Abstract
In this chapter a state of the art of the literature on small jurisdictions is provided, focusing on the features most relevant to social security, such as: the impact of economic and environmental shocks; scale disadvantages and flexibility; the limited human resources and infrastructure; the training needs; the limited number of people covered by social security; the importance of migration; and the strong ties with other states. Issues related to homogeneity and proximity, to the unity of administration and the lack thereof in the benefit schemes, and financial issues will be discussed. In this chapter, we also give an overview of the existing literature dealing with the common features of small jurisdictions, focusing on the features relevant to social security. As such, this part gives a status quaestionis concerning our central theme: are small jurisdictions confronted with specific issues or problems when dealing with social security?
Access this chapter
Tax calculation will be finalised at checkout
Purchases are for personal use only
Notes
- 1.
Baehr (1976), pp. 163 ff.
- 2.
- 3.
Mumford asks a similar question in relation with taxation, suggesting that perhaps taxation can better be considered from the perspective of the globalised South or from the perspective of developing countries (Mumford 2017, pp. 96 ff).
- 4.
Christmas-Møller (1983), p. 46.
- 5.
Moitrier (1980), pp. 77–78, adding that this is true even if in theory first thoughts would lead to the opposite conclusion that as regards both objectives and manner of execution no such specific distinction exists: from the point of view of objectives, whatever its size may be, a social security system fulfils the same needs and ensures the same objectives; and from the point of view of its manner of execution, it could be considered that a social security system does not depend upon the number of beneficiaries it may have.
- 6.
Bertram (2011), p. 1.
- 7.
Irving (2011), p. 227.
- 8.
Srebrnik (2004), pp. 329–341.
- 9.
Consell General (2014), p. 10.
- 10.
Williams et al. (2013), p. 15.
- 11.
- 12.
Encouraging small jurisdictions to do so is e.g. Bernal (2018), pp. 98–99.
- 13.
- 14.
International Social Security Association (1980a), pp. 13–14.
- 15.
International Social Security Association (1980a), pp. 13–14.
- 16.
Brown (2010), p. 58.
- 17.
International Social Security Association (1980a), p. 13.
- 18.
On this, see Briguglio (2018).
- 19.
See also Briguglio (2018), p. 88.
- 20.
- 21.
An island like Granada was nearly completely destroyed by hurricane Ivan in 2004; many more other examples could be given.
- 22.
Castro-Guttiérrez (2008), p. 2.
- 23.
Williams et al. (2013), p. 2.
- 24.
- 25.
International Social Security Association (1980a), p. 13.
- 26.
Castro-Guttiérrez (2008), p. 2.
- 27.
International Social Security Association (1980a), p. 14.
- 28.
Williams et al. (2013), p. 52.
- 29.
- 30.
Bouchet (2019), p. 6.
- 31.
- 32.
- 33.
- 34.
- 35.
Grön Caroline, as quoted in Thorhallsson (2017), p. 40.
- 36.
- 37.
International Social Security Association (1980b), p. 40.
- 38.
- 39.
International Social Security Association (1980b), p. 40.
- 40.
- 41.
Brown (2010, p. 56), referring to Baker (1992) making the point that “in case of small states, only a few brains need be drained before a serious systemic crisis occurs.” A report from the OECD on the characteristics of the populations of 28 OECD countries around the year 2000 found that the Caribbean region loses between 25 and 47% of its nationals with higher education through emigration each year.
- 42.
- 43.
- 44.
Brown (2010), p. 56.
- 45.
Brown (2010), p. 61.
- 46.
Brown (2010), p. 61.
- 47.
Donlan et al. (2017), pp. 207–208.
- 48.
- 49.
Castro-Guttiérrez (2008), p. 5.
The heads of the CARICOM Social Security Organisations meeting in 2019 asked for special attention for the modernisation of the social security schemes, the use of ICT, as well as for training and research (X. (CARICOM. Social security schemes urged to modernize) 2019b). Also the year before the Governor of the Eastern Caribbean Central Bank called for a more functional cooperation among social security schemes in areas such as corporate governance, research and development and investment (SKNIS 2018).
- 50.
Brown (2010), p. 56.
- 51.
Butler and Morris (2017), p. 5.
- 52.
On these issues, see: Azzopardi Muscat and Camilleri (2018).
- 53.
Bertram (2011), p. 13.
- 54.
- 55.
- 56.
Gales (1994), p. 64.
- 57.
Thorhallsson (2017), pp. 41–42.
- 58.
International Social Security Association (1980b), p. 40.
- 59.
Prasad et al. (2013), p. 5.
- 60.
Prasad et al. (2013), p. 5.
- 61.
Brown (2010), p. 60.
- 62.
See also Brown (2010), p. 56 in favour of in situ training.
- 63.
Brown (2010), p. 61.
- 64.
Brown (2010), p. 61.
- 65.
Castro-Guttiérrez (2008), p. 6.
- 66.
Castro-Guttiérrez (2008), p. 6.
- 67.
Castro-Guttiérrez (2008), pp. 8–9.
- 68.
- 69.
International Social Security Association (1980d), pp. 93–94.
- 70.
- 71.
International Social Security Association (1980d), p. 94.
- 72.
On health in small states, see: Azzopardi Muscat and Camilleri (2018).
- 73.
- 74.
Sometimes the emigration of larger amounts of people from one larger state to the small country reflects particular historic coincidences; we can refer e.g. to the important Portuguese migration to small states like Andorra or Luxembourg.
- 75.
- 76.
The processing of a pension application for a migrant worker was often considerably lengthier than if he/she had worked in only one country. From 10–12 October 1979 the ISSA held a regional European meeting in London on the problems of speeding up the processing of migrant workers’ benefit claims, a brief record of which appeared in No. 4/79 of the International Social Security Review. See also International Social Security Association (1980c), pp. 56–57.
- 77.
- 78.
International Social Security Association (1980c, pp. 56–57): The participants also devoted special attention to the question of movements of tourists; each year streams of temporary migrants, sometimes of considerable intensity, passed through many of the small states represented at the meeting. “This could not fail to influence the operation of social security”. See also with relation to health care: International Social Security Association (1980c), p. 58.
- 79.
Prasad et al. (2013), p. 34. On the issue of remittances in the small Commonwealth states, see: Cover-Kus et al. (2018), here pp. 11–12.
An interesting social security issue with relation to remittances, consist in the question whether these remittances should be included in the income of the recipients of income tested social security benefits.
- 80.
Baldacchino (2011).
- 81.
Prasad et al. (2013), p. 31.
- 82.
On this issue, see: Von Brockdorff and Vella (2018).
- 83.
On this issue, see Bertram (2011, p. 12), where we read: “So long as diaspora members retain their citizenship and the right of return, they are effectively part of the set of individuals and groups to whom social policy applies. Social policy is here understood as policy that shapes the long-term structure and functioning of all social groups for which the small state is their economic, cultural and political ‘home’ and source of identity.”
- 84.
See also Moitrier (1980), p. 82.
- 85.
Bertram (2011), p. 20.
- 86.
- 87.
- 88.
See e.g. for Jersey: Gales (1994), p. 62.
- 89.
See also Hartley Lees (1994), p. 8.
- 90.
It is remarkable that in some literature, especially relating to the Caribbean coordination agreements, there seems to be a confusion between the concepts ‘harmonisation’ and ‘coordination’, using the first concept when the latter is meant. See e.g. Williams et al. (2013), pp. 18 and 54.
- 91.
External financing is important for many small states. More specifically, foreign assistance and concessionary loans have often played an important role in subsidizing development and the welfare et al. 2013, p. 34).
- 92.
- 93.
- 94.
Brown (2010), pp. 46–47.
- 95.
Prasad et al. (2013), pp. iii and 28–29.
- 96.
Prasad et al. (2013), p. 29 referring to for instance Grenada and Trinidad and Tobago.
- 97.
Prasad et al. (2013), p. 29.
- 98.
Caruana and Kalweit (2019), p. 13.
- 99.
- 100.
Veenendaal (2013), p. 245.
- 101.
- 102.
This can be the consequence of legally relevant texts being in the older national language (e.g. Italian in Malta) or the continued use of the language of the former colonisator, which often is then even elevated to the rank of official language of the state (exclusively or in combination with the broadly spoken national language, as with Papiamento in Aruba).
- 103.
- 104.
Brown is hard in its critics: “These are seductive arguments – usually put forward by analysts whose life experiences are almost exclusively in large countries – that distort and romanticize the observed reality of small states. It is a ‘big country’ view of small states” (Brown 2010, pp. 47–48).
- 105.
Brown (2010), pp. 46–47.
- 106.
- 107.
- 108.
Brown (2010), pp. 46–48.
- 109.
Brown (2010), pp. 46–48.
- 110.
Sometimes this is even reflecting custom. Mrs Kuautonga, a young Solomon Islands lawyer reports: “[…] there is a custom called the wantok system that is very common in Solomon Islands, whereby the position as public servant is used to serve the benefit of relatives, family members and friends. It is a form of corruption that has been imprinted in the minds of the general public. As long as one is public servant, you have to serve your wantoks despire the fact that you have certain codes of conduct to abide by. So it’s a conflict between performing to the expected standard and using the office for the best interest of wantoks…” (Caruana and Kalweit 2019, pp. 13–14).
- 111.
That corruption was a problem needing further examination in small jurisdictions was recognised by the meeting of law ministers and attorneys general of all commonwealth jurisdictions. See: The Commonwealth (2018).
- 112.
- 113.
Prasad et al. (2013), p. 30.
- 114.
An exception, being Osborne writing: “Most programs, however, are plagued by varying degrees of political interference” (Osborne 2012, p. 3).
- 115.
- 116.
- 117.
Moitrier (1980), p. 81.
- 118.
Castro-Guttiérrez (2008), p. 2.
- 119.
International Social Security Association (1980b), p. 41.
- 120.
Moitrier (1980), p. 81.
- 121.
International Social Security Association (1980b), p. 41.
- 122.
See Bertram (2011), pp. 13–14.
- 123.
Prasad et al. (2013), p. 27.
- 124.
Castro-Guttiérrez (2008), p. 3.
- 125.
This integration in broader institutions is seen by some as problematic: see Hartley Lees (1994), p. 8.
- 126.
The lesser fragmentation of schemes was seen as an advantage of the social security of smaller jurisdiction; see: Moitrier (1980), p. 80.
- 127.
Henry (2013), p. 31.
- 128.
- 129.
Williams et al. (2013), pp. 54–55.
- 130.
Especially small island developing states have a weak internal tax base and rely on ‘border taxes’ (Williams et al. 2013, p. 35); see also Bertram (2011), pp. 15–16. By border taxes we understand trade taxes collected by customs, which in some small states may account for a disproportionately large share of total revenues vis-à-vis personal/corporate income or property taxes (Brown 2010, p. 53).
- 131.
Paddison (2006), p. 20.
- 132.
International Social Security Association (1980a), p. 14.
- 133.
International Social Security Association (1980a), p. 14.
- 134.
Williams et al. (2013), p. 28.
- 135.
Williams et al. (2013), pp. 44–45.
- 136.
Prasad et al. (2013), p. 34.
- 137.
Wolf (2016), p. 7.
- 138.
Veenendaal and Wolf (2016), p. 281.
- 139.
International Social Security Association (1980b), p. 40.
- 140.
Bartumeu (1994), p. 75.
References
Anckar D (2002) Why are small island states democracies? Round Table 365:375–390
Anckar D (2004) Direct democracy in microstates and small island states. World Dev 32:379–390
Azzopardi Muscat N, Camilleri C (2018) Challenges and opportunities for the health sector in small states. In: Briguglio L (ed) Handbook of small states. Economic, social and environmental issues. Routledge, London, pp 445–774
Baehr PR (1976) The perennial problem of small states: a survey of research efforts. Coop Conflict 11(2):163–182
Baker R (1992) Scale and administrative performance: the governance of small states and microstates. In: Baker R (ed) Public administration in small and Island states. Kumarian Press, West Hartford, pp 5–25
Baldacchino G (2011) The power of Jurisdiction in promoting social policies in small states. UNRISD. www.unrisd.org/publications/pp-baldacchino. Accessed 8 Feb 2020
Bartumeu E (1994) Social security for migrant and cross-frontier workers in Andorra. In: International Social Security Association (ed) Small schemes in today’s social security. International Social Security Association, Geneva, pp 73–90
Bernal RL (2018) Small states in the global geopolitical landscape. In: Commonwealth Secretariat (ed) Small States. Economic Review and Basic Statistics. Commonwealth Secretariat, London, pp 93–100
Bertram G (2011) Assessing the structure of small welfare states. Social policies in smalls states series. Commonwealth Secretariat and United Nations Research Institute for Social Development, London
Bouchet M (2019) Déconstruisons le concept de “petite nation”: le cas du Luxembourg. Idea Fondation. https://www.fondation-idea.lu/2019/04/25/deconstruisons-le-concept-de-petite-nation-le-cas-du-luxembourg/. Accessed 1 June 2020
Briguglio L (2018) The vulnerability of small states. In: Commonwealth Secretariat (ed) Small states. Economic review and basic statistics. Commonwealth Secretariat, London, pp 85–92
Brown DE (2010) Institutional development in small states: evidence from the commonwealth Caribbean. Halduskultuur – Adm Cult 11(1):44–65
Butler P, Morris C (2017) Preface. In: Butler P, Morris C (eds) Small states in a legal world. Springer, Cham, pp v–viii
Caruana J, Kalweit D (2019) The Islands and Small States Institute: from a programme to a centre of excellence. In: 30th Anniversary Commemorative Publication. University of Malta, Valletta
Castro-Guttiérrez A (2008) Pooling administrative resources. Human resources management: improving personal qualifications and training. Presented at the International conference for social security schemes in small countries, Libreville, Gabon
Christmas-Møller W (1983) Some thoughts on the scientific applicability of the small state concept: a research history and a discussion. In: Höll O (ed) Small states in Europe and dependence. Wilhelm Braumüller, Wien, pp 35–53
Collins P, Warrington E (1997) The new public administration: lessons from the experiences of small and Island states. CAPAM/IASIA, Mahé
Consell General (2014) Déclaration Commune des Présidents de Parlement des Petits États d'Europe. Actes i Exposicions. http://www.consellgeneral.ad/ca/actes-i-exposicions/9-conferencia-de-presidents-de-parlament-dels-petits-estats-d2019europa/declaration-commune-des-presidents-de-parlement-des-petits-etats-d2019europe-a-l2019occasion-de-la-conference-organisee-a-andorre-en-date-du-26-septembre-2014. Accessed 7 Feb 2020
Cover-Kus H, Zaman S, Hope Khonje W, Ebrahim Z (2018) Small states in the global economy – a look at the past 25 years. In: Commonwealth Secretariat (ed) Small states. Economic review and basic statistics. Commonwealth Secretariat, London, pp 3–33
Dahl R, Tufte E (1973) Size and democracy. Stanford University Press, Stanford
Donlan SP et al (2017) Legal education and the profession in three mixed/micro jurisdictions: Malta, Jersey, and Seychelles. In: Butler P, Morris C (eds) Small states in a legal world. Springer, Cham, pp 191–212
Ewen C (1994) Social security for migrant and cross-frontier workers in Luxembourg. In: Small Schemes in Today’s Social Security (ed) International Social Security Association, pp 91–104
Forteza A (2008) The portability of pension rights: general principals and the Caribbean case. The World Bank, Washington, DC
Gales T (1994) Social security for migrant workers in Jersey. In: International Social Security Association (ed) Small schemes in today’s social security. International Social Security Association, Geneva, pp 57–72
Hartley Lees J (1994) Small social security schemes: problems and perspectives. In: International Social Security Association (ed) Small schemes in today’s social security. International Social Security Association, Geneva, pp 3–10
Henry R (2013) Caribbean development report: macroeconomic policy for structural transformation and social protection in small states. Economic Commission for Latin America and the Caribbean, Port of Spain
Hintjens H (2012) Consensual and participatory forms of democracy. Unpublished. Paper prepared for UNRISD – Commonwealth Secretariat project on Social Policy in Small States
International Social Security Association (1980a) Particular problems of small social security schemes: summary of the discussions. In: International Social Security Association (ed) Small social security schemes and their problems. European Series No. 3. International Social Security Association, Geneva, pp 12–14
International Social Security Association (1980b) Organisation and management of small social security schemes: summary of the discussions. In: International Social Security Association (ed) Small social security schemes and their problems. European Series No. 3. International Social Security Association, Geneva, pp 40–42
International Social Security Association (1980c) Problems arising from the relative scale of migratory movements: summary of the discussions. In: International Social Security Association (ed) Small social security schemes and their problems. European Series No. 3. International Social Security Association, Geneva, pp 56–58
International Social Security Association (1980d) Annex II: viability of social security schemes with a small number of participants. In: International Social Security Association (ed) Small social security schemes and their problems. European Series No. 3. International Social Security Association, Geneva, pp 93–94
International Social Security Association (1994) Small schemes in today’s social security. International Social Security Association, Geneva
Irving Z (2011) Curious cases: small island states’ exceptionalism and its contribution to comparative welfare theory. Editorial Board Sociol Rev 2011:227–245
Moitrier J (1980) Conclusions of the general reporter. In: International Social Security Association (ed) Small social security schemes and their problems. European Series No. 3. International Social Security Association, Geneva, pp 77–84
Mumford A (2017) The taxation of small states and the challenge of commonality. In: Butler P, Morris C (eds) Small states in a legal world. Springer, Cham, pp 87–99
Organisation of American States and Inter-American Council for Integral Development (2015) Analysis of bilateral and multilateral social security security agreement as they relate to pensions. Presented during the Second Meetings of the Working Groups of the XVIII Inter-American Conference of Ministers of Labor.
Osborne D (2012) The impact of economic conditions on the financial sustainability of social security schemes. The global economic crisis was not all bad for the financial sustainability of Caribbean social security schemes. Presented at the International Conference of Social Security Actuaries and Statisticians, Berlin, Germany
Paddison O (2006) Social security in the English-speaking Caribbean. United Nations, Santiago
Panke D (2010) Small states in the European Union. Coping with structural disadvantages. Routledge, London
Prasad N, Hypher N, Gerecke M (2013) Seeing big. Transformative social policies in small states (Research paper 2013-3). UNRISD, Geneva
SKNIS (2018) CARICOM heads of social security meeting. www.sknis.kn/29th-caricom-heads-of-social-security-meeting/. Accessed 1 June 2020
Srebrnik HF (2004) Small Island Nations and democratic values. World Dev 32:329–341
The Commonwealth (2018) Commonwealth Small States Centre for Excellence in Malta. https://thecommonwealth.org/small-states-centre-excellence. Accessed on 1 June 2020
Thorhallsson B (2017) Small states in the UNSC and the EU: structural weaknesses and ability to influence. In: Butler P, Morris C (eds) Small states in a legal world. Springer, Cham, pp 35–64
Veenendaal W (2013) Size and personalistic politics: characteristics of political competition in four microstates. Round Table – Commonw J Int Aff 102:245–257
Von Brockdorff P, Vella M (2018) Demographic transition and population ageing in small states. In: Briguglio L (ed) Handbook of small states. Economic, social and environmental issues. Routledge, New York, pp 475–490
Wettenhall R (1992) Small states: some machinery-of-government considerations. In: Baker R (ed) Public administration in small and Island States. Kumarian Press, West Hartford, pp 49–68
Williams A, Cheston T, Coudouel A, Subran L (2013) Tailoring social protection to Small Island developing states. Lessons Learned from the Caribbean (Discussion paper Social Protection & Labor, no. 1306). The World Bank, Washington, DC
Wolf S (2016) Die Erforschung von Politik und Recht in Kleinstaat und Monarchie. Eine konzeptionelle Einführung. In: State Size Matters. Politik und Recht im Kontext von Kleinstaatslichkeit und Monarchie, Sebastian Wolf (ed) Springer Fachmedien, Wiesbaden, pp 1–12; Recht im Kontext von Kleinstaatslichkeit und Monarchie, Sebastian Wolf (ed) Springer Fachmedien, Wiesbaden, pp 277–284
X (2019a) Chapter 6. Special feature: the Caribbean small states. In: OECD (ed) Latin American economic outlook. OECD, Paris, pp 185–199
X (2019b) CARICOM social security schemes urged to modernize. https://guyanachronicle.com/2019/07/17/caricom-social-security-schemes-urged-to-modernise. Accessed 1 June 2020
X, Projects of the Caribbean Community, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Projects_of_the_Caribbean_Community
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
Copyright information
© 2021 The Author(s), under exclusive license to Springer Nature Switzerland AG
About this chapter
Cite this chapter
Pieters, D. (2021). Small Jurisdictions; Their Common Features, in General and as Far as Social Security Is Concerned. In: Social Security Law in Small Jurisdictions. The World of Small States, vol 8. Springer, Cham. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-030-78247-4_2
Download citation
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-030-78247-4_2
Published:
Publisher Name: Springer, Cham
Print ISBN: 978-3-030-78246-7
Online ISBN: 978-3-030-78247-4
eBook Packages: Law and CriminologyLaw and Criminology (R0)