Abstract
The following comments concentrate on the areas of disagreement in the positions of Joost Pauwelyn on the one side and Gabrielle Marceau and Anastasios Tomazos on the other. As Joost Pauwelyn and Gabrielle Marceau are two of the main proponents in the debate on the relationship between international law and the WTO system, in dealing with their views one has to address several of the core issues raised in this discussion so far. In order to better understand these issues and the respective positions presented, it appears appropriate to take some of their earlier writings into perspective.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
Preview
Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.
References
Klaus Adomeit (1986), Normlogik — Methodenlehre — Rechtspolitologie: Gesammelte Beiträge zur Rechtstheorie 1970–1985 (= Schriften zur Rechtstheorie Vol. 120), Berlin (Duncker & Humblot) 1986.
Robert Alexy (1994), Theorie der Grundrechte, Frankfurt a. M. (Suhrkamp) 21994.
Lorand Bartels (2001), Applicable Law in WTO Dispute Settlement Proceedings, in: Journal of World Trade 35 (2001), 499–519.
Jeremy Bentham (1970), Of Laws in General (1782, ed. posthumously by H. L. A. Hart), London (The Athlone Press) 1970.
Wladiyslaw Czaplinski / Gennady M. Danilenko (1990), Conflicts of Norms in International Law, in: Netherlands Yearbook of International Law 21 (1990), 3–42.
Walter Dubislav (1981), Die Definition, Hamburg (Felix Meiner Verlag) 41981 (reprint of the 3rd edition of 1931).
Karl Engisch (1977), Einführung in das juristische Denken, Stuttgart et al. (Kohlhammer) 71977.
Alexandra Gonzalez-Calatayud / Gabrielle Marceau (2002), The Relationship between the Dispute-Settlement Mechanisms of MEAs and those of the WTO, in: Review of European Community and International Environmental Law 11 (2002) No. 3, 275–286.
Herbert Lionel Adolphus Hart (1971), Bentham’s ‘Of Laws in General’, in: Rechtstheorie 2 (1971), 55–66.
Herbert Lionel Adolphus Hart (1992), The Concept of Law, Oxford (Clarendon Press) 1992.
Peter Hilpold (2002), Aktuelle Rechtsfragen zum WTO-Streitbeilegungsverfahren, in: Favorita Papers 2/2002, 46–61.
Wilfred C. Jenks (1953), The Conflict of Law-Making Treaties, in: British Year Book of International Law 30 (1953), 401–453.
Wolfram Karl (1984), Treaties, Conflicts between, in: Rudolf Bernhardt (ed.), Encyclopedia of Public International Law Vol. 7, Amsterdam / London / New / Tokyo (North Holland) 1984, 468–473.
Hans Kelsen (1979), Allgemeine Theorie der Normen (edited by Kurt Ringhofer and Robert Walter), Wien (Manz) 1979.
Friedrich Klein (1962), Vertragskonkurrenz, in: Karl Strupp / Hans-Jürgen Schlochauer (eds.), Wörterbuch des Völkerrechts Vol. 3, Berlin (de Gruyter) 21962, 555.
Ulrich Klug (1982), Juristische Logik, Berlin (Springer) 41982.
Kyung Kwak / Gabrielle Marceau (2002), Overlaps and Conflicts of Jurisdiction between the WTO and RTAs. Paper presented in the Conference on Regional Trade Agreements, WTO 26 April 2002 (available at http://www.wto.org/english/tratop_e/region_e/sem_april02_e/sem_april02_reading_e.htm9).
Hans Lenk (1974), Konträrbeziehungen und Operatorengleichungen im deontologischen Sechseck, in: Hans Lenk (ed.), Normenlogik. Grundprobleme der deontischen Logik, Pullach bei München (Verlag Dokumentation) 1974, 198.
Gabrielle Marceau (2001), Conflicts of Norms and Conflicts of Jurisdiction: The Relationship between the WTO Agreement and MEAs and other Treaties, in: Journal of World Trade 35 (2001) No. 6, 1081–1131.
David Palmeter / Petros Mavroïdis (1998), The WTO Legal System: Sources of Law, in: American Journal of International Law 92 (1998), 398–413.
Joost Pauwelyn (2003), Conflict of Norms in Public International Law. How WTO Law Relates to Other Rules of International Law, Cambridge (Cambridge University Press) 2003.
August Reinisch (2002), Der Streit ums Forum — oder: Was gehört eigentlich vor WTO-Panels?, in: Recht der Internationalen Wirtschaft 48 (2002), 449–456.
Richard Robinson (1968), Definition, Oxford (Clarendon Press) 1968.
Klaus F. Röhl (1995), Allgemeine Rechtslehre. Ein Lehrbuch, Köln et al. (Heymann) 1995.
Yuval Shany (2003), The Competing Jurisdictions of International Courts and Tribunals, Oxford (Oxford University Press) 2003.
August Thon (1878), Rechtsnorm und subjectives Recht, Weimar (Böhlau) 1878.
Joel Trachtman (1999), The Domain of WTO Dispute Resolution, in: Harvard International Law Journal 40 (1999) No. 2, 333–377.
Erich Vranes (2003), The Banana Dispute. Fundamental Issues under WTO Law, in: Fritz Breuss / Stefan Griller / Erich Vranes (eds.), The Banana Dispute. An Economic and Legal Analysis, Vienna / New York (Springer) 2003, 39–111.
Ota Weinberger (1989), Rechtslogik, Berlin (Duncker & Humblot) 21989.
Wolfgang Weiss (2003), Security and Predictability under WTO Law, in: World Trade Review 2 (2003) No. 2, 183–219.
Wilhelm Heinrich Wilting (1996), Vertragskonkurrenz im Völkerrecht, Köln et al. (Heymann) 1996.
Rüdiger Wolfrum / Nele Matz (2003), Conflicts in International Environmental Law (= Beiträge zum ausländischen öffentlichen Recht und Völkerrecht Vol. 164), Berlin (Springer) 2003.
Manfred Zuleeg (1977), Vertragskonkurrenz im Völkerrecht. Teil I: Verträge zwischen souveränen Staaten, in: German Yearbook of International Law 20 (1977), 246–276.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Editor information
Editors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
Copyright information
© 2008 Springer-Verlag Wien
About this chapter
Cite this chapter
Vranes, E. (2008). Comments on Joost Pauwelyn’s Paper: ‘How to Win a WTO Dispute Based on Non-WTO Law?’. In: Griller, S. (eds) At the Crossroads: The World Trading System and the Doha Round. Schriftenreihe der Österreichischen Gesellschaft für Europaforschung (ECSA Austria) / European Community Studies Association of Austria Publication Series, vol 8. Springer, Vienna. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-211-69379-7_3
Download citation
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-211-69379-7_3
Publisher Name: Springer, Vienna
Print ISBN: 978-3-211-22403-8
Online ISBN: 978-3-211-69379-7