Biofuels: Sustainable Innovation or Gold Rush? Identifying Responsibilities for Biofuel Innovations
Based on fieldwork and literature review we have investigated the rise and fall of jatropha cultivation in Tanzania over the last decade, and its negative socio-economic and environmental impacts. Based on the fact that the most vulnerable actors, small farmers, were affected the most, through loss of land and income, we conclude that biofuel innovations have so far been irresponsible. In this chapter we draw lessons for future biofuel innovations through the identification of stakeholder responsibilities. We do so by developing a framework which is based on current discussions on the meaning of ‘sustainability’ and recent ethical work on moral responsibility. In addition, we use the framework to reflect on the jatropha biofuel innovation experiences. Additional fieldwork will be done to gather information on visions and expectations and to discuss responsibilities for sustainable biofuel innovations in Tanzania. Our preliminary conclusion is that stakeholder participation and a clear demarcation of responsibilities are preconditions for sustainable biofuel innovations.
KeywordsBiofuels Sustainability Moral responsibility Discourse ethics Tanzania
We want to thank everybody who made this research possible. During the field work this included several students, colleagues, and our interviewees. During writing we benefited from comments by our colleagues. This article was produced as part of the project “Biofuels : Sustainable Innovation or Gold Rush?”, funded by the Responsible Innovation Programme (MVI) of the Netherlands Organisation of Scientific Research (NWO).
- Apel, K.O., and M. Kettner. 1992. Zur Anwendung der Diskursethik in Politik, Recht und Wissenschaft. Frankfurt am Main: Suhrkamp.Google Scholar
- Aristotle. 1985. Nicomachean ethics. Trans. Terence Irwin. Indianapolis: Hackett.Google Scholar
- Balkema, A.J., S. van Dijk, S. Heijnen, G.P.J. Verbong, H.A. Romijn, and E. Huntjens. 2010. ‘An impact assessment methodology for small scale renewable energy projects in developing countries funded under Dutch policies defined to contribute to the millennium development goals’. Proceedings of the Berlin conference on the human dimensions of global environmental change. 8–9 October 2010, 1-11. Berlin: Environmental Policy Research Centre (FFU).Google Scholar
- Balkema, A.J., and H.A. Romijn. 2012. Innovative business models for sustainable biofuel production: The case of Tanzanian smallholder jatropha farmers in the global biofuel chain. In The business of social and environmental innovation. New Frontiers in Africa, eds. Hamann, R., M. Hall, E. Wosu Griffin-EL, and V. Bitzer, 75–100. London: Springer, and Cape Town: UCT Press.Google Scholar
- Bergius, M. 2012. Large scale agro investments for biofuel production in Tanzania—impact on rural households. Norway: University of Agder.Google Scholar
- Beyene A., C.G. Mungongo, A. Atteridge, and R.K. Larsen. 2013. Biofuel production and its impact on local livelihoods in Tanzania, a mapping of stakeholder concerns and some implications for governance. Stockholm Environmental Institute, working paper 2013-03.Google Scholar
- Chambers, R. 2009. Dr. Robert chambers elaborates on good practices for participatory GIS. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=awL1Hpy7spA (video).
- Cramer, J. 2007. Testing framework for sustainable biomass. Available at http://www.sustainable-biomass.org/dynamics/modules/SFIL0100/view.php?fil_Id=857. Accessed 9 April 2015.
- Diop, D., M. Blanco, A. Flammini, M. Schlaffer, M.A. Kropiwnicka, and M.M. Mankhof. 2013. Assessing the impact of biofuels production on developing countries from the point of view of policy coherence for development. European Commission, Final Report February 2013.Google Scholar
- EASAC. 2012. The current status of biofuels in the European Union, their environmental impacts and future prospects, European Academia Science Advisory Council EASAC policy report 19 December 2012 ISBN: 978-3-8047-3118-9. This report can be found at www.easac.eu.
- FAO. (2010). Jatropha: A smallholder bioenergy crop, the potential for pro-poor development. Integrated Crop Management 8.Google Scholar
- FAO/UNEP. 2010. Decision support tool for sustainable bioenergy, UN Energy report by UN Food and Agricultural Organisation and the UN Environmental Programme, ISBN: 978-92-5-106638-6 (see box 2 for opportunities and impacts of biofuel projects on global, national and local scale).Google Scholar
- Giampietro, M., and K. Mayumi. 2009. The biofuel delusion, the fallacy of large scale agro-fuel production. UK and USA: Earthscan.Google Scholar
- Habermas, J. 1990. Moral consciousness and communicative action. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.Google Scholar
- Habermas, J. 1991. Erläuterungen zur Diskursethik. Frankfurt am Main: Suhrkamp. (English, 1993).Google Scholar
- Heijnen. 2010. The impact of small scale renewable energy projects in least developed countries, a baseline study. M.Sc. thesis, Eindhoven University of Technology, The Netherlands.Google Scholar
- Hermele, K., L. Olsson, and A. Jerneck. 2009. Justice and fairness in resource governance: Conflicting views on allocation and access. Paper presented to the conference on the human dimensions of global environmental change. Amsterdam, 2–4 December 2009, Theme 5, Panel 5: Allocation and Access in Earth System Governance.Google Scholar
- Hooijkaas, N. 2010. The impacts of large-scale Jatropha production on the GHGbalance, carbon stock and socio-economics in Kilwa, Tanzania. M.Sc. thesis, Copernicus Institute, Utrecht University, The Netherlands.Google Scholar
- Jackson, T. 2009. Prosperity without growth; economics for a finite planet. Book published 16th October 2009 by Routledge.Google Scholar
- Jonas, H. 1979/1984. Das Prinzip Verantwortung. Frankfurt am Main: Suhrkamp; The imperative of responsibility: In search of an ethics for the technological age. Chicago: The University of Chicago Press.Google Scholar
- León-Moreta, M. 2011. Biofuels—A threat to environmental and human rights? An analysis of the impact of production of feedstock for agrofuels on the rights to water, land and food, European. Journal of Legal Studies 4(1): 102–120.Google Scholar
- Leopold, A., and K. Diets. 2012. Transnational contradictions and effects of Europe’s bioenergy policy, evidence from Sub-Saharan Africa, Fair Fuels? Working paper 4.Google Scholar
- Locke, A., and G. Henley. 2013. Scoping report on biofuels projects in five developing countries. London: UKaid and Overseas Development Institute.Google Scholar
- MEM (Ministry of Energy and Minerals). 2012. First draft; National liquid biofuel policy, August 2012. The United Republic of Tanzania.Google Scholar
- Mitchell, D. 2008. A note on rising food prices. World Bank Policy Research, Working paper 4682.Google Scholar
- Neef, M.M. 2010. Outside looking in: Experiences in barefoot economics. Book and video (http://www.democracynow.org/2010/11/26/chilean_economist_manfred_max_neef_on).
- Nordhaus, W. 2008. A question of balance, weighing the options on global warming policies. Yale: Yale University Press. ISBN 9780300137484.Google Scholar
- Ottinger, R.L. 2007. Biofuels—potential, problems and solutions. http://cmsdata.iucn.org/downloads/cel10_ottinger_2.pdf. Accessed 20 May 2011.
- Pols, A.J.K. 2010. Transferring responsibility through use plans. In Philosophy and engineering: an emerging agenda, ed. I. van de Poel, and D. Goldberg, 189–203. Dordrecht: Springer.Google Scholar
- Romijn, H.A., S. Heijnen, and S. Arora. 2013. Standardizing sustainability: Certifying Tanzanian biofuel smallholders in a global supply chain. In Sustainable value chain management: Analyzing, designing, implementing, and monitoring for social and environmental responsibility, ed. A. Lindgreen, S. Sen, F. Maon, and J. Vanhamme, 473–487. Gower: Burlington.Google Scholar
- Rosling, H. 2006. Hans Rosling shows the best stats you’ve ever seen (video) at the 2006 TED Conference in Monterey, CA.Google Scholar
- Rosling, H. 2007. Hans Rosling’s new insights on poverty (video) from TED 2007.Google Scholar
- Sulle, E., and F. Nelson. 2009. Biofuels, land access and rural livelihoods in Tanzania. London: IIED.Google Scholar
- Tremmel, J.C. 2006. Handbook of intergenerational justice. Cheltenham: Edward Elgar.Google Scholar
- UNEP. 2012. GEO5, global environmental assessment. UNEP.Google Scholar
- van Eijck, J.A.J., E.W.M. Smeets, H.A. Romijn, A.J. Balkema, and R.J.J. Jongschaap. 2010. Jatropha assessment: Agronomy, socio-economic issues, and ecology: Facts from literature. Utrecht: NL Agency.Google Scholar
- van Teeffelen, J. 2013. Fuelling progress or poverty? The EU and biofuels in Tanzania. Evert Vermeer Foundation and Fair Politics.Google Scholar
- Vorley, B., L. Cotula, and M.-K. Chan. 2012. Tipping the balance: Policies to shape agricultural investments and markets in favour of small-scale farmers. Oxford: Oxfam GB/IIED.Google Scholar