In the previous two chapters, we studied a prototypical model of an ion channel. The model consisted of a differential equation involving a gating mechanism that could be either open or closed. A Markov model governed the gating and we derived a system giving the probability density functions of the states involved in the Markov model. We used the probability density approach to compute optimal theoretical drugs and noted that a mutation leading to an increase in the closed to open reaction rate could be completely repaired by an optimal closed state drug.
In the previous two chapters, we studied a prototypical model of an ion channel. The model consisted of a differential equation involving a gating mechanism that could be either open or closed. A Markov model governed the gating and we derived a system giving the probability density functions of the states involved in the Markov model. We used the probability density approach to compute optimal theoretical drugs and noted that a mutation leading to an increase in the closed to open reaction rate could be completely repaired by an optimal closed state drug.
Next, we extended the prototypical model to also include an inactivated state. The inactivated state can also be affected by mutations and we studied the particular case in which the rates from inactivated to open and from inactivated to closed were increased by a factor μ referred to as the mutation severity index. In this case, we observed that an optimal drug was represented by a blocker associated with the inactivated state. We were again able to completely repair the effect of the mutation using the theoretical drug.
In this chapter, we shall move closer to realistic Markov models of sodium channels. These models tend to be somewhat more intricate than the prototypical model we have studied so far. Providing Markov models of the sodium channels has been a very active field of research for decades and a series of models are available. We have chosen to study models that seem to capture the basic structure applied in many models but are manageable from a mathematical point of view. We choose this approach for clarity of presentation and not for its ability to represent specific data. It is, hopefully, quite clear that the method we use to analyze the models is applicable to many other models.
Mutations of the sodium channel can lead to impaired inactivation. This may lead to leakage of the sodium current, which can again trigger arrhythmias. Here we will consider a model of the \(\Delta\) KPQ mutation of the SCN5A gene. This mutation may lead to an arrhythmogenic disorder referred to as the long-QT syndrome, which can lead to sudden cardiac death in the worst case. There are several models representing the effect of the \(\Delta\) KPQ mutation. One that is well known is provided by Clancy and Rudy [14]. Their approach to model the impaired inactivation is to introduce a burst mode in the model where no inactivation state is available. We will consider two ways of modeling the effect of the mutation.
In the first approach, we will use the method utilized above. We will simply increase the reaction rate from the inactivated to the closed state and from the inactivated to the open state by a factor μ ≥ 1, referred to as the mutation severity index. This change will clearly reduce the probability of being in the inactivated state. It is therefore a model of impaired inactivation.
The second approach is to introduce a burst mode in the model. When the channel is in the burst mode, there is no inactivated state. This model will be parameterized such that it is highly unlikely that the channel will enter the burst mode for the wild type case, but the probability of entering the burst mode is considerably higher in the mutant case.
12.1 Markov Model of a Wild Type Sodium Channel
Markov models have turned out to be a powerful tool in representing the physics of the sodium channel and a series of alternatives have been proposed by various authors. Since this is still a very active field of research, it is hard to claim one particular model as the definitive model. We shall therefore focus on a kind of model that has a structure that seems to be more or less agreed upon but, as usual, we attack this problem with simplicity in mind. This also holds true for the way we introduce the effect of a mutation.
We start by considering a simple model of the sodium channel, illustrated in Fig. 12.1. The actual functions used in our computations will be given below. However, we should note that the functions will always be chosen such that they satisfy the principle of detailed balance, which, for the model given in Fig. 12.1, means that the following relation holds:
The model of the closed states deserves a comment or two. Let us assume that a sodium channel consists of three subunits and these subunits may exist in two states: closed or permissible. The whole channel is in the state C_{0} if all three units are in the permissible state. Over a brief period given by \(\Delta t\), the channel can change from the state C_{0} to the open state and the probability of this event is \(\Delta tk_{co}\) or it can change to the inactivated state with probability \(\Delta tk_{ci}\). However, the channel can also go from the permissible state C_{0} to the state C_{1} and the probability of doing this is \(3\Delta t\beta\). The reason for the factor of three here is that it is sufficient that one of the three subunits closes. By assuming that the subunits act independently, we find that the probability is \(3\Delta t\beta\). The same reasoning gives us the rest of the transitions between the different closed states.
12.1.1 The Equilibrium Solution
The equilibrium probabilities of the model given in Fig. 12.1 are characterized by the equations
where c_{0} denotes the equilibrium probability of being in the state C_{0}. Similarly, the other variables are defined as the equilibrium probability of being in the states C_{1}, C_{2}, C_{3}, I, and O. We express all probabilities in terms of the open probability:
Here the subscript w is used to indicate that q_{ w } represents the wild type case.
12.2 Modeling the Effect of a Mutation Impairing the Inactivated State
The mutation impairs the inactivated state of the channel. In Sect. 11.3 we modeled this by increasing the probability of moving from the inactivated state to the open state or to the closed state. This was done by increasing the rates k_{ io } and k_{ ic }. We use the same approach here and define
increases as μ increases. Although these calculations concern the equilibrium state, this is a pretty strong hint of an increased open probability in the dynamic case as well and an increased open probability is exactly the problem one observes when inactivation is impaired.
12.3 Stochastic Model of the Sodium Channel
We use the same model of the transmembrane potential as above (see (10.2) on page 154). Recall that the stochastic differential equation is given by
$$\displaystyle{ Cv^{{\prime}} = -g_{ L}\left (v - V _{L}\right ) -\gamma g_{Na}(v - V _{Na}), }$$
(12.6)
where C is the capacitance of the membrane, V_{ L } is the resting potential of the leakage current, and V_{ Na } is the resting potential of the sodium channel. The parameters are listed in Table 12.1.
The sodium channel can be either open (O), with γ = 1, or closed (C), with γ = 0, and, as usual, the state of the channel is determined by a Markov model. Since C = 1, we rewrite the equation in the more convenient form
$$\displaystyle{ v^{{\prime}} = -g_{ L}\left (v - V _{L}\right ) -\gamma g_{Na}(v - V _{Na}), }$$
(12.7)
where g_{ L } and g_{ Na } now have the unit^{1} ms^{−1}.
12.3.1 A Numerical Scheme with an Invariant Region
A numerical scheme for the model (12.7) can be written in the form
$$\displaystyle{ v_{n+1} = v_{n} - \Delta t\left (g_{L}\left (v_{n} - V _{L}\right ) +\gamma _{n}g_{Na}(v_{n} - V _{Na}\right )), }$$
(12.8)
where γ_{ n } is either zero or one and where \(\Delta t\) denotes the time step. We assume that the condition
$$\displaystyle{ \Delta t <\frac{1} {g_{L} + g_{Na}} }$$
(12.9)
holds and, under this condition, we will show that an invariant region for the solutions generated by the scheme (12.8) is given by
$$\displaystyle{ \Omega = \left (V _{L},V _{+}\right ), }$$
$$\displaystyle{v_{n+1} = H(v_{n},\gamma _{n})\leqslant H(V _{+},1) = V _{+}}$$
and
$$\displaystyle{v_{n+1} = H(v_{n},\gamma _{n})\geqslant H(V _{L},0) = V _{L}.}$$
So, by induction, it holds that \(\Omega = \left (V _{L},V _{+}\right )\) is an invariant region for scheme (12.8).
12.4 Probability Density Functions for the Voltage-Gated Channel
The systems modeling the probability density functions in the wild type and mutant cases are of exactly the same form; the only difference is given by the mutation severity index. The probability density functions of the states of the Markov model given in Fig. 12.2 are given by
$$\displaystyle\begin{array}{rcl} a_{o}& =& -g_{L}\left (v - V _{L}\right ) - g_{Na}(v - V _{Na}), \\ a_{c}& =& -g_{L}\left (v - V _{L}\right ), {}\end{array}$$
(12.12)
with ρ_{ o } denoting the probability density function of being in the open state, ρ_{0} denoting the probability density function of being in the state C_{0}, and so on.
12.4.1 Model Parameterization
To carry out numerical computations comparing the properties of the wild type and the mutant sodium channel, we need to define the rates involved in the model described in Fig. 12.2. We use the rates
The parameters are given in Table 12.2 and we introduce the mutation as we did in the previous chapter: We increase the probability of going from the inactivated state to either the open or the closed state. More specifically, we define
$$\displaystyle{\bar{k}_{ic} =\mu k_{ic}\text{ and }\bar{k}_{io} =\mu k_{io},}$$
where, as usual, the wild type case is given by μ = 1.
Table 12.2
Parameters of the Markov model illustrated in Figs. 12.1 and 12.2
ab
V_{ ab } (mV)
s_{ ab } (1/mV)
τ_{ ab } (ms)
co
-60
0.1
0.01
oi
-120
0.05
3
ic
-80
-0.15
10
cp
-60
0.1
0.1
12.4.2 Numerical Experiments Comparing the Properties of the Wild Type and the Mutant Sodium Channel
In Fig. 12.3, we show the probability density functions of the open state, the inactivated state, and the sum of the closed states for the wild type case (μ = 1) and two mutations (μ = 10 and μ = 30). The properties of the solutions are summarized in Table 12.3, which presents the expected values of the open state, the inactivated state, and the sum of the closed states.
Table 12.3
Probability of being in the open, closed, or inactivated states and the expected value of the transmembrane potential, provided that the channel is open, closed, or inactivated
μ
π_{ o } × 100
π_{ c }
π_{ i } × 100
E_{ o }
E_{ c }
E_{ i }
1
0.0067
0.9951
0.4834
-50.8
-84.9
-83.5
3
0.0080
0.9982
0.1765
-41.1
-84.9
-79.6
10
0.0162
0.9989
0.0942
-13.4
-84.9
-57.0
12.4.3 Stochastic Simulations Illustrating the Late Sodium Current in the Mutant Case
Impaired inactivation of the sodium channel leads to a late sodium current, which is illustrated in Fig. 12.4. The figure also includes experimental data of the sodium current taken from Bennett et al. [2]. We observe that, by using μ = 30, the model fits the experimental data fairly well.
12.5 A Theoretical Drug Repairing the Sodium Channel Mutation
We introduce a theoretical drug for the sodium channel of the form given in Fig. 12.5. The equilibrium probabilities of the model are characterized by the equations
and therefore, with the drug specified by (12.13), we have o_{m, d} = o_{ w }, so the open probability at equilibrium is repaired.
12.5.1 Numerical Experiments Using the Blocker of the Inactivated State
We have seen that a blocker of the inactivated state is a promising candidate for repairing the mutation described in Fig. 12.2. The drug is characterized by (12.13), so we have
and the parameter k_{ bi } remains to be determined. In Table 12.4, we show that the blocker is more efficient the larger k_{ bi } is. In fact, the blocker is able to repair all the relevant statistical properties of the solution. The statistical properties presented in the table are introduced in Sect. 4.2 on page 72.
Table 12.4
The open probability, π_{ o }, the expected value of the transmembrane potential, E_{ o }, and the standard deviation, \(\sigma _{o}\), for increasing values of k_{ bi }. For large values of k_{ bi }, the statistical properties of the mutant are completely repaired by the drug
k_{ bi }
π_{ o } × 10^{3}
E_{ o }
\(\sigma _{o}\)
WT
0.067
-50.794
46.828
MT
1.534
12.991
26.831
10^{−6}
1.341
12.940
26.913
10^{−5}
1.180
12.487
27.634
10^{−4}
0.556
8.240
33.343
10^{−3}
0.135
-16.903
49.326
0.01
0.070
-47.563
48.205
0.1
0.067
-50.729
46.869
1
0.067
-50.791
46.830
In Fig. 12.6, we show the open state probability density functions of the wild type, the mutant, and the drugged version of the mutant. Again, we see that the drug completely repairs the open state probability density function.
12.5.2 The Late Sodium Current Is Removed by the Inactivated State Blocker
In Fig. 12.4 above, we demonstrated, using Monte Carlo simulations, that the mutation under consideration leads to a significant late sodium current comparable to the current observed in experiments. By using the drug described in (12.13) with \(k_{bi} = 0.01\text{ ms}^{-1},\) we see that the late current more or less completely disappears (see Fig. 12.7).
12.6 Notes
1.
The basic structure of the Markov model in Fig. 12.1 is taken from Patlak [65], who discusses and evaluates several possible models in relation to experimental data.
2.
Modeling the effects of a drug on the sodium channel is motivated by the paper of Clancy et al. [16].
The use of the odd units for g_{ L } and g_{ Na } stems from the fact that we have, for notational convenience, incorporated the capacitance of the membrane in these constants.
References
2.
P.B. Bennett, K. Yazawa, N. Makita, A.L. George Jr., Molecular mechanism for an inherited cardiac arrhythmia. Nature 376, 683–685 (1995)CrossRefGoogle Scholar
14.
C.E. Clancy, Y. Rudy, Linking a genetic defect to its cellular phenotype in a cardiac arrhythmia. Nature 400, 566–569 (1999)CrossRefGoogle Scholar
16.
C.E. Clancy, Z.I. Zhu, Y. Rudy, Pharmacogenetics and anti-arrhythmic drug therapy: A theoretical investigation. AJP Heart Circulatory Physiol. 292(1), H66–H75 (2007)CrossRefGoogle Scholar
65.
J. Patlak, Molecular kinetics of voltage-dependent Na^{+} channels. Physiol. Rev. 71(4), 1047–1080 (1991)Google Scholar
Open Access This chapter is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/), which permits use, duplication, adaptation, distribution and reproduction in any medium or format, as long as you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, a link is provided to the Creative Commons license and any changes made are indicated.
The images or other third party material in this chapter are included in the work’s Creative Commons license, unless indicated otherwise in the credit line; if such material is not included in the work’s Creative Commons license and the respective action is not permitted by statutory regulation, users will need to obtain permission from the license holder to duplicate, adapt or reproduce the material.
Authors and Affiliations
Aslak Tveito
1
Glenn T. Lines
1
1.Center for Biomedical ComputingSimula Research LaboratoryLysakerNorway