A new case of underdetermination. Goethe vs. Newton on the prism experiments. The British Journal for the History of Philosophy, 24(2), 322–346.Google Scholar
  19. Müller, O. [BSiS]: Border spectra in the skies of Hokusai and Hiroshige. Japanese traces of Newton or Goethe? A colour mystery. In Bushart et al. (Eds.): [CH]:129–144, 376–381.Google Scholar
  20. Müller, O. [CSC]: Colour spectral counterpoints. Case study on aesthetic judgement in the experimental sciences. In Nussbaumer [RvI]:150–169. http://nbn-resolving.de/urn:nbn:de:kobv:11-100180762
  21. Müller, O. [GPmS]: Goethes Pech mit Schelling. Optimistische Blicke auf ein ideengeschichtliches Fiasko. In Corriero et al. (Eds.) [NRiS]:131–185. http://nbn-resolving.de/urn:nbn:de:kobv:11-100228398.
  22. Müller, O. [GPUb]: Goethes philosophisches Unbehagen beim Blick durchs Prisma. In Steinbrenner et al. (Eds.) [F]:pp. 64–101.Google Scholar
  23. Müller, O. [ZSUF]: Zu schön, um falsch zu sein. Über die erkenntnisleitende Rolle des Schönheitssinns in der Physik. Frankfurt/Main: Fischer (Forthcoming).Google Scholar
  24. Newton, I. [NTaL]: A new theory about light and colors. Philosophical Transactions 80 February 19, 1671/2, pp. 3075–3087.Google Scholar
  25. Newton, I. (1964a). [OQEO]/III: Opera quae extant omnia. Tom. III. Stuttgart: Friedrich Frommann Verlag.Google Scholar
  26. Newton, I. (1964b). [OQEO]/IV: Opera quae extant omnia. Tom. IV. Stuttgart: Friedrich Frommann Verlag.Google Scholar
  27. Newton, I. (1973). [UFVo]: The unpublished first version of Isaac Newton’s Cambridge lectures on optics 1670–1672. In D. T. Whiteside (Ed.). Cambridge: Cambridge University Library.Google Scholar
  28. Newton, I. [PNPM]: Philosophiae naturalis principia mathematica. In Newton [OQEO]/III:1–174.Google Scholar
  29. Newton, I. [O]: Optics: or, A treatise of the reflections, refractions, inflections and colours of light. In Newton [OQEO]/IV:1–264.Google Scholar
  30. Nussbaumer, I. (2010). [RvI]: Restraint versus intervention. Painting as alignment. Nürnberg: Verlag für moderne Kunst.Google Scholar
  31. Quine, W. V. O. (1975). [oEES]: On empirically equivalent systems of the world. Erkenntnis, 9(3), 313–328.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  32. Quine, W. V. O., & Ullian J. S. (1978). [WoB]: The web of belief (2nd ed.). New York: Random House.Google Scholar
  33. Steinbrenner, J., & Glasauer, S. (Eds.). (2007). [F]: Farben. Betrachtungen aus Philosophie und Naturwissenschaften. Frankfurt/Main: Suhrkamp.Google Scholar

Copyright information

© Springer International Publishing AG 2017

Authors and Affiliations

  1. 1.Institute for Philosophy, Humboldt UniversityBerlinGermany

Personalised recommendations