Abstract
This Fifth Amendment’s self-incrimination clause has been at the center of constitutional discussions over neuroimaging’s future. That it is not because it clearly would apply to neuroimaging – but rather because neuroimaging raises a easily formulated (albeit difficult to answer) Fifth Amendment puzzle: It seems to count as both of what are supposed to be two mutually exclusive categories in Fifth Amendment law, because it is both like a witness statement (or “testimonial”) and like physical evidence such as blood flow or other physiological processes. This chapter explores various solutions scholars have proposed to this puzzle, rooted in distinctive theories of the self-incrimination clause – and the unanswered questions each of these theories raises. It also emphasizes another point that has received less attention in discussions of self-incrimination and neuroimaging: idea that Fifth Amendment protection for our thoughts and other mental process should perhaps sometimes cover the biology underlying that thinking even when government plausibly claims it wants access to it for reasons other than inferring our thoughts or beliefs.
References
Allen, R. J., & Mace, K. M. (2004). The Self-Incrimination Clause Explained and Its Future Predicted. Journal of Criminal Law and Criminology, 94, 243–293.
Amar, A. R., & Lettow, R. B. (1995). Fifth Amendment First Principles: The Self-Incrimination Clause. Michigan Law Review, 93, 857–928.
Brennan-Marquez, K. (2012–13). A Modest Defense of Mind-Reading. Yale Journal of Law and Technology, 15, 214–272.
Clark, A., & Chalmers David, J. (2008). The Extended Mind. In A. Clark (Ed.), Supersizing the Mind: Embodiment, Action, and the Cognitive Experience. Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press.
Farahany, N. A. (2012a). Incriminating Thoughts. Stanford Law Review, 64, 351–408.
Fox, D. (2009). The Right to Silence as Protecting Mental Control. Akron Law Review, 42, 763.
Holloway, M. B. (2008). One Image, One Thousand Incriminating Words. Temple Journal of Science, Technology & Environmental Law, 27, 141–174.
Kerr, O. S. (2016, September 9). Thoughts on the Third Circuit’s Decryption and Self-incrimination Oral Argument. The Volokh Conspiracy. Washington Post.
Lacy, J. W., & Stark, E. L. (2013, September). The Neuroscience of Memory: Implications for the Courtroom. Natural Reviews Neuroscience, 14(9), 649–658.
Pardo, M. S. (2006). Neuroscience Evidence, Legal Culture, and Criminal Procedure. American Journal of Criminal Law, 33, 301–337.
Pardo, M. S. (2008). The Self-Incrimination Clause and the Epistemology of Testimony. Cardozo Law Reviews, 30, 1023–1045.
Pardo, M. S., & Patterson, D. (2013). Minds, Brains and Law: The Conceptual Foundations of Law and Neuroscience. Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press.
Pustilnik, A. C. (2013). Neurotechnologies at the Intersection of Criminal Procedure and Constitution Law. In S. Richardson & J. Parry (Eds.), The Constitution and the Future of Criminal Law. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.
Schulhofer, S. (1991). Some Kind Words for the Privilege Against Self-Incrimination. Valparaiso University Law Review, 26, 311–336.
Stoller, S. E., & Wolpe, P. R. (2007). Emerging Technologies for Lie Detection and the Fifth Amendment. American Journal of Law and Medicine, 33(2/3), 359–374.
Stuntz, W. J. (1988). Self-Incrimination and Excuse. Columbia Law Review, 88, 1227–1296.
Stuntz, W. J. (1995). Privacy’s Problem and the Law of Criminal Procedure. Michigan Law Review, 93, 1016–1078.
Thompson, S. K. (2007). A Brave New World of Interrogation Jurisprudence. American Journal of Law & Medicine, 33, 341–357.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
Copyright information
© 2017 The Author(s)
About this chapter
Cite this chapter
Blitz, M.J. (2017). The Fifth Amendment: Self-Incrimination and the Brain. In: Searching Minds by Scanning Brains. Palgrave Studies in Law, Neuroscience, and Human Behavior. Palgrave Macmillan, Cham. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-319-50004-1_4
Download citation
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-319-50004-1_4
Published:
Publisher Name: Palgrave Macmillan, Cham
Print ISBN: 978-3-319-50003-4
Online ISBN: 978-3-319-50004-1
eBook Packages: Behavioral Science and PsychologyBehavioral Science and Psychology (R0)