Punishment and Privacy

  • Daniel Marshall
  • Terry Thomas


Life in prison or on a community sentence inevitably impacts on matters of privacy. Prisoners have records opened up on them and have their photographs taken. Prisoners may have DNA samples taken from them, using reasonable force if necessary, and officers use various techniques of control and restraint to maintain order in prisons. Article 8 of the European Convention has been interpreted as protecting not just privacy but the right to physical integrity and is capable of protecting individuals against forms of involuntary ill-treatment. Electronic monitoring as a form of community sentence in particular, for all its invasion of privacy, does provide a more economic and ‘normal’ existence for the wearer compared to a custodial sentence in prison


  1. BBC News (2008c) Call for Prison Bugging Inquiry, 9 February (available at http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/uk_politics/7236536.stm accessed 25 November 2016).
  2. BBC News (2012b) Most Prisons Are Overcrowded – Prison Reform Trust, 28 August (available at http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-19395427 accessed 24 November 2016).
  3. BBC News (2014b) Full Jails Told to Take in More Prisoners, 13 June (available at http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-27836961 accessed 18 November 2016).
  4. BBC News (2017b) Transgender Woman Found Dead in Cell at HMP Doncaster, 5 January (available at http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-south-yorkshire-38518833 accessed 18 March 2017).
  5. Birth Companions (2016) Birth Charter for Women in Prisons in England and Wales, March, London (available at http://www.birthcompanions.org.uk/media/Public/Resources/Ourpublications/Birth_Charter_Online_copy.pdf accessed 24 November 2016).
  6. Brown S (2014) Synthetic Cannabis Causing Serious Health Problems in English Prisons. The Guardian, 15 May.Google Scholar
  7. Buchanan RT (2015) Transgender Woman Joanne Latham Dies in Milton Keynes Male Prison. The Independent, 1 December.Google Scholar
  8. Cabinet Office (2008a) Engaging Communities in Fighting Crime, London.Google Scholar
  9. Cameron D (2016) Prison Reform: Prime Minister’s Speech, 8 February (available at: https://www.gov.uk/government/speeches/prison-reform-prime-ministers-speech accessed 22 November 2016).
  10. CoE (Council of Europe) (1950) European Convention on Human Rights, Strasbourg.Google Scholar
  11. Corston Report (2007) A Report by Baroness Jean Corston of a Review of Women with Particular Vulnerabilities in the Criminal Justice System, London.Google Scholar
  12. CSJ (Centre for Social Justice) (2015) Drugs in Prison, March (available at http://www.centreforsocialjustice.org.uk/core/wp-content/uploads/2016/08/CSJJ3090_Drugs_in_Prison.pdf accessed 22 November 2016).
  13. Davies M, Croall H and Tyrer J (2010) Criminal Justice (4th ed.), Harlow: Pearson Education Ltd.Google Scholar
  14. Dyer C (2003a) Law Lords Rule There Is No Right to Privacy. The Guardian, 17 October.Google Scholar
  15. Fenton S (2016) The Women Forced to Give Birth in Front of Prison Guards. The Independent, 25 May.Google Scholar
  16. Franklin B and Murphy D (1991) Local Rags with a Reputation in Tatters. The Independent, 30 October.Google Scholar
  17. Gayle D (2015) Transgender Prisoner at HMP Bristol ‘Being Sexually Harassed’. The Guardian, 20 November.Google Scholar
  18. Gov.uk (2009) Prison, Probation and Rehabilitation: Public Protection Manual (available at https://www.gov.uk/government/collections/prison-probation-and-rehabilitation-public-protection-manual accessed 21 April 2017).
  19. Gov.uk (2017b) Apply for a Gender Recognition Certificate, London (Available at https://www.gov.uk/apply-gender-recognition-certificate/overview accessed 8 May 2017).
  20. Hamilton M and Sims P (2016) Johnson in the Perm-ier League: Footie paedo Has Landed ‘Cushy’ Job Inside as a BARBER. The Sun, 23 May.Google Scholar
  21. Home Office (1964) Children and Young Persons Act 1963: Parts 1 and 11 (Circular No. 22/1964), London.Google Scholar
  22. Home Office (1989) Press Access to Court Lists and to the Register of Decisions in Magistrates Courts (Circular 80/1989), London.Google Scholar
  23. Home Office (2008) Government Responds to Casey Report (Press Release) 18 June, London.Google Scholar
  24. Home Office (2012b) The Government’s Alcohol Strategy, Cm 8336, March, London.Google Scholar
  25. Home Office (2013e) Using Conditional Cautions with Sobriety Requirements, London: Home Office.Google Scholar
  26. House of Commons (2015e) Transgender Equality Inquiry, Women and Equalities Committee (1st Report of Session 2015–16), HC 390, October, London.Google Scholar
  27. Mair G and Nee C (1990) Electronic Monitoring: The Trials and Their Results, Home Office Research Study 120, London: HMSO.Google Scholar
  28. Mair G and Mortimer E (1996) Curfew Orders with Electronic Monitoring. Research Study No. 163, London: Home Office.Google Scholar
  29. MoJ (Ministry of Justice) (2008a) Disrupting the Supply of Illicit Drugs into Prisons: A Report for the Director General of National Offender Management Service by David Blakey, May.Google Scholar
  30. MoJ (Ministry of Justice) (2008b) Offenders to Wear High-Visibility Jackets on ‘Payback’ (Press Release) 1 December.Google Scholar
  31. MoJ (Ministry of Justice) (2016c) Prison Safety and Reform, Cm 9350, November, London.Google Scholar
  32. MoJ (Ministry of Justice) (2016d), Review on the Care and Management of Transgender Offenders, November, London.Google Scholar
  33. MoJ (Ministry of Justice) (2016e) Official Statistics – Prisoner Transgender Statistics, March/April 2016 England and Wales – 9 November, London.Google Scholar
  34. MoJ (Ministry of Justice) (2016f) ‘Sobriety Tags’ Rolled Out Across London (Press Release) 25 February, London.Google Scholar
  35. MoJ (Ministry of Justice), Home Office and Attorney General’s Office (2009) Engaging Communities in Criminal Justice, April, Cm 7583, London.Google Scholar
  36. MoJ (Ministry of Justice), NOMS, and HM Prison Service (2017) Prison Population Figures: 2017, May (available at https://www.gov.uk/government/statistics/prison-population-figures-2017 accessed 8 May 2017).
  37. NAPO (National Association of Probation Officers) (2008) High Visibility Vests – Threats, Abuse, Boycotts and Legal Issues (Press Release) 30 December, London.Google Scholar
  38. NCA (National Crime Agency) (2016) National Strategic Assessment of Serious and Organised Crime 2016, 9 September, London.Google Scholar
  39. NOMS (National Offender Management Service) (2011) Care and Management of Transsexual Prisoners (Reference PSI 7/2011), London.Google Scholar
  40. NOMS (National Offender Management Service) (2012b) Certified Prisoner Accommodation (Reference PSI 17/2012), London.Google Scholar
  41. NOMS (National Offender Management Service) (2014a) Mother and Baby Units (Reference PSI 49/2014), London.Google Scholar
  42. NOMS (National Offender Management Service) (2014b) Community Payback High Visibility Tabards (Reference PI 12/2014), London.Google Scholar
  43. NOMS (National Offender Management Service) (2016a) Searching of the Person (Reference PSI 07/2016), London.Google Scholar
  44. NOMS (National Offender Management Service) (2016b) Cells, Area and Vehicle Searching (Reference PSI 09/2016).Google Scholar
  45. NOMS (National Offender Management Service) (2016c) The Interception of Communications in Prisons and Security Measures (Reference PSI 04/2016).Google Scholar
  46. NOMS (National Offender Management Service) (2016d) The Care and Management of Transgender Offenders (Reference PSI 17/2016), London.Google Scholar
  47. Northamptonshire Police (8 December 2014) Northamptonshire Sobriety Bracelets Pilot Project: Update Northamptonshire: Northamptonshire Police (https://www.northants.police.uk/#!/News/24735).
  48. NPS (National Probation Service) (2005) Visible Unpaid Work (Reference PC 66/2005).Google Scholar
  49. OCJR (Office for Criminal Justice Reform) (2009) Publicising Sentence Outcomes: Guidance for Public Authorities on Publishing Information (Including Via the Internet) About Individual Sentencing Outcomes Within the Current Legal Framework, December, London.Google Scholar
  50. Pegg D and Evans R (2016) Controversial Snooping Technology ‘Used by at Least Seven Police Forces’. The Guardian, 10 October.Google Scholar
  51. Pepper M and Dawson P (2016) Alcohol Abstinence Monitoring Requirement: A Process Review of the Proof of Concept Pilot, London: MOPAC.Google Scholar
  52. Ramsbotham D (2005) Prison Gate – the Shocking State of Britain’s Prisons and the Need for Visionary Change, London: The Free Press.Google Scholar
  53. Robins J (2016) More than Half of Local Newspapers Don’t Have a Court Reporter. The Justice Gap (available at http://thejusticegap.com/2016/10/half-local-newspapers-dont-court-reporter/ accessed 19 March 2017).
  54. Russell B (2008) ‘Community Payback’ Vests Spark Rebellion by Probation Officers. The Independent, 30 December.Google Scholar
  55. Sabur R (2017) Police Investigate Allegations Criminals ‘Bribed Security Staff’ to Fit Their Electronic Tags Loosely to Evade Curfews. Daily Telegraph, 4 February.Google Scholar
  56. Sample I (2016) Synthetic Cannabis ‘Having a Devastating Impact in UK Prisons’. The Guardian, 1 May.Google Scholar
  57. Shute S (2007) Satellite Tracking of Offenders: A Study of the Pilots in England and Wales Research Summary No. 4, Ministry of Justice.Google Scholar
  58. Thomas T and Thompson D (2010) Making Offenders Visible. Howard Journal of Criminal Justice, 49(4): 340–348.Google Scholar
  59. UN (United Nations) (1990) Standard Minimum Rules for Non-custodial Measures (The ‘Tokyo Rules’) Resolution 45/110 of the General Assembly, 14 December, New York.Google Scholar
  60. Weston A (2016) New High-Tech System Trialled at Altcourse to Combat Prison ‘Throwovers’. Liverpool Echo, 6 December (available at http://www.liverpoolecho.co.uk/news/liverpool-news/new-high-tech-system-trialled-12277721?utm_content=buffer06b9c&utm_medium=social&utm_source=twitter.com&utm_campaign=buffer accessed 18 March 2017).
  61. Yorkshire Evening Post (2015) Transgender Woman Should Never Have Been Sent to Leeds Prison Says Grieving Partner, 20 November (available at: http://www.yorkshireeveningpost.co.uk/news/transgender-woman-should-never-have-been-sent-to-leeds-prison-says-grieving-partner-1-7581859 accessed 21 November 2016).

Copyright information

© The Author(s) 2017

Authors and Affiliations

  • Daniel Marshall
    • 1
  • Terry Thomas
    • 2
  1. 1.School of LawLiverpool John Moores UniversityLiverpoolUK
  2. 2.School of Social SciencesLeeds Beckett UniversityLeedsUK

Personalised recommendations