Abstract
There is no single, common agreed-upon definition of industrial policy. The nature and scope of industrial policies adopted by states has changed over time. Historically, national governments played a central role in the implementation of industrial policy by supporting infant industries, ‘picking the winners’ and investing large amounts of public money via the disbursement of financial subsidies to private companies. Nowadays however, mainstream economists agree that market mechanisms are essential for getting the relative price right and thereby facilitating efficient resource allocation. Notwithstanding this, in some cases governments can play a crucial role in facilitating industrial transformation. There are three ways for public administration to impact the behaviour of entrepreneurs, i.e., through a legal framework creating an administrative and legal environment favourable for economic activities; through a political climate supporting objectives defined by the government; and by offering financial assistance and tools to improve the position of selected beneficiaries. On one hand, industrial policy is treated as an equivalent to restructuring policy, i.e. one which helps change the structure of the economy and gives new impetus for growth and development. However, on the other hand it can be used to intervene in the market, thus disturbing competition. In both cases we can observe similar or even identical arguments for such opposite policies, but with the consequences for beneficiaries and their competitors understood in completely different ways. The main objective of this chapter is a review of the various definitions of industrial policy, as well as a presentation of arguments for and against industrial policy understood in the traditional way. To this end we analyse articles, chapters in books, and scientific papers to find out the main schools of industrial policy, their aims, goals and instruments, as well as the envisioned consequences to entrepreneurs and for the economy as a whole, including changes in the competitive position of beneficiaries, competitors and customers. In order to ensure clarity, thematic unity, precision, and a proper presentation of various approaches to industrial policy, the chapter has been prepared using original statements, phrases and quotations from over 110 publications, supplemented in some cases by the author’s own critical remarks and opinions.
Keywords
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution.
Buying options
Tax calculation will be finalised at checkout
Purchases are for personal use only
Learn about institutional subscriptionsReferences
Aghion P (2011) Some thoughts on industrial policy and growth. In: Falck O, Gollier C, Woessmann L (eds) Industrial policy for national champions. MIT Press, Cambridge, MA
Aiginger K (2007) Industrial policy: a dying breed or a re-emerging phoenix. J Ind Compet Trade 7(3):297–232
Aiginger K, Sieber S (2005) Towards a renewed industrial policy in Europe, prepared as Chapter 1 for the background report of the competitiveness of European manufacturing. European Commission, DG Enterprise
Aiginger K, Sieber S (2006) The matrix approach to industrial policy. Int Rev Appl Econ 20(5):573–601
Ambroziak AA (2014a) Renaissance of the European Union’s industrial policy. Yearbook Polish Eur Stud 17:37–57
Ambroziak AA (2014b) Review of the literature on determinants of the locational attractiveness of regions. In: Ambroziak A (ed) New Cohesion Policy of the European Union in Poland. How it will influence the investment attractiveness of regions in 2014-2020. Springer Cham, Heidelberg, New York, Dordrecht, London
Ambroziak AA (2015a) Europeanization of industrial policy: towards re-industrialization? In: Stanek P, Wach K (eds) Europeanization process from the mesoeconomic perspective: industries and policies. Cracow University of Economics
Ambroziak AA (2015b) Theoretical aspects of regional interventions. In: Ambroziak AA (ed) Regional dimension of the EU economic policy in Poland. Warsaw School of Economic Press
Arrow K (1962) Economic welfare and the allocation of resources for invention. The rate and direction of inventive activity, economic and social factors. The National Bureau of Economic Research, Princeton University Press.
Aubert C, Falck O, Heblich S (2011) Subsidizing national champions: an evolutionary perspective. In: Falck O, Gollier C, Woessmann L (eds) Industrial policy for national champions. MIT Press, Cambridge, MA
Bailey D, Cowling K (2011) Rebuilding the city: a focus for European industrial policy? Policy Stud 32(4):347–364
Baldwin RE (1969) The case against infant-industry tariff protection. J Polit Econ 77(3):295–305
Beath J (2002) UK industrial policy: old tunes on new instruments? Oxf Rev Econ Policy 18(2):221–239
Becker G (1985) The best industrial policy is none at all. Bus Week 8(25)
Bianchi P, Labory S (2006) Empirical evidence on industrial policy using state aid data. Int Rev Appl Econ 20(5):603–621
Bianchi P, Labory S (2011a) Industrial policy after the crisis: the case of the Emilia-Romagna region in Italy. Policy Stud 32(4):429–445
Bianchi P, Labory S (2011b) Economic crisis and industrial policy in the Union: the need for a long-term vision of industrial development. In: Posta PD, Talani LS (eds) Europe and the financial crisis. Palgrave Macmillan, London
Camagni R, Capello R (2010) Macroeconomic and territorial policies for regional competitiveness: an EU perspective. Reg Sci Policy Pract 2(1):1–20
Caves RE (1987) Industrial policy and trade policy: the connections. In: Kierzkowski H (ed) Protection and competition in international trade: essays in honour of W. M. Corden. Blackwell, Oxford
Chang HJ (1994) The political economy of industrial policy. St Martin Press, New York
Chang HJ (2006) Industrial policy in East Asia—lesson for Europe. EIB Papers 11(2):106–133
Cimoli M, Dosi G, Stiglitz JE (eds) (2009) Industrial policy and development: the political economy of capabilities accumulation. Oxford University Press
Cimoli M, Dosi G, Stiglitz JE (2015) The rationale for industrial and innovation policy. Intereconomics 50(3):126–132
Cohen E (2006) Theoretical foundations of industrial policy. EIB Papers 11(1):84–106
Commonwealth Secretariat (1980) The world economic crisis: a commonwealth perspective. Selected background papers prepared for a Commonwealth Group of Experts, Commonwealth economic papers: no. 13
Cradden C (2014) Neoliberal industrial relations policy in the UK: how the labour movement lost the argument. Palgrave Macmilan, London
Crafts N (2010) Overview and policy implications. Learning from some of Britain’s successful sectors: an historical analysis of the role of government, Department for Business Innovation and Skills. BIS Econ Paper 6:1–17
Dahlman CJ (2009) Growth and development in China and India: the role of industrial and innovation policy in rapid catch-up. In: Cimoli M, Dosi G, Stiglitz JE (eds) Industrial policy and development: the political economy of capabilities accumulation. Oxford University Press
Debande O (2006) De-industrialisation. EIB Papers 11(1):64–82
Di Maio M (2009) Industrial policies in developing countries: history and perspectives. In: Cimoli M, Dosi G, Stiglitz JE (eds) Industrial policy and development: the political economy of capabilities accumulation. Oxford University Press
Donges JB (1980) Industrial policy in West Germany’s not so market—oriented economy. World Econ 3(2):185–204
Driscoll RE, Behrman JN (1984) Introduction. In: Driscoll RE, Behrman JN (eds) National industrial policies. Oelgeschlager, Gunn & Hain, Cambridge, MA, pp 1–24
El-Agraa AM (1997) UK competitiveness policy vs Japanese industrial policy. Econ J 107(444):1504–1517
Eliasson G (2011) Advanced public procurement as industrial policy. The aircraft industry as a technical university. Springer, New York, Dordrecht, Heidelberg, London
Enos JL (1986) Korean industrial policy. Prometheus 4(2):239–253
European Commission (2002) Industrial policy in an enlarged Europe, Communication from the Commission to the Council, the European Parliament, the Economic and Social Committee and the Committee of the Regions, Brussels, COM(2002) 714
European Commission (2005) State Aid Action Plan. Less and better targeted state aid: a road map for state aid reform 2005-2009, Brussels, COM(2005) 107 final.
European Commission (2011) EU industrial structure 2011. Trends and performance. Enterprise and Industry Magazine
European Commission (2012) A stronger European industry for growth and economic recovery, Communication from the Commission to the Council, the European Parliament, the Economic and Social Committee and the Committee of the Regions, Brussels, COM(2012) 582
European Commission (2014) For a European industrial renaissance, Communication from the Commission to the Council, the European Parliament, the Economic and Social Committee and the Committee of the Regions, Brussels, COM(2014) 14
Fagerberg J (1996) Technology and competitiveness. Oxf Rev Econ Policy 12(3):39–51
Falck O, Gollier C, Woessmann L (eds) (2011) Industrial policy for national champions. MIT Press, Cambridge, MA
Fogel K, Morck R, Yeung B (2011) National champions and economic growth. In: Falck O, Gollier C, Woessmann L (eds) Industrial policy for national champions. MIT Press, Cambridge, MA
Galag A (2008) Industrial policy in the Middle East and North Africa: rethinking the role of the state. The American University in Cairo Press, Egypt
Geroski PA (1989) European industrial policy and industrial policy in Europe. Oxf Rev Econ Policy 5(2):20–36
Glykou I, Pitelis CN (2011) On the political economy of the state, the public-private nexus and industrial policy. Policy Stud 32(4):461–478
Gollier C, Julien B (2011) National champions under credit rationing. In: Falck O, Gollier C, Woessmann L (eds) Industrial policy for national champions. MIT Press, Cambridge, MA
Grossman GM, Horn H (1988) Infant-industry protection reconsidered: the case of informational barriers to entry. Quart J Econ 103(4):767–787
Gruber HG (1966) The anatomy of classical and modern infant industry arguments. Weltwirtschaftliches Archiv 97:325–344
Gual J (1995a) The coherence of EU policies on trade, competition and industry, Discussion paper 1105. Centre for Economic Policy Research
Gual J (1995b) The three common policies: an economic analysis. In: Buigues P, Jacquemin A, Sapir A (eds) European policies on competition, trade and industry. Conflicts and complementarities. Edward Elgar, Surrey [as seen in:] Välilä T (2006) No policy is an island—on the interaction between industrial and other policies, EIB Papers 11(2): 8–33
Gual J, Jódar S (2006) Vertical industrial policy in the EU: an empirical analysis of the effectiveness of state aid. EIB Papers 11(2):80–105
Haley UCV, Haley GT (2013) Subsidies to Chinese industry: state capitalism, business strategy, and trade policy. Oxford University Press
Hannon E, Monks K, Conway E, Kelly G, Flood P, Truss K, Mastroeni M (2011) The state and industrial policy in Ireland: a case study of the Irish pharmaceutical sector. Int J Hum Resour Manage 22(1):3692–3710
Harr LN (2014) Do patterns of trade and international competitiveness support the case for industrial policy? Policy Stud 35(3):221–245
Hart M, Driffied N, Roper S, Mole K (2008) Evaluation of regional selective assistance (RSA) in Scotland 2000-2004. Scottish Executive Social Research, The Scottish Government
Johnson C (ed) (1984) The industrial policy debate. ICS Press, San Francisco
Khan MH (2009) The political economy of industrial policy in Asia and Latin America. In: Cimoli M, Dosi G, Stiglitz JE (eds) Industrial policy and development: the political economy of capabilities accumulation. Oxford University Press.
Klimenko M (2004) Industrial targeting, experimentation and long-run specialization. J Dev Econ 73(1):75–105
Krugman PR (1987) Is free trade Passé? J Econ Perspect 1(2):131–144
Krugman PR (1994) Competitiveness: a dangerous obsession. Foreign Aff 73(3):28–44
Lall S (1999) Promoting industrial competitiveness in developing countries: lesson from Asia, Economic papers 39. Commonwealth Secretariat
Lall S (2001) Comparing national competitive performance: an economic analysis of the World Economic Forum’s Competitiveness Index, Queen Elizabeth House working paper S 61.
Lall S (2004) Reinventing industrial strategy: the role of government policy in building industrial competitiveness, United Nations Conference on Trade and Development, G-24 Discussion paper series 28
Landesman MA (2015) Industrial policy: its role in the European economy. Intereconomics 50(3):133–138
Latsch W (2008) The possibility of industrial policy. Oxf Dev Stud 36(1):23–37
Lin JY (2014) Industrial policy revisited: a new structural economics perspective. China Econ J 7(3):382–396
Lin J, Chang HJ (2009) Should industrial policy in developing countries conform to comparative advantage or defy it? A debate between Justin Lin and Ha-Joon Chang. Dev Policy Rev 27(5):483–502
Lindbeck A (1981) Industrial policy as an issue in the economic environment. World Econ 4(4):391–406
Miller JC, Walton TF, Kovacic WE, Rabkin JA (1984) Industrial policy: reindustrialization through competition or coordinated action? Yale J Regulat 2(1):1–37
Morelli C (2012) Jute, firm’s survival, and British industrial policy: government action under globalisation. In: Fujioka R, Umemura M (eds) Comparative responses to globalisation. Experiences of British and Japanese Enterprises. Palgrave Macmillan, London
Naudé W (2010) Industrial policy. Old and new issues, working paper 106. World Institute for Development Economics Research
Navarro L (2003) Industrial policy in the economic literature. Recent theoretical developments and implications for EU policy, Enterprise Directorate-General, European Commission, Enterprise Paper No 12.
Neuman M (1990) Industrial policy and competition policy. Eur Econ Rev 34:562–567
Ngandu S (2008) The absence of gender in South Africa’s new industrial policy framework. Agenda 22(78):199–207
Nolan P, Huaichuan R (2004) Industrial policy and global big business revolution: the case of the Chinese coal industry. J Chin Econ Bus Stud 2(2):97–113
OECD (1992) Technology and the economy: the key relationships. Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development, Paris
Pack H (2000) Industrial Policy: Growth Elixir or poison. World Bank Observ 15(1):47–67
Pack H (2006) Industrial policy in Europe in the 20th century. EIB Papers 11(1):36–62
Pack H, Saggi K (2006) The case for industrial policy: a critical survey, World Bank Policy Research working paper 3839
Pack H, Westphal LE (1986) Industrial strategies and technological change theory versus reality. J Dev Econ 22(1):87–128
Parr JB (2014) Neglected aspects of regional policy: a retrospective view. Environ Plann C Gov Policy 32:1–17
Peres W (2009) The (Slow) return of industrial policies in Latin America and the Caribbean. In: Cimoli M, Dosi G, Stiglitz JE (eds) Industrial policy and development: the political economy of capabilities accumulation. Oxford University Press
Pindel J, Hosomi T, Diebold W (1979) Industrial policy and the international economy, the triangle papers no 19. The Triangle Commission. A Private North American-European-Japanese Initiative on Matters of Common Concern
Riess A, Välilä T (2006) Industrial policy: a tale of innovators, champions, and B52s. EIB Papers 11(1):10–35
Rodrik D (1996) Coordination failures and government policy: A model with applications to East Asia and Eastern Europe. J Int Econ 40(1):1–22
Rodrik D (2004) Industrial policy for the twenty-first century. Faculty Research Working Papers Series, Harvard University, RWP04-047
Rodrik D (2008) Normalizing industrial policy, working paper 3. The International Bank for Reconstruction and Development, The World Bank
Rodrik D (2009) Industrial policy: don’t ask why, ask how. Middle East Dev J 1(1):1–29
Saad-Filho A (2012) Neoliberalism, democracy and development policy in Brazil. In: Fine B, Kyung-Sup C, Weiss L (eds) Developmental policies in transition. The neoliberal era and beyond. Palgarve Macmilan, London
Schneider BR (2015) Industrial policy in Latin America: business-state relations and the new developmentalism. Palgrave Macmilan, London
Schrank A, Whiford J (2009) Industrial policy in the United States: A Neo-Polanyian interpretation. Polit Soc 37(4):521–553
Sharp M (2001) Science, technology and broad industrial policy: the coevolution of policies at national, regional and European level, Final Report prepared within TSER programme
Singh A (2011) Comparative advantage, industrial policy and the World Bank: back to first principles. Policy Stud 32(4):447–460
Smith A (1976) An inquiry into the nature and causes of the wealth of nations. The Glasgow edition of the works and correspondence of Adam Smith, vol II. Oxford University Press
Sonobe T, Otsuka K (2014) Cluster-based industrial development. Kaizen management for MSE growth in developing countries. Palgrave Macmillan, London
Spencer BJ, Brander J (1983) International R&D rivalry and industrial strategy. Rev Eur Stud 50(4):707–722
Stehrer R, Baker P, Foster-McGregor N, Koenen J, Leitner S, Schricker J, Strobel T, Vieweg H-G, Vermeulen J, Yagafarova A (2015) The relation between industry and services in terms of productivity and value creation, Research Report 404. The Vienna Institute for International Economic Studies
Stiglitz JE, Yifu J, Monga C (2013) Introduction: the rejuvenation of industrial policy. In: Stiglitz JE, Yifu JL (eds) The industrial policy revolution. I. The role of government beyond ideology. Palgrave Macmillan, London
Succar P (1987) The need for industrial policy in LDC’S—a restatement of the infant industry argument. Int Econ Rev 28(2):521–534
Thirwall AP (1974) Regional economic disparities and regional policy in the common market. Urban Stud 11:1–12
Toivanen O (2006) Innovation and research policies: two case studies of R&D subsidies. EIB Papers 11(2):54–79
Tyson L, Zysman J (eds) (1983) American industry in international competition. In: Zysman J, Tyson L (eds) American industry in international competition: government policies and corporate strategies. Cornel University Press
Välilä T (2006) No policy is an island—on the interaction between industrial and other policies. EIB Papers 11(2):8–33
Vestal JE (1995) Planning for change: industrial policy and Japanese economic development, 1945-1990. Oxford University Press
Wade RH (2012) Return of industrial policy? Int Rev Appl Econ 26(2):223–239
Weiss L (2012) The myth of the neoliberal state. In: Fine B, Kyung-Sup C, Weiss L (eds) Developmental policies in transition. The neoliberal era and beyond. Palgarve Macmilan, London
White LJ (2008) Antitrust policy and industrial policy: a view from the U.S., Working Paper 08-04. Reg-Markets Center, AEI Center for Regulatory and Market Studies
Whitfield L, Buur L (2014) The politics of industrial policy: ruling elites and their alliances. Third World Quart 35(1):126–144
Williams D (2010) Industrial policy. Local Econ 25(8):612–621
Wong SK, Liu Y (2011) Optimal industrial policy in vertically related markets. J Int Trade Econ Dev 20(5):631–650
World Bank (1993) The East Asian miracle, economic growth and public policy, A World Bank Policy Research Report. Oxford University Press
Wren C (2010) The industrial policy of competitiveness: a review of recent development in the UK. Reg Stud 35(9):847–860
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Editor information
Editors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
Copyright information
© 2017 Springer International Publishing Switzerland
About this chapter
Cite this chapter
Ambroziak, A.A. (2017). Review of the Literature on the Theory of Industrial Policy. In: Ambroziak, A. (eds) The New Industrial Policy of the European Union. Contributions to Economics. Springer, Cham. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-319-39070-3_1
Download citation
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-319-39070-3_1
Published:
Publisher Name: Springer, Cham
Print ISBN: 978-3-319-39069-7
Online ISBN: 978-3-319-39070-3
eBook Packages: Economics and FinanceEconomics and Finance (R0)