The Case for Ethical Guidelines: Preventing Conflict in the Selection of World Heritage Sites
The criteria and procedure for inscription on the UNESCO World Heritage List are defined by the 1972 World Heritage Convention and its accompanying Operational Guidelines, but both documents still do not offer definitive parameters to which the World Heritage Committee can refer when deciding on nominated sites that are in dispute, or under protest, or can potentially cause conflict. The Committee is therefore left with significant latitude in interpreting ethically ambiguous issues accompanying nominations—a situation conducive to inconsistent decisions and politicking. As such, decisions by the World Heritage Committee are vulnerable to political pressure, and nominations have become a source of conflict on both local and international levels.
This chapter posits that creating ethical guidelines to augment the existing inscription criteria for World Heritage sites can help the Committee arrive more consistently at judicious decisions on ethically challenging nominations, and that using the lens of ethics in assessing the substance of a nominated site as well as possible consequences of its inscription can help prevent conflict. An examination of three nominations involving disputes between states illustrates different conflict situations and how ethical guidelines can work as a deterrent. An analysis of the Committee’s rules and actions shows how the site selection process has become politicized, and why ethical guidelines are necessary given the prevalence of heritage contestation. A review of the context by which select international organizations produced ethical codes reveals that enacting ethical guidelines within UNESCO’s current site selection structure is feasible, while the distinct configuration of the site selection process crucially ensures that they will be operable and enforceable. This chapter concludes that ethical guidelines are therefore a justifiable conflict prevention measure for the selection of World Heritage sites.
KeywordsConflict prevention Ethics Inscription process UNESCO World Heritage
My deepest gratitude to Mr. Peter Stevens for the translation assistance and Ms. Karen Nomorosa for all the support, technical and otherwise.
- Aziz, D. (2003). The utility of an international legal approach to the Jerusalem question: Camera obscura or camera lucida? Singapore Journal of International and Comparative Law, 7, 511–544.Google Scholar
- Beazley, O. (2007). A paradox of peace: The Hiroshima Peace Memorial (Genbaku Dome) as world heritage. In J. Schofield & W. Cocroft (Eds.), A fearsome heritage: Diverse legacies of the Cold War (pp. 33–50). Walnut Creek: Left Coast Press.Google Scholar
- Burke, S. (2012). The long and winding road: A challenge to ICOMOS members. In E. Negussie (Ed.), Changing world, changing views of heritage: Heritage and social change, Proceedings of the ICOMOS Scientific Symposium in Dublin Castle, 30 October 2010 (pp. 29–36). Paris: ICOMOS International Secretariat.Google Scholar
- Consortium for the Promotion of the Modern Industrial Heritage in Kyushu and Yamaguchi to Inscription on the World Heritage. (n.d.). About consortium. Retrieved from http://www.kyuyama.jp/e/action/a01.html.
- Convention Concerning the Protection of the World Cultural and Natural Heritage, Nov. 16, 1972, U.N.T.S. No. 15511. Retrieved from https://treaties.un.org/doc/Publication/UNTS/Volume%201037/volume-1037-I-15511-English.pdf.
- Cooper, T. L. (1998). The responsible administrator: An approach to ethics in the administrative role (4th ed.). San Francisco: Jossey-Bass Publishers.Google Scholar
- De la Torre, M. (Ed.). (2005). Heritage values in site management: Four case studies. Los Angeles: Getty Publications.Google Scholar
- Disko, S. (2010). World Heritage sites in indigenous peoples’ territories: Ways of ensuring respect for indigenous cultures, values and human rights. In D. Offenhäußer, W. Zimmerli, & M.-T. Albert (Eds.), World Heritage and cultural diversity (pp. 167–177). Cottbus, Germany: German Commission for UNESCO.Google Scholar
- Earth Dialogues Forum. (2002). Globalization and sustainable development: Is ethics the missing link? Synthesis report. Retrieved from http://www.gcint.org/fs/Lyon_2002_Earth_20Dialogue_20SynthesisReport.pdf.
- Galis, A. (2009). UNESCO documents and procedure: The need to account for political conflict when designating World Heritage sites. Georgia Journal of International and Comparative Law, 38, 205–235.Google Scholar
- Henly, J. (2001, August 7). Fighting for the mighty monuments. The Guardian. Retrieved from http://www.theguardian.com.
- Higashioka, T., & Matsui, N. (2015, June 22). Japan, S. Korea agree to cooperate on respective World Heritage site candidacies. The Asahi Shimbun. Retrieved from http://ajw.asahi.com/article/behind_news/politics/AJ201506220035.
- ICOMOS Report on the Proceedings of the 34th Session of the World Heritage Committee, Brasilia 2010 (2010, August 26). International Secretariat e-news. Retrieved from http://icomos.org/publications/e-news/2010/E-news_58_20100826.pdf.
- International Centre for the Study of the Preservation and Restoration of Cultural Property. (n.d.). What is ICCROM? Retrieved April 1, 2014, from http://www.iccrom.org/about/what-is-iccrom.
- International Council on Monuments and Sites. (1981). Advisory body evaluation on the old city of Jerusalem (Al-Quds) and its walls. Retrieved from http://whc.unesco.org/archive/advisory_body_evaluation/148.pdf.
- International Council on Monuments and Sites. (1996). Advisory body evaluation on the Hiroshima peace memorial (Genbaku Dome). Retrieved from http://whc.unesco.org/archive/advisory_body_evaluation/775.pdf.
- International Council on Monuments and Sites. (2002). Ethical commitment statement for ICOMOS members. Retrieved from http://www.icomos.org/images/DOCUMENTS/Secretariat/StatutesAmendments_R2_20130325/st2002-ethical-commitment-en.pdf.
- International Council on Monuments and Sites. (2015). Evaluations of nominations of cultural and mixed properties to the World Heritage List. Retrieved from http://whc.unesco.org/archive/2015/whc15-39com-inf8B1-en.pdf.
- International Federation of Red Cross and Red Crescent Societies. (n.d.). Ethics in disaster response. Retrieved from http://www.ifrc.org/en/what-we-do/disaster-management/responding/ethics-in-disaster-response.
- International Union for the Conservation of Nature. (n.d.). Ethics specialist group. Retrieved from http://www.iucn.org/about/union/commissions/cel/cel_working/cel_wt_sg/cel_sg_ethics.
- Liwanag, M. A. (2014). Ethical guidelines for the selection of UNESCO World Heritage sites: A potential conflict prevention measure for the World Heritage Committee. Unpublished master’s thesis, International Christian University, Japan.Google Scholar
- Lloyd, R., & de las Casas, L. (2005, December 1). NGO self-regulation: enforcing and balancing accountability. Alliance Extra. Retrieved from http://www.alliancemagazine.org/article/ngo-self-regulation-enforcing-and-balancing-accountability.
- Mitsubishi Heavy Industries, Inc. (2001). In J. Pederson (Ed.), International directory of company histories (Vol. 40, pp. 324–328). Detroit: St. James Press.Google Scholar
- Morris-Suzuki, T., Low, M., Petrov, L., & Tsu, T. Y. (2013). East Asia beyond the history wars: Confronting the ghosts of violence. Oxon: Routledge.Google Scholar
- O’Keefe, P. (1994). Feasibility of an international code of ethics for dealers in cultural property for the purpose of more effective control of illicit traffic in cultural property. Retrieved from http://unesdoc.unesco.org/images/0009/000985/098554eo.pdf.
- Sung, S. (2013, September 18). Korea protests Japan’s promotion of forced labor sites as world heritage. Arirang News. Retrieved from http://www.arirang.co.kr.
- The Economist. (2010, August 28). A danger list in danger: UNESCO’s World Heritage sites. Retrieved from http://www.economist.com/node/16891951.
- UN World Tourism Organization. (1999). Global code of ethics for tourism. Retrieved from http://dtxtq4w60xqpw.cloudfront.net/sites/all/files/docpdf/gcetbrochureglobalcodeen.pdf.
- Underwood, W. (2008). New era for Japan-Korea history issues: Forced labor redress efforts begin to bear fruit. The Asia-Pacific Journal: Japan Focus. Retrieved from http://www.japanfocus.org/-William-Underwood/2689/article.html.
- UNESCO. (1999). International code of ethics for dealers in cultural property. Retrieved from http://unesdoc.unesco.org/images/0012/001213/121320m.pdf.
- UNESCO. (2014). Decisions adopted by the Executive Board at its 192nd session. Retrieved from http://unesdoc.unesco.org/images/0022/002238/223810e.pdf.
- UNESCO. (2015, July 5). World Heritage—39th World Heritage Committee 2015-07-05 15:00-18:50 [Video file]. Retrieved from https://www.youtube.com/watch?t=904&v=Mnp-FyTHr-s.Google Scholar
- UNESCO Ethics Office. (2011). The Ethics Office annual report 2011. Retrieved from http://www.unesco.org/new/fileadmin/MULTIMEDIA/HQ/ETHICS/images/Ethics%20Office%20Annual%20Report%202011.pdf.
- UNESCO World Heritage Centre. (1979). Report of the Rapporteur on the third session of the World Heritage Committee (Cairo and Luxor, 22–26 October 1979). Retrieved from http://whc.unesco.org/archive/1979/cc-79-conf003-13e.pdf.
- UNESCO World Heritage Centre. (1980). Report of the Rapporteur on the fourth session of the World Heritage Committee (Paris, 1–5 September 1980). Retrieved from http://whc.unesco.org/archive/1980/cc-80-conf016-10e.pdf.
- UNESCO World Heritage Centre. (1981). Report of the Rapporteur on the first extraordinary session of the World Heritage Committee (Paris, France, 10–11 September 1981). Retrieved from http://whc.unesco.org/archive/1981/cc-81-conf008-2reve.pdf.
- UNESCO World Heritage Centre. (2000). Report of the twenty-fourth session of the World Heritage Committee (Cairns, Australia, 27 November–2 December 2000). Retrieved from http://whc.unesco.org/archive/2000/whc-00-conf204-21e.pdf.
- UNESCO World Heritage Centre. (2001). Report of the Rapporteur on the twenty-fifth session of the Bureau (Paris, UNESCO Headquarters, Room X, 25–30 June 2001). Retrieved from http://whc.unesco.org/archive/2001/whc-01-conf207-inf2e.pdf.
- UNESCO World Heritage Centre. (2010). Report of the decisions adopted by the World Heritage Committee at its 34th session (Brasilia, 2010). Retrieved from http://whc.unesco.org/archive/2010/whc10-34com-20e.pdf.
- UNESCO World Heritage Centre. (2013a). Operational guidelines for the implementation of the World Heritage convention. Retrieved from http://whc.unesco.org/archive/opguide13-en.pdf.
- UNESCO World Heritage Centre. (2013b). Rules of procedure. Retrieved from http://whc.unesco.org/document/125501.
- UNESCO World Heritage Centre. (n.d. a). Jerusalem. Retrieved from http://whc.unesco.org/en/tentativelists/1483.
- UNESCO World Heritage Centre. (n.d. b). World Heritage in danger. Retrieved from http://whc.unesco.org/en/158.
- UNESCO. (n.d.). Ethics Office. Retrieved from http://www.unesco.org/new/en/ethics-office.
- World Association of Non-Governmental Organizations. (n.d.). Code of ethics and conduct for NGOs. Retrieved from http://www.wango.org/codeofethics.aspx.