Abstract
This chapter will outline some of the evidence that hypnotism had gained public acceptability and medical legitimacy by the start of the twentieth century. This evidence includes an increase in scientific articles on hypnotism published in British medical journals over this period before the Great War. Traditional annual medical speeches given by eminent physicians started to pay attention to the aspects of the doctor-patient relationship which were therapeutic but not physical. The most eminent physician of his day William Osler became famous not only for his clinical wisdom but his ‘bedside manner.’ I will also describe the transitions which the medical profession required for that acceptance and assimilation. Medical hypnotism started to lose the trance state as the vehicle for positive healthy affirmations and for many clinicians, suggestive therapy was the preferred name for the technique in the period leading up to the First World War. Most of the original New Hypnotists joined a new club, the Medical Society for the Study of Suggestive Therapy. Charles Lloyd Tuckey was its first president and its membership included the most significant medical psychologists of the day. Its lectures were published in a journal for general practitioners. Hypnotism and suggestion not only survived but made several important contributions to the contemporary medical, psychological and the intellectual discourse.
Access this chapter
Tax calculation will be finalised at checkout
Purchases are for personal use only
Notes
- 1.
Sarah Marks, ‘Psychotherapy in Historical Perspective’, History of the Human Sciences, 30 (2017) (pp. 3–16); Sonu Shamdasani, ‘Psychotherapy in Society. Historical Reflections’, in The Routledge History of Madness and Mental Healthed. by G. Eghigian (London: Routledge, 2017) (pp. 363–78).
- 2.
Henri Ellenberger, The Discovery of the Unconscious, the History and Evolution of Dynamic Psychiatry (London: Allen Lane, 1970) (p. 171); Pierre Janet, Psychological Healing: A Historical and Clinical Study, 1 (New York: MacMillan 1925) (p. 200).
- 3.
George Gifford, Psychoanalysis, Psychotherapy, and the New England Medical Scene, 1894–1944 (New York, NY: Science History Publications, 1978); Eugene Taylor, ‘Psychotherapeutics and the Problematic Origins of Clinical Psychology in America’, American Psychologist, 55 (2000) (pp. 1029–33); John Andrick, ‘The “Chicago School of Psychology” and Hypnotic Magazine: Suggestive Therapeutics, Public Psychologies, and New Thought Pluralism, 1895–1910’, History of Psychology, 23, 1 (2020) (pp. 1–25).
- 4.
Andreas-Holger Maehle and Heather Wolffram, ‘Guest Editorial’, Notes and Records: The Royal Society Journal of the History of Science, 71 (2017) Special Issue: ‘History of Hypnotism in Europe’, ed. by Andreas-Holger Maehle, and Heather Wolffram (pp. 119–23).
- 5.
Teri Chettiar, ‘“Looking as Little Like Patients as Persons Well Could”’: Hypnotism, Medicine and the Problem of the Suggestible Subject in Late Nineteenth-Century Britain’, Medical History, 56 (2012) (pp. 335–54).
- 6.
PhilipKuhn, ‘The Medical Society for the Study of Suggestive Therapeutics’, Ch. 7 in Psychoanalysis in Britain, 1893–191, Histories and Historiography (Lanham: Lexington, 2017) (pp. 159–180) (p. 174).
- 7.
Kuhn, ‘The 1898 BMA Hypnotism Debates’, Ch. 3 in Psychoanalysis (pp. 31–45) (p. 35).
- 8.
Charles Mercier, ‘Suggestion and Crime’, British Medical Journal (10 September 1898) (p. 678).
- 9.
Alan Gauld, A History of Hypnotism (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1992) (p. 561).
- 10.
John Milne Bramwell, Suggestion: Its place in Medicine and Scientific Research (N.P., 1897).
- 11.
Charles Lloyd Tuckey, ‘Hypnotism and Suggestion’, The Medical Annual and Practitioners Index (Bristol: John Wright, 1898) (pp. 77–85) (p. 77).
- 12.
Gauld, Hypnotism (p. 350).
- 13.
Rhodri Hayward, ‘The Emergence of the Unconscious’, Ch. 1 in The Transformation of the Psyche in British Primary Care, 1889–1970 (London: Bloomsbury, 2015) (pp. 1–30).
- 14.
William Bynum, Science and the Practice of Medicine in the Nineteenth Century (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1994) (pp. 191–6).
- 15.
Bynum, Science (p. 196).
- 16.
L. Forbes Winslow, Recollections of Forty Years (London: John Ouseley, 1910) (p. 374).
- 17.
L. Forbes Winslow, Spiritualistic Madness (London: Baillère, 1877).
- 18.
Anon, ‘Lyttleton Forbes Winslow's Obituary’, Light, 33, 1692 (14 June 1913) (p. 288).
- 19.
Edwin Ash, ‘Modern Hypnotism. A lecture delivered before the PTS’, Lancet, 168, 4341 (10 November 1906) (p. 1308).
- 20.
Edwin Ash, ‘Some Experiments in Hypnotism’, Lancet, 167, 4300 (27 January 1906) (pp. 216–20); Edwin Ash, ‘The Induction of Hypnosis’, Lancet, 168, 4330 (25 August 1906) (pp. 501–4).
- 21.
Arthur Hallam, ‘Editorial’, Health Record (July 1911) (p. 74).
- 22.
Kuhn, ‘The London Psycho-Therapeutic Society (1900–1915)’ Ch. 4 in Psychoanalysis (pp. 49–95).
- 23.
Anon. ‘Obituary—C. Lloyd Tuckey’, Journal of the Society for Psychical Research, 22 (1925) (pp. 115–7) (p. 116).
- 24.
Charles Lloyd Tuckey, ‘Some Notes on Hypnotic Suggestion’, General Practitioner (6 June 1904) (pp. 350–1); Charles Lloyd Tuckey, ‘ Some Notes on Hypnotic Suggestion’, General Practitioner (13 June 1904) (pp. 367–8); Charles Lloyd Tuckey, ‘Some Notes on Hypnotic Suggestion’, General Practitioner (20 June 1904) (pp. 382–4); Charles Lloyd Tuckey, ‘Notes on Some Cases of Obsession’, General Practitioner (26 September 1903) (pp. 607–8); Charles Lloyd Tuckey, ‘Notes on Sexual Perversion’, General Practitioner (7 November 1903) (pp. 703–4); Charles Lloyd Tuckey, ‘The Utility of the Study of Suggestion to the Student and Practitioner’, General Practitioner (6 April 1907) (pp. 210–3).
- 25.
Kuhn, ‘Medical Society for the Study of Suggestive Therapeutics’, Ch. 7 in Psychoanalysis (p. 162).
- 26.
C.M. Vaillant, ‘An Historical Sketch of the Emergence of Liverpool Psychiatry’, Journal of the Liverpool Psychiatric Club, 1 (1963). http://www.priory.com/homol/livpsy/19th.htm [accessed 6 May 2020].
- 27.
Anon. ‘Treatment by Hypnotic Suggestion’, British Medical Journal (28 April 1906) (pp. 979–80).
- 28.
Kuhn, Psychoanalysis (pp. 164–6).
- 29.
Charles Lloyd Tuckey, ‘Correspondence’, Lancet (12 October 1889) (p. 776).
- 30.
Percy Allan, ‘M.S.S.S.T.’, General Practitioner (24 November 1906) (p. 748); Anon. ‘The M.S.S.S.T’, Journal of the Society for Psychical Research, 13 (1906) (pp. 14–5).
- 31.
Anon. ‘The M.S.S.S.T.’, Morning Post (4 July 1907) (p. 3).
- 32.
The story of the interconnections between suggestion and psychoanalysis and their subsequent representations are beyond the scope of this book but are well covered by Ellenberger and Borsch-Jacobsen. Ellenberger, Discovery; Mikkel Borch-Jacobsen, ‘Hypnosis in Psychoanalysis’, Representations 27 (1989) (pp. 92–110).
- 33.
L. Forbes Winslow, Suggestive Power of Hypnotism (London: Rebman, 1910) (p. 20).
- 34.
Algernon Blackwood, ‘The Man who Found Out’, in Ancient Sorceries and Other Weird Stories (London: Penguin, 2002) (pp. 131–46).
- 35.
Rebecca West, The Return of the Soldier (London: Virago, 2010) (p.126).
- 36.
Kuhn, Psychoanalysis (p. 167).
- 37.
Borch-Jacobsen convincingly argues that although Freud removed hypnotism from his mind cure it was impossible to completely remove suggestion from the therapeutic encounter. Mikkel Borch-Jacobsen, ‘Hypnosis in Psychoanalysis’, Representations 27 (1989) (pp. 92–110).
- 38.
Alfred Schofield, Unconscious Therapeutics: or, the Personality of the Physician (Philadelphia: Blakiston, 1904).
- 39.
S. Weir Mitchell, Doctors and Patients (Philadelphia and London: Lippincot, 1888).
- 40.
Richard Cabot, ‘The Use and Abuse of Rest in the Treatment of Disease’, Psychotherapy: A Course of Instruction in Sound Psychology, Sound Medicine, and Sound Religion, 2 (1909) (pp. 23–38) (p. 28).
- 41.
Schofield, Unconscious Therapeutics (p. 100).
- 42.
Schofield, Unconscious Therapeutics (p. 100).
- 43.
Michael Bliss, William Osler, A Life in Medicine (New York: Oxford University Press, 1999) (p. 264).
- 44.
William Osler, ‘The Faith that Heals’, British Medical Journal (18 June 1910) (pp. 1470–2) (p. 1470).
- 45.
Osler, ‘Faith’ (p. 1471).
- 46.
William Osler, ‘The Student Life’ in Aequinamitas (Philadelphia: Blakiston, 1910) (pp. 413–44) (p. 424).
- 47.
Charles Lloyd Tuckey, Psycho-Therapeutics, 4th ed (London: Baillière, Tindall and Cox, 1900) (p. 157).
- 48.
John Woods, ‘Abstract of an Address on the Psychic Side of Therapeutics’, Lancet (20 February 1904) (pp. 489–92) (p. 492).
- 49.
Thomas Claye Shaw, ‘The Influence of Mind as a Therapeutic Agent’, Lancet (6 November 1909) (pp. 1369–73); Thomas Claye Shaw, ‘The Influence of Mind as a Therapeutic Agent’, British Medical Journal (6 November 1909) (pp. 1352–6) (p. 1352).
- 50.
Anon, ‘Educational Number: The Training of the Medical Profession’, British Medical Journal (28 August 1897), (p. 509).
- 51.
Anon, Special Edition, British Medical Journal (18 June 1910).
- 52.
T. Frederic Gardner, ‘President’s Address’, British Medical Journal (Supplement) (11 June 1910) (pp. 362–6) (p. 363).
- 53.
Louis Rose, Faith Healing (Harmondsworth: Penguin Books, 1970).
- 54.
Anon, ‘Modern Miracles of Healing’, British Medical Journal (20 August 1910) (p. 479).
- 55.
Mary Baker Eddy, Science and Health with Key to the Scriptures (Boston: Christian Science Publishing Society, 1934) (pp. 112–3).
- 56.
Anon, ‘Faith-Healing’, British Medical Journal (15 October 1898) (p. 1187).
- 57.
Sheryl Root, The Healing Touch: Spiritual Healing in England c.1870–1955 (Unpublished PhD thesis, University of Warwick, 2005) (p. 76).
- 58.
Charles Herman Lea, A Plea for the Thorough and Unbiased Investigation of Christian Science and a Challenge to its Critics, 2nd ed. (London: Dent, 1915) (p. 7).
- 59.
Stuart Mews, ‘The Revival of Spiritual Healing in the Church of England’, Studies in Church History, 19 (1982) (pp. 299–332) (p. 312).
- 60.
Mews, ‘Spiritual Healing’ (p. 313); Samuel McComb, ‘The Christian Religion as Healing Power’, Hibernian Journal (October 1909) (pp. 10–27); Harrington Sainsbury, ‘Christianity, Science and “Christian Science”’, Church Quarterly Review (April 1910) (pp. 63–8).
- 61.
Anon, Spiritual Healing: Report of a Clerical and Medical Committee of Inquiry into Spiritual Faith, and Mental Healing (London: Macmillan, 1914) (p. 8).
- 62.
Root, Healing Touch (p. 246).
- 63.
Anon, Spiritual Healing (pp. 52–3).
- 64.
Arthur Myers and Frederic Myers, ‘Mind Cure, Faith-Cure and the Miracles of Lourdes’, Proceedings of the Society for Psychical Research, 9 (1893) (pp. 160–209).
- 65.
Ruth Harris, Lourdes: Body and Spirit in a Secular Age (London: Allen Lane, 1999) (p. 351).
- 66.
Lesley Hearnshaw, A Short History of British Psychology 1840–1940 (London: Routledge, 1986).
- 67.
Mathew Thomson, ‘Practical Psychology’, Ch. 1 in Psychological Subjects: Identity, Culture and Health in Twentieth-Century Britain (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2006) (pp. 23–6).
- 68.
Anon, ‘Memory Means Money’, Times (21 February 1903).
- 69.
Richard Harte, The New Psychology or the Secret of Happiness, Being Practical Instructions as to How to Develop and Employ Thought Power (London: Fowler, 1903); Stanton Kirkham, The Philosophy of Self-Help: An Application of Practical Psychology to Daily Life (London: Puttnams, 1909); Arnold Bennet, Mental Efficiency (London: Hodder and Stoughton 1912).
- 70.
Bernard Petitdant, ‘Professor Elmer Ellsworth Knowles and its [sic] Radio Hypnotic Crystal’ Kinésithérapie Revue, 20 (2020) (pp. 41–4).
- 71.
Marc Demarest, ‘Latent Powers, Latent Demand. A Look at the Mail-Order Occult in Anglo-American Culture 1895–1920’ (The International Association for the Preservation of Spiritualist and Occult Periodicals: Forest, OR, 2017). http://www.ehbritten.org/docs/demarest_popular_occulture_july_2017.pdf [accessed 14 July 2017].
Bibliography
Allan, Percy. 1906. ‘M.S.S.S.T.’, General Practitioner (24 November): 748.
Andrick, John. 2020. ‘The “Chicago School of Psychology” and Hypnotic Magazine: Suggestive Therapeutics, Public Psychologies, and New Thought Pluralism, 1895–1910’, History of Psychology, 23, 1: 1–25.
Anon. 1897. ‘Educational Number: The Training of the Medical Profession’, British Medical Journal (28 August): 509.
Anon. 1898. ‘Faith-Healing’, British Medical Journal (15 October): 1187.
Anon. 1903. ‘Memory Means Money’, Times (21 February).
Anon. 1906. ‘Treatment by Hypnotic Suggestion’, British Medical Journal (28 April): 979–80.
Anon. 1906. ‘The M.S.S.S.T’, Journal of the Society for Psychical Research 13: 14–5.
Anon. 1907. ‘The M.S.S.S.T’, Morning Post (4 July): 3.
Anon. 1910. ‘Special Edition’, British Medical Journal (June 18).
Anon. 1910. ‘Modern Miracles of Healing’, British Medical Journal (20 August): 479.
Anon. 1910. Spiritual Healing: Report of a Clerical and Medical Committee of Inquiry into Spiritual Faith, and Mental Healing. London: Macmillan.
Anon. 1913. ‘Lyttleton Forbes Winslow's Obituary’ Light, 33, 1692: 288.
Anon. 1925. ‘Obituary—C. Lloyd Tuckey’, Journal of the Society for Psychical Research, 22: 115–7.
Ash, Edwin. 1906. ‘Some Experiments in Hypnotism’, Lancet, 167 (27 January): 216–20.
Ash, Edwin. 1906. ‘Modern Hypnotism. A Lecture Delivered Before the PTS’, Lancet, 168 (10 November): 1308.
Ash, Edwin. 1906. ‘The Induction of Hypnosis’, Lancet, 168 (25 August): 501–504.
Bennet, Arnold. 1912. Mental Efficiency. London: Hodder and Stoughton.
Blackwood, Algernon. 2002. ‘The Man Who Found Out’, in Ancient Sorceries and Other Weird Stories. London: Penguin. 131–46.
Bliss, Michael. 1999. William Osler, A Life in Medicine. New York: Oxford University Press. 264.
Borch-Jacobsen, Mikkel. 1989. ‘Hypnosis in Psychoanalysis’, Representations, 27: 92–110.
Bramwell, John Milne. 1897. Suggestion: Its Place in Medicine and Scientific Research. N.P.
Bynum, William. 1994. Science and the Practice of Medicine in the Nineteenth Century. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. 191–6.
Cabot, Richard. 1909. ‘The Use and Abuse of Rest in the Treatment of Disease’, Psychotherapy: A Course of Instruction in Sound Psychology, Sound Medicine, and Sound Religion, 2: 23–38.
Chettiar, Teri. 2012. ‘“Looking as Little Like Patients as Persons Well Could”: Hypnotism, Medicine and the Problem of the Suggestible Subject in Late Nineteenth-Century Britain’, Medical History, 56: 335–54.
Demarest, Marc. 2017. ‘Latent Powers, Latent Demand. A Look at the Mail-Order Occult in Anglo-American Culture 1895–1920’. The International Association for the Preservation of Spiritualist and Occult Periodicals: Forest, OR, 2017. http://www.ehbritten.org/docs/demarest_popular_occulture_july_2017.pdf [accessed 14 August 2017].
Eddy, Mary Baker. 1934. Science and Health with Key to the Scriptures. Boston: Christian Science Publishing Society.
Ellenberger, Henri. 1970. The Discovery of the Unconscious, the History and Evolution of Dynamic Psychiatry. London: Allen Lane.
Gardner, T. Frederic. 1910. ‘President’s Address’, British Medical Journal (Supplement) (11 June): 362–6.
Gauld, Alan. 1992. A History of Hypnotism. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Gifford, George. 1978. Psychoanalysis, Psychotherapy, and the New England Medical Scene, 1894–1944. New York: Science History Publications.
Hallam, Arthur. 1911. ‘Editorial’, Health Record (July): 74.
Harris, Ruth. 1999. Lourdes: Body and Spirit in a Secular Age. London: Allen Lane.
Harte, Richard. 1903. The New Psychology, or the Secret of Happiness, Being Practical Instructions as to How to Develop and Employ Thought Power. London: Fowler.
Hayward, Rhodri. 2015. ‘The Emergence of the Unconscious’, Ch. 1 in The Transformation of the Psyche in British Primary Care, 1889–1970. London: Bloomsbury. 1–30.
Hearnshaw, Lesley. 1986. A Short History of British Psychology 1840–1940. London: Routledge.
Janet, Pierre. 1925. Psychological Healing: A Historical and Clinical Study, vol 1. New York: MacMillan. 200.
Kirkham, Stanton.1909. The Philosophy of Self-Help: An Application of Practical Psychology to Daily Life. London: Puttnams.
Kuhn, Philip. 2017. Psychoanalysis in Britain, 1893-1913, Histories and Historiography. Lanham: Lexington.
Lea, Charles Herman. 1915. A Plea for the Thorough and Unbiased Investigation of Christian Science and a Challenge to its Critics, 2nd ed. London: Dent.
Maehle, Andreas-Holger and Wolffram, Heather. 2017. ‘Guest Editorial’, in Notes and Records: The Royal Society Journal of the History of Science, 71, Special Issue: ‘History of Hypnotism in Europe’, ed. by Andreas-Holger Maehle, and Heather Wolffram. 119–23.
Marks, Sarah. 2017. ‘Psychotherapy in Historical Perspective’, History of the Human Sciences, 30: 3–16
McComb, Samuel. 1909. ‘The Christian Religion as Healing Power’, Hibernian Journal (October): 10–27.
Mercier, Charles. 1898. ‘Suggestion and Crime’, British Medical Journal (10 September): 678.
Mews, Stuart. 1982. ‘The Revival of Spiritual Healing in the Church of England’, Studies in Church History, 19: 299–332.
Mitchell, S. Weir. 1888. Doctors and Patients. Philadelphia and London: Lippincot.
Myers, Arthur and Myers, Frederic. 1893. ‘Mind Cure, Faith-Cure and the Miracles of Lourdes’, Proceedings of the Society for Psychical Research, 9: 160–209.
Osler, William. 1910. ‘The Student Life’, in Aequinamitas. Philadelphia: Blakiston. 413–44.
Osler, William. 1910. ‘The Faith that Heals’, British Medical Journal, (June 18): 1470–2.
Petitdant, Bernard.2020. ‘Professor Elmer Ellsworth Knowles and its [sic] Radio Hypnotic Crystal’ Kinésithérapie Revue 20: 41–4.
Root, Sheryl. 2005. The Healing Touch: Spiritual Healing in England c. 1870–1955. Unpublished PhD thesis, University of Warwick.
Rose, Louis. 1970. Faith Healing. Harmondsworth: Penguin Books.
Sainsbury, Harrington. 1910. ‘Christianity, Science and “Christian Science”’, Church Quarterly Review (April): 63–8.
Schofield, Alfred. 1904. Unconscious Therapeutics: Or, the Personality of the Physician. Philadelphia: Blakiston.
Shamdasani, Sonu. 2017. ‘Psychotherapy in Society: Historical Reflections’ ,in The Routledge History of Madness and Mental Health, ed. by G. Eghigian. London: Routledge. 363–378.
Shaw, Thomas Claye. 1909. ‘The Influence of Mind as a Therapeutic Agent’, Lancet (6 November): 1369–73.
Shaw, Thomas Claye. 1909. ‘The Influence of Mind as a Therapeutic Agent’, British Medical Journal (6 November): 1352–6.
Taylor, Eugene. 2000. ‘Psychotherapeutics and the Problematic Origins of Clinical Psychology in America’, American Psychologist, 55: 1029–33.
Thomson, Mathew. 2006. ‘Practical Psychology’, Ch. 1 in Psychological Subjects: Identity, Culture, and Health in Twentieth-Century Britain. Oxford: Oxford University Press. 23–6.
Tuckey, Charles Lloyd. 1889. ‘Correspondence’, Lancet (12 October): 776.
Tuckey, Charles Lloyd. 1898. ‘Hypnotism and Suggestion’, Medical Annual and Practitioners Index. Bristol: John Wright. 77–85.
Tuckey, Charles Lloyd. 1904. ‘Some Notes on Hypnotic Suggestion’, General Practitioner (6 June): 350–1.
Tuckey, Charles Lloyd. 1904. ‘Some Notes on Hypnotic Suggestion’, General Practitioner (13 June): 367–8.
Tuckey, Charles Lloyd. 1904. ‘Some Notes on Hypnotic Suggestion’, General Practitioner (20 June): 382–4.
Tuckey, Charles Lloyd. 1903. ‘Notes on Some Cases of Obsession’, General Practitioner (26 September): 607–8.
Tuckey, Charles Lloyd. 1903. ‘Notes on Sexual Perversion’, General Practitioner (7 November): 703–4.
Tuckey, Charles Lloyd. 1907. ‘The Utility of the Study of Suggestion to the Student and Practitioner’, General Practitioner (6 April): 210–3.
Tuckey, Charles Lloyd. 1900. Psycho-Therapeutics: Treatment by Hypnotism and Suggestion, 4th ed. London: Baillière, Tindall and Cox.
Vaillant, C.M. 1963. ‘An Historical Sketch of the Emergence of Liverpool Psychiatry’, Journal of the Liverpool Psychiatric Club, 1. http://www.priory.com/homol/livpsy/19th.htm [accessed 6 May 2020].
West, Rebecca. 2010. The Return of the Soldier. London: Virago. 126.
Winslow, L. Forbes. 1877. Spiritualistic Madness. London: Baillère.
Winslow, L. Forbes. 1910. Recollections of Forty Years. London: John Ouseley.
Winslow, L. Forbes. 1910. Suggestive Power of Hypnotism. London: Rebman.
Woods, John. 1904. ‘Abstract of an Address on the Psychic Side of Therapeutics’, Lancet (20 February): 489–92.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
Copyright information
© 2023 The Author(s), under exclusive license to Springer Nature Switzerland AG
About this chapter
Cite this chapter
Bates, G.D.L. (2023). The Triumph of Medical Hypnotism. In: The Uncanny Rise of Medical Hypnotism, 1888–1914. Mental Health in Historical Perspective. Palgrave Macmillan, Cham. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-031-42725-1_10
Download citation
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-031-42725-1_10
Published:
Publisher Name: Palgrave Macmillan, Cham
Print ISBN: 978-3-031-42724-4
Online ISBN: 978-3-031-42725-1
eBook Packages: HistoryHistory (R0)