Land and Water Reforms in South Africa: “Men in White Coats”

  • Deepa JoshiEmail author
  • Natasha Donn-Arnold
  • Mart Kamphuis
Part of the Water Security in a New World book series (WSEC)


Despite numerous legislative attempts to redress past injustices, the redistribution of land and/or water remains a key challenge in post-apartheid South Africa. South Africa is currently identified as being in a state of a water crisis – and there are contentious and deeply polarized viewpoints on how the water security situation is linked to the transformation agenda. Through the narrative of an “emerging” female black farmer’s experiences with land and water reforms, this article gives a first-person account of the institutional barriers that keep intact an unequal, inequitable and unjust agrarian structure. The analysis also makes explicit how the transformatory agenda does not address the complexity of inequalities by race, crosscut as they are by gender and other social variables. By aiming to integrate an erroneously conceived homogeneous formerly excluded in an agrarian system meant to exclude them, the post-apartheid land and water reforms not only fail, but in turn make the formerly excluded “failed”. These analyses suggest that a feminist agenda which calls for a structural overhaul of policies and strategies as well as institutional structures and cultures might provide a much-needed antidote to the de-railed reform/justice agenda in South Africa.


Water redistribution Post-apartheid era Water security Female farmers Reform agenda Unjust agrarian system 


  1. Bond P (2004) Water commodification and decommodification narratives: pricing and policy debates from Johannesburg to Kyoto to Cancun and back. Capital Nat Social 15(1):7–25CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  2. Bond P (2013) Water rights, commons and advocacy narratives. S Afr J Hum Rights 29:125–143Google Scholar
  3. Borràs M (2016) The triad for an equitable society: agroecology, feminism, and solidarity economy. The Gender Lens: Essays by Students from Wageningen University, Gender and Natural Resources Management 2016, 7–9Google Scholar
  4. Cornwall A, Harrison E, Whitehead A (eds) (2007) Feminisms in development. Zed Books, London, pp 201–213Google Scholar
  5. Cousins B (2010) The politics of communal tenure reform: a South African case study. In: Anseeuw W, Alden C (eds) The struggle over land in Africa. HRC Press, Cape TownGoogle Scholar
  6. Cousins B (2016) Land reform in South Africa is sinking: can it be saved? University of Western Cape, PLAASGoogle Scholar
  7. Donn-Arnold N (2015) Title withheld. MSc honours thesis research report. Department of Geography and Environmental Studies, University of Western Cape, South Africa. 57ppGoogle Scholar
  8. Gaventa J, Cornwall A (2006) Challenging the boundaries of the possible: participation, knowledge and power. IDS Bull 37:122–128CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  9. Hall R, Cousins (2015) Commercial farming and agribusiness in South Africa and their changing roles in Africa’s agro-food system. In: International conference on rural transformations and food systems: the BRICS and agrarian change in the global South [online]. Cape Town, University of Western Cape. Available at: Accessed 24 May 2017
  10. Harrington C (2014) Water security in South Africa: the need to build social and ecological resilience.
  11. Jacobs P, Lahiff E, Hall R (2003) Land redistribution. Evaluating land and agrarian reform in South Africa series; no. 1. Programme for land and Agrarian studies, School of Government, University of the Western Cape: 34ppGoogle Scholar
  12. Kamphuis M (2015) Narratives of water: an assessment of capabilities of emerging and existing farmers in relation to the National Water act, South Africa. Master’s thesis: Wageningen UniversityGoogle Scholar
  13. Lahiff E, Li G (2012) Land distribution in South Africa: a critical review. The World Bank, Washington, DCCrossRefGoogle Scholar
  14. Mies M (1998) Globalization of the economy and women’s work in a sustainable society. Gend Technol Dev 2(1):3–37CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  15. Molyneux M (2007) The chimera of success: gender ennui and the changed international policy environment. In: Cornwall A, Harrison E, Whitehead A (eds) Feminisms in development: contradictions, contestations and challenges. ZED Books, London, pp 227–240Google Scholar
  16. Muller M et al (2009) Water security in South Africa. Development planning division. Working paper series no.12, DBSA: Midrand: 40ppGoogle Scholar
  17. Ncube B, Lagardian A (2014) Approaches for emerging farmer participation in water resource management: the case of the Breede-Gouritz Catchment Management Agency (BGCMA), Western Cape. Report on the review of water allocation in the Breede-Gouritz catchment management agency deliverable 1. CPUT, Cape TownGoogle Scholar
  18. Nussbaum M (2006) Frontiers of justice. Disability, nationality, species membership. Belknap Press, CambridgeGoogle Scholar
  19. Nussbaum M (2007) Human rights and human capabilities. Harvard Hum Rights J 20:21–24Google Scholar
  20. Nussbaum M (2011) Creating capabilities. The human development approach. Belknap Press, CambridgeCrossRefGoogle Scholar
  21. Sardenberg CMB (2007) Back to women? Translations, resignifications and myths of gender in policy and practice in Brazil. In: Cornwall A, Harrison E, Whitehead A (eds) Feminisms in development: contradictions, contestations and challenges. Zed Books, New York, pp 48–64Google Scholar
  22. Schalkwyk V et al (2012) Unlocking markets to smallholders. Lessons from South Africa, Mansholt publication series (10). Wageningen Academic Publishers, WageningenGoogle Scholar
  23. Turton A (2015) Sitting on the horns of a dilemma: water as a strategic resource in South Africa. IRR Bull 6(22):1–29Google Scholar
  24. Turton A et al (2004) A hydropolitical history of South Africa’s international river basins. Water Research Commission, Report no. 1220/1/04Google Scholar
  25. Van Koppen B, Schreiner B (2014a) Moving beyond integrated water resource management: developmental water management in South Africa. Int J Water Resour Dev 30(3):543–558CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  26. Van Koppen B, Schreiner B (2014b) Priority general authorisations in rights-based water use authorisation in South Africa. Water Policy 16(1):19CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  27. Vargas V (1992) The feminist movement in Latin America: between hope and disenchantment. Dev Chang 23:195–214CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  28. Walker S (2001) Piety in the sky? Gender policy and land reform in South Africa. UNRISD, GenevaGoogle Scholar
  29. Walker C (2011) Women’s land rights, agrarian change and gender transformation in post-apartheid South Africa. In: Du grain à moudre. Genre, développement rural et alimentation. (Dir.) C. Verschuur. 247–267. Actes des colloques genre et développement. Berne: DDC-Commission nationale suisse pour l’UNESCO. IHEID, GenèveGoogle Scholar
  30. Wolff J, De-Shalit A (2013) On fertile functionings: a response to Martha Nussbaum. J Hum Dev Cap 14(1):161–165. doi:10.1080/19452829.2013.762177CrossRefGoogle Scholar

Copyright information

© Springer International Publishing AG 2018

Authors and Affiliations

  • Deepa Joshi
    • 1
    Email author
  • Natasha Donn-Arnold
    • 2
  • Mart Kamphuis
    • 3
  1. 1.Centre for Agroecology, Water and ResilienceCoventry UniversityCoventryUK
  2. 2.University of Western CapeCape TownSouth Africa
  3. 3.CITIES FoundationWageningen UniversityWageningenThe Netherlands

Personalised recommendations